Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Serendipity

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    Serendipity Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Serendipity

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Caterers 1,325 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nameless Catering Company

    Nameless Catering Company

    (14 reviews)

    I had the chance to go to one of their sampling/tasting events and got to try every item on the…read moremenu - and it was all superb! I was super impressed with the various options they had and that they can get you an order within 48 hours. I use a lot of catering for work, and this seems really well priced compared to other catering options. They have four kitchens around Indy and a ton of delivery trucks so they can make an order anywhere in town work - which instills a lot of confidence! I was impressed with their ease of ordering and customer service. I loved their Mexican food and healthy food options. I will definitely use them the next time I am looking for catering for work or personal!

    I have had Nameless at many events around Indianapolis and each time was spectacular. When I…read moredecided to look for a caterer for my own event, Nameless was the first group I called. The level of customer service is unmatched. Personal contact was made within the same day, menus were created with two days along with a full quote and breakdown. The cost was higher than others, however the product is worth the Splurge. Between Nameless and others there was about a $500 difference in quotes. The response time and considerations made make Nameless well worth it. They don't flinch at large group sizes, over 400 in my case, and help guide newcomers through the process. If you see Nameless on the catering list you just know you are about to have an incredible meal.

    City Barbeque

    City Barbeque

    (235 reviews)

    $$

    This is probably our last visit to City Bbq. We have been going to this location since they opened…read moreand the Greenwood location even longer. We ordered the City Sampler. Normally we take some food home with us. On this visit we ate it all and left wanting more, just not more of any of the meat. The portions were definitely smaller. Three slices of brisket and turkey. The brisket was so tough I had to get a knife to cut it. It was dry and had no flavor. The pork was dry. And the turkey was salty. My husband said the sausage was good. It was the best meat on the plate. I didn't eat any of it. Fries, hush puppies and Texas toast were fine. Service was good. You order at the counter and they call your name when your food is ready.

    This Thanksgiving, in lieu of frying a couple of turkeys like I do every year due to some medical…read morerestrictions on lifting and twisting, I ordered a whole smoked turkey from City Barbeque. I ordered it chilled for pickup the day before, and we popped it in the fridge. It was ready for an easy pickup exactly at the time slot I had set when ordering. The day of, we followed the instructions supplied via QR code and heated the turkey in the oven between 2-2.5 hours. It was outstanding. We fed 6 people and had a ton of leftovers. Unfortunately I did not get a picture of the cooked bird, but I got a picture of the box ;-) Everyone loved the turkey and I may just have a new go to for an easier holiday, without needing to stand out in the weather to fry them myself. I would definitely do this again.

    Graze Craze - Indianapolis

    Graze Craze - Indianapolis

    (3 reviews)

    Every Thanksgiving needs a hero, and this year ours came packaged in a wooden box tied up with…read moretwine. I had been searching everywhere for a graze box to bring to our friends' gathering and finally decided to give Graze Craze a try. I'm so glad I did. Shortly after placing my order, they reached out to let me know the store would be closing earlier than expected the day before Thanksgiving. They easily adjusted my pickup time, and I really appreciated them being proactive instead of leaving me to discover locked doors. Now...this next part was completely on me. ‍ I showed up a little early while they were absolutely buried preparing holiday orders. They had part of my order ready, apologized, and asked if I could swing back once everything was finished. A short while later they contacted me exactly as promised, and pickup was a breeze. The customer service alone deserved five stars. Then I opened the boxes. They were honestly almost too pretty to eat. Every detail looked intentional--from the presentation to the handwritten note tucked inside. I was genuinely excited to show up with them. The best part? They weren't just pretty. Every single person commented on how beautiful they looked...then immediately started talking about how good everything tasted. That's the dream when you're bringing food to a holiday gathering. Presentation Meter: (gift-worthy) Party Impressiveness: Guests gathered around before the lids were even fully open. I live on the south side, so this isn't exactly around the corner for me--but I'd happily make the drive again. Great food, thoughtful customer service, and a local business I'll gladly continue supporting.

    Super disappointed to leave a one star review but my experience with Graze Craze has been horrible…read more I received a gift card for my birthday and I went in person this week to place an order. When I walked in, I heard someone say from that back that they'd be with me in a little while. It wasn't long before a young man came out to speak with me. It was about 90 minutes before closing and he immediately told me I should not expect service right before closing. I apologized, said I thought they closed at 6pm, he said they did, then said he'd go to the back to see if they'd be willing to talk to me. Someone was in the back washing dishes, but never came to the front. The same employee came back out, sighed, and said he'd take my order. I told him I had never been in, I just heard about it from the gift card, and was curious what I could order and what was included with the menu items (inside, it's just a counter and a table off to the side with trays/boxes with names, but not prices or a list of what comes in them). He told me I should read the TV, which looked to be off at the time. He turned it back on while huffing and puffing, then said "LOOK!" at the menu, which was just names of the boxes with prices, not sizes or again what's included/what I can choose from. I remained calm, despite feeling uncomfortable, and again asked if I could see a list of what's included or what I can choose from, and if I can pick something up same day or order for a future pickup (I was honestly hoping for a grab & go cooler like other similar places but no problem, I can order something for another time). I still have no idea what items are available, as the employee was just getting more and more mad at me with each question, which he refused to answer. I told him I was feeling uncomfortable, which he just said, "okay!" so I said I didn't feel like I was wanted there as a customer, and I left. I've tried calling the store to rectify the situation and maybe speak with a different employee or member of management. Either the phone just rings and rings or the same employee I spoke with in-person answers. I really wanted to use my gift card but I'd rather throw it away than go through that experience again. I'm very discouraged at this point, but glad I can get great products and service at The Bountiful Board instead.

    Serendipity - catering - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...