Never again! I should have been tipped off to what fortune awaited us when there was not one other customer in the place at twelve noon, on a Saturday, in the summer. Ordered a dozen garlic Parmesan wings, two personal "pizzas", one regular & the other white. Let's start with the wings. Absolutely no flavor, which will be a recurring theme. All they did was sprinkle Parmesan cheese on the wings. To be fair, they were crispy, but again, the breading tasted like cooking oil. Drowning the wing in ranch dressing was the only way to make it palatable. Twenty five minutes later the "pizzas" arrived. The white pie was barely edible. Literally just burnt mozzarella cheese on a thin, hard, favor-less crust. Maybe the garlic & spice delivery truck didn't come this week? Their regular pie definitely was an improvement over the white, but nothing to write home about. No joke, you can make a better tasting pizza at home using only three items from Costco...stone flat bread, mozzarella cheese, & Mama Rao's sauce. I will acknowledge that the place was clean & the young lady working the counter was attentive. They also do have free refills on fountain drinks, so there's that. Overall, the fact that this place is a franchise boggles my mind. Like, how to did someone get hoodwinked into thinking this was a wise long term investment opportunity? I wish this place luck, but let's be honest, it won't be here the next time I am in Wildwood. read more

Stopped in to the Santucci's in Rio grande today which is owned by the same owners as the wildwood location. The new location is also convenient when out running errands off island. For today's order, I opted for the pizza of the month special and it certainly did not disappoint and was made with Pepperoni whipped ricotta basil and mikes hot honey. Congrats to the owners on bringing the same consistency to the menu we know and love at the new location. We will obviously continue to support both the wildwood and Rio grande locations! read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Ordered through GrubHub as they were listed as the fastest for delivery on a Friday night. A Friday night at the beach. Well....after placing the order the estimated time was an hour. Not sure who provided the wildly inaccurate ETA. We ordered 2 classic burgers and fries and a cheese dipping sauce. The burgers were some of the best we've had. Perfectly cooked without dripping grease and great seedless buns. The toppings were accurate and plentiful. The fries were crispy and perfect to dip in the cheese sauce. Besides the delivery delay, we were happy with the quality, flavor and portion size of our meals. Packaging was good and the restaurant's delivery driver was super nice. Definitely would order again for pick up or just dine in. read more

I went here for lunch at the Rio Grande location and the pizza was ok. The crust was great but the rest was just ok. I will have to try other slices to see if it can get better read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Huge portions, quick service. We were in Wildwood during the off-season in March an event at the convention center. The places that are open in the off season in the evening (6-8pm) are limited. We were excited to see Santuccis was open and had immediate seating. I will be back! read more

I started to call at 9:30 trying to put in an order and they kept hanging up the phone on me so I drove 20 minutes to the store and when I got there the manager Haley told me they stopped taking orders at 9:30 and they shut off the oven at 9:30 but online it says they are open until 10. I think either you guys should serve people until the time it says online or you should post that you close at 9:30 but then again you'll probably stop serving food at 9 o'clock if you do that also the manager Haley was very rude. Would not recommend going here. read more

Came for lunch with my family and ordered a large pie. We sat inside and enjoyed the calm atmosphere, it was the off season so nice and chill. We got a large cheese half pepperoni square pie. The staff were friendly and our pizza came out in good time. It's a very saucy pie, but we enjoyed that. Good flavor, and good value for money. A large pie fed 2 adults and 2 teenagers. I would come back again. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Large cheese & pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Full disclosure this is for the Keenan location, which i went to after a night of drinking... The pizza is decent , reminded me of an adult version of Ellio's pizza. Wouldn't say it was the best but it wasn't the worse just Mid. I tried 3 different pizza shops that night, still came up mid. I like my pizza with a nice cheese pull i didn't get that here. The crust is thick and hard (pause) which would soak that liquor right up. read more

See all

We ordered a pepperoni pizza, a buffalo chicken pizza and a six piece order of boneless chicken wings. I went in to pick it up and found the place to be a pleasant little space with big windows and an open dining area. The service was friendly and my order came out from the back just when it was scheduled to! The food was a bit of a mixed bag, unfortunately. For the pepperoni and buffalo chicken pies, the flavors were great but the dough itself was on the gummy side. The biggest food issue, though, were the boneless wings. When they were advertised as a six-piece for $11, I assumed there'd be six good-sized tenders. Instead, I got eight tater tot-sized chicken bites, served cold, and tossed in a bbq sauce that was described as smoky BBQ but tasted like Sweet Baby Ray's. That felt like a real bad ripoff. Debating whether or not to go back. I love the year-round businesses in Wildwood, but there are so many good places to get a pizza here. read more

Over priced and basic af food. Not quality. Seriously - my chicken cheese steak was Cisco (over) precooked chicken with cheese and a bit of onions. So dry and almost cold. The fries were super cold. This sub was so bad. $18 too hahahaha whack. Pizza.....$16 for 4 slices with the same dry chicken. Pizza cold it had coagulated cheese on top. If it was warm it would have been ok, 2-3 stars at max. Mind you, I got there 1 min after the time I was given. 1 minute. Friday evening too! Skip this place for reals dough. read more

