I may have died and went to heaven! I've experienced some good food in my 5 decades on this planet...but this place??? WOW! The drive to Eagleville....beautiful! The atmosphere in the town? Amazing!! The ambience when you step into this building? incredible!!! The feeling you get when the first bite hits your lips? Euphoria!!!! I ordered the Stromboli...absolutely the best ingredients this side of Sicily! I've been here multiple times now over the last 5 years and I've never once been disappointed! 99 out of 5 stars! read more

If you're looking for a 24-minute road trip from Franklin for a great dinner, put this place at the top of your list! It's absolutely worth the drive to Eagleville! First thing to know: they don't take reservations, so plan to arrive early. But if there's a wait, don't worry, it can actually be part of the experience! On Thursday through Saturday, check out the Waiting Room. Look for the door right next to the main entrance, head upstairs, and you'll find a great bar where you can relax while you wait. We started downstairs at the bar, and our bartender was amazing! She made a fantastic Old Fashioned. The only thing that could have made it better? Clear ice! You know I'm always looking for that! Once we were seated, we started with the Garlic Knots, and WOW, were they good! And here's a little insider tip: don't let them take the bowl when you're finished! There's some incredible garlic butter left in the bottom, and you're going to want that later! We also ordered the Margherita Pizza, and it was sooo good! For our entrees, we tried the Alfredo Lasagna, Baked Tortellini Lasagna, and Chicken Marsala. The Alfredo Lasagna was good, although I was hoping for a little more Parmesan flavor. The Baked Tortellini Lasagna, on the other hand, was fantastic, great flavor and definitely one I'd order again. The Chicken Marsala was also excellent. And whatever you do, get the Bread Service! It's a must-have. And remember that garlic butter I told you to save from the Garlic Knots? Yep... you're going to need it! Of course, you have to save room for dessert. One cannoli, please! And yes, it was the perfect way to finish the meal. The service was amazing, the food was fantastic, and the atmosphere made the drive completely worth it. So, what are you waiting for? ROAD TRIP TIME TO EAGLEVILLE! One final hint: watch those speed-limit changes as you get closer to town! Let's just say the city has found a creative way to encourage everyone to slow down. Cheers! read more

See all

It is a very small place and you can expect to wait if you come at the peak hours. The food and service were absolutely amazing! My husband and I split the chicken marsala but that was after we gorged ourselves on the amazing garlic knots and even ordered an additional order! Their wine selection is very good. We went with another couple and split a bottle of wine and had some old fashions. Our waitress, Lauren, was very attentive and even put up with our antics! read more

Visited Sorelle's on a recommendation from a friend, and it lives up to the hype! The restaurant is small and cozy, and be prepared to wait for a table. We arrived at 6, and were told it would be a 30 minute wait, but after less than 15 minutes we were seated! We ordered the garlic knots, lasagna, chicken scarpariello, and the tiramisu. Everything we tried was incredible, and the service from our server Cadence was great! No parking lot for customers but plenty of street parking! read more

See all

This restaurant was very cute and cozy! My Stromboli was massive, and very cheesy! The service was great and our waitress was very kind. read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

Have been here a couple of times and can definitely say this place is a good decision! The food is delicious with generous portions, the staff are so friendly, and the vibes are very mom and pop Italian which I love (especially considering the building is in the bones of an old home. Also, plenty of street parking outside in a charming town! Check it out! read more

See all

This is the only Italian in middle Tennessee we'll eat out. If we aren't making it ourselves at home this is the place. The sauce is perfect, you taste the ingredients, not garlic. The tomatoes shine and the gluten free noodles are perfectly cooked. Service was excellent and very attentive. The ambiance was just what you'd expect for a family Italian gem. read more

