We stopped in here on our way home from Beaufort. We wanted to buy some of the dairy products, but the one we'd gone to in Morehead City wasn't open yet. They were fully stocked so I got a few different things to try, including buttermilk, butter, and heavy cream. After eating all these at home, I can confirm that they're absolutely delicious! The flavor and richness and freshness are so much better than anything you get from the grocery store. I've made buttermilk ranch, buttermilk cornbread, and buttermilk waffles - all tasted perfect! This shop is also very cute and welcoming, super clean and well decorated. I didn't find the service to be as friendly as the location in Morehead City, but it was still a bit early in the day so nbd. read more

See all

I've been to the farm and other stores like this one and this family always does the best!! The ice cream is delicious and they have a great variety. They have many flavors of ice cream, even though I always get salty caramel!! They also have milks, packaged ice cream, sometimes butter and cheese, and so many other cute farm things. This new store is clean, wide open, and the folks are always friendly. We went in today, Saturday afternoon, to grab a treat. My husband wanted a milk shake, and the young woman gave him the suggestion of using chocolate milk instead of white milk. It was awesome!! She also suggested to me a sundae. She was very friendly and sweet and I'm sorry I did not get her name. I hope they have enough business to stay open here!! We will certainly be back. read more

Simply Natural Creamery - The counter of ice cream bins and toppings. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Wee are in and out of this place all the time. Not only is the ice cream good but they have milk that tastes like milk from my childhood on the farm. I buy pints but she always gets a waffle cone. Every flavor I've tasted has been exceptional. The ice cream parlor atmosphere and the smell of fresh waffle cones is very nostalgic. The staff is super nice and almost know our names. It's great. read more

We went here on a Saturday night around 7pm and everyone else also had a similar idea. Even though there was a decent crowd, I thought the line moved fast and the staff were friendly. The shop was super cute and I loved the theme throughout. We ordered the birthday cake in an ice cream cone bowl. It was definitely a great take on the birthday cake flavor and the cone was a nice touch. If you are debating how many scoops to get, 1 scoop is usually plenty as they are quite full scoops. We also got their lemonade and chocolate milk. The lemonade was more on the tart versus sweet side. The chocolate milk was okay, could have been a bit creamier. However, that is just a personal preference. I would definitely return to try another flavor of ice cream because they had so many amazing options. read more

Simply Natural Creamery - Birthday cake ice cream- 1 scoop. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

We love this place! So much so that we went 3 times during our week long visit to family in NC. We came in on a Saturday night and they had waves of busy moments but we did not have to wait long at all to be served. Beyond generous serving sizes too! They also have a drive through option and nice outdoor seating. So many different and delicious ice cream flavors with optional add ins or drinkable shakes. We bought some milk from the self serve fridges and made decadent buttermilk pancakes the next day. Also brought home a couple pints to share at home. The best part is that it's tummy friendly to lactose intolerant individuals!! read more

Simply Natural Creamery - Flavors and sizes for cups & cones. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

SOOOO GOOOOD Our family's first question is always, "Do you have anything dairy-free?" because one of us has a deadly milk allergy. When they told us that, yes, they had not one but two dairy-free sorbets, we were ALL IN! My dairy allergy person ordered mango sorbet, and let me tell you, it was the best darn sorbet I have ever tasted in my LONG life. This sorbet had actually little CHUNKS of mango in it, AND a swirl of Chamoy sauce!! To. Die. For. My chocolate shake person (because they are usually the driver) was able to get a chocolate shake, made with chocolate ice cream, AND with chocolate milk! He was soo happy. My super chocolate ice cream person was very happy with the warm brownie sundae, which had a swirl of fudge sauce lining the cup, complete with their choice of ice cream, whipped cream, and a cherry. I am the coffee and toffee person of the group, and I was so so happy with the coffee-toffee flavor...my two absolute favorite flavors in one ice cream! Even their waffle cone was hands-down delicious. I also had a scoop of chocolate peanut butter which was very good, but coffee-toffee I could do again and again. We were especially pleased that this ice cream is made with the much more digestible Jersey milk. We wish we lived nearby because WOW this place is amazing, and well worth the long line we waited on! Plus the kids behind the counter were really ON IT and friendly, despite the crowd. THANK YOU for being open late, and open on a holiday weekend when half of New Bern is shut down!! LOVED IT! read more

Delicious and generous portions...service very good with friendly staff. Very clean and brightly lite.

The ice cream is very good but how they make specialty items is inconsistent. I had a great hot fudge sundae the first time with all the fixings but the second time other than hot fudge there was nothing else on it. The third time was even worse. We were told they were not doing sundaes or specialty items because there were only 2 staff working that night. So scooping ice cream into a dish or cone was all they would do. And the store really wasn't busy. Not sure they will get a fourth chance. read more

The ice cream was delicious, great service. It's clean. There was a lot of people there.