Our second time here; almost a year after they opened. They've expanded their menu; which I think…read moreis great! Same great quality, wait time, dedication, and atmosphere as before. We started out both getting the Dutch Mules to drink; which was a nice crisp take on a classic Moscow Mule. I also got The Stapleton later; which consisted of a fine whiskey, triple sec, OJ, and some other additives which was like drinking a whiskey mimosa without the bubbles. Super delish! My wife got the Knickerbocker sandwich on the special list, and I got the Huckleberry panini. Both very satisfying and satiating in their own ways. Both came with homemade in house chips covered in light spices We loved it, and will be back! Reasonable prices without cutting costs; which is definitely appreciated these days.

Tried Crooked Cattle for takeout on a DoorDash happy hour promotion at 25% off (unclear if this was…read morea one time deal or a daily offering). I ordered the Beef of Weck and Potato Salad given past reviews seemed to deem these two items as menu staples. The potato salad was fine, in need of a big pinch of salt. The Beef on Weck was a hardy, and a big portion for a sandwich, the extra horseradish wasn't necessary unless you're really a fan. However, the sandwich should be eaten with the au jus, otherwise it borders on flavorless. I did find the bun overly salty. Filling but not fufillying. Additional note... When I went to pickup the staff member wanted me to sign off on a receipt of the full amount without the discount. When I stated I paid online, he responded it had to do with the fact DoorDash doesn't allow for a tip. When I asked for a new bill representative of what I paid, the manager came and said they ask for the signature to confirm it was picked up... Then I said, I can indicate that here on the app, and he agreed and let me go with my food. Overall the interaction made me uncomfortable as I've never experienced a similar situation with pickup. Perhaps just me, but something I feel someone should be made aware of if they're ordering to-go.

He'll service was great but who microwave mayonnaise got the momberger and they microwave the whole…read moresandwich what more can I say flavor none in the meat. Very disappointing but service was great

Everything I have ordered from here has been delicious. I usually get subs that's the only place I…read morecan get an egg and olive sub which I love and I love capicola it was excellent.

I always try to stop in here when I am in the area. So many goodies to choose from. Everything is…read morealways so delicious! Chocolate frosted brownies are a favorite with my family. I love the cinnamon rolls. It's so hard to pick only a few items. The place is nicely decorated in a farmhouse theme. The staff is always friendly and eager to serve. I am a repeat customer for sure. Follow their FB page to see what is being made everyday.

Excellent baked goods, coffee and service!! I enjoy bringing my son and being greeted with a smile…read more It is bright and cheerful!

Food matches the service horribleread more

Absolutely delicious. We had the meatball and the grilled chicken. Very good. You can use your…read moredining dollars and your points. Very nice workers also. Highly recommend.

Came here after backpacking, it was delicious…read more Food: the sandwiches were amazing and worth every penny. The turkey with apple and bacon was amazing. The schnitzel sandwich was also very good. The fries, at $8 as a side were not worth it, I would have rather ordered another sandwich than got two sides of fries. The chips were also almost flavorless, except that of 99% fresh oil. The kids grilled cheese was American cheese, and thus, imho, was not very good. One of my kids took a bite and didn't like it either. Ambiance: simple, nice view of the lake. Service: friendly staff. Tl;DR: I'll be back, but won't order sides or the grilled cheese.

We visited after a recommendation from a friend. We drove by twice before we could even locate the…read moreplace- not very visible The restaurant offers tables inside, deck seating & a large lawn area in the back with a lake view. Orders are taken at the front- no table service and orders are called out to pick up when ready. Sorry- but not a lot of ambiance here. The menu is standard pub fare- sandwiches, paninis & salads. Our sandwiches were tasty but not exceptional. Sorry- it does not make the bucket list for a repeat visit!

The presentation is amazing and the taste backs it up. The wait staff is always very friendly and…read moreaccommodating, with pretty consistently fast service. The restaurant has a rustic feel to it, and not at all in a negative way. More so a homey way. The food quality could rival some Michelin star restaurants and all for an affordable price. Their Friday night dinners have amazing options, and is recommended for when you don't feel like cooking.

The service was phenomenal, our server was pleasant and could definitely read our group. We came in…read morefor breakfast, was enjoyed by all, wasn't a 5-star breakfast but the service definitely was. This new restaurant is definitely a good place to stop. The atmosphere is pleasant and nice.

Amazing sandwiches, wicked fries, great service. Ordered online and picked up in 15 mins. Couldn't…read morehave been easier. Or more delicious. Def 5

I can't believe it took me THIS long to try this Ithaca staple. The sub was packed with flavor. The…read morefries were perfectly fried and seasoned. And the portions were the right amount for one satisfying meal. I recommend ordering ahead online, especially on weekends, to avoid the line that can sometimes form.

Such a cute spot! TONS of pastry's and sweet treats. There will always be something that catches…read moreyour eye! I always love their creative coffee specials. The staff is very friendly, and quick to prep the drinks and breakfast sandwiches!

Sad I didn't take any pictures for my review but it seems to be on brand that I'm always…read moreforgetting. Overall, have been coming to the bakery for year. Well before it's charming renovation, back to when it had leather bar stools at the bakery counter and Jim in the back making the best apple fritters you've ever had. I come whenever I'm in town and it's always good. I think more than anything I come for the nostalgia. The Rice Krispie treats are always a solid pick and I enjoy them a lot. Same with the smiley face cookies, the bakery frosting is the best. I got a parfait for the first time since high school though and was sorely disappointed. They used to use wake robin yogurt (which I do remember them discontinuing some years ago), but now the yogurt is SO sweet. Overall it makes the parfait too sweet with the homemade granola and blueberry coulis. I couldn't help but notice how much smaller the parfait portions are too. They used to be full sized cups and now they're nearly half their former size which was definitely disappointing considering the price has certainly not gone down. In summary, the bakery will always hold a special place in my heart. Been going since I was a baby. The treats are good, sandwiches are solid, and they have a wide variety of beverages. Steer clear of the updated parfait though

Finally made it here and wasn't disappointed. Their sandwiched are everything I imagined. Large,…read moreexpertly constructed, resonably priced and tasty.

Great sandwiches! Great customer service. Great atmosphere. Very friendly. Great food! Grind the…read morehamburger in front of you.

What a hidden gem. We were traveling through and found this little spot to eat at. It's like…read moreeverything is homemade - it's so fresh, delicious, and definitely make sure to try whatever seasonal lemonade she has available. Great price, great food and GREAT people! Lunch was a 10/10. Hope I can come back when it's warm out to enjoy the view even more.

The lady that took my order was not friendly. The sandwich I got I wished I got something else…read more The chips was from the bottom of bag. They were all broken small pieces. Won't spend my money there