1. Sky Island Lodge

1. Sky Island Lodge

0

Rodeo, NM

Cancel

Open app

Search

Sky Island Lodge

4.3 (3 reviews)

Sky Island Lodge Photos

Recommended Reviews - Sky Island Lodge

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Sky Island Lodge

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Hampton Inn Lordsburg - Meeting Room

Hampton Inn Lordsburg

(99 reviews)

$$

DIRTY ROOM-- Stayed there June 9, 2026 The next morning…read morewhile picking up my bags in the bathroom, I noticed poop under the toilet seat on the porcelain. Grabbed a Kleenex tried rubbing it off but it was dried hard. Also upon checking in, Found part of a tortilla chip by the bathroom tub and Cotton swab under the sink on the floor with something on it. Please take note of the price increase of over $150 (You are paying for a swimming pool that is no longer there, and no more gym either, which is completely unfair) I strongly suggest considering other options before Staying here. Price goes up and quality goes down-- go figure.

Don't stay here we were very disappointed with the Hampton inn in lordsburg. To begin with we were…read morecalled and notified that the elevator was out of service. Had the call been earlier we probably would have changed hotels but it was a little late to find a place at that point. I was assuted someone would help with luggage. So we agreed to climb to the third floor. There was no one to assist with luggage When I entered the room I went to adjust the thermostat on the air conditioning system and the cover for the controls fell off in my hand. It was broken. Then I went into the bathroom and found there was no toilet paper holder. It had been pulled from the wall and removed from the room. When I advised the desk clerk that the holder was missing she said she would note it for maintenance. I think maintenance already knew or would have still been in the room. The bed must have been in that room for 15 years to have depressions as deep as it does. Likewise the pillows are little balls of something that are not very comfortable. There are no longer any amenities in the room such as makeup mirrors. We ask for at the front desk for a mirror but there were not available. It's as if the rooms have been stripped of all the things that used to be there for the convenience of the traveler. Primarily because of the elevator when we checked in we asked it was possible to get a discount on the room. We were advised that it would be difficult since we had paid in advance but that she would check with the manager. When I called about the toilet paper holder being missing again requested a discount because of the condition of the room and the elevator I got the same sndwer. At this point I've heard from no one about anything. None of these things would have been true in any of the Hampton inns I've stayed in before. It was very disappointing and my last day in a Hampton Inn.

Portal Peak Lodge & Store - Lodge Room

Portal Peak Lodge & Store

(19 reviews)

$$

Portal Finding a delicious, healthy restaurant in the…read moreoutback is always an unexpected treat. Good food, good music, great service. Huevos rancheros from their brunch menu, trout perfectly cooked and a Greek salad with fresh greens at dinner. Authentic latte from their Italian espresso machine. Friendly servers who check back often and bring extra salsa on request and who had no problem loaning us two of their mugs to use in our room for morning coffee. When we expressed our appreciation of the musical selections playing on their sound system, the owner explained that it was a random mix of "stations" selected by various employees over the last 16 years! This was our second visit while on a road trip in two successive years. Will we be back again? What do you think?

My review is only for the Motel portion of the Portal Lodge. My first room was unmade so I…read morerequested an alternate room. Good news, the second room was clean. The downside was the unavoidable decor and atmosphere. If you dial the wayback machine to the 1960's then you can imagine the room. The interior was extremely dark with a small window facing onto a common deck. The curtains were drawn because otherwise any guest walking by could look inside. Hence it was an exceptionally dark room with a small amount of filtered light. Updating the furnishings, painting the inside, etc. would make a huge improvement. Overall, I would have vastly preferred camping. Unfortunately, I didn't think of that ahead of time and had already booked 2 nights at the lodge. After one night I found the lodge too depressing and returned to Tucson. I did not request a refund since it was my mistake and the lodge needs the money for room renovation. The Portal region itself is fantastic. Great hiking, birding, and so on.

The Gadsden Hotel - Gorgeous

The Gadsden Hotel

(87 reviews)

$$

We have stayed here twice, and our latest this week was a great improvement from the first a decade…read moreago. This place is worth staying at just to soak up the history and ambiance. The staircase and stained glass are not to be missed. When you stand in the lobby look around you, you feel transported to another era. The rooms are much improved and comfortable, though the bathrooms are small by modern standards. Be patient for the hot water. The restaurant was great for dinner - see photos of our meals below. We started with cocktails in the bar and the bartender really does a great job. The service here was flawless - everyone was super helpful and pleasant. One thing: there is no place for breakfast here. We bought muffins the night before and made do with the Keurig coffee maker. Our destination early the next morning was Whitewater draw for the cranes - its about a 30 minute drive from the hotel.

The only think I would say that was great with this hotel is the interior decorations and…read morehistorical background.  But other than that, I would say its very worn down.  The governor suite didn't have hot water for my whole stay. When I reported it, the front desk person said there's nothing they could do. They didn't offer any solutions.  The queen suite had a weird smell throughout my stay. Almost like a moldy smell. Everyday I also smelled cigarettes coming through to my room.  Front desk service was very slow. The pillows were VERY uncomfortable. The remote in the room was damaged and didn't work.  Over all I don't think the workers care about their customers. I wouldn't stay here again.

Sky Island Lodge - hotels - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...