A coworker told me about Sweet Tooth Bakery and omg their stuff is so good I love their Blueberry Lemon cheesecake is my favorite and I went into the shop the other day and Abby was so nice and helpful everyone needs to check them out you want be disappointed. read more

Sweet Tooth catered my wedding and other important events in my life. I got married in August, and people are still talking about the coconut bavarian cream wedding cake. For the wedding cake, I sent over designs and the cake was identical to what I asked for. For other events, I've ordered vegan and gluten-free cupcakes for guests who need them. Every time, they've arrived packaged separately and carefully to avoid contamination. My vegan friend loves the way their vegan cupcakes come out! They also have keto friendly cheesecakes and cookies that are delicious. I will add that they are popular so plan ahead if you'd like to use them for events. Cupcakes are easier to get closer to the event, but if you have your heart set on a cake design from them, you need to get on their calendar ASAP because they book up fast. read more

Sweet Tooth - a wedding cake surrounded by cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Stumbling upon Sweet Tooth was an absolute delight. The sweet treats were fantastic. It felt like even the ice cream was made in house. I enjoyed the cinnamon rolls, while my wife enjoyed the chocolate covered Oreo, the pecan bar and their vanilla bean ice cream. I wish I lived closer to this place as I'd make regular visits there all the time. LASTLY, the two young ladies working there (I wish I could remember their names) were so nice. They clearly have a good time working there and the vibe of the store is light and fun. I strongly recommend this place whenever you're in Fayetteville, NC. read more

The presentation of treats are great, however, the cupcakes are a bit dry for my liking. The price is a little high, as well.

I was just wandering down Sycamore Dairy Rd walking for exercise when I saw a sign for the Sweet Tooth Shop. Well, I am a touch overweight partially due to my fondness of sweets and just couldn't pass by without checking out their offerings. They offer a variety of desserts, coffees, milkshakes, and even breakfast sandwiches. I decided to sample a couple of their mocha cupcakes, Very tasty! The mocha flavored whipped cream on top was incredible. I actually thought I was drinking a mocha Frappuccino, except of course it was whipped cream piled high on the cupcake. The cupcake was light and tasted great too. It was a chocolate cake flavor. I didn't taste it separately so I'm not sure if it too was mocha flavored. The Sweet Tooth Shop offers a variety of items. They have milkshakes, cinnamon rolls, monkey bread, breakfast quiches, espressos and lattes, key lime bars and peanut butter bars, brownies, donuts, and cupcakes. There may be more they offer, those were the items I remember. I would definitely suggest the Sweet Tooth Shop if you're looking for something sweet. read more

Sweet Tooth - One mocha cupcake in a plastic carrying package. - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Yelp came to my rescue again. I was looking for a bakery to provide treats for the staff at the hotel where I was staying. I had had a long trip and had not had a good nites sleep. They were so helpful in meeting my needs that I thought a dessert treat was in order. This sweet shop had an extensive array to choose from. The variety of goodies was impressive. I got cake pops, cannolis which she filled as I waited, small treats that looked like mini tacos filled with cheesecake. I also got a reeces triple chocolate cookies for myself. The staff really enjoyed the treats. My cookies was yummy and soft (which is what I like). The cupcakes looked amazing and so did the macarons. read more

We ordered takeout dessert from here and it left much to be desired . The cupcakes were very very small especially for the price . The cheesecake was alright but did not taste fresh at all. The cream cheese brownie was bland . Probably won't be back read more

Sweet Tooth - Red velvet cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Small cozy place, brownie, red velvet cake and turtle cupcakes. They where moist about $3.79 per cupcake

very rude staff do not understand what good people skills are as far as the food cupcakes are very dry and stale bugs fly and roaches running around this place is dirty will never spend a cent here again. run from this place do not waste your time read the reviews read more

