Actually 10 stars! The sub roll tasted fresh out of the oven! The meats and cheese were…read moreoutstandingly fresh! Topped of with crunch pickle slices and a spicy relish. A cute little paper bag of chips, maybe homemade? Of course, I had to have a milkshake. Hersheys ice cream so nothing too special. The decor is all antique ice cream shop sourced from around the area. The counter service was fast and I ate outside on wrought iron tables and chairs with a lovely park in the background. Definitely stop here for lunch!

Portions were huge and food was OK…read more The older blonde woman behind the counter was visibly annoyed by any and all questions asked of her and repeatedly ignored or rolled eyes at me. I should've left. I specifically asked if the turkey in the Rueben-esque Turkey panini was deli slices or more like breast Thanksgiving style. They said it wasn't slices. When it came out - it was like sliced deli meat from Wegman's. Not what I wanted. The panini itself was huge and want and fresh enough. But, I asked three times for clarification so I wasn't happy. My friend got a Chef Salad what was huge and fresh. Looked delicious. I got an iced brewed tea and when I went up for a refill, again, death stare. Not impressed with service or attitudes here. Menu looked good but this small street has tons and tons of places to eat with much kinder and friendlier staff.

Absolutely a must visit place! We were on a long drive and needed a stop. At Gauss' we got…read moreexcellent ice cream (so creamy! so tasty!) and the unexpected joy of a great place for the kids to burn off some of that excess energy. Staff were lovely and friendly, prices were very reasonable, ice cream was delicious, and the play equipment for the kids was awesome! There's a bathroom inside as well as a little store with various knickknacks. Private parking lot and also a drive thru.

This family has truly taken great customer service to another level. The upside down banana split…read morehas became one of my favorites. Awesome country setting where you can sit and relax while the kiddos are playing.

Just went there today for the first time, and wow can I recommend. Such a variety of flavors,…read morechoices, and combinations. Several I found quite different and innovative. I enjoyed the kiddie size strawberry cheesecake sundae. I chose vanilla soft serve, fresh strawberries, small cheesecake pieces in it complete with the graham cracker crust, with whipped cream. I chose not to have the sprinkle and the cherry, and the nice woman made the price less. It was fantastic and refreshing on a very hot day! Highly recommend!

Always the very best Sundays and milkshakes. Friendly courteous staff. We go there often. Clean and…read moretidy

Great throwback ice cream stand. Cash only and not an ATM in sight, so be sure you have some green…read moreon you. Just ice cream (no food), but a great selection. Soft serve or scooped and a huge variety from sundaes to cones, and all kinds of things in between. I opted for 'Flurry' style dessert, basically soft serve with your favorite candy or cookies mixed in. I have to say it was delicious. The ice cream was super creamy and rich. If you are in the area, definitely stop in!

We come here every year and it's always large portions and great prices. I only got a picture of…read moremine since my kids ate there's so fast lol.

Need better distancing for Covid also the workers thought it was a good idea to put hot fudge at…read morethe bottom of the cup for a hot fudge Sunday... please tell me who puts fudge at the bottom of the CUP!!!!!!!!!!! Please teach them the proper method besides that it's hard to mess up ice cream but they sure tried their best

These are the BEST doughnuts I have ever had. No. Seriously. THE best. But I do have to confess…read morethat I didn't stray too far from the cruller and the plain glazed doughnut just because my mouth wouldn't let me. The texture of both was moist... not the just-about-cooked-and-still-sort-of-wet kind of moist, but the perfectly-cooked sort where the dough just melts in your mouth. (I'm a texture eater... What can I say?) and there wasn't so much glaze that it overpowered the doughnut (I'm lookin' at you, Krispy Kreme). Now, I must give you fair warning that there isn't much of a selection. They offer the basics: plain, glazed, crullers (on Fridays), jelly-filled, chocolate, powdered, blueberry, and the occasional seasonal flavors like pumpkin, BUT they are so delicious that you don't need all the crazy toppings to distract you from the dough. A dozen doughnuts goes for $7.45 and they accept credit/debit on anything over $5. They also offer bagels, but 1) why would you ever buy a bagel outside of the metropolitan NYC area and 2) why would you buy a bagel when their doughnuts are so damn delicious??

Best bagels in town to say the least. Cinnamon rolls, when available are to die for…read more Make many trips for the bagels and cinnamon rolls and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend this bakery.

Great local ice cream shop in downtown Athens. Ice cream is Hersheys and is the hard scoop type…read more Sorry, no soft serve. Sweet Sharlene's is run by a non-profit in the valley, called Penn York opportunities. Weekly sundae specials are posted. As well as ice cream, they sell popcorn, canned and bottled drinks, and some other snack foods. Their prices are very reasonable. $2 for single scoop, $3 for a double. $1 for a bag of popcorn. There is seating in the square around the store. Parking is ample in the lot behind the Guthrie family practice clinic. Hours are: 11am-8pm Tuesday-Sunday. Closed Mondays.

When we visit Nichols, NY we make a point to get some fresh ice cream at Dad's…read more Friendly owner and reasonable prices. Multiple flavors. Great service.

This is such a great little place. Delicious ice cream in a wide variety of flavors. Try the orange…read morepineapple, the banana cream, black cherry, or the cotton candy flavors. The town looks like something right of of an old Western. Lots of charm!