Cancel

Open app

Search

Stay True Tattoo

3.5 (8 reviews)
ModerateTattoo, Piercing
Closed • 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

By appointment only

Updated over 3 months ago

Services - Stay True Tattoo

Piercing

Tattooing

Stay True Tattoo Photos

Recommended Reviews - Stay True Tattoo

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ash V.

Ash V.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ash V.

Ash V.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Katie R.
83
141
0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Stay True Tattoo

Verify this business for free

People searched for Tattoo 642 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Steve's Tattoo & Body Piercing

Steve's Tattoo & Body Piercing

3.7
(56 reviews)
5.6 mi
•$$

Review / Complaint About My Experience With David at Steve's Tattoo…read moreI've been getting tattooed at Steve's Tattoo for years -- by Steve himself and by many artists who've come and gone, including David, who this review is specifically about. Up until recently, I actually liked David's work. He's done multiple tattoos on my sleeve and even tightened up some older pieces to make everything flow together. His talent can be great when he actually tries. But what happened this year is something people deserve to be warned about. 1. The First Red Flag Last year David tattooed a tarot card of my dog on my bicep. The work turned out great, but his behavior that day was... off. He was short, rude, and uninterested in even basic communication. I brushed it off as a bad day. We talked afterward about finishing my sleeve, so I assumed things were fine. 2. October 26th Appointment - The Point Where Everything Went Sideways I booked an appointment for October 26th at noon to finish some filler on my sleeve. What actually happened: He made me wait over 30 minutes just to start setting up. He barely spoke and acted irritated from the second I walked in. I explained what I needed: the same pattern and color he started near my wrist, carried up the rest of the arm. I put my headphones in because the tension was so uncomfortable. While he was tattooing, it felt like he kept going over the same spots repeatedly. I have tattoos on my neck and feet -- I know what tattoo pain and swelling look like. This was different. When I looked, the area was extremely red, raised, and bleeding more than anything I've ever had. When I got home, I realized why: He only used ONE color -- and it was the WRONG color. The design didn't match my sleeve at all. It looked sloppy, rushed, and honestly more like flames than the pattern he originally created. It already looked like something that will age terribly. I emailed him politely because I was genuinely afraid I had somehow upset him and he did this intentionally. That's how uncomfortable and off his behavior was. He told me to come back on December 10th so he could "fix it." 3. December 10th - The Gaslighting & Disrespect I went to my appointment today hoping he would make it right. Instead: He completely gaslit me. He insisted the tattoo "is the same" (it absolutely is not). He claimed "there's no room," "it would look crowded," and "that's the best he can do." When I showed him the areas that are clearly different, he just argued and dismissed everything. And then he said the part that really tells you everything you need to know: "I don't want to work on it anymore." "You're being too emotional." "I just don't feel like it." He refused to finish the work he messed up. I begged, I reasoned, I even offered to pay him AGAIN just to fix the damage -- because I've already had multiple artists start and stop this sleeve and I wanted the same person to finish it. He didn't care. When I asked for Steve's contact info, he refused to give it to me. When I turned to look for a business card, he literally yelled at me: "WHAT ARE YOU DOING? THE DOOR IS RIGHT THERE." He treated me like trash and threw me out of the shop after knowingly giving me a tattoo that doesn't match, isn't the right color, and was done so aggressively that it raised and bled more than any tattoo I've ever had. 4. Why I'm Warning People I've never disrespected an artist. I tip well. I sit still. I don't complain. I've never caused a scene or been rude. There was absolutely no reason for him to treat me the way he did. And here's the truth: **If David gives you work you don't like, he will NOT fix it. He will gaslight you, blame you, and then kick you out.** I don't know if he was having a bad month, a bad year, or if something happened between appointments. But what I DO know is this: What he did to my arm was careless and nothing like the work he is capable of when he actually tries. And the way he treated me -- after years of being a good client -- was inhumane, unprofessional, and completely unacceptable. People deserve to know.

Steve, the owner of Steve's tattoo gave me this dragonfly tattoo two years ago. It completely blew…read moreout a year later. I do not recommend Steve's tattoo to anyone.

