Ok so I was here at this location like last year and I came back since I was in the area and I was so happy to see that Anna Walters was working there still! She definitely made my time memorable and was able to provide an amazing service again! Of course the ice cream was spectacular but the customer service at this establishment is incredible. Can't wait to come back! read more

Went here on a Saturday afternoon with my family as we explored more of Downtown Westfield. There is street parking and designated lots dotted around. We just found a parking lot and parked. There are some tables and chairs in the front part of the shop so you can stay and enjoy as well as two benches outside if the weather is cooperative. The place is located on a side street and is pretty easy to find. They have a steady stream of customers coming in and out and they specialize in ice cream and cookies. They also have brownies as well. You can get them as ice cream sandwiches, an open faced cookie with ice cream on top (same with brownie), or just ice cream. There might be more I missed but I was preoccupied because one of my kids has multiple food allergies so we went in with not very high hopes, but it turns out they have all the ingredients printed out for you - so great news for those with complicated food allergies. Having said that, my kid could only have 2 cookies and 2 ice cream (chocolate, mint chocolate) flavors and it covers his favorite ice cream flavor of all time: chocolate. He's allergic to wheat, eggs, avocado, peanuts, tree nuts, kiwi, and pineapple and he didn't have a reaction. They got his ice cream from the back with a new spoon so no cross contamination. Major kudos there! We got: COOKIES AND CREAM SANDWICH: yep, cookies and cream ice cream between two cookies and cream cookies for my eldest who is a fan of everything cookies and cream. She really enjoyed this and ate most. I was impressed. The adults helped her finish it off. BROWN BUTTER DOUGHNUT (seasonal) + BLACKBERRY CRUMBLE SANDWICH: you can do split flavors so I did for the adults' treat. These were sandwiched between Snickerdoodle and Gooey Butter Cake Cookies. They will also split it for you if you want and make sure both halves have both flavors (yes, I wanted). Yum! DARK CHOCOLATE: my youngest got this in a kiddie cup. Yep, the one with food allergies. He ate it ALL and I didn't get a taste. I suppose that tells you a lot. The ice creams weren't too sweet but this might depend greatly on the flavors you get and the cookie(s). Ours were just right... though my husband said the cookies were maybe too much, haha. A great place to get an indulgent treat. And I'm glad my youngest was happy with his ice cream. You do have the option of getting them warmed at the end as well as toppings but my metabolism now really can't do additional goodies. Never mind what I already got. No regrets though! They're somewhat reasonably-okay priced... $4.50 for the kiddie cup and $9.19 for each ice cream sandwich (they are big and shareable so $4.60 per person?). However, I feel like I could have also finished one by myself if it were hot outside and I hadn't eaten in 2 hours. Okay, price isn't the most economical; just don't go regularly. I like how I didn't need to chug down a cup of water after the ice cream AND cookies so I was thoroughly pleased. The staff there are super friendly and helpful on top of all that! The tables look cleanish (I spotted tiny crumbs that were missed) but we wiped them down anyway like we usually do. I'll definitely be back when I'm in need of a treat! Sadly, no photos this time sound since everyone started eating as soon as they got them. read more

The line at this location wasn't bad at all and moved pretty quickly. The girl who took my order was also very sweet and warm, which made for a nice experience. I really like the concept of building your own ice cream cookie! The menu is easy to follow and walks you through the ordering process step by step: Step 1: Choose your top and bottom cookie Step 2: Choose your ice cream flavor Step 3: Add your toppings You also have the option to warm up your cookie, which I definitely should have done! I think warming it up would have enhanced both the flavor and texture of the cookies. I ordered a chocolate chip and Cookies 'n Cream cookie with s'mores ice cream. The flavors paired really well together, but I think it would have been even better served warm. I would definitely come back to try other flavors and experiment with different combinations! read more

See all

Love the concept but premium prices are a but much. Average of 9-10 bucks for ice cream is a bit wild but I guess the times we live in and based on location. Serving sizes are good- so it may be best to split one with someone. read more

Kind of your standard cookie and ice cream place. They specialize in ice cream sandwiches; you can also get them hot pressed (after assembled it is put into a hot press to warm both cookies on the outside). It was an ice cream sandwich, nothing to tell a friend to tell a friend about, but if I was in the area again this could be an option for dessert. The cookies are chewy so its a good texture for the ice cream sandwiches. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious cookies , such a cool variety of flavors as well ! Parking is tricky as they're parked on a busy street but worth the double park ! 28$ a dozen and they do serve ice cream as well ! read more

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

See all

Visited during a very busy time - Friday evening. Even though it was freezing cold outside, the cozy, warm establishment welcomed us with a sweet aroma. There was a rather long line (about ~4 groups in front of us). and though the people behind the counter seemed very busy they served us with a huge smile on their face. We were able to sample ice cream before buying and it made all the difference. Pictured is the brownie sandwich with their seasonal donut flavor and the toasted s'mores. It is warmed without toppings, but it was perfect! Vegan and gluten free flavors are available. read more

