Great ice cream in a bunch of flavors you don't ever see plus mini golf. What else do you need?read more

My husband and I love there soft serve Ice Cream. Can't wait to go back there next summer.read more

Be aware this spot is cash only and the nearest atm is down the street at Stewart's!…read more The ice cream is great! I ordered the peanut butter Sunday and will admit there was just too much. At one point all I could scoop out were toppings and it was just too rich for me. However, the ice cream, when I did get a scoop of it out was delicious! Just watch out those sundaes are huge! I def will be ordering something different next time I come. The parking lot is extremely spacious and the patio to eat on is nice. It did take a minute to get the ice cream but nothing too crazy. Happy with the experience!

Hold crud I ordered a large soft serve and had to cut the server off after she had poured about 8…read moreinches of vanilla pistachio twist! Heaven

I've gone to Hayner's a few times and they have great soft serve ice cream. I went this afternoon…read moreand everything was great, as usual. I got a twist soft serve in a cup with cookie crunch and it was SO GOOD. Also, even though it was a bit busy, service was very quick and the employees were super sweet--a girl a few years younger than me made my ice cream and she was super respectful and professional. Definitely will return!

Ice cream was good. Service was great. The outdoor seating overlooking the field is what makes this…read moreplace!

Loved the ice cream. Lovely picnic tables nearby. Prices fair and great portion sizes.read more

Pros: - takes credit card and cash…read more- hard ice cream selections - nice ambiance and well lit Cons: - large pot hole in parking lot exit - soft serve flavors are not the best One thing I can say about their staff is they're very efficient! Love the texture of the ice cream and I have enjoyed both visits this season. They have light and uplifting music playing with areas set away from the parking lot and roadway. It is lit with string lights and has a more adult date night vibing area to the right of the windows. My ice cream was lopsided, but otherwise, it was a great experience! So if the lines are long, just know they'll get to you usually within 5-10 minutes. No wildly long waiting time. Parking is a bit challenging. We will be back this season and hopefully see some new soft serve flavors debuts as the season progresses!

This little place is fantastic. 10 outta 10. Small, carry-out only, place located on a busy…read morecorner, one window for ice cream orders and another for food. They offer special summer lobster roll sandwiches- hot lobster sandwiches after offered after 5 pm, otherwise it's chilled. We had two gyros, mine was chicken, and my daughter had the lamb. Beef is a third option. These sandwiches are hot, fresh, loaded, and absolutely scrumptious!!! No photos, because I rapidly snarfed down half my sandwich in rapid fire. Both chicken and lamb were amazing. We split an order of fries. Those were awesome too. Great fries. For drinks, the freshly squeezed lemon aide was again, 10/10. We will be returning...I definitely need to explore the ice cream side of the business. Go here. It's great.

Mama's is open: it is officially spring! This time I had…read morethe lobster roll. There seriously must be twice the lobster meat on this as they give at "99!" The owner showed me the box from the provider: Maine lobster! The roll was hot and buttery and the fries perfectly crispy. I couldn't finish! Which is too bad because the Peach Sundae looks amazing. As for Cole slaw: I compare everyone's to my own mama's, and miss her's sorely. This place is iconic in the area. Don't miss it.

I was there yesterday , my treat after my Doc. apt on Sunday …read more I was probably a little disoriented from the test. I'm not sure if i said Vanilla soft on a cone. The young girl kept asking me while i was trying to talk , WHAT KIND. I finally said sorry i didn't realize i didn't say what flavor. She was rude and when i went to my car with my cone she stared at me still taking about about me. I could read lips. Rude, i've been coming to JJ's since the 80's my Dad took us. I left the parking lot before i finished my cone because she was still looking at me. Find better help please. I work in customer service as account manager for over 30 years , she needs training. On how to be kind. 5stars for the owner 1 star for service that day.

my son went for two small scoops of chocolate chip ice cream with jimmies. They gave him one scoop…read moreof chocolate (size of a baseball) and a "shake" that is all milk with chunks of something in it. when he told the woman this was not his order, she said: well, I couldn't hear you and that's all I have. $13+ rip off. Can't get money back because they require cash. Don't go there! I'm shocked there are good reviews...

Very cute diner in the heart of Schagicoke, NY. Very clean inside with excellent service from the…read morewaitress. I can tell this is a hometown favorite. Some of the customers appear to be regulars here. Places like this are the best. Today I stopped in on my way home from getting tires. I had the grilled chicken sandwich with the macaroni salad. It's was very delicious. Next time I pull through I will remember to stop back. They have a great menu with reasonable prices. Huge ice cream menu too.

Good burgers and excellent soft ice cream Pleasant servers…read more Not speedy but worth a little wait

There's about 12 flavors and yet I felt there was multiple of the same but diff variations vanilla,…read morevanilla bean or oatmilk vanilla. When there could have been more options such as what they show in the website. But it was mediocre. Kind of expensive for froyo. I don't know if I'd go back. Maybe if they change up the flavors. The girl behind the counter was super sweet though and helped w any questions bc we were first timers.

Not worth the price especially considering quality of customer service . Would not go backread more

Five years later and we made it back. I still love this place for its unassuming charm and fun…read moreweekly flavors. What made me instantly need to visit was the "chocomint" flavor that is so good. When we arrived I noted that the lawn was immaculate... perhaps they installed new grass in the past year or so. Ice cream was relatively inexpensive and came up super fast. There were lots of colorful picnic tables to sit and eat at. The only downside was that my ice cream melted fast (and my wife says I am a fast ice cream eater). Maybe it was an off night or maybe I am just hotter than I thought...

Great ice cream. I had the coffee/ chocolate twist and the coffee ice cream tasted like coffee! I…read morefind that many don't. They sell many other savory delights. Salt potatoes and hot buttered corn are two of the more uncommon items. I would go back to try more of the special flavors of ice cream.

Small ice cream store on the corner. Pretty big menu with lots of options. You can find something…read moreyou like. Only have small and large sizes, no mediums!! People working are pretty friendly. They could get a little better at scooping the ice cream into the cones without cracking the cones.

Friendly service and a fun vibe. But the ice cream isn't great despite the awesome sounding…read moreflavors. Left somewhat disappointed.