Loved it! Incredibly kind and helpful staff and really fun finds! Was in town visiting family and…read morewe took a break to check out a local place for a welcome change and distraction from the usual. Got an extra blanket for the hotel and a cool tee with the name of a local NY record store which matches a completely different local bar where we are from. All that and an insane jumpsuit! Would go again, for sure!

Great store and very kind staff! They have a wide selection of items. Definitely will be coming…read moreback.

Hands down the best furniture Consignment store around…read more Everything is honest and straightforward. Great stuff prices right. Massive turn over of merchandise. Great teak furniture they bring over from Indonesia. Solid heavy grade A teak unbeatable price.

I originally lived close by in Bayville and would stop in almost every weekend to check on current…read moreinventory. I love this family-owned shop and continue to shop there from the nearby Huntington area. Most of my original oil paintings, marble consoles and art glass came from attic door. Yes, it's a small shop - but also a treasure. Because it's a consignment shop, inventory frequently changes. I never found anyone condescending to me and the prices were very reasonable. I also check out their Instagram and Facebook occasionally to see if there is something of interest to me

Great customer service. The new store looks great. I love what the new owner did with the new…read morechanges and exciting merchandise. Wide range of selection of jewelry and china.

I never even made it into the store, because I went there on both a Wed. and Thurs. in July, and it…read morewas closed, even though the hours posted on the door said they should be open. Not a way to run a business.

Lots of interesting, and even one-of-a-kind items! So much to look at. There is literally something…read morefor everyone here! Antique, Vintage, Handmade, and New items!

I can see that nobody gives a crap about this place with so few reviews but whatever…read more I returned here after being away for a while and my last visit here was many months ago - the placed seemed half empty (or half FULL if you like). I can tell vendors were "pulling out". But things kinda (?) changed here . They now are back to being FULL again however - but all the prices are very high now! The dealers here seem to do what ALL DOPEY ANTIQUE DEALERSHIPS do : They blindly look up prices on ebay or the internet . This is not a good practice because PRICES ARE FLUID on collectibles and antiques. Always were , always will be. Again, it's all about not caring / not wanting to "move things along" - this is what retired vendors & dealers do. They probably have a pension check coming in and don't REALLY need the extra money. The staff here was less than helpful, less than friendly , less than knowledgeable and now sit "Floyd's Baber Shop" style with a round kitchen table in the middle of the store -- and you can hear all their takes on recent current events and the news . Oh wonderful ! I did buy a few OK / lower priced things here but I hope the dealers involved can get their act together and lower some of the stupid old fashioned prices on junk like Flintstones jelly glasses and old magazines that are collecting dust . (Crazy Prices of note: One average fashion magazine from the 1960s -- it was Vogue or something- was marked $75.00 . So it clearly was somebody looking up internet prices - saw one rare issue of Italian Vogue - either sold or was merely asking for $75.00 - and bingo : he thinks his is ALSO worth $75.00 ). Stupid.

Lots of fun things there! Very neat and clean, especially for a thrift store! Everything also for a…read moregood price!

Stopped in on my way to dinner to look at the dvd selection. I bought a dvd and a book. It's a…read moresmall store but they have a great selection of clothes that are brand new from closing sales and donations. Chris was very friendly from start to finish. He let me know that they post videos on their instagram showing what they have in store and you can call to place an item on a short hold if you see something that you're willing to come in to get which is really nice. They also do giveaways on their instagram. The books and dvds were very reasonably priced !

This antique store appears to be a small unassuming store. However, once you enter the store you…read moreimmediately realize that it is smaller on the outside and bigger on the inside. Once you enter the store there is a plethora and an incredible diversity of antiques carefully sectioned according to theme. Owned by Sabbath and assisted by Laura, the customer can easily get lost and forget the time. I found so many interesting items I didn't have the time to completely see everything. Initially, I telephoned the store searching for an antique candlestick telephone. Laura advised me she had one and she'd place it on the side till I could get to the store and not to worry. When I went to the store I met Laura who was very friendly, patient, knowledgeable and informative. Many of the antiques are subject to price negotiation unless otherwise marked. Once I called the store seeking an antique Edison wax cylinder phonograph. Although they had none available, I was referred to other antique stores in the nearby area that might have what I was looking for. The owner, Sabbath, is a very friendly person who owns this treasure land and is also very friendly, knowledgeable and will work with the customer. Laura is totally the same. I'm happy to rate Antique Attic with the highest rating possible and if you're ever in the area, please stop in and meet Sabbath and Laura. Respectfully submitted.

One of my fave antique stores ! I try to pop in weekly to see what's new . Owners are so nice and…read moreprices are great. So many items for everyone and selection is great!!!!

my favorite thrift store! i got a furby and a paris hilton playboy magazine! highly recommend for…read moreall your nostalgia needs!

Spoke to Trish on the phone and she was very very nice. That's one of the first things I look for…read morewhen doing any type of business. Believe it or not people like Brian and Trish are hard to come by.

Not the greatest consignment shop around. Many other shops in locust valley that have more variety…read moreof stuff.

Valley Attic is a unique and special store filled with gems!…read more I've been doing business with "the sisters" for over 7 years and recommend them to anyone and everyone. They are dedicated, provide personalized assistance and care about their consigners and buyers. They truly want the best outcome for all. Although it is second hand store, they only accept first quality high end items and unusual finds, which makes shopping and consigning such a positive experience. They have an amazing eye and have curated an inventory filled with items that you will rarely find anywhere else. The Items are often posted on Instagram so you are always up-to-date on what pieces are coming in, another unique feature. Calling all kinds of customers, including Stagers and Decorators. Just visit and you will be addicted, too. Valley Attic transactions are always pleasure!