My coworker and I wanted to get dessert after our dinner and found this place down the street. We decided to check it out. It's located on the same street as the Fresh Fish Market and across of Main Street Spirits on Main St in, I believe, downtown Rahway. There is only paid metered street parking around the area. Prior to ordering, I was given the option to sample some of their flavors. I ordered a small with two flavors: Banana Dulce de Leche and Espresso. The Banana Dulce de Leche was a pleasant surprise, with a good banana flavor that was unfortunately overpowered by the caramel. I also found the Dulce de Leche to be a bit icy, which didn't blend well. The Espresso was okay, but had only a light, aromatic coffee flavor. I thought it wasn't strong enough in my opinion. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Overall, it's a nice spot for dessert after lunch or dinner, and the large seating area is a plus.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Wholly Cow - Espresso & Banana Dulce de Leche - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This is a fun spot for gelato or a coffee.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I had a small cup with mango and coconut gelato. The coconut gelato was delicious and I enjoyed the mango as well. These flavor profiles in the flavors I had are strong so if you don't like coconut don't order the coconut gelato. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There is a nice area inside to relax and enjoy the gelato.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I liked the music that was playing when I was there as well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Wholly Cow - Small mango and coconut gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Came here for some ice cream. We got 2 small gelatos. The flovors we chose were ube and dulce de leche banana. And chocolate hazelnut and cookies and cream. My favorite was the chocolate hazelnut. It was thick, smooth, and creamy. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was nice as well. You can sit and play games.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Wholly Cow - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Absolutely delicious gelato ! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Such a cute spot with a nice variety of flavors ![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The vanilla bean is absolutely delicious in a Afagoto ! Prices are a little high but worth the price ! read more

See all

A slick gelato spot in downtown Rahway serving up around 10 flavors plus espresso and coffee on the side. I had the banana dulce de leche. The actual banana flavor came through, which is rare and appreciated. The balance was spot on. It wasn't too fruity or too sweet. Only downside was the icy texture in the dulce de leche, which distracted from the gelato's creaminess. I knocked a star off because of that. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Inside, it's stylish and cozy. Gold spirals on the walls give it a touch of glam without being over the top. The vibe is calm and polished.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service was efficient but not particularly warm. The staff member seemed focused, but a little friendliness would have elevated the visit. Street parking is metered and a bit tricky, but circling the block usually does the trick. Great spot for a quick sweet fix with some flair. read more

Wholly Cow - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

A standard and lovely gelato for a warm summer day and night. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The location is optimal in Rahway downtown and the space is open airy and millennial modern with windbreak chairs and great supportive seating to study, chat, play board games with friends, and hang out treat with the kids.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff is each time attentive and efficient, letting you have 2-3 samples until you finally decide your order. The staff friendliness is kind and refreshing when there's eager patrons who want a sugar fix. To note-- Their espresso drinks and lattes are delicious as any barista at a cafe. Standard flavors like Pistachio and Stracciatella are solid, true smooth to texture without so much heft, definitely full flavor. Their mango gelato is decadent and feels like you just had a case of Alfonso mangoes delivered to you. Another pleasant and robust favorite order is an affogato with vanilla or any flavor is a seminal go-getter treat that's energize you and tick that checkbox of decadence. All in all, an amazing and needed addition to Rahway! My partner and I treat ourselves to a gelato more often than warranted, but in these times of gloom & concern, we're trying to live a little, even for just a scoop. 5 stars & Rahway mainstay. read more

Daughter saw purple ice cream, well gelato and had to go inside. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Chocolate cones were a nice touch and the location itself was beautiful.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service was prompt, staff were naturally friendly. As for taste I haven't had much gelato to compare it to. Ube flavor was good not over powering or sweet. Lost a star for the value an espresso size cup for $7.20 (cash) was steep. read more

Wholly Cow - Ice cream flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Oh my goshhhh!!! Just do yourself a favor and go here!! You want a delightful refreshing ice treat, this is the place! Was craving a chilling treat & came here with my bestie per her recommendation. Sooo good! Ordered a cup with part blood orange sorbet and part mango. Soo happy and wanted more. Next time, I will order the lemon sorbet! For coconut lovers, the coconut gelato is delish as well! Also, tried their gigantic triple chocolate cookie which was amazing! read more

