Just started going here after years of ignoring the place- I'm so happy I finally went! They have…read morethe best eggplant parm I've had in this area! It's crispy edges and cheesy goodness and a hearty portion. My friend takes the pasta and we both get salad and a glass of wine and dinner is done. The wait staff have always seated us quickly, brought drinks fast, & remained attentive. The garlic knots were also amazing. It may not be pretty from the outside but don't let that stop you! Enjoy!

We decided to try pizza at Tommy's in Hertford. Ordered a 16" thin crust "Bianca". It looked good…read morebut was horrible. The crust was like cardboard. I've had frozen pizza that was better. We are not picky eaters, but this pizza was beyond bad. Now that I'm home my stomach is killing me. We've had Italian subs from this shop which were pretty good. Don't think we'll be coming back.

After a 7 hour drive, we were looking for a restaurant for dinner after 8:30 pm on a Thursday…read morenight. The only open sign was at Lucky's. As we walked in, we realized the "open" sign had just been turned off. The young man inside was cleaning but welcomed us in and said he'd be happy to make us a pizza. In about 10 minutes we had a delicious pie! The sauce is wonderful. I would definitely order pizza from Lucky's the next time I'm in Corolla. Great oizza and kind staff.

If you hate pizza, order here. The only lucky bit of this…read moreplace was the free grated cheese packets.

As you can see by the picture I crushed it before I snapped a pic $5 for a slice with any toppings…read moreis a good deal - good size slice and great flavor and toppings! Was a little slow but worth it, highly recommend checking this place out

The best in the area. Always top notch! At least a once a week outing. Let's go now! Value is…read moregreat too.

I ordered boneless wings and I got wings bone in and wrong flavors. They always get the orders…read morewrong. Start checking your order before you leave

The best pizza in this and any other place I've been to. Is it the water? Is it the staff?? I don't…read moreknow but it's GOOD!

Food was delicious , service was wonderful and super friendly and the space itself was so cute and…read morepretty. Will definitely be returning. We brought our 2 year old and she loved her food and the waitress was so sweet to her.

Very disappointing. We have eaten there many times in the past 2 years and were always pleased with…read morethe food and service. My daughter was visiting and we chose the Herringbone for dinner on Tuesday before New Years Eve. I ordered the loaded potato soup and the tuna small plate. My daughter had the salad and the shrimp appetizer The soup arrived barely hot and watery. Her salad was fine Then came the tuna with a smear of avocado and corn relish. None of it was edible. The tuna was definitely not fresh . By contrast the shrimp dish was delicious. The waitress graciously offered a replacement but by then I had lost my appetite. I am hoping that this was an uncommon experience because we really liked it beforehand.

Proper NY Pizza! By far the BEST pizza in the OBX. We got the slices of cheese, margarita, deep…read moredish, and a couple specialties. Prices are about normal for what the pizza economy is. The restaurant is fun and great outdoor seating! Highly recommend if you're in search of good pizza. It's a kind of pizza you'd be happy with eating once a week. The boneless wings were very good, crispy, and tangy. Great size too. Service is very attentive and fast. Great service. This is the spot to grab OBX pizza!

I haven't been to this place in almost a decade. That being said when I came home to visit my best…read morefriend's birthday this was the number one on our food list. Did not disappoint. The service is quick and he even helped me with ordering as I didn't remember what things could be ordered or how they could be ordered for just slices. Very nice chill location they have outdoor seats and allow for pets as well.

Ordered online, everything was correct, hot and timely. Service was great. Food was delicious. The…read morepizza delicious and the garlic parmesan wings were fantastic!

Camden is lucky to have this gem. Amazing pizza, reliable service, and a pepperoni & meatball combo…read morepizza that keeps us coming back on the regular!

Best pizza around!!!!! Only wish they had delivery service and some specials every weekread more

Wiseguys is always good friendly service and great food i recommend the meatball sub and cheese…read moresticks Great local spot

To start, very pleasant greeting by Shelby. Main dining room was full but she quickly prepared a…read morehigh top near the bar. She said it would be 5 minutes but it was more like 3 and the table was ready. John explained the specials and took our order. Drinks came promptly and the food came out in a few minutes and was very good. A wonderful experience and good food.

Went there for dinner on May 6, 2026. Very nicely decorated place. Now the overrated part. No bread…read morefor the table, first issue. I had the pasta limone and so did my sister. It was so darn lemony, we could hardly eat it. The shrimp were done well, but the pasta was so puckeringly lemony that it was impossible to enjoy. My sil agreed. They are doing this great dish wrong.

The restaurant was open and guests were already seated so we went there for lunch. It was good, but…read morethey told us that we would only have to wait for 10 minutes and it turned into half an hour before our food came. It was not only that our meals took so long, but when they finally arrived we were also shocked by the portion sizes. Honestly, we felt a little bit ashamed.

Absolutely the BEST pizza in town!!! You can not go wrong. Antipasto is great too!!! Subs are…read morefantastic as well. Again, you can't go wrong!!