4.5 stars !! It would be 5, but they took a bit longer than they said it would take. I actually didn't mind, because I wanted it done right and was paying 100% myself, vs. any insurance reimbursement. My car looks brand new, everything was casual and easy peasy. I got quotes from several places. They were the most affordable. I've got 2 vehicles, am a gearhead owning everything from Porsches to '67 GTO's and '55 Chevys and this is my body shop from now on !! Include these folks, (friendly, easy) in any quotes you get for bodywork. I chose them for the price and reviews. And the results in 2025 for my 2011 Avalon were 100% !! read more

One of the worst experiences I've ever had dealing with a shop. Took an older vehicle in to get looked at. My insurance aha d already previously sent an adjuster and gave me a quote. I did not fully understand that this shop was going to do a counter quote. After dropping off my car and getting my insurance info over (which I should have never done) I get notified two weeks later that my vehicle is totaled because the shop sent a counter quote back to my insurance and stripped a lot of the vehicle down and said it was going to cost upwards of 10,000 to fix in which my insurance totaled the vehicle. Because my insurance totaled the vehicle this shop would not let me have my vehicle back unless my insurance paid them over $3,000 for the "work" that was "performed" and the "daily vehicle storage fee". The car was never repaired, and I was left with a now "totaled" vehicle that only had cosmetic issues and a bent door frame... Beyond the worst experience at any shop I've ever had. Do not take your vehicle here as this shop tries to squeeze money out of insurance and will hold your vehicle hostage. Edit after shop reply 10/30/25: My first mistake was dropping the vehicle off. My second mistake was sending my insurance info over. All I wanted was the door bent back straight and a basic repair. When I dropped my vehicle off I don't remember it being clear that you were going to do a tear down and then charge a storage fee towards insurance. After I finally Received my vehicle back from your shop I put my own vehicle back together after I got it back and it took me about 2hrs. Charging my insurance $3000 for no actual repair work is insane. I remember quote for quote what you said to insurance since they hadn't paid you yet and they were only willing to pay you around $1200 for vehicle storage and the "work" preformed.. you said "that's not good enough." because you wanted over $3000 from my insurance for this "work" that was preformed and storage fees... aka just a tear down of the inner fender, the outer fender flair the front bumper and grill taken off and lights off. (The only reason I brought this vehicle in is because wind pulled the driver door open and bent the hinges and slightly cracked where the hinges are welded to the A pillar. A simple fix is all I asked for not a full a pillar replacement...." you bent the front fender while getting the door open (which I could have done myself but wanted to try and not bend anything more which is why I took this to a shop in the first place...) and then did a full tear down of the driver side door including taking the glass out.. I don't even care about that Jeep anymore and was willing to just give it away at that point in this process because of how pissed off I was and still am about this whole thing. You should have called me before sending any "supplement" to my insurance. Moral of the story for anyone who is considering this shop: don't involve insurance with this shop or you will be sitting between a shop feud with your insurance as the shop is trying to squeeze money out of the insurance company. They might like to do repair work but all this shop sees when you have insurance involved is dollar signs. read more

I took my hail damaged Toyota Avalon to Set It Off after having an insurance company estimate of the damage at about $7,000. The team at Set If Off saw greater damage and fought with the insurance company about the cost which ultimately resulted in them agreeing the car was a total write-off. Progressive valued the car at $13,700 but Set It Off referred me to a guy who fights with insurance companies on the behalf of car owners, and now Progressive has agreed on a valuation of $18,000! So Set It Off got no work from me but got me a tremendous financial benefit at no benefit to themselves. That is what I call exceptional customer service! read more

Set It Off Paint & Body - Hail damage in not always evident! - Body Shops Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

this is the only shop I'd ever trust with any of my vehicles. They not only have superior customer service they do the highest quality work. their completion times are excellent and unlike every other body/paint shop in Wyoming and Colorado who are booking months out, they have always gotten me in and repairs started within a few weeks! read more

I'm very pleased with the job that Set It Off was able to do with my van. It looks brand new. Even better than it was before it went in. My van is a bit customized and I was worried there would be problems but they got all of it handled. They were super responsive and good with correspondence. Shelby is the best. Great customer service. read more

Set It Off Paint & Body - After photo - Body Shops Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