See all

I loved the cookies and brownies. The service was cool. The ice cream was very lack luster and underwhelming unfortunately. read more

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Came here on a Sunday afternoon. I got a scoop of ice cream and 6 cookies. I got the bear batter ice cream with hot fudge and whipped cream. It was delicious. And i tried the butter cake cookie, chocolate chip, cookies and cream, carrot cake, Nutella, and cookie monster. My favorite was the butter cake cookie. read more

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Decent ice cream! Didn't try the baked goods. I would definitely go back. Blackberry crumble was tart & sweet! read more

See all

It was very good and unique the service and vibe there was nice to. Hiiiiiiiiiiiuiiuuiuiuiiiiiiiii

Loved this place! You get to pick your cookie and ice cream and then make the sandwich there and warm it up on the spot. Cookies are fresh and perfect size for the sandwich. Usually the cookies are thick and not proportional to the ice cream. I got a chocolate chip cookie on one side and confetti on the other side. The ice cream we got was their seasonal milk and cookie flavor. Must try! read more

The Baked Bear has absolutely amazing cookies and Ice cream, but I'd like to give a moment to shout out the employees at this location. I had a delivery sent to me when I was very sick and had just got out of the hospital. There was a message written to me from a family member in the notes which they included on the bag, but the staff at the Baked Bear went ahead and wrote me their own message to me as well. This was super sweet of them, and one step above anything they had to do. 10/10 recommend this location from the cookies, icecream, and the staff ! read more

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Have been to this location a handful of times and the environment is always wonderful. They have a wide variety of fresh cookies and when combined with their ice cream, they make for a delicious treat read more

Hands down-- best dairy free ice cream sold at a dessert shop that I have ever had. Paired with the brownie-- OH MY GOSH. The desserts here are a little pricey but honestly, the dessert is so decadent you don't even care about the price card. So many options and flavors! read more

Been to baked bear locations near the beaches in south jersey. This is similar, although the store is fairly small with only limited seating. Also just like the other locations, no parking lot. Need to look for metered parking It's decent. It will be close to a $10 ice cream, which puts it in line with summery. I personally prefer summery although admittedly I'm not a cookie ice cream sandwich person. read more

See all

The Baked Bear is another entry into the trend of undercooked cookies with maximum sugar, albeit with an ice cream twist. My experience was positive here, as the friendly workers made it easy to navigate the multiple steps towards creating my own custom ice cream sandwich. The flavors for both cookies and ice cream were diverse, with cookies like snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, and funfetti, as well as classic ice cream flavors like cookie dough and cookies and cream. The toppings were also pretty diverse, with sprinkles, m&ms, and other ice cream standards. The icing on the ice cream was the ability to warm the sandwich up a bit in a waffle press, making the cookies a little gooier and the sandwich a little less frozen. Lastly, while the space itself only has a few tables, it is right in downtown, so it can serve as a quick pitstop. That said, these sandwiches get messy fast, so may not be great to grab while you continue on your Westfield walk. read more

The Baked Bear - Brownie and chocolate chip cookie with cookie dough. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

I visited The Baked Bear on a whim in hopes of getting ice cream sandwiches on a super cold Saturday. My small group managed to find parking in a lot less than a block away and we quickly rushed to get to the shop. The space is large, clean, and well-organized, which is obvious from the moment you walk in. The person working behind the counter was friendly, efficient, and quickly handled the orders before us, so we didn't have a very long wait. They have some vegan and gluten-free options, gf is always appreciated by me. I opted to try their v/gf fudgy brownie cookie with old fashioned vanilla ice cream. I found the cookie to be very hard, and I don't think I could have attempted to eat my treat as a sandwich. The others in my group had soft cookies and were able to eat theirs as sandwiches. Not a huge deal, that's just the way the cookie crumbles sometimes. I really loved the ice cream portion and if I were to return, I would consider trying the chocolate chunk cookie instead to see if I get the same results. read more

See all

Attended to grand opening yesterday at The Baked Bear in Westfield! Great concept! You have so many choices! You can create your own ice cream sandwich. Buy cookies or ice cream!!! Basically any combo! Lots of customers! Staff friendly! Explained options! Rewards program available! Highly recommended! We got the cookie sandwich Chocolate chip cookies Cookie batter ice cream With mini chocolate chips Yum! Great sweet treat to end the night in Westfield! read more

See all

The Baked Bear - Westfield's Ultimate Ice Cream Sandwich Experience The Baked Bear in Westfield is pure dessert joy--a custom ice cream sandwich spot that absolutely delivers. We definitely will be back. I built a sandwich with brambleberry ice cream between a "gooey butter cake" cookie and a "funfetti" cookie, and it was everything I didn't know I needed. The ice cream was phenomenal--thick, creamy, and with a soft-serve-like texture that held up beautifully between the warm cookies. The vibe here is laid-back and family-friendly, and the staff were exceptionally patient and friendly, even with a line forming. Everything's clean, the restrooms included, which is always a good sign when a place handles high traffic with care. Pro Tips: * Mix and match cookies--you can't go wrong. * Brambleberry is a sleeper hit--rich, tangy, and perfectly balanced. * Great for a post-dinner treat or casual weekend stop with family or friends. Final verdict: This spot hits the sweet spot--creative, comforting, and done right. A total win for Westfield. read more

