Jerry took great care of us while at the B&B. It's a short…read morewalk to the old lighthouse and really close to the Main Street too. Breakfast was great! Really intimate surroundings with only four rooms so you could have chats in the morning. West coast warning: if the fire dept needs to be called a loud siren goes off and it is super loud, especially when asleep. We found this out in the morning. I thought for a second we were being invaded by Canada! Lol.

Jerry and Claudine took such good care of us during our stay! The breakfasts in the morning were so…read moredelicious and changed daily! There is always coffee available in the dining room (courtesy of the Keurig machine), and in the afternoon/evening, there are fresh cookies! This charming B&B only has 4 rooms, so you'll never be overrun with people. You're very close to the old lighthouse and the water, as well as the 'downtown' area of restaurants, bars, ice cream, etc. The rooms are a bit small (especially the bathroom), as that was the way rooms were built in the 1800s, but our room served its purpose of giving us a close location while visiting family. **If you are not from New York (or a small-ish town?), you must know this information!!! In small towns like Sodus, the fire department is all volunteers. When someone calls for them, to alert all the volunteers that they are needed, they set off a crazy loud air siren!! I'm all for nostalgia and quaintness of years past, but come one people, everyone has a cell phone. Call those volunteers! When the first (of 3) sirens went off at 11:00pm, Jim G and I didn't know what to think! Was Canada finally sick of our bs and coming to invade? Was the nuclear power plant not too far away melting down? Was a tornado a-comin'? No one was leaving their homes or driving off in a panic, so we tried to ignore it and sleep. Then another one a bit later. Then the final one at 4:00am! Our fellow travelers found our fear hilarious at breakfast! We can laugh about it now, but seriously, catch up with the technology, lol! Thanks, Jerry and Claudine!

Been staying here for years it's the best. Fantastic hosts wonderful muffins in the morning and…read morecoffee.

Just spent the last three nights in this most delightful slice of heaven. The rooms were…read morewonderfully appointed and very cozy and the hosts, Margaret and Larry, made us feel right at home. My wife, my children, and I had such a great time over Father's Day weekend. I highly recommend the Wickham House!

This place is great. The hosts are very nice and helpful. The town is a great place to visit too.read more

Mike and John were great the house was beautiful and the house was within walking distance of…read moredowntown.

What a beautiful Bed and Breakfast. Georgia the host was such a lovely, warm and kind person. She…read moreshared her story of raising her 6 kids in this farm house. The house is clean and decorated with antiques. Could use a few updates but what you get from the host, the incredible breakfast, the beautiful serene backyard, the water view and decks, makes it perfect. Would highly recommend this place to anyone. Thank you Georgia.

Wow the amazing rooms, delicious breakfast , and they have a Dock! Georgia is so sweet and kind and…read morewould recommend A+

The best bed and breakfast with orchard horse ranch/vineyard. They over look orchards which skirt…read moreLake Ontario.

Warm friendly hosts in a 150 year old home. Not every room has a closet, coat rack yes closet no:…read morehowever it's only for a night or two. Some rooms have larger bathrooms, again no big deal for a night or two. Fresh breakfasts with local fruits and maple syrup. Very relaxing weekend get-away.

The place is great me and a couple freinds went up there fishing and these people who own the place…read moreare very nice and the breakfast was great also.ya can wake up walk across the lawn and your fishing catching 10 pound browns and slobbers it was awsome and one after the other it was nuts really so within the first 20 minutes you were beat already arms are hurtin for real ..i highly recommened this spot its great ill be goin again soon ..good luck everyone who goes here ...rip there lips off

Belinda makes you feel at home! This beautiful old gristmill is so warm and inviting and stunningly…read moredecorated with a fascinating history with the Underground Railroad. You feel like you've stepped into the past (with indoor plumbing, that is)! Belinda, the owner, is one of the nicest, most welcoming people. So fun got talk to!! She gave my wife and I a tour of the house when we checked in, and oh my goodness, was her breakfast good!! Very accommodating to allergens, Vegan, Vegetarian, and Gluten free needs as well. LGBT friendly, beautiful landscape, nice restaurants nearby, lots of activities going on in the summer months, definitely worth the visit to Sodus! We can't wait to go back!!

