Northeast Ohio Classic made by the Italian Family that has owned it for decades. Sweet sauce makes the pie read more

Sam's Pizza Shop - Mushroom Pepperoni original - Pizza Near Me - Newton Falls, Ohio

Pizza was so so, 5/10 Lady working the counter is rude, unfriendly. Needs some better customer service skills. read more

Pretty disappointed with the crust & sauce. The sauce was bitter canned pizza sauce & crust was burnt and hard like a rock. The family hated it. I know why I never order here! Money in the trash can. read more

Sam's Pizza Shop - Burnt Trash Served Here! - Pizza Near Me - Newton Falls, Ohio

I'm basing this review on our trip today. We were at the Spartan Race in Windham this afternoon and stopped at Sam's on our way home. First off the pizza itself was easily a 4 star review, but that was the only good part. They have three booths inside. One was occupied by two kids, the other two by signs and pizza boxes. The manager acted like he was surprised anyone would want to eat inside. He dug up a couple cups and a roll of paper towels. The table was falling apart, and the stools at the bar were cracked and falling apart. They did give the impression that back when the restaurant was a more "happening" place to be and I'm sure the bar was lined with teenagers on date night. There were also a bunch of flies and stink bugs in the "dinning area". As far as the pizza goes it was really good. Very saucy and the crust had a nice crunch to it. They used fresh mushrooms as opposed to the typical canned mushrooms places used so that was an added bonus. All in all with the quality of the pizza this place could easily be a 4 star establishment. They definitely need a remodel and as it stands I couldn't recommend dinning I'm at Sam's. But I definitely recommend ordering it for carry out. read more

Sam's Pizza Shop - Sams pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Newton Falls, Ohio

See all

Tonight was a good night. The half-sheet was very good. Could have used a little more sauce. Still haven't given Gionino's a shot.

If you order through door dash the people at Sam's think it's ok to prepare your food late, treat the driver like she's a piece of dirt, give the driver half your order, and then treat her even worse when she calls about the things you didn't give her. No customer service at all. Will never deal with Sam's again. read more

Well, we finally went back for the pizza a few days ago. It wasn't quite as good as I remember but overall still good. The crust was nice, thick and done just right. I must admit though that the toppings were lacking. On one pie we had pepperoni, mushrooms and green peppers. They were there but I would have liked there to be more. The other pie was just pepperoni. It seems that they strategically place the roni so that there is only 2 maybe 3 pieces per slice. I don't know about you but I want more. Of course we had to get the cheesy bread sticks which are still delicious. And remember, you have to dip them in ranch dressing. Mmmm....Mmmmm.....Good. read more

Sam's is a Newton Falls, Ohio staple. My mom grew up in town, and even though we live up in Akron, we still have a lot of family in the area. What a great reason to stop by Sam's on our way out of town and pick up our favorite pizza - everything but anchovies! You can never go wrong with a Sam's Pizza - warm or cold, it's the pizza to beat. read more

Sam's Pizza Shop - Everything but anchovies - Pizza Near Me - Newton Falls, Ohio

Been eating this pizza for close to 30 years. Was always very good. Best in the world Now it's hit or miss. More like home made. Chicken used to be garlic favored. Now it's dry with breading Little pricey. Would recommend if they could produce a product that was consistent. Still order about 3 times a year vs. 45 times a year. Like I said. It and miss read more

They have messed up our order EVERY TIME we have come here. We've waited 20-30+ mins PAST the time they told us our order would be ready, every time. We called several times tonight. No one answered. They were open. We walked in. Called while in the lobby. They all laughed and said, "Don't answer it. We're practically closed." Tried to order a cavatell with meatballs. "Sorry, we aren't serving pasta currently." What kind of a business shuts down production of their products before they shut down??? Also, the bugs flying around was the topper on that cake. This place sucks all around. read more

Good Pizza, and the wings were pretty good. We were a bit surprised that they weren't really set up for dine-in, but they did try and get us settled in nonetheless! read more

Love their homemade ranch dip!! Goes well with everything. The fish sandwich and fried chicken are very good. Ben makes a mean philly steak sandwich. And I love the fried chicken and jo's or French fries. They have amazing lasagna, when they make it. Its usually more of a catered item food but I would absolutely love for them to add it to their everyday menu so more people have to start asking for it and I can talk him into making it more often. Its really delicious take my word for it. You have to try it at least once and you will be hooked. Very fairly priced and great food. Nice employees , curtious and helpful. Hometown, well known, local family owned pizza shop. Been around for years and will continue to be around many more. Loyal long time customers friendly and curtious staff. It's a must to buy a pint of the ranch dip to take home. That stuff goes great with their 24 cheese sticks orders. YUM!! read more

My favorite pizza around. Gotta get the deluxe with their dipping sauce. It's to die for. I usually get mild wings on the side that are also pretty good, can be a little dry sometimes. Always a great meal here!!!! read more

Bad customer service. Mediocre pizza at best. The people working there act like the customers are bothering them when you come pick up your order. read more

I have never been impressed by the pizza (my husband swears you have to catch them on the right night!) when another place in town ran out of wings... I tried sams. Omg the Cajun ones are so yummy!!!! read more

Pizza done on bottom middle very uncooked and doughy manegement rude when you call to tell them about it very nasty pizza dont eat here

Traveling through the area we Googled up a restaurant in route. Sam's Pizza Shop came up recommended. Nothing to look at from the outside but gave it a try. The service was terrific! Friendly and helpful. There were customers waiting in line. Everyone was polite and smiled. Good hometown appeal. The pizza was delicious! Fresh! Hot! and Just the right flavors. Glad we found this hidden treasure. Hope we have an opportunity to come by again. Thank you read more

I have had pizza from here for years. It is a very well made pizza and is always cooked just the right amount of time. Also have many good sandwiches along with wings. You also have to get a order of the cheese sticks, those are a must every time. read more