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

See all

So excited this is open so close to home! Went grand opening week, friendly staff and helpful on flavor choices. You can pick and flavor cookies and ice cream to create your own sandwich. You can also just order cookies, ice cream, brownies on their own. The cookie was soft and doughy, I feel the cake batter ice cream was lacking some flavor but will come back to try another combination! read more

The Baked Bear - Confetti cookie cake batter ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Wow!! I've followed the baked bear on IG for years and finally got to try their new Westfield location. We went on a promo day where everyone got a free ice cream scoop, so I only paid for the cookies. Prices are expensive, but the sandwiches are huge and delicious. You can customize with any cookie, brownie, ice cream and topping. You can even buy the cookies or ice cream separate. The line moved quickly and had a great cookie sandwich - chocolate chip cookies with s'mores ice cream. Can't wait to try other flavor combinations! read more

See all

Delicious! And it was free today, we were surprised and enjoyed this little treat:) would come again! read more

The Baked Bear - Store photo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

And, desert is served ! The staff was so friendly I loved it ! You choose your two cookies (mix and match if you'd like!) we did Nutella and macadamia nut cookies ! Then choose your ice cream. They let you taste test so we tasted s'mores, almond brittle cake, and mud pie. S'mores is more than your basic s'mores it feels rich. While I'm not an almond girlie that ice cream doesn't taste much like almonds it taste like a good old cake batter and that's a good compliment! But our favorite was mud pie with its sweet espresso taste it won us over. 10/10 . And to the ladies who work there today thank you you're amazing. Also, I was truly surprised that for a Sunday they weren't super busy. would love to gate keep talk but this is too good to not share. read more

See all

Went to the Baked Bear with some friends after doing an escape room. We were all excited to try a bite of "The Baked Bear." Weirdly enough, some of the bites of The Baked Bear tasted like oven cleaner or just straight up paper towels. Around 1 hour after eating The Baked Bear, we all went through a troubling time in the bathroom. Even the next day, many of us woke up in absolute bowel pain. I'd avoid going to The Baked Bear in the near future. No idea what's going on in their Ice Cream Creation Lab, but i don't like it! read more

This place was amazing!!! customer service is great, and i got the fudge sundae with mud pie ice cream and brownie. read more

The Baked Bear - Fudge Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

New go-to spot. Love all of it. Also can order by delivery service. One of the better dessert spots in town.

I love this place! I felt like a spoiled big kid teehee Great bumping music, and the staff was super sweet and patient with me walking me through the process. If you guys get a sandwich I definitely recommend getting it hot pressed, it was the bomb! read more

The sandwiches are great I shouldn't have to ask more than once for it to be warmed up. I don't care tha you have to put gloves on. Do your job read more

I was excited to check this place out, but I have to say I was disappointed. Everything is sold ala carte. If you want just a cookie, you can buy that by itself, as well as the ice cream. The cookies are UNDERCOOKED in my humble opinion. Did not like that. I don't know why they do that. And the ice cream options were slim. We went over the weekend (in February) in the evening. Its a small shop, with few tables and was very crowded. Those that had a table weren't moving even though they were clearly finished. There was also staff on break taking valuable table real estate. So we ate ice cream outside in February. It's a novel idea, but once was enough. I won't be going back. read more

This review is just about the cookies. I still haven't tried the ice cream or ice cream sandwiches yet but the cookies are amazing. If you like crumbl and all the others like them then you will love baked bear. Baked bear cookies are actually better than all the cookie places imo. They are the same size round but they are thinner. They have great flavors, always fresh and always soft but they are about 1/2 the price. Most of those cookie places charge about $5 per cookie. Baked bear is around $2.50. You get great flavors and more for your money. Love the cookies and love the concept of the cookie ice cream assembly. I need to try the in ice cream with the cookies soon but 5 stars if you just want a fresh box of cookies. read more

See all

I visited today and was welcomed by a wonderful team of staff. They were incredibly friendly and offered recommendations. I tried mint chocolate chip ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies. Even though it was 30 degrees, the weather didn't stop me from enjoying some ice cream. This idea is such a winner and will be popular all year long. Definitely check it out and support this business-you won't regret it! read more

Are you kidding me? How is this place in business? The cookies are just awful - thin, falling apart when you pick them up, sickly sweet, and visually so unappealing - just total garbage. If you buy 2 cookies with ice cream to make a sandwich, it will cost you $10. And it will be a lousy ice cream sandwich at that. Do yourself a favor and skip the hype. This is probably the worst experience I have ever had with baked goods. The fact that this chain has expanded to multiple states with multiple locations is baffling. I guess it just proves what poor taste the average person has these days. Don't waste your money on such junk. read more

Great place to experience something different and unique. Ice cream was delicious and service was excellent. Family friendly business. Will definitely be back. read more