I wish I could give the Cobblestone Cottage B & B more stars! This was our second visit in as many…read moreyears and we can't say enough about the CC. Tammy and Dave are excellent hosts and two of the nicest people we've met. We need more folks like them in this world. The room (Captain's Quarter) was spotless and very comfortable. Tammy's breakfasts are not only delicious, but are truly works of art. The location is perfect for sightseeing and easy to get to. We HIGHLY recommend staying at the Cobblestone Cottage. It is THE best B & B we've ever experienced. We will be back next year! Thanks Tammy and Dave. you guys are awesome. Frank & Jeannie

We had a wonderful 3-night stay at the beautiful Cobblestone Cottage. We felt welcome right away…read moreand so comfortable - it felt like home! The room (Captain's Quarters) was spacious, bright, and clean. Tammy and Dave were terrific about accommodating our food allergies (gluten, dairy, and soy) and went all out for breakfast: coconut yogurt with gluten free granola, accompanied by yummy toppings, even pancakes and muffins. What a treat! We're usually limited to eggs and bacon - we had that too! We'll be back when visiting the area and highly recommend this inn.

So the wife and I like to go to the Renaissance faire in Sterling New York at least once a year and…read moretypically will stay at a hotel in Oswego, however this year I decided to book a bed and breakfast for us and randomly chose this place after searching online. It was pretty close in proximity to the Ren Faire so that was a bonus. Kind of looks like your standard farmhouse when you pull up, however the inside looks incredible. The owner, I think his name was Josh, gave us a brief history of the place the next morning and I believe he said it was built in the late 1800s. Like I said it's very nice inside and each of the four rooms as a bonus that you don't typically find in farmhouses, has a window air conditioner. Quick tip however for anybody reading this and considering going there, if you're like me and you prefer your bedroom to be a little on the cooler side when you're sleeping, go up and turn on that air conditioner as soon as you arrive. The upstairs rooms can get pretty warm, of course I was there at the end of July but still it's going to take a couple minutes for that air conditioner to bring it down a few degrees. But anyway we slept pretty well, I received a text message at 8:30 the next morning alerting me that there was a tray of coffee and creamer and stuff outside the door and breakfast was served just a couple minutes past 9:00. The really interesting part about this particular place was the barn. When you pull up to the house, obviously being a farmhouse there's a barn out back. Not much to look at really, just looks like a barn.. But Josh gave us a look inside as we were leaving the next morning. I should have got some pictures but the inside is fully decked out as a venue that could be used for a wedding/reception and or any other small party or gathering. There's a bar area, a stage, some really cool lighting, and an upstairs area where a lot of tables were set up. If you're thinking about having a wedding in that area and are looking for somewhere to possibly have your reception, or in theory the actual wedding as there is a stage there... By all means give this place some consideration. Outdoors has a lot of space and a few more tables, there was a fire pit and contrary to another review that was left on here a few years ago there's a permanent structure that was built for a ladies room and a men's room. Like I said we were here just a few days ago at the end of July so the Flowers that would typically be in bloom in the springtime had passed and the ones that would be coming around in another month and a half or so obviously had not bloomed yet however judging by the number of bushes that I'm seeing, I'm sure it looks quite amazing when everything is trimmed and all the flowers are out and everything is decorated. Anyway, by all means if you're looking for somewhere different than your standard hotel room to stay and you're in this area, check this place out. Pricing wasn't that much different than a king size bed would have been in Oswego and I guarantee nobody at a hotel would have brought me coffee.

We came to this wonderful barn for a wedding. Josh, the host, was wonderful with accommodations. We…read morewere nervous about using the outhouse, but the outhouse was the biggest and cleanest I've ever seen. The barn itself was beautifully decorated, and tables were spaced out enough. We really had a wonderful time.

We had an unbelievable experience at the Inn. My daughter and her bridesmaids stayed there…read moretogether the night before and after her wedding. The space was perfect for the girls to be comfortable and we took amazing photos there in the morning before her wedding. Maureen, the owner, was so accommodating and readily available to answer questions and offer suggestions . We even hosted a small gathering on the porch after the rehearsal which was the perfect space. I would highly recommend the inn whether you are looking for a uniquely beautiful setting for a small group or looking for a romantic location for a stay in the Finger Lakes.

Had an amazing stay here!! The inn is clean, beautiful and close to town. The food was amazing and…read morethe owners could not have been nicer. We stayed during covid and everything was done perfectly in terms of covid guidelines. Perfect upstate getaway!

Wonderful hosts, wonderful views. The owner, Gary Adamson,…read moreis a fountain of knowledge and good times. His partner, Linda Markell, knows how to make guests feel welcome and comfortable.

Adorable and well maintained little bed and breakfast in a scenic location overlooking the lake…read more Friendly hosts cook the BEST breakfasts and are helpful and knowledgeable about the region, wines, and dinner options. If you are extra lucky, they might even serenade you. I have been here twice, and both times stayed in the room with the bath that is disconnected from the room. It is NOT a shared bath, it is just a few steps outside the room. Not a big deal at all and it's HUGE. Paradise on the Lake is a great home base when exploring the gorgeous Finger Lakes. I won't stay anywhere else.