Photos
Steve, the owner of Steve's tattoo gave me this tattoo two years ago. It's completely blown out. Just awful.
Steve, the owner of Steve's tattoo gave me this tattoo two years ago. It's completely blown out. Just awful.
Half Sleeve
Half Sleeve
Nostril piercing done by Jessica

See all

Nostril piercing done by Jessica
Spike O Matic Tattoo

Spike O Matic Tattoo

4.0
(7 reviews)
5.9 mi
•$$

I've been here twice, once for a small Friday the 13th tattoo with Billy and once for a large…read morecustom piece with Zach. Both experiences were faaaantastic! I really can't say enough good things about Zach. I looked through his entire portfolio while waiting for my Friday the 13th tattoo and decided then my next big piece would be by him, since he's got that clean, bright traditional style I love. We emailed a bit then set up a consultation. I knew the placement and basic design elements--a portrait of my cat, flowers, maybe her name--and left the rest up to Zach. When I came in for my appointment and finally saw his sketch, I was ecstatic. It was so much better than what I had come up with, which is why I'm glad I gave Zach creative license and let him do his thing. We had talked about splitting it up into 2 sessions, but I was sitting well so we knocked the whole thing out in 3 hrs. I had a lot of fun talking with Zach and Billy and the other artists that popped in, and Zach made sure I had some candy halfway through to keep my blood sugar up :) Once he finished Zach actually brought me into Spike's studio so he could see it, which was cool, since he was Spike's apprentice! The tattoo healed beautifully, no hard spots/loss of ink and very minimal weeping. In conclusion: this place is great, Zach is great, and I can't wait to get my tax refund and come back for more work!

This will probably be one of the only shops I could give 5 stars to-and they deserve it…read more I've been to countless tattoo shops, and Spike's is on a pedestal. The staff is easy going and professional, and above all, absolutely amazing and gifted artists. They truly work with you, put in the time and effort, and have a passion for their jobs. I've gotten most of my tattoos here, and even had them cover up past tattoos. (Not because they were necessarily bad, but because the guys at Spike's just do so much better.) My tattoo work has been displayed on several different websites and I'm constantly receiving compliments-I turn everyone over to Spikomatic. The shop is newer. Give it a few years and I have no doubts it will take over as Madison's prominent tattoo shop. UPDATE: I've been disappointed in my last few runs there. They're losing most of their artists, and the fun atmosphere has gone way down, as has the work.

Photos
Spike O Matic Tattoo
Spike O Matic Tattoo
Spike O Matic Tattoo

See all

Rockwell Tattoo

Rockwell Tattoo

3.0
(6 reviews)
4.8 mi
•$$

Seneca did my tattoo, he drew it out for me exactly how i described it, then did my tattoo…read morebeautifully. The whole thing only took about 35 minutes. A couple months later and it looks amazing and healed amazing. Thank you seneca!!

I've never been treated so poorly and with a lack of respect. Though, from what Dave said, this is…read morecommon for tattoo shops. I had a consult with Dustin and set up my appointment for three weeks out. I paid my $50 and was told he'd be emailing me artwork for my cover up tattoo. Fast forward to the week of my appointment, I still hadn't heard from Dustin, so I shot him an email asking to see what he had. No response. Two days later, I sent him another email. Still no response. Three hours before my appointment I sent him a final email saying I would have to cancel since he was not responding to me. Still two weeks later he has not responded to me! Now, out of pure principle, I wanted my $50 deposit back- Insert owner Dave. Wow! He's a real work of art. Apparently this whole thing is my fault, because I expected an email from a busy tattooer! You mean the email I was promised to see a design that I was getting permanently inked on me?! And HIS PREFERRED CONTACT by the way. And, I should have just gone to the appointment anyway and confronted him. Well, that's not how I do business. Dave put no ownership on them, no blame on his buddy's part. He was just really defensive. He even made me feel like shit when I mentioned that I would be spending over a grand on a tattoo and that I thought I was entitled to the response that I was promised. "Everyone spends a thousand on a tattoo, you're not special" exact words from Dave.

Photos
Carpeting in Stanley Kubrick's THE SHINING.
Carpeting in Stanley Kubrick's THE SHINING.
Rockwell Tattoo's Logo
Rockwell Tattoo's Logo
Rockwell Tattoo

See all

Stay True Tattoo - tattoo - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...