So...this place was connected to Dolce Aroma next door…read more While waiting for my dessert next door, I ordered a slice of their pizza (thinking that it would be a New York Style Pizza). Well, turned out this pizza was quite small....definitely NOT New York sized. Also, the quality was a bit low as well...especially for its pricing. For such a small slice, I thought 3 bucks would have been more fair. Oh Well...now I know. Doubt I'll be returning here, or to is sister bakery next door.

finally found what I'd call great pizza. From the first bite, you can tell they take the time to…read moremake it right the first time . The crust was crispy on the outside with just the right amount of chew inside. The sauce had a fresh, slightly sweet flavor that didn't overpower the cheese, and everything tasted incredibly well-balanced. nothing felt overly greasy or heavy. Even the toppings were evenly distributed, which sounds simple but makes a big difference. Some places don't even put enough cheese and then you're eating mostly sauce and dough. The atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming, and the staff were friendly and attentive. If you're picky about pizza or just looking for something that stands out from the usual chain spots, this place absolutely delivers. I'll definitely be coming back. I think this is the best place in Fayetteville for pizza unless I'm wrong.

Always the best- and biggest pizzas. Great chewy authentic Brooklyn crust. My wife wanted their…read morepizza for our anniversary dinner, and the guys made a special mushroom heart for her. Great job, great food and good guys working there.

I ordered three large pizzas for a work event, and my staff totally loved the pizza. I had people…read morefrom other departments that came because they could smell it down the hall. The highlight of the pizzas we selected was the Neapolitan, which has arugula and prosciutto. That was an unexpected hit. Service was very good. They gave extra condiments. Definitely will order from them again.

Best NY style pizza in the Pinehurst area. The wait is worth it. There is a reason you have to…read morewait in line and then wait 15 - 20 minutes for your pie to come out. Ask for crispy if that is what you like. His red sauce is also very tasty and combined with his dough, he gets the #1 rating. I just moved here from NYC where I lived for 67 years so I think I am a good judge. His meatball parm hero is also excellent. Tasty meatballs with his spicy sauce combined with fresh mozzarella cheese and good bread combine for a treat. This is our go to place for pizza and meatball parm hero's. So far that is all we have tried so possibly more recommendations to come down the road.

Delicious gluten free! Their gluten free crust is bigger than average with great flavor! I've had…read moreit twice and it's one of my favorite crusts. The put a good amount of toppings on. They are easy to order from in person or over the phone.

Excellent choice for thin crust pizza in Southern Pines!…read more We ordered various pizzas for pick up. Our order was ready and accurate on arrival. The employees are friendly and welcoming. Overall, we enjoyed our meal and recommend this pizza place to others!

Great food, fun little arcade in the back. The games need to be fixed but overall was a good timeread more

This is the best Italian food I've ever had. The ambience is homey, food is fresh. Olive oil is…read moreimported and is delicious. Thank you for a wonderful time!

Food was NOT good. Un-accommodating to any customizations and received COLD food on my pickup…read moreorder. We are NOT in Italy. The food is NOT good or "authentic" enough to refuse adding ricotta to the top of my pizza.. or justify the whack restaurant hours. The bruschetta was very bland and looked like my toddler threw it together. I couldn't even manage to bite into anything but plain, limp bread because everything was falling off. However, it somehow wasn't as bad as their arancini, which I would accredit to the work of a school lunch chef. Overcooked. Looked and tasted like something processed and frozen, then reheated. The only credit they deserve is that they own a wood--fired oven; except my pizza was stone cold biting into it, because they let it sit out while I was on the way. To top it all off, a tiramisu! Which, I didn't know could be screwed up until today. Wet, gelatinous in some layers, and the sweetness was odd. Tasted like erythritol or some sugar replacement. Ciao!! But I will not be returning again.

Visiting relatives and SO wanted a pie. Found this restaurant, with pictures, on our Internet…read moresearch. We were immediately greeted upon entrance. Not sure how long the establishment has been here, but it looks new. Plenty of lighting, seating and video games, very family friendly. We opted for take-away since we had a long day. We placed our order then noticed the dessert case. Scrumptious looking cake slices and made to order cannolis. A gentleman came out to talk with us while our order was being made and the young gentleman that waited on us was extremely nice. When we arrived home the SO noticed his cheese pie was not well done as requested. He had to heat it in a cast iron pan to cook it to his request. The family enjoyed their pepperoni-sausage pie and my lasagna was a bit too oily for my liking. I honestly regret having to give them three stars but sadly it was unanimous.

The food was alright, but the service is incredibly kind. There were also arcade machines going off…read moreevery 5 minutes if you're into that. The pizza looked a lot better than it tasted and don't touch the cheesecakes.

BE CAUTIOUS WITH THESE CROOKS!!!!!…read more Tiger's has a huge sign posted in front of their restaurant advertising a Large 1 topping pizza for $8.99. Sounds great, Well, I call and place the order for 1 Large 1 topping pizza and I show up to the store and the gentleman at the register informs me that the price of the food is 12.99 and explained that I never requested the "Special". This is terrible business! If you're going to advertise a price it needs to be honored. I'm all about supporting local businesses but I will not support businesses that conduct business in this manner. Needless to say, I will never return to this place!

Me and my girlfriend get here every time we are craving pizza. One because usually small businesses…read moreare better and the food is great. Everyone time we go the service is great. I will say the ambiance of the place is comfortable, but needs a little updating. But we both love this place!

My family and I love Little Italy and have been customers there for several years. They are one of…read morethe many hidden gems of Fayetteville! Hands down, Little Italy, has the best pizza in town AND it reheats well at home, too! The atmosphere is cozy and inviting and they usually decorate for each season, which always adds a nice touch to overall dining experience. On our most recent visit there, our server was Kari P and she was amazing! Kari kept the flow of the meal at a nice pace and was prompt in keeping beverages filled. Kari was also very knowledgeable of the menu and has the perfect personality in interacting with customers-very courteous, professional and prompt. We love Little Italy!

I've been going here for years now. It's normally really good but this recent visit turned me off…read moreforever. I got the seafood pasta dish like I always do but this time the recipe was incredibly different. I was annoyed because I paid for what I always get but this time the seafood tasted like it had gone off. The noodles are normally thin but they were thick this time. The seafood in the pasta tasted like it had gone bad and there was extra seafood in there this time that just made the dish unappetizing. It normally comes with basically just mussels and shrimp, this time, it came with entire little octopus' and octopus rings that normally aren't there. I took a bite of a few different things but everything tasted awful. I'm writing this at 4am the morning after. I'm sitting in my bathroom vomiting my guts up after eating a few bites of their seafood pasta. It tasted like somebody just scraped together the stuff nearing expiration and threw it into my dish. I have been coming here for years and getting the same dish every time. I don't know why they changed the recipe or why they thought that dish was acceptable to serve.