See all

This is hands down the best Italian food you'll find within a 50-mile radius. I ordered the Stromboli, and the portion was so generous it could easily be shared between two people. The side of meatballs was equally impressive--hearty, flavorful, and plentiful. The service was exceptional. Maggie & Maddie were sweet & helpful. If you're visiting with a larger group, I definitely recommend making a reservation. We came in as a party of nine, and the staff went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable and well taken care of. The restaurant offers two dining areas: a spacious front section and a cozy back area. Just keep in mind that parking is limited to street parking only. read more

See all

Ok, been buying your pizza for many years and think its the best in the area. Ordered two pies tonight and I have to say they both were very doughy and bread like. Crust looked different and bottom was thicker than normal. If changing the dough recipe please go back. Tonight was my worst experience with take out pizza unfortunately. read more

Hands down the best Italian food I've found around here! This little family-owned restaurant is such a gem. It's tiny, so there's usually a wait, but you can often get on the waitlist ahead of time online which helps. Totally worth it though! The penne alla vodka is the star of the show in my opinion, truly the best vodka sauce I've ever had!! My family loves it so much that even when they order something like chicken parmesan, they ask for it with the vodka sauce. I didn't have dessert this time, but their desserts are usually amazing and definitely worth saving room for. The staff is always the sweetest and gives you that true small-town, welcoming feel. Between the food and the atmosphere, it's become one of my favorite spots and a go-to recommendation! read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

Sorelles is a community favorite restaurant with a small hidden bar in the back, outfitted as a Italian diner. Service is good. The Al Pacino is penne sitting in a bowl of water and oil, with grilled chicken. The Chicken Marsala with spaghetti was good. There is a full bar. Reservations are recommended. read more

See all

The staff and the food were absolutely amazing!!! Definitely recommend going if you're ever in the area! It's nice to go to a place where you don't feel judged! read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

See all

Our waitress was amazing! We had a party of 7, we were able to sit right away! Only downside is that it's a small place and it gets loud in there with people talking! Food was a 10/10. read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

Absolutely wonderful, such a welcome to Eagleville. Great menu, home made Italian cuisine with outstanding service. Couldn't ask for more. Will definitely return. read more

Good Italian food in Eagleville! Call ahead, because this is quite the local hotspot! Depending on the day and time, you might be in for a bit of a wait. Staff are very kind and helpful. Pasta was good and definitely restaurant quality, but the pizza was the star!! This restaurant is definitely an Eagleville gem! read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - 18" Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

First visit to this quaint place. Got there at 3:30p and place was already packed and had a waiting list. They do have an upstairs bar area to wait in but it doesn't open til 4p. Service was very good. Friendly, attentive.the food was good. I had higher hopes after reading reviews, but maybe we ordered the wrong items. I'll try the pizza next time as it looked very good, or a different pasta. Make not there is no courtesy bread u til AFTER 4p. That was a disappointment, especially when we ordered pasta dishes. read more

See all

This is a gem of a family restaurant that may seem to be out in the middle of nowhere, but that is well worth a visit. The service was excellent, warm, and friendly. The Penne Ala Vodka was amazing! So flavorful! I'm going to have trouble ordering anything different in the future. The Baked Ziti was good but not great. The pizza was good, but huge! For the regular pizzas there is only one size, which is 18 inches. They have a gluten-free pizza (smaller at 12 inches) that is pretty good. They also have gluten-free pasta, which was almost indistinguishable from the regular pasta. It is great that they have some gluten-free options, especially being an Italian restaurant where bread and pasta dominate. The restaurant is cozy and comfortable, and everything was clean. Overall a great experience. We'll definitely be back, especially because I can't resist the Penne Ala Vodka! read more

See all

Nice place in downtown Eagleville, good atmosphere and friendly service. Garlic knots were good, seemed to be store bought dinner rolls with butter sauce. Chicken piccata was good, sausage pepper onion sandwich was good but had no peppers or onions. Meatballs solid and Calzone was also good. A nice lunch for us. read more

Fantastic Italian food in a small town. Garlic knots are delicious. Lots and lots of butter. Just FYI. I had the chicken parmigiana and I would order it again. Tender and flavorful. Great service! Super nice/friendly people. The dining room is very cozy as it's not very big. It's about 30 minutes from Franklin but well worth the drive. I'll be going back! read more

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Eagleville, Tennessee

Tomato sauce is excellent! So are fried ravioli, marsala sauce on chicken, garlic knots ! Cute little bar. This place is the real deal!

