Haven't been here in awhile and decided to come for dinner one evening recently. Never had the meatloaf Wellington nor have I had meatloaf in a long time so it was suggested I try it. Wow did I make the right decision? It was absolutely delicious cooked too perfection. The service was great, and the price was not bad. ($26) the ambience is welcoming and it's a very nice size upstairs and down. I will definitely be back to this establishment again. If you want some good food, definitely check this place out. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Meatloaf Wellington. Delicious! - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

Food is very good. we regularly take out or eat there. However I was extremely disappointed tonight when I ordered ratatouille salad with shrimp to go. Adding shrimp to the salad is extra $10 and I received 4 medium sized shrimp. That is not a serving and for $10?? I called and asked to speak to a manager and was told that no one was available on site to discuss and if I wanted to call back in 3 days someone might be available. Seriously no manager available on a Saturday night??? read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - 4 medium sized shrimp - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

In Monroe on vacation. Stopped in the Taphouse on two separate locations. Great service. Tasty food. Good beer choices. Clean. Highly recommend. read more

Haven't been here since it changed from the Barnsider some years back. Staff was pleasant and not lazy. Place looked a lot cleaner and brighter than years back. Nice menu selections fair prices given today's economic market. Plentiful on the plates. Burger was well done not medium as ordered. Other than that, looking forward to going again. read more

I was checking out the Sugar Loaf artisan streets when I got hungry so I stopped by for a quick bite. I ordered the meatloaf Wellington and tap house salad to split with my boyfriend. Prices are on the high end side but we both were able to eat for a grand total of $40. The salad was simple but had a lemon vinaigrette and it was so good that my bf dipped the bread in it. The Meatloaf Wellington at Sugar Loaf Taphouse is honestly a hidden gem. It's like they took a comfort-food classic and gave it a gourmet upgrade. The meatloaf itself is tender and flavorful, wrapped in this perfectly golden puff pastry that's buttery and flaky in all the right ways. The mushroom duxelle they add gives it this earthy depth, and the gravy? Oh, the gravy--it ties everything together with this rich, savory finish. It's served with a side of creamy mashed potatoes that are so smooth, they feel like a hug for your soul. The portion is generous, and the presentation is surprisingly fancy for a taphouse. I love that the also include some veggies to balance out the heaviness of the dish. The vibe of the place is warm and inviting, too--like a small-town pub where you can just relax and enjoy good food. The staff is friendly, and you can tell they have pride in what they serve. They give great recommendations as well. If you want something comforting but elevated I highly recommend the meatloaf Wellington. read more

See all

What a great place to grab dinner! Came for a family dinner and they did not disappoint from the food for the service it was a top to down great place to eat. Our sever Julianne was super helpful and full of personality. Taking the tables order she gave up opinions and recommendations, really helped make it a great experience. The table ordered Bruschetta and sloppy Joe dip. The sloppy Joe dip was sweet and tangy, a great eat. The bruschetta was different with apples, walnuts and Gorgonzola cheese. Julianne pro tip got me to switch to Vodka sauce instead of red sauce for the chicken parm. It was so good like I couldn't believe how big the portions were and how amazing it all tasted. We had some drinks, enjoy the mood lighting and laughter of the rustic style of this restaurant. It was a 5/5 star meal and we all had leftovers to look forward too. read more

See all

Food was amazing! Stopped in for lunch, everyone was friendly and polite. My companion had the chicken pot pie soup as a starter. Then fish and chips as the main course. I had chicken dumplings with apple slaw and teriyaki sauce as a starter and the Sunday Sliders with chicken cutlet and pickle on a potato roll and house pickle slaw (I skipped the honey butter/dairy). I loved the house pickle slaw which is made with vinegar (I think ACV) instead of mayo--added the perfect sweet and sour flavors to the slider. I also had a side of sweet potato fries--everything was tasty. Prices were super reasonable and the serving size was excellent--starters are great for sharing with a group. Ambiance was comfortable. Will definitely come back to try more options! read more

See all

Four of us stopped by on a Monday afternoon for a quick lunch. Upon arrival we were immediately seated & attended too. The food was delicious. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

$17 for the blackened chicken sandwich with the tiniest little sliver of chicken you've ever seen. this place continues to raise its prices like crazing while plummeting in quality. staff is great though, wish i could give them a separate review. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

Place is so cozy! Great menu, I ordered the filet mignon sliders, top on my list now. Food came promptly. Our waitress was professional and kind, took great pictures of us. Never expected such a great ambiance with great food in a beautiful little town. You guys made my day. read more

See all

The ambiance to this place is a bar that has an extension of a dining room with 11 or 12 tables. The food was good we had the Cesar salad and filet mignon sliders. The mayo on the sliders was very good. My daughter had the raviolis and they were huge and 4 to an order. She is 5 and finished them all. The service is where this place falls apart. From my understanding this is typically the busy time of year for this town, if that's the case then they need to hire alot more staff. We ordered refills on drinks and never got those uuntil our check came and that was only because I had to ask for them. Overall the food is good they just need more dining room support. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

