New Mexico 01-2024 Shaffer Hotel in city of Mountaire. There is a lot of hiking and day trip opportunities just steps away from this gorgeous sun drenched little burg. But today it was cold as a Wells Digger Butt. Only 6 degrees. We stopped at the Shaffer Hotel which shares a building with the restaurant and according to signage a ghost or 2. The waitress was very nice. The interior design was very eclectic and extremely Southwestern busy...I ordered a Iced tea With lemon And BLT on toast with French fries Tony ordered a Iced tea also with a burger. Our food was very good. Definitely will go back if ever in the area. Highly recommend for toy to check it out, it's awesome!!! read more

See all

I rented a suite for several months while my homestead was being built.Very clean, amazing prices, friendly staff.

Went to the Shaffer dining room, after a camp out at Fourth of July campground and checking out the Quari ruins (reviews on those too). They were nice to allow me come in with my dog, not to mention the gave him some good water and some bacon for being a well behaved dog. I had the burger and fries with lemonade. Sorry didn't take pics of the food. It was very good. Took half of it home and had it for dinner. Heating it up was just as good. Place was clean, staff was friendly and the price was reasonable. If you are heading out in the Mountainair area stop and have a bite to eat.Enjoy the drive. read more

Shaffer Hotel - Hotels Near Me - Mountainair, New Mexico

See all

Our group of 12 arrived for lunch at 1pm and the cafe had about 4-5 other tables occupied. The place runs with just one cook and one waitress. Reading some of the recent reviews, my expectations were lowered starting out but I was blown away. The artwork everywhere is interesting, very historic atmosphere. Eclectic furniture. The waitress was so nice and attentive and handled the regular lunch crowd plus our group with efficiency and grace. Food was hot and fresh. Most of us had burgers, but a salad, a breakfast and a couple NM specialties were ordered as well and everyone cleaned their plates. We even had a free history lesson from the lady working in the gallery regarding the origins of the hotel and the subsequent owners. This was a great stop for lunch while we toured the local mission ruins. read more

Out on a motorcycle ride and stopped for lunch. There was 10 of us. Service was great, food was very good. What a neat old hotel with lots of history. read more

The rooms and hotel were not clean. Coffee area was dirty and understocked. My room had the towels rack missing, wasn't the cleanest, no windows and a huge spot on the wall with no plaster from water damage. In my friends room the door could not be locked. Carpet was stained and the baseboards were dirty. The stairs and lobby needed to be cleaned, swept, vacuumed and dusted. It is a historic 101 year old hotel, need maintenance and deep cleaned everywhere.​ read more

I am not one to write reviews but in this case I felt I needed to. . I spent the last couple of days in Mountanair, NM (1/22-1/24/25). It's a lovely small town. My friend had to be in Albuquerque and I had a 5 hour drive south but we decided we wanted to have breakfast in the historical Schafer Inn before we left even though it didn't open until 10. We arrived about 10:10 and the doors were still locked. Thankfully the very nice La Galeria next door was open. Linda Marie was so nice to give us the history of the Schafer Inn while we waited. The hotel opened 30 minutes late and the only employee (wearing both cook and waitress hats) was one the phone almost the entire time we were there. We gave her our orders. My friend ordered huevos rancheros and I asked for one egg over easy and a piece of bacon. Our drinks were water for my friend and I asked for tea. I should have been more specific since I got iced tea instead of hot tea but I figured it was my error. Eventually we're were given our breakfasts. They were inedible. I was given the basic breakfast even though I had asked for just one egg and one piece of bacon. Again, it wasn't a big deal. However the eggs were cold as well as everything that was on my plate. The hash fries did not even resemble potatoes. They were dried out and rock hard. The bacon was microwaved and was also devoid of any moisture. It was inedible! The toast was cold and the jelly was brown in color but was a name brand grape jelly. My friends breakfast was a total mess, cold and also inedible. How difficult is it to make breakfast? I have never had such a horrible meal. McDonalds would be considered gourmet next to this meal. I would rate it as minus since I ate none of mine and the waitress made it clear she didn't want to be there. It's such a shame since it's a lovely town and the building itself is a true gem. Shame on the Schafer for charging for inedible food read more