This has quickly become one of my favorite local restaurants, and my family's go-to for great Italian food! It's a family-owned establishment, with a comfortable/casual environment and consistently friendly, attentive service. I have truly never been disappointed. From pizza, pasta, and Stromboli, to their salads and appetizers, all the way to their cannoli and zeppoli (basically Italian beignets) -- all of it is authentic and delicious! And to top it all off, sometimes when we have been there on a Saturday night they have even had a live saxophone player playing laid-back jazz music. This is definitely one of those must-try restaurants in the area and I can't recommend it enough! read more

See all

Best Italian food! We ordered pepperoni and sausage pizza and Baked Rigatoni with Italian Sausage. The pizza is some of the best we have had . Even the crust had good flavor ! Their sausage was soo good. Service was great. Next time we will save room for dessert. read more

I had the tortellini lasagna with a side of meatballs ... rich tomato sauce and good amount of cheese ... homemade bleu cheese dressing and garlic knots yummmmmm . Service was fantastic .. it's a tiny place and it's always busy .. parking can be a challenge on the weekends . It's pretty loud in there so if you are wanting a romantic quiet dinner it is going to be difficult to hear what your guest is saying . read more

See all

The garlic knots , pizza, stromboli, and drinks are worth the wait. And the staff is fabulous. On our first trip I had to try the calamari, having lived on the Mediterranean, I try anywhere they say they have fresh fried calamari. The first visit it was cooked perfectly. Second visit- over cooked. (It doesn't take much to over cook it unfortunately- and I'll be giving it another try!) We have tried their pizza two times. Next time we will return to the stromboli. (I save the butter garlic mixture from the garlic knots for my pizza bones.) Their marinera sauce is tasty- I order a side with the garlic knots. (On our first visit, we were seated in the bar area, where there was a man and his guitar playing some great 70's and 80's tunes.) Tip: If you ahead it might save you wait some time! read more

See all

The food was delish! We started with the garlic rolls and Caesar salad both were excellent. We also ordered a pizza to share the crust was so fresh and delicious and not too thick. We also ordered Chicken Parmesan and an order of Chicken Piccata excellent as well. We took quite a bit home and enjoyed another hearty meal as the portions are not huge but sufficient. The prices are reasonable, the waitress was pleasant and attentive. The atmosphere is nice. I can't wait to go back. It's an hour from our home but was great. These girls know what they are doing and have an outstanding passion for good food. read more

Such a mixed bag. The food was incredible. Everything we had was delicious. Our server Heather was fantastic. But as an old restaurant guy, the host staff...and whoever answers the phone...needs major hospitality training. Made us feel like pariahs because we had the nerve to want to eat there. It's a shame because the food is 10/10. But I always thought small businesses wanted paying customers. Made us feel like we were intruding on their private clubhouse. And they had twice as much staff in the house as they did diners. Wish it hadn't happened because this would be a favorite spot otherwise. Still giving them 4 stars because the food is great (5+). Would give them another shot at some point...everybody has bad nights...but it will be a while. read more

Drove an hour to eat here per good reviews to celebrate a birthday. When we got there they were closed for kitchen updates. Would have been nice to have that posted on their website. Heartbroken. read more

We absolutely loved this restaurant!! The owners and waitstaff were so friendly and accommodating. The food was delicious. There were six of us dining and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their entrees. We'll definitely be back. I'd advise getting there early as lots of people obviously love this place read more

There's not another mom and pop Italian place in town thats as good (especially compared to all the chain Italian restaurants). The pizza's are all once size and for 2 adults and a child we always take home leftovers (their cold pizza for breakfast is where it's at). We like the meat lovers. The salad house Italian dressing is really good! I recommend it. The meatballs give homemade vibes and my family always orders them. The garlic knots are 10/10 - probably because they're sitting in a pool of butter. If a pool of butter isn't for you don't get these. The seating can get tight, and they get very busy. There's no changing table in the bathrooms. read more

There is nothing not to love about this place. Every single thing on the menu is outstanding. From pizza to pasta you can not go wrong! Meatballs are also incredible! read more

Shaina was the best server in this place!!!! We love the food and come here so often! Love the sisters!!! read more

See all

Loved the pizza. Best I've found in the area. Our table was awkward with the pillar between us.

This place is so good. Lexi our server was great. Attentive, Energetic and fun. She kept our glasses full and the food was amazing. We will definitely be going back. read more

We ordered a large to go margherita pizza with onions, bacon and pepperoni. So disappointed in the outcome - no bacon on the pizza, very few pepperonis and onions were a few in the middle. The top 3" next to the crust of the pizza was just cheese and sauce. It seems for $36.00 it would have had more ingredients! read more

We bought a house in Chapel Hill specifically in Unionville last February and have branched out in the area and have decided to start trying different restaurants and businesses in the area. We are definitely not out of state individuals as both of us were born in middle Tennessee and have experienced both big and small town restaurants and know that the quality can be 0 to 100 and anywhere in between but for us sorelles he is definitely at the 100 mark my girlfriend, and I love to go there as often as we can the fact that it's a small restaurant with such good food and good service makes us happy to give them our business which cannot be said for several other businesses we have visited in the middle Tennessee area that call themselves restaurants. This place is always clean as a good atmosphere and everyone that I have seen that works there has always been in a good mood and has given us amazing service. I personally tip specifically based on service to me and the people I'm with which mainly covers how quickly I get my food how often I'm asked about refills and how nice they are to me while doing it most restaurants I have been to fall short and I have no problem tipping next to nothing for bad service. This restaurant received the biggest tip that I have ever given because of how fantastic the surfaces not to mention the food. Hopefully this place gets all the business that I can from the local community and stays a nice hole in the wall restaurant that isn't too busy on the weekends or the weekdays. read more

Small town restaurant. Food was good. Service was really good. Not many options there but definitely one of the places to visit if you're in this area. read more

Ambiance was amazing! We loved the cozy hidden gem vibe. Although it was packed, the service was great. Our waitress was very attentive and knew the menu. The food was really good. The quantity of the food was a lot for the price so that's a PLUS. Prices were good as well. It's definitely a hidden gem and will come back! read more

See all

Lexie's Service was amazing tonight!!! She is attentive Energetic!! amazing server to go with amazing food!! Best Italian food ever!! read more

Love, love, LOVE this place for amazing Italian food. Every time we come here, the food is OUTSTANDING. It's a family-owned restaurant and you can tell that everything is consistently good. I've had several dishes here and each one was so tasty. The sisters that own this restaurant really take pride in it because they also make sure that service for their guests is top notch. When we come in, we're always recognized and greeted as if we were part of their family. I love the new addition to their waiting area inside and the front porch is always a fun place to wait. I can tell you, an hour wait if you even have that is VERY WELL WORTH IT. The place is so cute and cozy! Not trying to throw shade on Demos, but that place has NOTHING on Sorelles who serve AUTHENTIC Italian. There's truly no comparison! read more

I really enjoyed this place. The vibe of the restaurant is really relaxing. We came in on a Saturday afternoon it was busy but not too busy. We got the bread service and the freshly baked bread was perfect. It was crunchy and soft. The only thing I didn't like was how little balsamic they put in the olive oil. It was like 3 drops of it. That's why I didn't give 5 stars. The chicken parm was tasty I wish it was a little crispier but the flavor was nice and the spaghetti was good. The Chicken masala was tasty. Oh the house made Italian dressing was so good. I wish they sold it. All in all we will be back. I wanna try their pizza read more