I took my Tacoma in to get the hood and roof repainted and they did an amazing job. They worked with my budget, got my truck in ASAP, and finished it in a timely manner. I'll definitely be going back to get more paint work done in the future. Pictures are before and after. read more

Set It Off Paint & Body - After paint. They washed the entire truck. - Body Shops Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Wow - I can't say enough great things about the group at Set It Off. We got in an accident that did a pretty large amount of damage to our car (fortunately no one was hurt!) the down side was our insurance wasn't going on to cover anything so it all was coming out of pocket. The staff here was incredible with doing their best to get the work done quickly while also keeping in mind we were paying out of pocket. They also were so great at keeping us up to date with the status of the repairs each week. Our car now looks brand new and runs even better than before! I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone! read more

Set It Off is a great quality team of hard working people that genuinely want to help. The entire staff is friendly and give efficient and quality estimates/repair. If you live in northern Colorado this is definitely the shop to go to. read more

Set It Off Paint and Auto Body was my second quote! I so wish I had gone there first. Huge difference in the price ...They completed my ENTIRE vehicle for $500 LESS than the first place, which was ONLY a visual quote! I recommend these guys 100% as they treated me so right! Always up front with me on everything they did so NO surprises...EVER! I will TOTALLY be back! Thanks EVERYONE at Set It Off Paint an Body...YOU GUYS ROCK! A shout out to Adam and Josh...thanks for being so patient with all my calls :) read more

Needed a new bumper for my daughter's Jeep after she was involved in a collision. Shelby and her crew helped us significantly by great communication and excellent service and little wait. Would definitely recommend!!!! read more

Got my car back today. Josh and his team did a stellar job. I think it actually looks better after the accident and his working on it than it did before. He finished with time to spare and tried his hardest to stick to the original estimate (appreciate that). Lastly, his team cleaned my car before I picked it up; considering it's a beagle mobile and they were dog hairs and nose prints everywhere, it was such a nice gesture. Recommend 110%. read more

Set It Off Paint & Body - 2006 Hyundai before Josh's magic - Body Shops Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

This was my first experience with an auto body shop. I had $13k worth of hail damage to my new car! Shelby and all of the guys made this experience smooth (for me!) There were a lot of hiccups in terms of parts coming in damages, or back order. However, Shelby went to bat for me with all of the part vendors and the insurance company. She kept me informed every few days, which I appreciated! It could not have gone better for me. I truly appreciate Shelby and all of her leg work on my behalf. The techs did an amazing job and my car looks so pretty again! I will recommend them to anyone and everyone! Thanks guys, you rock! read more

I am relatively new to the Fort Collins area (5 months), and after being side swiped as I was exiting a parking lot, I did not know where to turn. I first went to two other auto body shops before approaching Set it Off Paint & Body. When entering Set it Off Pain & Body, both Adam and Josh welcomed me with warm greetings. Throughout the entire experience, Adam and Josh were accommodating and personable. Dealing with insurance can be a daunting task, but Adam and Josh went above and beyond, fighting for every penny I deserved, and then some. I can truly say that I found a shop that is trustworthy, in an industry that trust is often questioned and one can ever be 100 percent sure. Thank you Adam, Josh and the rest of the Set it Off Paint & Body team! Your service and above average restoration ability is truly appreciated. read more

Everyone at Set It Off Paint & Body were extremely helpful and did an amazing job on my Jeep Cherokee after I was in an accident. Shelby who works in the front office was very nice from the very beginning. She helped me understand the process and kept me updated along the way. My Jeep was in and out in about two weeks! The work they did speaks for itself, I would reccomend anyone in the area to go to Set It Off for any auto body needs! read more

See all

Everyone at Set It Off was very helpful and sincere after I was in my accident. They tried to help me repair a car that ultimately needed to be totaled, but gave me clear, unbiased information in the process. As a young female walking into this shop I didn't feel like I was being taken advantage of or shyster'd. They helped me navigate the situation and gave me a ton of advice even before I had decided to bring my car there. Although they were never actually given the opportunity to repair my vehicle, I was confident that they would've done a good job and tried to help me save some money where I could too. God forbid I have any problems in the future, I'll definitely be back! read more