Wholly Cow - Mix of blood orange and mango sorbets - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Finally got the chance to try Wholly Cow and it did not disappoint. There are not many places that have REAL homemade gelato in Union County but Wholly Cow does! I got an ice cream sandwich. Dulce de Leche gelato sandwiched in between two soft homemade chocolate chip cookies. It was great. The selection on offer is also great as well. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Inside there is plenty of places to sit and it is open pretty late, 11:00pm, which is awesome.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Really nice spot, delicious espresso gelato but some of the other flavors I tasted were a bit too sweet for my liking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance was nice- really big space with a cozy couch and a few squishy chairs, and there are also games you can play.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Friendly service, and some cute cow pictures on the wall read more

Wholly cow this place is just that, literally. I was so surprised to find a hidden local gem that makes FRESH, REAL gelato. So real, I thought the pistachio gelato was mislabeled because it wasn't the color green! I got the pistachio and cookies and cream! So yummy! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Service was great and the shop was so cute![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It had touches of cow print all over which I loved![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Highly recommend checking them out! read more

Wholly Cow - Medium gelato with pistachio and cookies and creme - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

This gelato shop was so good. It is perfect for an evening walk or an afternoon sweet tooth break. I had the chocolate chip cookie sandwich with vanilla bean, they were already premade and put right by the ice cream selection, the other option they had available was peanut butter cookie with strawberry jam gelato which sounded delish! The cookie remains soft, even with the hard ice cream in it. the cookie cost $6.75. There was only one gentleman working there but they just open recently so I'm sure they're just figuring things out to see how many customers they get. The place is so cute inside, the music and ambience were a vibe!! Check it out. read more

See all

The gelato and bakery items are amazing! My favorite is the gelato named after Harry Potter spell Stupify! The service is always friendly and efficient they even offer you explanations of limited flavors and most popular. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The atmosphere is eclectic and very attractive.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]They have sufficient spacing for small group of friends like 10 and of course more intimate setting for a quiet date night[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Beautiful cosy clean place, i tried mint chocolate chips gelato small size but definitely enough. It's creamy & smooth, not sure if it's authentic but taste great . read more

See all

Tried the affogato. The espresso is good just like any other cafe you visit, but the cost of the affogato itself is 2$ + more than others I've had at over 9$ for a cup without tip(10.34$ with 1$ tip)when they normally can be had at 6-7$(some places even offer 2 scoops at 6 bucks which is a steal). There's a lot of space inside to sit and the person that helped me out was pretty nice. Great spot but if the affogato price reflects the price of their other products, it's a tough buy. read more

Fresh ingredients, Refreshing service & a cool chill ambiance! From their freshly baked Cookies & Muffins to their delish beverage items you can't go wrong. read more

Wholly Cow - & Can't forget about the classics! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Lovely place for a quick bite and a delicious latte. ...................................................................................... read more

we came by with my family tonight. parking wasn't easy and was kinda nervous about getting out of the car. alittle sketchy small portions and not my favorite spot. the lady working was extremely sweet. read more

Love, love, love this place. Great gelato, coffee etc. but the cookies are downright amazing. [[HIGHLIGHT]]very confortable seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great place to hang or work.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service is always A+ read more

We stopped in here today after I saw them post on Instagram that they have options for those with allergies. Our son has a nut allergy and it was great to see that all of the flavors are in separate containers and use their own scoopers. We all loved our flavors (both kids were big fans of Cookies and Cream) and the server was very patient and helpful. The space is also very nice, a great spot to just sit and enjoy your gelato. We'll be back soon! read more

We stopped in on a rainy Friday night after getting pizza at Nancy's, we found it by accident while looking for parking. The ambiance inside is so nice, it's just mellow and has nice lighting and just a generally nice place to hang out. The gelato was good, I got banana dulce de leche and my daughter got strawberry, we enjoyed it! Also warmed up with a cappuccino which was great. The woman working was so friendly. Will definitely be back. read more

Had been wanting to try it bc I love gelato but was disappointed. The space is very cool and sleek but the ice cream is not Italian gelato.. too firm and not creamy enough. Pistachio was very subdued, as was banana dulce de Leche. Plus was 2 flavors for a small cup (which is big in my view) but overall didn't meet my (high) expectations.. back to my search for the real gelato! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The space is super cool but the gelato isn't great.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The green tea tasted like it was made incorrectly, and the other flavors we tried weren't much better. The cups are very small for the price and the service is slow. They should have a second person working behind the counter. read more