The pizza came hot and had a nice balance of sauce and cheese. The pizza is thin, with the cheese below the sauce, but it worked well! The crust was the right level of crisp and chew. The meatballs were tasty, moist, and came in a tomato sauce that was slightly sweet but not overpowering. The garlic bread also came with a great sauce, but the bread itself didn't seem the freshest (not stale, but not fresh either). read more

If you are native to the NEPA square old forge style pizza, then this pizza is not for you. If you enjoy meatball or chicken parm hoagies, then definitely give it a try. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Man, I was surprised with how good Santucci's pizza was. It looked like an ordinary Detroit style pizza, but the cheese had an especially good flavor. The cheesesteak was really good too. I'd order that again in a heartbeat. I wasn't impressed with the fries. To be fair, they were delivered from Wildwood to Cape May, so maybe they just don't travel well. I'm sure they're just fine when they're hot and fresh. read more

Not a fan at all. The pizza is not good because the sauce is awful on it and it's always soggy.

I would without a doubt eat here again. If you're craving pizza, then grab some from here. (We got ours to-go) My wife was in the mood for a Sicilian, which is what we thought this placed served based on pictures posted to Yelp (and frankly the name). However, I would not classify this pizza as Sicilian - not thick and airy/crunchy. I wouldn't classify it as deep dish or Detroit-style either. (No caramelized edges) I'd describe it as a hearty hand-tossed in the shape of a square. (Which means I doubt it's hand-tossed. LOL!) The sauce is put on top of the pizza, which gave me some hesitation but ultimately was quite good. It didn't make it a mess to eat, and more importantly, the sauce was portioned well and tasted good! All-in-all, the flavor of the dough, cheese, and sauce made for a delicious bite! My wife had The Works, and loved the combination of toppings; which she said there was plenty of. I also got a chicken parm sandwich, it was also delicious! Not your typical frozen chicken tenders fried and delivered with sauce and cheese. This had a flavorful breading, lots of cheese, and a great hoagie roll. I'd get this again too! Pics attached of everything but The Works. I was too busy eating to snap a pic of it. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Square pizza with the first bite taken - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Stick with the pizza - the salad was not good. The chicken cutlet was burnt to a crisp and as a result so dry I had to throw the whole thing away and there were so many onions on it that I couldn't even eat the rest of it. Super disappointed. read more

This is my number 1 favorite pizza at the shore! The crust is perfect and the sauce outstanding . There are just 2 of us most of the time and we end up eating the leftovers right from the refrigerator,It's that good. read more

Decided to give it a try today. Very nice and inside. Large sitting area. The employees are very friendly and welcoming. They leave a water bowl and bowl of dog biscuits for those walking their furry friends. We took the antipasto and pizza to go. Great flavor. The pizza is not to thick and not too thin. We enjoyed both the antipasto and pizza. Would definitely go back. read more

See all

Good pizza. Nothing special. The staff were friendly and the place appeared clean. I like the size of their personal pizza. It isn't too small like some places. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Margherita personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

I tried a personal size gluten Friendly Pizza. It was the best gluten free wheat free pizza. It tastes just like your other pizza. Thank you

The 1st time we had the pizza was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Told all our friends they need to try it. I said the the best in CMC. Tonight 5/7/2026. Not so much. It sucked! Under cooked. I called and spoke with Jim, and let him know the issue, he asked if I wanted to come back and he would give me a new pizza and stromboli. I was already home after I waited there for a half hr. I said No, I'm not coming back, then he said that he would give me a credit. He just needed my Name and number. I said I didn't give you my number. He said I have it, I'll call you back. I said ok. Waited a few minutes, no call. So I called back, the young lady answered the phone, took my message , then he called. He told me that I had to come in tomorrow for a Margarita pizza. That's only half of what I ordered. I said a Margarita pie costs 50.00$? That's when he said to me, well you need to bring your order back now for me to give you credit! I said, not coming back I threw it in the trash! Then he said well I just can't take your word for it and hung up on me. Word of mouth goes really far! Sorry this happened. read more

This is my number 1 favorite pizza at the shore! The crust is perfect and the sauce outstanding . There are just 2 of us most of the time and we end up eating the leftovers right from the refrigerator,It's that good. read more

So thankful they were opened yesterday! My friend and I enjoyed our flatbread pizza and the garlic Parmesan fries! And, birch beer soda! Yum all around! The counter girl was very friendly and helpful, as well. I do wish it wasn't so warm in there. Air conditioning would have helped especially for the staff. Decor is cute with inside seating and a take out counter. Looking forward to a Stromboli on my next trip down the shore! Check them out! read more

See all

Ordered 3 hoagie style sandwiches from their menu. The two Smoked turkeys had thick slabs of slippery processed turkey (??) meat. The Classic Italian had thick pieces of pork fat products that were definitely mostly fat. I will never go there again for a sandwich. We thought about throwing them out on inspection but picked through because we were hungry. Russo's was closed. SO DISAPPOINTED. Wawa makes a gourmet sandwich by comparison. UGH!!! read more