I am the fleet manager for a small non profit that provides care for elderly and young adults with mental and physical disabilities. We provide a safe environment so the families and loved ones can continue to work with peace of mind. And we met Josh and Adam when were presented with an opportunity to get a van donated if we could remove a whole body wrap that had been on there for 12 years. I spent three days and tons of blisters scraping and got it all off as well as lots of paint. And so I began a journey of trying to find someone that would be willing to paint it out of the kindness of their hearts. And after many calls we found Josh. When we took our group of Veterans over to see their new van named Freedom in honor of our Veterans we all had tears in our eyes from the outstanding job that we were gifted. Our buses are old and tired but since then we have dedicated all of our business when their is the need for body work to this shop. They truly care about their customers and community. We would never ask for another donation but have total trust that Josh will treat us fairly and with outstanding workmanship. Thank you so much Josh and his team. read more

Set it off paint and body was very prompt, responsive, willing to work with me with my budgetary restrictions, and very professional. Their work made my car look like new. I would recommend them to anyone! read more

Fantastic! My tuck looks better than when purchased. Recently my truck was involved in an accident where the rear bumper was damaged as well as the rear quarter panel. I took it to Josh and the crew at Set It Off and was very pleased with their willingness to help make my situation better. I was pleased with their assessment of the damage and ability to relay that information to me in terms that I could understand. I feel that this shop went above and beyond to insure my standards were more than met and it showed in their finished work. I would highly recommend this shop over any other in Northern Colorado. read more

All of the employees at Set It Off have been amazing! Our 2015 WRX has been in twice now- once for a major repair after an accident, and a second time for a bumper repair after an incident with a raccoon. Both times, Adam and Josh were both so courteous, timely, and great at communicating with us along the way. The first time they promised us that the repaired side of our vehicle would look better than the original- I didn't think it was possible- but they were right! Our car looks perfect once again, and we had no surprises along the way. We have previously taken a vehicle to Abra for repairs, and Set It Off is leagues ahead, both in customer service as well as the quality work they do. We are so happy with the way they have also seamlessly handled our insurance claims. Finally, they support the community, including donating to nonprofits. I can not recommend them highly enough! read more

I highly recommend Set It Off Paint & Body for all your paint and body repair needs. Unfortunately I needed their services twice within a six month period and both times they exceeded my expectations. In addition to the outstanding repair work they did on my car, the customer service they provided was the best I have received from any industry in years - bar none. read more

Set it off just completed a small job, painted fenders for my motorcycle. They came back PERFECT!! I had to buy a new tank, the fenders look new also. Friendly staff, honest and quality service. read more

When for a quote for a basic repaint for $20,000.00.... wow... lol... buyer beware!!!

Set it off has once again created a master piece , I wanted a paint job that was an eye stopper . not only did they deliver they knocked it out of the park .although I chose an outlandish color josh took that paint wand and made it come to life ! Not everyone will agree with my colors , but the workmanship shines . THANK YOU JOSH AND THE CREW OF SET IT OFF !!!!!!! read more

See all

From start to finish I have been absolutely impressed and appreciative of the work done by the folks at Set it Off Paint and Body. I picked up my car on Friday after dropping it off on Tuesday for repairs from a parking lot collision. I was adamant about hoping to have it back for the weekend, and I received a call first thing Friday morning that it was ready to go. The exterior work looked perfect, and on top of that, I was delightfully surprised to find they had nicely vacuumed and cleaned out the entire interior of my car, which was looking pretty rough when I had dropped it off. Adam and his team were wonderfully communicative and accommodating, in addition to providing top-quality work that matched the estimate exactly. This was the first time I'd had to have repairs done on a vehicle, and I was so grateful for how patient and helpful the team at Set it Off was throughout the process. They definitely went above and beyond expectations and I would recommend them in a heartbeat! THANKS GUYS! read more

I have a custom car that received some fiberglass damage. Josh and his crew were more than up to the task at repairing the damage and matching the paint. They were able to get the work done very quickly and the results are great. I took the car to a car show the next day and even after telling people that there had been repair work done, nobody could believe it. The guys at Set It Off are great to work with and I plan on bringing more work their way! read more

Josh and the rest of the crew at Set It Off are simply the best. They did an amazing job with my '06 Matrix after an accident. They have impeccable customer service, great communication throughout the repair process and they worked with my insurance company to get the job done right with no surprises. I cannot recommend them highly enough - you wont be disappointed! read more