Best NY style pizza in the Pinehurst area. The wait is worth it. There is a reason you have to wait in line and then wait 15 - 20 minutes for your pie to come out. Ask for crispy if that is what you like. His red sauce is also very tasty and combined with his dough, he gets the #1 rating. I just moved here from NYC where I lived for 67 years so I think I am a good judge. His meatball parm hero is also excellent. Tasty meatballs with his spicy sauce combined with fresh mozzarella cheese and good bread combine for a treat. This is our go to place for pizza and meatball parm hero's. So far that is all we have tried so possibly more recommendations to come down the road. read more

SoPies Pizza - Meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

Lots of street parking! Place was busy. We ordered the pizza to be picked up later in the afternoon (I highly recommend this) We ordered the Buffalo Chicken pizza- cheese on half- it had just enough heat - the crust was very thin and the cheese stayed on half. The Buffalo wings were good- the blue cheese- didn't have chunks- just cream. The carnivore pizza was good- not much sauce, meat was flavorful. When I went to pickup- there was not clear instructions on where to go? After asking a couple of people we got it! You can always go in and get slices. read more

SoPies Pizza - Carnivore pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

SoPies Pizza serves the best New York-style pizza I've had. The pizza was delicious, flavorful, and had the perfect crispy crust. In fact, it was better than some of the pizza I've had back home in New Jersey. The garlic knots were outstanding as well- huge, buttery, and packed with garlic flavor. They were served with a tasty marinara sauce that paired perfectly with them. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm in NC. read more

Staff were super friendly. The place is busy and they could get away with mediocre service but made me feel welcome. The manager (owner?) treated his staff well and was working the line just like they were. Seemed organized and like everyone knew their job. Definitely will go back. Was a bit pricey which seems to be the norm these days. read more

Great pizza spot when you feel like treating yourself to more than delivery (ahem papa John's or dominos). We called on a Saturday so the wait was an hour. We tried the nonna which is absolutely amazing! So good. I loved the sauce so wanted more of it, buts it's almost cheese stick like taste is great. We also had the gluten free pizza and it was very good! As a gluten lover myself, I found it hard to tell it was any different. read more

SoPies Pizza - Gluten free pepperoni and pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

See all

My brother ordered it for Christmas Eve while we were visiting. We got two pizzas (one was cheese, another pepperoni), they were great. We also got the fried ravioli (okay), and a salad with ranch (what you expect from a side salad with ranch). read more

Be prepared to wait. Man - it's so hard to balance a review between food & service! Let's start with food: Great selection to choose from. Pizza is delicious. I had the calzone. For $19.99, I assumed it was going to be huge. It is. Definitely will feed 4 people. It was delicious with tons of cheese. Hot sandwiches are good, too. My biggest reason for giving 3 rather than 4 stars is it took over 40 minutes for me to get my calzone. Everyone else at my table received their order & finished eating....and I still waited. Literally everyone in the 6pm Saturday night crowd came & left .... & my calzone still wasn't done. No exaggeration- people walked in, ordered, & left with their food, but mine hadn't been made. I heard the staff lead shout, "Make two spare cheese," so at 30 minutes I asked about my calzone. "We're starting it now. Give us 8 minutes." Finally Now? At 40 minutes I'm asked how I want it cut, and a few minutes later it is ready. That's just poor management. It appears they gave my husband his premade pizza slices, & discarded the rest of our order. You'll also need to know that just because they have pizza slices already ready & you just want 1 or 2 slices, it'll still take a few minutes to get your pizza. It's good food. I'd like to go again, but I'm not a fan of wasting my time. read more

Was told by many to try SoPies. We recently moved to area for a short term stay. We will be eating here at least once a week till we head back to NY. This place has NY pizza ! Bravo! read more

This place has really gone downhill since I last had a slice here, within the past year. Bought a deluxe slice today & it was mediocre at best: not served hot enough, meat & veggies looking pretty sad, outer crust barely brown. But it was the best looking of all the pies they had by the slice, all of which looked way undercooked, not browned or bubbly. Harris Teeter serves a way better slice than these folks, and for less money. read more