It's great that Santucci's is open year round. Their pizza is always a hit. Also they have good French fries as well. Eat in or takeout it's always consistently delicious. read more

I wanted to like Santucci's so much. I was excited to try them and happy they're a year round place. They have a nice spot right off the boardwalk. It's kept clean, not great for parking, but good to walk to. Your best bet is to pay for parking in the lot on Ocean and walk over vs trying to find street parking (which is also metered in season.) The employees have always been nice... I just haven't had one thing from there that was good enough to pay their prices. The pepperoni pizza was incredibly salty, the chicken fingers were just okay, the fries just okay. Better food for better pricing in other spots on the island. read more

Amazing service! I ordered catering for my daughter's birthday. From start to finish was perfect and so easy. The food was delicious,so many compliments!!! I had dietary restrictions the accommodations were perfect and The delivery drivers walked everything down to the beach for us! Amazing job guys! read more

We were eager to try Santucci's since there was so much hype around their new location opening in Wildwood. We were in the final hours of our Memorial Day weekend down the shore and already had the car packed up. We stopped by and took a large pie to go. The restaurant was very busy so we had to quickly take our box and squeeze out the door as we weaved through the crowd of sandy beachgoers. As we power walked through the parking lot we could only smell the pizza fresh goodness seeping through the holes in the box. We finally got to the car and were able to peep inside our box - now these slices glistened with a ruby red sauce blanketing the melty cheese, all nestled on the top of a fluffy but perfectly crisp square crust. I wanted to eat it immediately but we were already behind schedule so we buckled it up in the back seat and hit the road. Once we were on the parkway, we were ready to risk it all. If you saw someone's husband feeding them slices of pizza while driving past AC that was me and I have no regrets. I am still thinking of this pizza. A large was more than enough to feed the both of us plus we had some leftovers. We had gone in wanting to split a personal pie but they said they were out for the weekend. I can't wait to go back and I would recommend adding it to your new list of restaurants to try, it's the perfect way to change up from your typical Wildwood Italian or pizza takeout. read more

Not bad but not amazing. This seems to be a very popular pizza and is a nice addition to the area when you want something a bit different than a regular slice. The crust is nice and crispy and the sauce was decent. The cheese is under the sauce similar to an upside down Sicilian. I would come back again for sure. read more

See all

Great pizza off the boardwalk! Square pizza at its best. Service and atmosphere are great as well.

The pros - the hoagies were good. Got a chicken cutlet and chicken parmigiana. The cons - the pizza was just not good. We really wanted to like it but the sauce had no taste and there was barely any cheese on it. read more

I'm not sure why people like this pizza. I found it tasteless. I'm a NY pizza person or Sam's on the boards. Haven't had anything else from the menu so maybe give it a try. read more

I looked at reviews and gave this place a try. It surpassed my expectations. I doesn't necessarily photograph well but I am instantly craving it. I had planned on going to Sam's Pizza Palace as it's my go to but luckily stopped here. This is so different than traditional NY style pizza, its crust is crunchy and flavorful( it reminded me of how I remember old school Pizza Hut in the pan). I'm hoping to bring back a bigger group to try and sample more of the impressive menu items. I highly recommend this establishment and the staff was extremely friendly and courteous. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Original pie with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Unique style, almost like if you took cheesy bread and opened it up and topped it with a gourmet marinara that was just right with the garlic notes, then the buttery edges of the crust to boot. Will return, more people are on to this I hope. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Plain small cheese - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Well this pizza made it. Pizza to never ever have again. Pre made soggy dough. No toppings evenly on the pie. Very sad. Pizza is terrible read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - $37 for a wish pizza. Wish there was toppings on the entire pie - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Excellent pizza. Robust sauce and crispy crust with a unique cheese first and square crust approach. The staff are kind and helpful. Forget Mack's and Sam's. This is the go-to place. read more

Ordered the pie for takeout. Great taste. Great toppings. Only detail is with the sauce on the top, the pizza cools down quite fast. Eat quickly friends! read more

Bland and not good. Not like the Philly location. Hope they get better I would like to see them succeed. I'll try again later in the summer

They may known for their square pizza but try their Italian hoagie. I'm not a foodie, but it was the best sandwich I've ever eaten. Other people often talk about the bread of a sandwich and I didn't get it until today. Best roll ever! Even the tomato was great. The pic doesn't do the quality of this hoagie justice! I'll try their pizza someday if I ever tire of their hoagies. read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Amazing pizza. My parents used to get this in Philly, so I took my boys to the one in Wildwood. This is one of the tastiest, most affordable meals down the shore. I just love everything about this pizza. A small pizza has 4 huge square slices, perfect for 2-3 people. And the cheese pulls while you eat it, as you can see in my photo. The restaurant was clean, and the employees were so nice. This will be a regular stop when we are down the shore. Yum! read more

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey