Came here for breakfast 3 days in a row during a recent stay nearby. The breakfast sandwiches are…read moreexcellent. They're cooked to order and the roll they serve them on is soft and fluffy. Coffee is good, excellent place if you're in the area.

Been going there for a few years now during the summer months before heading to the beach…read more Unfortunately will never go back. The place is in major need for a total renovation. The place has an unpleasant smell, everything is cruddy and it's only getting worse over the years. I know it's difficult to find help, but the folks working there seem unfriendly & don't really know what they're doing. The quality of food has declined, dried out rolls, poor quality mayonnaise. I don't think they are using Boar's Head or other quality cold cuts brands. They roast beef was well done, dry & gristly. The owner seems to be a nice guy. I hope he can improve the store. It's a Great location.

Good selection of bagels. Got the "Hobo" breakfast sandwich on Egg Bagel. Fantastic…read more Would definitely recommend / return Nice prompt service even on a busy morning. 5/5

Moments after I placed my order, I noticed the flat bagel sandwiches and started second-guessing my…read morechoice. When I heard another customer order one, that sealed it--I decided to change mine. I asked the woman who took my order if I could switch; she hesitated, likely because my bagel was already toasted, but then quickly agreed and handled it. It felt a bit awkward for a moment, but customer-service-wise it was the right move. This is a legendary bagel shop and worth a stop if you're nearby. The bacon, egg, and cheese I ordered was a bit dry--being toasted without a smear made it come off a little crusty. Next time I'd definitely get a smear, or maybe not have it toasted at all. The highlight, surprisingly, was the heavy-duty sweatshirt I bought as a souvenir--honestly felt even heavier than Carhartt. Tip: Go for the flat bagel version and don't skip the smear.

The store is clean and well stocked…read more They have an incredible seafood counter because most fish are wild- and locally-caught. Wild Caught Fish has brought my once borderline-high cholesterol down to normal levels. I love their Wild Ceviche, Wild Calamari, and Wild Rock Shrimp. Prices of seafood are comparable to those of other high-end grocery stores on the Island, such as Wegmans and Whole Foods Market, but Citarella has a larger section of wild caught fish; for example, I do not see Wild Caught Ceviche anywhere but here. The store has other things that I want: gourmet cheese, smoked salmon, caviar, Wagyu beef, nice homemade soups, etc. Everything always looks fresh. Staff gives expert advice and stellar service. Today Zaheer, from the butcher chop, took my order and did an excellent job. Lastly, there are small tables outside to dine. You will find everything you need here for a quick lunch. I enjoy grocery shopping here even though it takes me nearly an hour's drive to come. This was my 400th Yelp review, and I proudly chose Citarella to mark that milestone. I hope that my experience delivers an impact on those who read this review.

Citerella has good products, but the prices are honestly outrageous. I understand paying more for…read morespecialty items and quality ingredients, but almost everything feels heavily overpriced. It's hard to justify spending that much on basic groceries when there are plenty of other places offering similar (or better) quality for far more reasonable prices.

Best place in town Hands down Try it You will not be…read moredisappointed Friendliest staff in Southampton

Family owned. Pulled Pork is to die for. Beef tenderloin…read more Same. Best secret in S Hampton. You can keep Citarella.

Ask for some of that soup. Then ask if it's home made…read more If they tell you it is home made then they are lying to you! It's Progressive soup I've seen them opened the cans in the back

The panini was amazing. Recommended by the friendliest counter person I've encountered in a deli in…read morea long time. In highly recommend.

Everyone is so welcoming! I felt right at home, the cashier is such a sweetie! The food is a 10/10,…read morewith the hot bar and sandwiches and the service is so speedy!

Great sandwiches, friendly service and fair prices. All things that are getting harder and harder…read moreto find in the Hamptons. Love having them in the neighborhood!

This hole-in-the-wall spot doesn't look like much, but it is seriously a hidden gem…read more There is virtually no seating here, but the food is worth it I came with my mom and we knew that we were onto something when we were the only gringos in the place Although they have a bunch of American food on the menu you would be remiss not to order the Mexican food My mom and I both got quesadillas and, I'm not saying this lightly, we agreed that they were the best quesadillas either of us had ever had 9

Good tacos good Spanish food and their Cuban sandwich is amazing breakfast and lunch they closed…read moreearly at 4:3pm

We got the brie sandwich and the pesto grilled cheese. I would really recommend the Supreme Brie…read moresandwich. Nice vibes, very busy here, and they have a lot of different healthy drinks / sodas. I enjoyed it! The foverpriced / smaller but this is a beach town and it's relatively cheaper than dining in at the nearby restaurants.

Completely overrated. For the prices they're charging, I'd expect much better service, a better…read moreselection, and a more organized shopping experience. Instead, it felt crowded, unimpressive, and catered more to the hype than to quality. Southampton deserves better. I won't be back, and I wouldn't recommend it unless major improvements are made.