Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency

    1.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Get a quote

    You can now request a quote from this business directly from Yelp

    Services - Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency

    Homeowner or property

    Car and truck insurance

    Life insurance

    Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency

    Recommended Reviews - Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Philleo Agency Insurance - Team Philleo

    Philleo Agency Insurance

    (23 reviews)

    Insurance- yep not the sexiest thing to talk about but you simply have to have it. I've read in…read moreseveral financial columns, magazines and online that it's smart to review your coverage every once on awhile. I recently received my annual homeowners renewal notice and decided now would be a good time to shop around. Especially since they were increasing my premium- not a huge increase but nonetheless an increase and like everyone I want to be smart with my money. I decided to call an independent agency as they will do all the leg work for you, compare companies and find the best coverage for your situation. I called Philleo Agency Insurance in Brookfield and what a stroke of luck that was! Jenna Starr took my call and listened to what I needed. She asked me many detailed questions about my home and current coverage. Then she asked me to send over my current insurance company's declaration of coverage so that she could do a thorough comparison. After 3 days Jenna called me and was excited to tell Me she found me some great coverage, for BOTH my home and car, much more than I currently had and for less money. She emailed me The paperwork so we could review it. Then a few days later we met in her office and went over all the coverage and numbers. I was amazed at the increase in coverage including a one million dollar umbrella policy and it cost me much less- Than I was currently paying. The company I am now with is A+ rated too. Philleo is a small agency and I like the fact that they actually have an office that I can walk into and talk to my agent. I also like that when I call a human picks up the phone- none of this "press 1 if you want blah blah blah..." sometime I just want to talk to a person! They truly know the meaning of customer service. The personal touch was evident in all our conversations. I certainly hope I will never have to call Jenna with a claim BUT if I do, I know I will be well taken care of. Jenna handled everything even cancelling my current policy. It was a total "No-brainer" MORE Coverage for LESSI money. I am so happy I finally reviewed my current home and auto policies and that I called Philleo Agency Insurance. If you need insurance (and you do!) or if you need to review your current policies ( and you should!) then give Jenna Starr at Philleo Agency Insurance a call. Your wallet will thank you ;)

    This was my first time seeing our insurance entirely on my own so I was worried about how…read morefrustrating it would be. However, Jessica Beaman and the business is amazing. She responded quickly to my calls and emails. I felt that I understood the entire process and received the best deal. I greatly appreciate how kind and helpful Jessica was while we went through the different steps. It would highly recommend this business (and Jessica) to anyone seeking out assistance finding insurance coverage. Insurance is not easy to understand but I feel much more knowledgeable now. Someone else recommended this business to me and I'm very grateful that they did!

    Allstate Insurance: Dave Kelley

    Allstate Insurance: Dave Kelley

    (5 reviews)

    I've been holding off writing this until my mom was able to write to Dave himself personally which…read moreI believe she has now done. My parents had Allstate home and auto for 38 years and were with Dave and his office specifically for I believe at least 10 of those years. Their home on 52nd and Cleveland was flooded due to once again the city's terrible job of water management and the basement walls caved in, scaring them as elders terribly. The house was a loss. My parents were so upset and shook that I took over the process of dealing with insurance and the City of Milwaukee. Of course I was told that they didn't have flood insurance but when I asked about sewer backup insurance I was told by an agent that my parents didn't have that either.....My mom said it was never offered and this is the first time she's heard of it. Never the less, the agent I spoke with told me that if he were to "get in the Allstate car and come out to the house, it was going to be denied as a claim and their insurance would GO UP!!!" Mind you, they never made a SINGLE CLAIM in those 38 years!! To add insult to injury they never received so much as a phone call, email, letter, ANYTHING from Dave himself personally to say sorry for their loss. Thanks for 38 years of premiums though, right? I suppose this review will be put on the "have to download the app" like the one other bad review while the good reviews are there for all to see. Of course Allstate and Dave have been dropped since. Be careful of these insurance people folks!! Sincerely, John Treuden Jr

    First the agent Corrissa Kelley stayed late to set up our policy. Second the team helped when the…read moreold agencie Firehouse Insurance and provider Integrity Insurance failed to cancel the old policy. They helped again when the same idiots were trying charge me $153 for earned premium for my new vehicle which the failed to properly cover for seven months. Corrissa, Dawn, Craig and James are an excellent team.

    Smith & Hatch Insurance Agency - homeinsurance - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...