After a failed attempt to order online, apparently you cannot order online and they haven't removed it from their website, I called and placed my order successfully though. He also mentioned more flavors than what was shown online. The price per cupcake is good. We got 6, birthday cake, red velvet, strawberry and chocolate. My kids loved the birthday cake but who doesn't live confetti cake, blue frosting and sprinkles. I enjoyed the red velvet. The strawberry was by far my least favorite, the frosting is too strawberry-like but not natural strawberry more like strawberry jello flavored. The cakes are all the perfect sweet, which is great since the frosting is so sweet. The cream cheese frosting was great. As of this post, I didn't try the chocolate. The cake was also a little over cooked, slightly crunchy on the sides but overall they hit the spot. read more

Sweet Tooth - Strawberry, chocolate and birthday cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

I walked in and I was so excited and overwhelmed with all the delicious sweets everywhere. I went twice in one week (I shouldn't have) The macaroons were amazing Cheese cake- omg I got strawberry, turtle Carmel, Plan cheese cake and a sugar free Ice cream- crazy vanilla flavor for my daughter I have to say all was super delicious! My family and I enjoyed it and I recommend for you and your family to give it a try! read more

Bought a few small treats for my fiancé to try for his birthday since it was just the two of us celebrating. We both loved the cheesecake, one of the best we've ever had. The cupcakes we tried were good but not great. Cashier was friendly and helpful. Everything appeared clean and well organized. Overall a nice place, would definitely go again. read more

Once again, Sweet Tooth came through!! This bakery is amazing! Great customer service and delicious cake. While I live in NY this is the second time I order a birthday cake, without difficulty. I simply give them my idea/image and they execute beautifully. Thank you so much, again. read more

Sweet Tooth - Beautiful bouquet cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Ordered my daughter's 30th birthday cake here. They took the picture she liked of a cake and made it in an eight inch. Cake was made as promised on the date quoted. It had black icing so I was hesitant how it would taste but it was delicious. They'll have my business for future special occasions. read more

Sweet Tooth - Candles are not included - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

As a first time customer at Sweet Tooth, I was overwhelmed by the variety of desserts offered. With the assistance of a worker, I decided to purchase the Snickerdoodle cookie and Strawberry Cupcake. Both of the items were delicious. I will be back. read more

Sweet Tooth - Strawberry Cupcake and Snickerdoodle Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

The ice cream is pretty standard, better than grocery store (except not as good as Hagen daz or whatever) some of their specialty flavors are really good though. The cupcakes are amazing, again the specialty flavors are dank, and I would do unspeakable things for some red velvet cupcakes read more

My partner and I went in on a Wednesday afternoon at around 6:30pm and the shop was empty. A man greeted us and gave us plenty of time to decide on what we wanted. We ended up getting a Mocha cupcake, Strawberry cupcake, strawberry macaron, and a chocolate macaron. It came out to about $14.00 total. First we tried the macarons which were okay-ish. Nothing stood out about them and the strawberry one had a really mild taste. The chocolate was okay as well but the filling did taste like the store bought chocolate icing. Next we tried our cupcakes and they were honestly very mid. The Mocha just tasted like plain old box-chocolate cake. It fell apart when taken out of the wrapper and the frosting was very underwhelming and resembled whipped lard. It was not sweet at all like how a cupcake is supposed to be. The strawberry cupcake was a similar situation except the cake part tasted like bread. Neither cupcake gave any sweet notes that would be considered anything above mild and the frosting on this one was also giving whipped lard that smelled like strawberry. The only reason for the 2nd star was because the flower on top of the strawberry cupcake was good and the mocha had a nice presentation. All in all I wouldn't purchase again. read more

After the owner or worker white lady call me a bitch getting out of the shop I will never recommend this business. We have a car dealership and I will never treat a customer like that no matter what a customer asks. Very disrespectful, after so many years ordering cakes that was very disappointing to hear. read more

I found this shop on a random yelp search for a Bakery to make my mom's bday cake. I initially wanted to order off the website but saw that they were "sold out" of the cake I wanted to order. I called and they were so great and willing to make the cake for me! I'd never ordered from them before nor have I ever been to the shop. I ordered the chocolate cake and it was SO GOOD!! It was almost like a brownie, the icing was perfect and not too sweet, it was just a perfect chocolate cake. Everyone at the party loved it and asked where they could get it :) I will definitely be a returning customer. Thanks again! read more

Sweet Tooth - The best chocolate cake in Fayetteville! - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Awesome service, I love how clean and relaxed it was inside. The ice cream and red velvet cake amazing.