Food was pretty bad, I had buffalo ravioli and there literally was no filling, ceasar salad was all romaine stems, hubby had fish and chips and fish was soggy, wait staff seemed confused, probably will not go back there read more

Frequent customer, nice atmosphere! The food didn't disappoint and the beer was intense. read more

Told you we'd be back! Went here on Saturday July 19th 2025 with my parents for a much needed dinner. Decided to go to this place because we haven't been here in a while. Be forewarned, it can still get crowded. Went inside, and there was a line at the host stand, however, we were sat right away at a booth. Server greeted us right away, and She was very pleasant. started with 3 waters, I ordered the Giggle Juice cocktail, my mom ordered the pineapple Margarita, and my dad ordered a titos with sprite. Our drinks came out in a timely manner, and there was something in the drink, but the server fixed it right away and made a new one. Looked over the menu, and decided on The Veggie Burger. Can't remember what my dad or mom ordered unfortunately. But our server took great care of us and constantly checked on us, including how the food was going! We all enjoyed our food and highly recommend Sugar Loaf Taphouse if you are in the area! Paid the check via a credit card and left a cash tip! Would definitely be back if we are ever in the area! read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Veggie Burger - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

Enjoying dinner with family. Very nice place with a nice atmosphere and ample parking space. The staff was very pleasant and serviceable; always making sure we were ok at our table. The food was delicious, and I like the dishes presentation. I would love to come back in the summer for an outside seating!!! read more

See all

Food was pretty good I had. salmon sandwich that I really enjoyed, with a salad and a good asian dressing. However I ordered a pear cider and they served me one without bubbles. What's up with that? It's like they got rid of a bottle that they opened by mistake. they brought me a fresh one but still. Why pass off stuff that is hanging around to paying customers? read more

Although we invariably wind up waiting, even with reservations, on weekends and area event happenings, the waiting is well worth it! We, my family and friends, love, love this place! The food, atmosphere and service is top notch . Best burgers and salads in the Hudson Valley! My absolute favorite is their Shepherd's Pie, which is off-the-charts good read more

Food was excellent quality was amazingly unexpected. My husband and I and our friends really enjoy the evening places should try.

Sugar Loaf Taphouse is one of our go-to spots every fall, especially before heading out to Warwick for apple picking. The food is consistently fantastic, and this time was no different. We had the burger (juicy and flavorful), the truffle flatbread (deliciously rich), the fig and prosciutto flatbread (sweet and savory perfection), and the chicken wrap. All the appetizers were top-notch as well! The service was excellent--friendly and attentive. It's such a cozy, welcoming place that always adds to our fall traditions. We absolutely love it here, and it's become one of our fall staples. Highly recommend stopping by! read more

See all

First time here was a found by accident and now when in this area we go. This place is super clean friendly staff and food is good.

Love this place! Usually crowded and often you have to wait to get in but well worth it! Somewhere you can bring your family too. Until yesterday I didn't realize they had an upstairs for seating as well. Food is amazing! The brussels sprouts appetizer is one of my favorite things! The wings are also a great choice. Got the filet mignon sliders but didn't think they were that great. Felt like they lacked something but can't put my finger on it. read more

See all

This is a great place but what's exceptional is the service and Alex the bartender made our experience so memorable. She was warm, funny and professional. Definitely coming back. Thank you. read more

I have never had a bad meal here! Their penne vodka and sloppy Joe appetizer are my two favorites. It can get really busy at night time and for lunch so I suggest making reservations prior to coming here. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - My favorite dish!! Penne ala vodka! - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

We used to go here when it was cold the barn cider. It was good then, and it is still good now. The service was good and the food was good. The atmosphere is nice. read more

Recently visited Sugar Loaf Taphouse for a lunch with some friends after the Xmas holiday. It's a nice rustic looking place, not overly large, with a dining room and a bar room with some tables. We were seated quickly and placed drink and meal orders. It was just the beginning of the lunch crowd and they seemed to have plenty of servers and staff on the floor. The service started out good but as tables filled it became slower. We had to flag down the server for drink refills several times and at least once they totally forgot our drink refills several order until the second reminder. I'm not sure why this happened as it seemed to me there were plenty of people working on the floor. Overall the food was good. I had the burger and fries. A typical burger, but nothing special or unusual. The others had various sliders which they remarked were very good. Prices were on the mostly reasonable side but some things were excessive. I'd avoid the appetizers next time. They weren't a great value for the prices charged. All in all it was an above average experience. read more