First of all, let me explain that this 5 star review is a bit different than the usual reasons for rating a business 5 stars. Actually the case could be made that the reason I rated it so high was, in fact, because the Shaffer Hotel/Diner/Gallery, has nothing in common with other 5 star hotels. 5 stars to most people means, luxurious rooms and amenities, fine dining, exclusive access to the property and a gallery that most of us would not feel comfortable walking into. However, the Shaffer Hotel offers an experience that none of these properties could even get close to. First of all, the Shaffer Hotel is located in the middle of Mountainair, New Mexico. It's a quaint town that is ready to welcome you with open-arms. No traffic, no parking problems, no hustle and bustle, no platinum credit cards needed. The hotel was built in 1923. It retains virtually all of the features in construction and architecture that instantly transports you back to the days when "luxury" meant a place where you could come in from the cold, enjoy a good meal and get a good's night rest in a comfortable room. An interesting fact about the Shaffer is that the builder, Clem "Pop" Shaffer, after experiencing a fire which destroyed a blacksmith shop he owned, built the hotel using concrete filled with metal machine parts, pipes, old car parts and any other pieces of metal he could lay his hands on. It should also be noted, that if you look at the pictures of the exterior of the hotel and in various places of the interior of the diner you will see what we now call, "swastikas." This symbol back in 1923 - long before the rise of Hitler in Germany - was a symbol used by Native American Tribes like the Navajos and Hopis to mean peace and goodwill. Even after the rise of Adolf Hitler, "Pop" Shaffer definately refused to relinquish this symbol to an evil dictator in a foriegn land. The rooms, by today's standards are small. Most have a double-bed, maybe a chair and a separate bathroom. However, there are other "cowboy" rooms, which just have a bed and chair with restrooms down the hall. You can literally feel the history all around you with every step you take into the lobby and up the stairway to the rooms. Are these accommodations for everyone? Absolutely not. However, if you and your family would like to literally "get away from it all" you will get this in spades at the Shaffer. The diner, which re-openned in June of 2019, offers breakfast, lunch and dinner. All of the items are priced between $5.00 to $9.00. The meals are prepared "to order" in a kitchen at one end of the diner. The food is hot and flavorful and the service is welcoming and relaxed. It's not fancy, but oh so enjoyable! The gallery is just a few steps from the diner. It's a great way to enhance your overall experience at the Shaffer. The atmosphere is peaceful. The artwork (provided by several different artists) offers a range of different styles and subject matter. When we were there, one of the owners/artists, Linda, explained the origin of many of the pieces. She fascinated with stories about the history of the Shaffer and the people who were part of it's incredible backstory. If you should be lucky enough to visit the Shaffer and wander into the Gallery, ask Linda about the ghosts at the Shaffer. So how can a hotel with creaky floors, small rooms and basic amenities, with a diner that offers basic home-cooked meals at great prices and an art gallery that offers you a cultural experience in a welcoming, "come as you are" atmosphere merit a FIVE star review? Simple really...the Shaffer and the town of Mountainair offers you an experience that can't be matched anywhere else. read more

See all

Had a great time eating and staying at this off beat little spot. Didn't see any ghost, but had a vibe like you might. read more

Shaffer Hotel - Hotels Near Me - Mountainair, New Mexico

This is a very nice inn in tiny Mountainair, NM. They had just recently opened when I stayed there. Although they overlooked a few things, the inn keeper was quick to remedy any oversights. There is diner there with an amazing breakfast. Also coffee and water provided in the second floor, very nice. read more

Great atmosphere but the food was subpar. Brisket tacos were dry and salty, couldn't finish one. Salad showed up after all the entrees were already half eaten. Half inch of water in the bottom of the salad bowls. Kept having t ask for things that were already ordered....the list goes on. What's the issue with Mountainair? Everywhere from the grocery store to the restaurants you get mediocre food and rude service. read more