They made my wedding cake and delivered exactly what I was looking for! The cake tasted and looked amazing. Thank y'all for being so patient with me and allowing me to keep making changes! If you're looking to do a custom cake for any occasion you HAVE TO come here, you won't regret it! They're very quick with their responses (I went through email). 5/5 stars, wish I could give y'all more! read more

Sweet Tooth - Custom wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Taylor greeted me with a big Hello. I came in specifically for the gluten free cupcakes (they are one of the only places that se gluten free) for my daughters 16th birthday and I was not disappointed. Not only do they sell the best gluten free cupcakes, but the atmosphere is amazing and the customer service is top notch. Will def come back! read more

Cute little shop with a great selection of flavors! Their newly added donuts are good! I had the Bavarian filled one today and I also tried some of their cake pop flavors, all were good! read more

Sweet Tooth - Java chip, carrot cake, and red velvet cake pop flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

First time here and their cupcakes and cakes taste great. Kind attention and great service. Nice place and ambience to go with family and kids. read more

Super delicious, moist, not super sweet so it hurts your teeth. The best in Fayetteville!

Ordered: wedding cake cupcake - unavailable, when I called to inquire about missing cupcake, was told they were out and had refunded the charge chocolate cupcake - very moist and tasty, seem very small in size green mint chip cupcake - pretty, but not very minty, tasted just like the chocolate one, but with green frosting, small size key lime bar - very good, reasonable size lemon bar - very good, reasonable size lemon bar - very good, reasonable size tling was top notch, unfortunately smaller than the length of my little finger - one bite size Marked as free delivery but charge $1.99 delivery fee?!? Pricey - bars are a better value at $3 than cupcakes at $3.49 read more

Sweet Tooth is a nice place when you're in the mood for a dessert. They have a variety of cupcakes, including mini cupcakes for those that want a taste, cake pops, dessert bars, and coffee bar beverages. The desserts are tasty, especially the cupcakes and from the few times I've been there, they taste quite fresh. The interior is pleasant. It's a mix of modern and typical coffee house words of wisdom. The staff are generally courteous and patient. Parking can be a hassle so sometimes parking one's car in the Super King buffet area is needed. read more

Sweet Tooth - Super moist cake pop. - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Wish they had more comfortable chairs. Also not all of their items are priced/ named. Besides that, this coffee spot is so convenient. Everything I've tried there so far has been yummy. Items are well priced compared to Starbucks or even Coffee Scene. Its new, clean and put together. Definite recommendation. read more

Sweet Tooth - Delicious Iced latte - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Extremely disappointed with the service I received. Where I'm from service like this is unacceptable. I was contacted late. This should've been a hint and then after a month of back and forth from 3 different people and different answers from everyone I get an email that says I must pay for my deposit this past Tuesday and that what I wanted could not be done. I did my research and like what I saw online as far the work on the cakes from Sweet tooth but they have no idea what professionalism is. I am very disappointed. I ended up settling for less and still got less than what I settled for. This is my nieces first birthday and in my family cake presentation is very important. I have wasted my money read more

I ordered a vegan vanilla cake with strawberry icing for my birthday from Sweet Tooth. The woman who took my order was so kind and helpful. The cake is absolutely delicious and looks beautiful! Couldn't recommend enough read more

