Wow what a Cake! My…read moresister arranged for a wonderful lemon cake from Naked Cake for my Mom's 90th Birthday. The cake was spectacular and the hit of the party. My Mom was quite particular in wanting a lemon cake, not too heavy but just perfectly sweet. It was as ordered. In addition to the cake were these wonderful tarts that allowed for the guests to choose. =The cake when on the plate looked like you would never be able to get through a piece because it was so rich but that was not the case. I also loved the lemon taste, as lemon can so many times be too tart or too bland - it was just right! Highly recommended!

Found by chance while searching for a wedding cake maker. Melissa was excellent in talking with us…read moreand determining our ideas, needs, and preferences. The cake and cupcakes were beautiful, and bonus points for accommodating my dietary concerns: celiac and nut allergy. In short, highly recommended, would definitely use again.

Love all the baked good there, beef pie and sausage rolls are my favourite and can't forget the…read morebutter Scotties. Great desserts, pies and jelly doughnuts to. Hummy hummy hum!!

Elmvale bakery is a quaint bakery located in the heart of Elmvale. When we arrived around 1pm,…read morethere was a line to the back of the store, however it moved quickly. There are a variety of menu options including both sweet and savory pastries, breads and pies. We ordered a peach and mango strudel and a dessert square with assorted berries. Both desserts were flavourful and very tasty. Will definitely be back!

Tiny place with an awesome amount of selection. For me the donuts were the hit. This place is just…read morea one min walk off of the Main Street. Been going for over 20 years. Breads are great as well. Selection becomes thinner in the afternoon. Absolutely worth the stop

Went here on a Saturday late morning and was expecting long lines or for them to be all sold out…read morebut there was no lines and plenty to choose from. We tried a variety of their donuts and they were all delicious. My favourite was the coconut key lime, but the chocolate coconut and apple fritter were delicious too. Prices are typical for a nice bakery (just under 3 dollars for lost donuts, 4$ for apple fritters)

Went for lunch with a group today. The staff are very accommodating, allowing you to reserve a…read moretable ahead of time and come to the table to take your order, even with customers at the counter. Our meal was quick to our table and served hot and fresh. Today's soup was tomato vegetable which was interesting, a new spin that I hadn't tried before. I paired it with a tuna fish sandwich which was fresh. Our group enjoyed a selection of dessert squares after which were also excellent. We were all thanked for coming in too which I think goes a long way.

When I was planning my wedding, Paula's was the first place I thought of for my wedding cake…read more Everyone there is friendly and helpful and the prices seem reasonable. I chose the 'Wedgwood' cake since I have always loved Wedgwood dishes, and it turned out to be a pretty cake that looked great with my cake topper. I am not usually a fan of store-bought cake in general and especially white cake, but I actually kind of liked the taste of Paula's white cake, and I also liked the lemon although the flavor was pretty subtle. I found the cake also lasted well, and was still fairly moist a few days later. One thing Paula suggested was getting the main cake and an extra slab cake as well to accommodate all our guests, although as it turns out we only used little more than one layer of the main cake so it would have been enough, and we were eating leftover cake for days and pawning it off to relatives - I believe she meant well with the advice, but I would suggest brides look at whether they are having a lot of other food as well before deciding how much cake to get. I also purchased some squares for later in the evening because making and cutting them myself that day would be too much hassle. Unfortunately I had to request they not include my favorite peanut butter squares, and I was disappointed to find out the replacement square was rice crispy squares. To me, that is a child's food and not classy wedding food, as well as being something simple that I could have made and pre-cut myself. Besides that disappointment, the other squares were tasty and wedding-appropriate. Overall I would suggest being careful about the quantity of cake you get and I would suggest checking in advance what peanut-free squares they will include, but otherwise I would recommend Paula's Pantry for your wedding cake and desserts based on taste, appearance, and price.

Kate made a customer rainbow layered birthday cake for my wife's birthday and it was amazing!! The…read morecake looked awesome and tasted even better. Quick, friendly and at a good price. Kate is now my "go too" for cakes.

From the owner: Specialize in regular, gluten-free and vegan friendly cakes and cupcakesread more

I got my sons birthday and Grad cake custom made. The staff is good, they have lots of suggestions…read moreto pick from. The cake looked good , my son was happy and we loved the flavors. They have cupcakes, different flavored cookies, vegan cup cakes, something for everyone.

My daughters favorite place for sweet baked treats. they also have gluten and keto options.read more

Store is Closed. Lease of space available…read more Was excellent for years especially soup & sandwiches & cheesecake

Very small but cozy place. Bought a strudel as well as a Bienenstich (Bee Sting), fresh and tasty…read more Bienenstich had a distinct sweet flavour but very light, strudel was more on the sour type thanks to the fruits as is supposed to be and I love that. If you enjoy baked good I definitely recommend this place, it will not look like your typical high end bakery but it will definitely delight your taste buds.