I bought a grilled chicken ceasar salad. The menu said shaved Parmesan . What I got was a pile of…read moreParmesan powder. Not the same . Also the chicken was cold and not freshly grilled. I understand having it pre-made for convenience, but they could have threw it on the grill and heated it up . Not sure if I'll go back

I first of all want to say, it takes a whole lot for me to write a negative review... and it pains…read moreme to have to say this, but this business is not what it used to be. I have been coming here for well over 5 years now, and I hate to admit that the service has been going down hill for quite some time.. the treatment I received this season is not as attentive, and the workers don't care about your experience there like they use to. I noticed the food quality and produce is the same- which is great; but the quality of the customer service has decreased tremendously. No one greets you when you go up to the back counter to order your take out food. I had to wait for the staff to be done talking with one another and laughing around while the staff poured the staff food. I had to address placing an order for myself - knowing I had been standing there for over 3 minutes with no one in-front of me on line, just waiting for the workers to finish their fun. It's fine to have a friendly work environment- but hi, hello- you are at work- and these are your customers. Loyal customers at that. 5 years coming here and I'm sad to say I won't be returning. I had asked for an iced coffee- which I order every morning I go there. And I asked for an iced latte for my partner. I remember there has been the same young girl making my latte.. and I get that you have to have milk in it/ but don't make the entire latte basically milk. And so this is over the third time ( 3RD TIME) we have gotten coffee from them and he hated his coffee, and complains about how milky it is. Me feeling horrible, I tell him to take it back to get and get an iced coffee instead of the latte- and so she tells him " you have to pay for it anyway since he ordered it" I looked at her and was so confused as to why she would tell us that we need to pay for something we asked for them to take back. Knowing the taste was too milky and not how a good latte should taste. It's the simple fact that the manager Deanna, she's been working there for years- she knows my face and I know her. This SAME exact situation happened last year where I came to her at the front register to ask her to make my latte over since it was incredibly milky. And she helped me just fine last year, I gave her back the entire latte - it's not like I drank more than two sips before handing it back to her. It's the simple fact that she tried to charge me for an item I returned back to them fully. And the fact that this has happened multiple times and I reminded her of it, and she still was saying that since I ordered it and they made it I have to pay for it... that is not how customer service works. I have worked in various fields of customer service my entire life & I am still dumbfounded by Deanna and this other young girl's words. All 3 of us were disappointed in something we had ordered. My other friend ordered a sandwich and a smoothie and he said his smoothie was not good, and way too watery. I've spent hundreds of dollars here over the years, easily- so for you to look at me and treat me with such disrespect is insulting and rude. I expected much more from a local family business that's been in my routine for years on end. All I asked for was an iced coffee instead of a latte and for the situation to be handled as it was is quite disappointing in terms of how this business is looking. I would consider the owner recommend a supervisor for matters like this because clearly there is a disconnect.

I'm a deli guy. Living in Texas for past 11 years I was thrilled to find this place for…read morebreakfast.... And for lunch. Breakfast sandwiches of course in the morning. The all American and hamptons classic were excellent sandwiches. My wife wouldn't let me eat here every day of vacation and the only reason I didn't is because I love her dearly.

I guess I've been coming here for 30 years now. Still reliable, fast service, I love the coffee…read moresince I like plain coffee that hasn't been roasted to death. Breakfast sandwiches are simple and uncomplicated and taste great. And you can get a full meal without having to mortgage your house.

Came here for breakfast 3 days in a row during a recent stay nearby. The breakfast sandwiches are…read moreexcellent. They're cooked to order and the roll they serve them on is soft and fluffy. Coffee is good, excellent place if you're in the area.

Been going there for a few years now during the summer months before heading to the beach…read more Unfortunately will never go back. The place is in major need for a total renovation. The place has an unpleasant smell, everything is cruddy and it's only getting worse over the years. I know it's difficult to find help, but the folks working there seem unfriendly & don't really know what they're doing. The quality of food has declined, dried out rolls, poor quality mayonnaise. I don't think they are using Boar's Head or other quality cold cuts brands. They roast beef was well done, dry & gristly. The owner seems to be a nice guy. I hope he can improve the store. It's a Great location.

The sandwiches are ok. This is not a place to sit down and eat. The service is slow. I would search…read morefor another place.

Very organized and CLEAN deli. Wow the fresh vegetables behind the counter being washed and cut…read morelooked divine. I ordered an egg cheese tomato on a roll and everything was fresh and nicely packaged. The tres leches I picked up from the fridge section was also delicious. Amazing staff, they were kind and efficient.

Came to Montauk on the off season and had to get ourselves a bacon egg and cheese while we were out…read morehere. This deli has been here for as long as I can remember coming out this way, and I was thrilled to see it was still opened during off season. We ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go. Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was giving clean, well stocked, and well organized. Prices are what they are given that it's Montauk. But my sandwich was piled high with bacon, eggs were cooked well and cheese was melted, so I really can't complain.

Excellent $10 Turkey and cheese with mayo and hot peppers sandwich. Big bag of Hal's salt and…read morepepper chips - expensive but excellent.

The two ladies running the deli this morning were in way over their heads. If you told me this was…read moreboth their first day working I would say that makes total sense. 3 ham and cheese sandwiches, 2 bologna sandwiches and an egg sandwich rocked their world. The eggs sat on the grill that wasn't turned on for a few minutes, The ham sandwiches required an incredible amount of time and effort. They eventually got done, but apparently that effort shattered any memory that the bologna sandwiches had ever existed. It's hard to put into words, but it was the opposite of too many chefs in the kitchen. There was no one at the wheel. Pete, you gotta keep at least one person who understands basic boars head on the morning shift.

Great hot food selection, good service. Friendly atmosphere. Highly recommend stopping there when…read moreyou're in the area

Every time we come to Amagansett, Goldberg Bagels is a must stop! They do really make exceptional…read morebagels and sandwiches and they're quick! My favorite is a spicy hobo on an everything made bagel and the bagels are so fresh and bouncy, and the eggs and bacon are cooked very well! my only complaint is that sometimes i see the cashier with gloves grab cash and then grab bagels and that is just unsanitary!

Meh Overrated chain…read morecan't get orders right, had this location again just because friends wanted it; you know, everyone hears ooo Montauk I gotta get this basic bitch shit there... and so they do. Nothing special, skip it if you're not a tourist posting on instagram

Does everyone know that besides being the best bagel shop on the North Fork, GOLDBERGS actively…read moresupports the local community? YES THEY DO! GOLDBERGS continues to support the Southold Historical Museum each year for their annual "History In the Making" pickleball tournament, which takes place next Saturday, May 30. 2026, at Tasker Park in Peconic. There are still some spots left! So next weekend, as you're rushing out the door for the 9 am tournament start time, know that GOLDBERGS will have free bagels waiting for you!!! Thank you GOLDBERGS for the great food and generous support. You are invaluable to this community.

Food was good but expensive and some of the staff members were kind of rude. The menu could have…read morealso been more clear with regards to when breakfast food sales start / end.