My boyfriends' parents recommended SoPies to us, so we stopped here after our four hour drive from Virginia to Pinehurst. I was starving so the pizza really hit the spot and I destroyed almost half the pie in one sitting. We got half bbq chicken without bacon and half white pizza, both of which we delicious. The person taking our order was also very sweet and friendly :). They have some limited seating but the restaurant is more conducive to takeout imo. Note that they charge a fee for cards so our total was a couple dollars extra. Would recommend paying with cash if you're able to as it was a higher fee than I'm used to seeing. read more

SoPies Pizza - 1/2 bbq chicken, 1/2 white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

Amazing- years of searching for a real NYC Pizza in both Southwest VA and now North Carolina and we found it! When you walk in and see the boxes piled up and see the slices of pizza waiting it just feels like you walked into a real NYC pizza place. It feels like a real pizza place, it sounds like a real pizza place and best of all the pizza tastes like real NYC pizza. I hear the meatballs are awesome but I was there for the pizza. Right by the train station in Southern Pines. We drive from Raleigh. Will do it again! read more

SoPies Pizza - I asked for the crust to be NYC done- that means crispy crust- and they delivered. - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

Unfortunately found hair in my salad and cooked into the pizza. I called and they didn't believe me. read more

SoPies Pizza - Hair - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

We cannot praise Reese enough for her kindness and patience with our order. We had an amazing time and the food was delish!!

Food is good, ambience is nice, however, don't try to ask for military discount there because it was like pulling teeth just for them to apply it even tho they offer it. It made me as a customer feel very uncomfortable. read more

Brings me back to Watertown days, They have great pizza close to Napoli's taste. We will definitely be back. Really boston, by way of pizza. Friendly staff and clean homy atmosphere. read more

See all

If you're looking for great pizza... this is it. Our options suck out in Hoke County and we have found our new place. It's a legit hole in the wall type of pizza place with a friendly staff. The pizza was perfectly cooked. They even had a pizza window that you could grab just a slice. We decided to eat inside since our kiddo was getting hangry. The pizza was SO hot it melted the knife. I asked at the pizza counter if they could cut it since it would be easier and quicker. Without hesitation they cut it up how I wanted it. We will be back!! read more

See all

Just moved here, have had takeout from here twice. Really good NY style slice and pie. Staff is super friendly. Have just ordered a pie and a salad, but I'm curious on the garlic knots bc I saw them being made and they looked amazing. This is gonna be my go-to pizza spot read more

Great Pizza! We were staying in Pinehurst and had it last week. It is the best in the area!

By far the best pizza in NC! The only problem you'll have with SoPies is wanting it all that time

The pizza was alright, a little burnt here and there, missing some sauce here and there but over all alright. Slices came out quick and the free refils were nice. The cashiers were polite. The restaurant Felt small and like a hole in the wall, there were chairs in the mens bathroom. read more

Found this place on Yelp and decided to go one night for dinner. We got there around 4, before the dinner rush. Off street parking is available, but minimal. The storefront isn't huge, but there are a few tables inside-- seat yourself. High chairs are available. You can see the employees tossing the dough from your table. Plates, straws, utensils, water, and cups are all self serve. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, buffalo wings, and mozz sticks. Everything came quickly! The pizza, especially, was delicious! Probably the best pizza we've had since we've lived in the area. My husband really enjoys pepperoni and they loaded it on. The wings were tasty, but they were more expensive than usual due to the chicken shortage. I have no complaints about the mozz sticks either. I think there were six in the basket and they came with a side or marinara. We had so much food, we ended up taking a lot home. There is a bar side, looks like it's at the bottom of the building with outdoor seating. We didn't venture down there, so I can't comment on that side of the facility, but I do know you can order food to be brought down. There were also a couple tables outside the storefront as well. All in all, staff was friendly, restaurant was clean, and food was great! We will most likely be back. read more

SoPies Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

See all

Service and environment is a bit chaotic but who cares? The pizza was very good. Will visit again in the future.