I work on Wind Turbines and travel alot, I find myself in the middle of nowhere New Mexico (Mountainair) and found the Shaffer Hotel and Restaurant. The Family that runs this hotel could not be any nicer! The hotel was build in 1923 and has some indian symbols on the building and the fence that look like Swatsaks but I asure you they are not. This hotel has been on Ghost Hunters and they have had a lot of inquires about weather this hotel is haunted or or not. The Hotel was remodeled a few years back and is very clean. They have 5 cowboy rooms witch is a bed and then you share a bathroom, they have 3 suites room 12 The honey moon suite is amazing! They have 10 more rooms that have private bathrooms.One room that is Handicap accessible. A banquet room and a meeting room. Along with free inter-net that works!!! A Game room, and a work out room, the hotel also has Dishnet work, the only down fall is the TV's are on the small side. There is a Restaurnt and a art shop, I haven't beeen in the shop yet but I've been to the Restaurant everyday! They have the best food in Town. It's not a large menu but there's enough on the menu to find something Different on a daily basis. So if you're looking for something to do check this historic build out! If you would like to research this hotel morego to there website www.shafferhotel.com and maybe a google search on Clem "pop" Shaffer. I hope this review is helpful! read more

See all

This is a view for the restaurant alone. We had lunch today in the Shaffer Hotel Dining Room. My wife had a patty melt while I had the Chili Relleno. There was very little about either meal that we enjoyed. As prices go, we felt both were overpriced at $8 each plus $2 each for a drink. The atmosphere was interesting and worth the visit. We would not visit the dining room again. The dining room had a one minute spot in the movie "My One and Only" with Renee Zellweger sitting the the dining room. Perhaps that's enough of a reason to visit, you might sit in the same chair that Renee sat. read more

Shaffer Hotel - This is the view seen in the movie "My One and Only" - Hotels Near Me - Mountainair, New Mexico

Stayed at this amazing place a couple of years back, while on the trail of Billy the Kid with a friend who lives in New Mexico. I was so pleased that he dug it up, versus some chain hotel somewhere. The hotel had great character and the dining room was just unique and amazing, both in architecture and cuisine. The hotel was was a quaint and cool experience all-around. I'm so sad to learn that it has closed. read more

This restaurant has evidently changed management since we were there this spring. We were SO disappointed today with our food. I had an awful patty melt with soggy fries. We have eaten there previously and the food was really good. Don't know what happened. The waitress was disinterested at best. We won't be going out of our way to visit Mountainair again. read more

My fiance and I recently held our wedding reception at the Shaffer. In general the staff was very nice and the food was good. However, the owner of the hotel is irresponsible and does not care about her guests. Every time we went in, to make arrangements, and even the day of our wedding, we had to ring the buzzer repeatedly - no response - before finally entering the hotel via the restaurant. When we made the last deposit, she tried to get extra money out of us for rooms already paid for, lost her copy of the signed contract, and then tried to convince us to change the contract that had already been signed by myself and a member of her staff for services to be provided. She blatantly ignored all of the instructions and requests we made, and indicated that while one of her staff remembered, she chose to ignore this staff member. As an example, three hours before the start of the reception, she called me to ask if the reception was at 4 or 6 pm - she thought it was at 6, her staff member thought it was at 4; the staff member was correct, and this information was stated in the signed contract (which, as stated, was misplaced). She also walked around the reception hall in extremely casual clothing refilling drinks - we wish that she had left this to the servers (who were extremely polite and helpful, and to whom we are very grateful). Additionally, I barely got to eat at my own wedding reception because every time I picked up my fork, she walked over to ask another question - all questions were supposed to be directed to one of our groomsmen so my new husband and I could enjoy the reception and mingle with our guests uninterrupted. It was very difficult to enjoy our reception with her constant interruptions, usually to confirm event details that had been discussed with her and other hotel staff at least a week before. It may also seem nitpicky, but my name was also blatantly misspelled on the door to the banquet hall, when hotel staff had it written down in at least three locations - and all of the guests noticed and commented on the error, to my great embarrassment. All in all, the staff were very nice, the bridal suite was extremely nice, and the hotel was nice enough to comp our breakfast the following morning. However, the owner herself is very scatterbrained and needs to act in a more professional manner towards her paying customers. After the beautiful ceremony, the reception was a gigantic letdown. If you want to stay at the hotel, we recommend it, but we don't advise holding large events there as long as the owner is this unprofessional. read more