Sweet Tooth - Loved my cake from Sweet Tooth! Vegan vanilla cake with strawberry icing. It was DELICIOUS! - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Great experience. Were able to accommodate a last-minute cake order, and it was absolutely delicious. Everyone was blown away with how good the cake was, and they got it done exactly when they said they would. Honestly, I don't know that I've ever had a richer chocolate cake. Will definitely be back. read more

Sweet Tooth - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

I must say, I'm definitely going to this place again. Customer service was amazing for one. Not only that, I found everything plus more. Everything I received was delicious . read more

Went into the shop on January 7 to buy my husband cupcakes for his bday. This was my first visit. The cupcakes look very nice.....but looks can be deceiving. I bought a variety of cupcakes and a few macaroons. The cupcakes were not moist, they were edible and the taste was ok, but for the price I expected way better then what I can do at home. The macaroons were good, unfortunately that will be the only reason to go back. Another plus, the store was very nice. read more

Sweet Tooth - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Great customer service. Zipped in and out to get the perfect birthday tweet for my boss and co-workers. These cupcakes are so cute and delicious! Simply perfect for my sweet tooth :) read more

Sweet Tooth - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Stopped last minute to grab cupcakes for a party. 12 cupcakes came out to around $32. They were good but not worth that price. I was the only customer, I had to wait for someone to actually come out and greet me. Finally, ordered and paid. As I was signing, the guy just walls away. That was it, no thanks, no have a good day, nothing. I even stood by for a moment to see if he would return, nope. Very very poor service. read more

On August 15, 2022 my daughter ordered Vegan cupcakes for my twin grand daughters birthday a specific way and when we picked them up they were completely wrong from the way they were ordered. They were suposed to be vegan cake bottom with strawberry on 6 of them and chovolate on 6 of them instead we were 6 chocolate and 6 strawberry cake bottom with vanilla on top. This afternoon August 16, 2022 I tried to resolve the problem by giving my daughter a refund or getting them to make the cupcakes the proper way and was told they weren't making anymore vegan cakes today. They also refused to refund my daughter. How are you to run a business when you can't even make it right let alone provide good customer service. Whatever you do don't give this place a chance, The manager or owner was very rude to me!!! read more

My son is autistic and all over the place. I was having a hard time finding something like what he wanted for his birthday. So after some research online I found sweet tooth. I made a quick call and they encouraged me to bring him and stop by any time. They were amazing with him and made the exact cake he wanted. I hid the cake from him until it was time and he was jumping up and down saying "This is the best birthday ever!!" A huge thank you to the entire staff for making his birthday perfect. read more

Sweet Tooth - They were amazing my with son. They took their time and made the exact cake he wanted. I will be coming back for every birthday! - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Absolutely loved my cake made by sweet tooth. Not only was it beautiful but it honestly was one of the best cakes I've ever had. The Customer service was great and the store is adorable! Will not only use them again but would HIGHLY recommend them to everyone!! read more

Sweet Tooth - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

What a gem find for the area!! Nice little spot tucked into a large commercial building. You walk in and get a great visual of the decadent offerings and coffee selection. I opted for the barista special coffee drink, which is called a Eurolatte...so delicious, but really sweet so be careful! Snagged a few different cupcakes to sample. The strawberry sundae was absolutely to die for!!! And to top it all off, the gentleman working the shoppe was very friendly and helpful with information and suggestions. Definitely a must visit place if you're craving something sweet!!! read more

I live out of state, but wanted to cheer up my friend who lives in Fayetteville and broke her arm while on vacation. I emailed Sweet Tooth Bakery to see if they delivered. I was told that they normally only deliver for weddings and events, but if I could give them a location they would see what they could do. We emailed back and forth and they said they could indeed deliver some cupcakes to her work for a small delivery charge. Kiersten was very helpful on the phone and they made up a cute assortment of cupcakes for her. Sweet Tooth Bakery went above and beyond to help me cheer up my friend. She shared the cupcakes with her coworkers and everyone said they were very yummy. read more

Sweet Tooth - The yummy cupcakes they delivered. - Bakeries Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all