state farm was charging me double the price I got from Weimer Over. Great savings and super nice…read morepeople.

From the owner: If you are looking for a local Lancaster, NY insurance agent to take care of your insurance needs,…read moreyou have come to the right place! Weimer Over Agency has been serving the Lancaster, NY area for over 50 years and has built a reputation for client satisfaction through hard work, dedicated employees, and the best customer service in the business. We Offer Complete Insurance Programs Personal Coverage * Auto * Home * Condominiums * Umbrella * Watercraft, Motorcycles, Recreational Vehicles * Flood * Personal Property Floaters for Jewelry, Fine Arts & Collections * Renters * Snowmobile * Landlord Business Coverage * Business Owners Policies * General Liability * Contractors Liability * Property * Automobile * Workers' Compensation * Disability * Umbrella * Garage Liability * Inland Marine/Equipment * Boiler & Machinery * Professional Liability

Highly recommend this insurance agency! They are compassionate, understanding, and hate to see…read morepeople being taken advantage of. Taylor and Colleen helped me out tremendously! 5 star customer service! 10/10

They are a phenomenal company of compassionate and dedicated individuals of whom I have personally…read morerecommended to multiple family members and friends and they have expressed these identified feelings regarding the company. Taylor Haines shopped around with multiple companies and was able to offer me a quite $100 less than any company I personally contacted.

My wife and I bought home insurance through WNY Consulting Group and we had a great experience. Our…read moreagent was Brett, and he did a fantastic job of answering all of our questions and helping us to find the right insurance policy. He was patient and thorough, and we'll definitely use WNY Consulting Group for future insurance policies.

From the owner: Tired of feeling like just another policy number? We work for YOU, not the insurance companies…read more Contact us today!

We have dealt with this office for over 40 years and would not go anywhere else for our insurance…read moreneeds. They always are friendly and efficient and treat us like family. Allstate has stood by us several times and made our claims easy to handle. We highly recommend this office!

Professional & Knowledgable staff with a family friendly atmosphere. What impressed me most is that…read moreinstead of just grabbing a policy from me they actually took the time to review and explain my options, made recommendations, and accepted my preferences without any heavy handed pressure. Switched to this agency and have never looked back, I have more personable and competent representation for all my needs. A ++ Agency, Staff, and company with no run around when you need to file..

They can have one star for giving me the cheapest quote, but after two months, different people…read moretelling me different things, numerous calls and emails, I still don't know if I have full coverage on my car. I took my car to their office for a photo inspection and was told I was all set. Apparently they took the photos wrong. No one ever let me know. It's still not resolved and I have been driving around without full coverage. That was a month ago. I called upset and they told me to just take a photo myself and send it to them, which I did. Again I was told I was all set. But when I called a few weeks later I am told no, actually my coverage is still suspended. I guess I will be switching insurance companies. Really regret leaving my old company for this nonsense.

Very pleased with this agency. I had been dealing with a competitor for years until the personnel…read more changed and mistakes started being made. Joe's agency had just opened and his rates were comparable. The switch was made. Kelly, the agent that I deal with, had some great ideas regarding saving $$. She pointed out that since the KIA - heated topic is my last review - was not being driven, I didn't need regular auto insurance, I just needed minimal insurance to keep the vehicle parked in my driveway until lease turn in time. Saved big time bucks here for a vehicle I neither needed nor wanted. The agency is easy to reach either by phone or email. Some one will get back to you and they are knowledgeable about the product they sell. Final note, no one here tried to upsell my homeowners by nickel and diming me about lower deductables, increasing coverage or any other such nonsense. I'm comfortable here which means everyone in my household sleeps well at night.

Tammy , one of the representatives, was absolutely amazing . She got back to me right away about my…read moreissue and immediately rectified it for me . Very kind and helpful. So glad to be with this company

Bob White was able to literally cut my homeowners and car insurance by half. He negotiated a…read morebetter price with my homeowners company and changed my car insurance to a better company. Bob has been exceptional! I wish I had begun work with him years ago.

Someone from this office deleted my car insurance policy for no reason and never informed me which…read morecaused the DMV to suspend my license and now I can't get to work. They literally ruined my life.

Shopping for insurance? I checked out about a dozen insurance companies and found Mike Messuro…read moreState Farm to be far and away the best. Extremely courteous and professional service and reasonably priced. Vivian was excellent in helping me get new auto and home insurance policies. I highly recommend and trust this agency and it's staff to give me the best possible service.