I've been here one other time when I met a couple of people for lunch. Then yesterday, I decided to call-in a large pizza for my family. After looking online at the menu, we went landed on the Deluxe Pizza. There were no prices listed online and I wasn't told how much it was until I picked up my order. I was caught off guard that one large pizza was $36!!! Sure it was good pizza, but it was not worth that cost. read more

Great pizza and wings. Always fast and great quality. True NYC pizza feel in the shop and always delicious. Highly recommend to everyone who comes into town and wants to get pizza. read more

We love the pizza here Most homes we order to pick up and it's always fresh hot & never soggy when we get home read more

Great little hole in the wall feel, yet big & bold on flavor, authenticity and service. Great folks building pies and a tasty offering of perfect beers to pair read more

SoPies Pizza - Carnivore, Misty IPA and a couple Sicilian slices....fantastic! - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

Pizza is always on point. Staff is friendly and polite. You get to watch them make the dough.

Decent pizza, but typical NY style service. "Yo, whatta you want?" You have to go up and order, chaos at the register area on Fri/Sat nights, packed, and tables are greasy. I think this would be a better place on a slow night, with good weather and eating outside. read more

This place pumps out the pizzas, very NY looking inside. Grab a slice or a whole pie. Let me tell you the crust is a-maz-ing, light, flakey, crispy and perfect to fold while eating. A great spot to stop for a quick bite. read more

We moved here 6 months ago and wanted to find a new spot for pizza. A local in the park suggested SoPies and it has been our go to ever since. It's great to stop in for a slice or call in for takeout. The staff is always nice and helpful. The seating is limited but we have been lucky enough each time to find a seat. read more

Friendly service and pizza very good however the cleanliness was something to be desired. I have never seen such disgustingly filthy baffles on a hood system. I've worked in the food industry most of my life and it's astonishing that a health inspector would let this pass. Extremely dangerous fire hazard not to mention food safety and sanitation nightmare. read more

Very nice small town pizza and quick, we ordered 5 maybe 6 pizzas to go on a weekend and they had them ready in 45mjns. Also had pizza by the slice for any interested in something to grab and go. The silicians were our favorites, we got a regular pepperoni and their nonna version read more

We love this pizza spot. The pizza is always delicious, the staff is always super friendly and kind. Highly recommend!

I must say the food is very good. We usually just get pies but sandwiches are good too. It's a small cozy pizza parlor that seats about 20 indoors and 16 outdoors. Fine for a quick slice and soda or beer. Family run business is very customer oriented. It's fun to watch them make the pies and on weekends especially it's fast paced and crazy but they've got the system down! Everybody kicks butt to make sure their customers are happy. read more

The pizza reminds me of home. They didn't disappoint when they said it was like New York Pizza. The pizza taste amazing the only problem is the crust is a little thin. Either way I still drive 35 minutes to get it. The staff is very friendly and the place is clean. I love it there because it reminds me of a regular pizza shop not like the chain pizza places with the just ok pizza. If you are ever in town or near by it's well worth a visit. read more

Amazing!!! ALL AROUND! The best pizza in Moore County!!! You will NOT be disappointed!

This is mine and my wife's favorite pizza spot in Southern Pines. When I tell you this place sits in my top 5 of the very best pizza I have ever had, then trust me I would not steer you wrong. First off they do not cut corners on ingredients...they have cup pepperoni's and everyone knows that that is as good as it can get. Pizza is not overloaded with cheese or sauce as every ingredient has the perfect amount. Crust is crispy with nice flavor as everyone knows that the crust either makes or breaks the pizza. The undercarriage is crispy which also doesn't cause the pizza to be flimsy. Service is awesome and very friendly! Always a pleasure to eat here!!!! read more

SoPies Pizza - 14" Pepperoni Pizza NY Style - Pizza Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

We always have great service and the food is always really fresh! Our go to pizza spot in the pines. Very kid friendly which we appreciate.

2nd best slice of pizza I have had in NC. It's always delicious after a night downtown, I usually stop and grab a couple slices to soak up the booze when I need it. read more

This place used to have fabulous pizza. The last several times I ordered from here it was okay at best. My order tonight was horrible. Pizza by the slice tasted like it was old and stale. Had to throw it out and order from another pizza place. With my job , I'm asked frequently where to grab a great slice. THis is the LAST place I would recommend. read more