Flew in from San Diego, and this was my first stop…read more I ordered takeout this time around, although dining in here is always a great experience too. The place is super cute with a fun atmosphere. * Shrimp Po'Boy: packed with shrimp. HUGE so order a half. I loved that the shrimp aren't heavily battered or overly fried. Easily one of the best po'boys I've had. * Shrimp Gumbo: absolutely delicious with a dark roux and great flavor. Overall, an awesome spot for authentic Louisiana comfort food.

This is one of our go-to's in South Louisiana and we always bring friends here when we can. The…read moresalads are big, fresh and wonderfully topped with crawfish or shrimp. The plate lunches are delicious and the po-boys are always an enticing option. Service is prompt, the dining room is comfortable and it features that beloved bad taxidermy. We always arrive hungry and leave happy.

August 31, 2026, I made a verbal complaint to the SM about my experience the previous evening. The…read moreSM was very defensive, dismissive, accusatory, unwilling to hear feedback, refused to investigate and/or fully listen to my complaint(s,) ignored valuable information as it pertains to shrinkage, etc. There are couple of sandwich artist who give away inventory in the absence of a mgmt. Unwilling to reach a resolution, the SM banned me from that particular location. Keep in mind, I purchase sandwiches at least three times a week if not more and I can provide bank statements to prove it. Subsequently, I asked the SM for contact information to corporate and/or the owner so he/she can hear my legitimate complaints, dates and times of the aforementioned shrinkage, etc. and she refused. In an effort to make matters worse, she informed me that this complaint/feedback, I'm taking my time to compose, will be re-routed to her without a resolution. How does a patron become banned for filing a complaint, providing constructive criticism, offering valuable operating practices in the absence of her presence, shrinkage, unprofessionalism, etc.? This makes one question her moral compass, ethics, and character.

Anyone else notice all the dead giant cockroaches inside the light fixtures on the ceiling? Dozens…read moreof dead bugs inside the lights, which lead me to believe that there is a bug problem at this establishment. They are also always out of something, onions, peppers, cookies, bread... it's something different every visit.

Very good and filling! Average fries. Cajun burger is big. Very juicy and spicy!! If you can't…read morehandle a lot of spice I would get the normal burger instead.

Service is terrible. The place is filthy. The food was good once upon a time, but now it's crap…read more The fried seafood was fried in old grease that wasn't hot enough, they used catfish belly meat to save a little money, and it tastes like dirt, and the hamburgers are more breadcrumbs than meat. Never going back again. So sad. They used to be good.

Despite the menu recommendation to add slaw to your Bougie Bologna sandwich, don't do it. Don't get…read moreme wrong, the slaw is good. Real good. Nice and vinegary like I like it. And they put a lot on the sandwich. But it overpowers everything else - the bologna flavor is lost. Also, get the bologna grilled to help bring out the flavor. It's a good sandwich. And it's huge. The potato salad is also very good. I will be back soon to try the pastrami, without the slaw. Maybe I can get a side order of slaw (and hopefully it'll be bigger than a condiment cup that most places consider a side order of slaw. Hopefully.) Also - put some of that Dirty Squirt sauce on your sandwich (or potato salad). It's a good mustard based sauce - kind of like a Carolina Golf but not too sweet.

Yes, yes, and yes. This is a great sandwich shop which opened up in the old jimmy John's in pville…read more Nice selection of sandwiches and they seem to focus on using local ingredients. The bread on the sandwich is so fresh and really stands out. Also the size is really enough for two to share but I don't want to :)

Service was fast and friendly...food was absolutely great!! Had the Darrel's Special and was as…read moregood as we heard it was!! 5 Stars!!! Staying at Golden Nugget and just wanted to get out for a bit and try something else...I recommend it!

After hearing from several people that we "had to check out Darrell's," we finally decided to hit…read moreit up for lunch. We arrived just a couple minutes after their 11 a.m. opening, and the place was already packed, a good sign in itself. Luckily, with only three of us, the hostess got us seated at a table right away. The exterior isn't much to look at, but stepping inside tells a different story. The interior has a sports bar meets old school diner vibe, with decor that gives the whole place a nostalgic, lived-in charm. We all decided on the Darrell's Special sandwich with jalapeño mayo, and it did not disappoint. Our waitress was fantastic the whole meal, constantly checking in, keeping our drinks filled, and making sure we didn't need anything else. Despite how busy the place was, our sandwiches came out in a surprisingly short time. The sandwich itself is a beast! A toasted, loaded bun stacked with ham, turkey, and roast beef (which I hear is made in-house), all topped with roast beef gravy, American, Swiss, and provolone cheeses, lettuce, mustard, and your choice of regular or jalapeño mayonnaise, of course we had the Jalapeño Mayo. The first bite reminded me of a warm French dip, but that impression quickly gave way to layers of different meat flavors, rounded out by the subtle heat of the jalapeño mayo. It practically melted in my mouth. Honestly, I wanted to finish the whole thing, but I didn't want to need to be rolled out of the building, so I boxed up the second half and enjoyed it again for dinner. Great food, great service, and now I understand what all the buzz was about.

The cuban sandwich was well-made and flavorful. The bread had a beautiful char and was my favorite…read morepart of the sandwich aside from the delicious combination of flavors.

Only can drinks available and bottled tea. On these very hot days a fountain drink machine with…read morecrushed ice would be better. Cuban sandwich good. Fries had a seasoning on top I didn't care for. The guy making the sandwiches seemed to never take off his gloves.

Glad we found this business on Yelp. We stopped on our road trip passing through on I10 and glad we…read moremade the detour. Took about 10 mins off the highway. We had the shrimp poboy and fries- which we split between two people and were plenty full. They have Cajun seasoning, hot sauce and plenty of napkins on the tables. You can eat indoor or outdoor. Plenty of drink selections!! The place is clean and you can even watch the fryers through a window. We had a poboy in New Orleans a few weeks before and it was no comparison to the one we had at Old Tyme--filled with large shrimp and plenty of them. We would detour here again. It is not a grocery store anymore...but a darn good place to eat. Lots of college vibes for the local university as well. Nice bathrooms that have funny decorations for him and her.

Best poboy experience in Acadiana. All varieties are great. Worth the drive…read more Not RV friendly. Streets are tight and parking is difficult but food make it worth it. A local hang out not on the tourist map but worth the trip for 5 star ***** poboy sandwiches.

Customer servuce lacking at the Youngsville, LA, store. While eating our sandwich order, we…read morenoticed a #2 Boardwalk special poster, $10.99, drink, chips & sandwich + tax. The sandwich looked identical to our order + drink ($11.54 + $1. 21 tax=$12.75). We paid $12.75 no chips, compared to $10.99 + $1.21 tax= $11.20 for the Boardwalk special which includes chips. Low rating is because employees aren't trained to automatically provide the lowest price to the customer, or even let the customer know that chips can be included for $1.50 less. And, when asked later about the price difference of the special bundle & not sharing that with us, we were not offered a complimentary (which we clearly paid for) bag of chips. Jersey Mike's product seems no better than Subway or other area fast food restaurants, in particular when comparing coupon prices or specials. The interior has a cute vibe & nice employees but it's not sufficient to compel us to return to this store given our personal experience.

Just opened In Youngsville, and I'll say a great addition. We were greeted by a very well trained…read moreand organized staff. I had up to this point never been to. Jersey Mike's, and the meat sliced fresh for sandwiches made for a very promising meal, and we absolutely delighted. I had the Italian sub which was delicious. Great atmosphere if you want to stay inside and enjoy the meal or take out. Very friendly, and great subs.