Everything was great... had the filet mignon sliders (MR and it actually was) and added fries. Best fries I've had in years. Tender on the inside and crispy on the outside. Sort of a steak fry narrow cut. Rare to be good enough to post about. Pricing was fair and with the quality felt we were getting a deal. Found the place on a recommendation from a local in the area... and they were right. read more

All I can say is wow... upon arrival I was worried that we wouldn't be able to get a table. The parking lot was full and the street was lined with cars. However, we were seated right away. The restaurant has a cool vibe, super attentive staff, and delicious food. We started with the sloppy Joe dip. Don't sleep on this simple, yet inspired appetizer. I had a special - onion soup sliders - and fries. The burgers were perfect. The onions and cheese and the onion soup dipping sauce were generous and well prepared. My wife had the Chicken Milanese. It was the biggest, most fresh plate of food I have seen at a restaurant in a good many years. I'm just sad I didn't snap photos. This is a 100% must visit. We can't wait to go back! read more

Sugar loaf taphouse is a staple of the community. Always good cold beer, great food and an awesome vibe. Anytime family or friends are in the area it's always one of my go to recommendations. Love this place! read more

Surprisingly good brunch place in a small town. We went there after a hike at the Indian Hill trails. It's a 10 min drive to feed the hungry hikers. First of all, they have a spacious parking lot. Cute out door seats for those with dogs. The indoor seats are great too. Service was good. The servers were nice but they were pretty understaffed. We waiting for a long time for our server to take our order and we could see him working each table trying his best to provide best service. Our food was really good. I loved my fries and I am pretty picky about my fries. The fish was pretty good too. The beer batter was nicely done. The flatbread tho yum!!! I didn't think it would be so good. I really had no expectation coming from NYC to have this quality of good food. (Sorry proud foodie of 5 boroughs...) Not to mention this is a tap house. They have a great selection of local beers including a lot of good upstate breweries. Definitely try a few beers. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Menu - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

We were in the area looking for a place to have lunch and found the Sugar Loaf Taphouse located on a quaint street in town. The Filet of Beef Sliders and the Pulled Pork Sandwich from the daily specials were both very good. The Barnsider Burger was a good-sized burger though a little dry. Service was very friendly though they were stretched a little thin in a busy Saturday afternoon. Overall, a solid local establishment for a casual meal. read more

See all

Amazing food and vibes! Portion sizes are great and super tasty food. Will come back more often! Also tons of parking read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Chicken club - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

Sweet atmosphere where everyone is welcomed. Good food and service local eatery in Sugar Loaf convenient and lotsof parking

Whatttttttt!! How have I never eaten here before?? I don't even know what to say besides, YUM. They went out of their way to ask a Vegan cook in the kitchen what is the best option for my sensitivities. And by golly am I impressed! My husband said the meatloaf was the best he's ever had in his life. read more

See all

Have been coming here for years and it's as good as ever! Great food. Great service. And Alex, sometime bartender, sometime waitress, is AMAZING! Her energy makes evey visit an experience. read more

Have heard good things about the place. Staff is somewhat drama - filled. I tried to work here and they would not hire due to management. Would not totally refer this place as a top place to eat at. read more

Amazing food, always consistent! Service is super friendly and on point, not hovering. Great place to eat! read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Chicken parm - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

We love the Tap house. The bar area is a little loud but it's a smaller room. Their food is awesome! The chicken dish is my favorite. You get two big chicken cutlets. It lasts me two meals. The staff is always nice, friendly and accommodating. read more

Sugar Loaf Taphouse - Chicken Milanese Delicious! - American Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

The only downside I see to this restaurant so thus far is that it isn't closer to home. I had received numerous recommendations about the food here and with good reason. One of the best Caesar salads I've had. The fish tacos were delicious although I did wish there were three of them. It should be noted I was also starving and subbed my side of rice for previously mentioned salad. My partner enjoyed his chicken dish and his chicken pot pie soup was amazing. Beautiful touch with the pie crust. My eldest enjoyed his burger; my youngest liked his chicken fingers and my middle child did think his steak unfortunately could've been better so maybe next time he'll try something else. Everyone had a great time however and the wiki sticks are always fun. Will be back. read more

Need some extra help!! Usually love this spot but they definitely need more servers. We didn't get our total order for apps and 45 minutes later still hadn't taken our dinner order. Very disappointing ‍ no one came to check on us. Waitress is totally overwhelmed. Hope they hire soon! read more

Stopped in to visit a friend who recently moved out of the area and was home visiting. The service was great, we were catching up and taking our time (which they at no point rushed us), however they were very attentive to our needs frequently. The apps my friend picked were Buffalo chicken ravioli and empanadas. I only tried the ravioli and while it wasn't my favorite, most seemed to enjoy. I got the short ribs and they were amazing! I wasn't crazy about the parsnip purée, but that is likely me not enjoying sweeter vegs. One friend had the sesame tuna and loved it and the other had ravioli which she enjoyed. I'd go back if I was in the area again. read more