Well, this was amazing! The reviews do not lie! We stopped here for Kate breakfast early lunch on our way home from the outer banks. We had our little dog in tow who had not eaten his breakfast so we were all pretty hungry! I ordered the grilled chicken bbq sandwich which was wonderful! My husband ordered the Philly cheesesteak on salad. We ordered a fried egg with cheese for our dog. She threw in some beef for the dog, he is now snoring in the back of the car! My husband said the salad was fresh and delicious and cheesesteak was excellent! All round a great place to stop. If ur in a rush u can order online so it's ready when u arrive. There's a cute little seating area outside for dogs and kids to stretch their legs! read more

Barnyard Betsy's - I forgot to take a pic of the food but this was Dobby after he ate x - Sandwiches Near Me - Creswell, North Carolina

Decent place for a sandwich in Creswell. We stopped here on our drive home from the beach for a quick lunch. The menu is posted on the wall and on laminated papers at the counter. We ordered the Philly cheesesteak and Italian sub with fried okra to go. Each item was delicious, filling, and reasonably priced. I particularly liked the bread they used and how they loaded up the subs with selected meat and veggies. I was full with just a half a sub. Barnyard Betsy's has limited indoor seating at a wall counter, clean single stall bathroom, and outdoor tables. Street parking is available. read more

See all

A nice little sandwich/sub shop. Plenty to street parking. While walking up to shop there are picnic tables outside or if you want to eat in there are a couple of bar seats. I greeted by a very friendly girl working the register and the man behind the plexiglass said hello. We went 30 minutes before closing so some of the subs were not available, it was ok I got the turkey sub with provolone,pickles, peppers, lettuce and tomatoes- bread was very fresh- I didn't say no oil- it was still good. The okra was very fresh and good- coating was thick. I also had the onion rings- they were delicious. Bathroom was very clean and neat (signs on wall were cool) read more

Already downed half of my sandwich before taking this picture, but the Italian hoagie was DELICIOUS, & whatever pickled veggies were on top were phenomenal. I also tried their corn nuggets which is definitely something I would go out of my way to get again. Very cute restaurant, looked very clean, bathroom was clean, service was fast, and workers were kind and helpful! read more

Barnyard Betsy's - Sandwiches Near Me - Creswell, North Carolina

Barnyard Betsy's in Creswell NC has yummy food, cute decor and friendly staff. Worth a stop!!

Delicious sandwiches and the staff was super friendly. It is more of a take out place with just a couple seats but it was definitely worth the stop. Also it was very reasonably priced for what you got. read more

Best Philly cheesesteaks! Very nice staff. Welcoming place. We stopped on way to outer banks from South Carolina. Great bacon egg and cheese. Wife got barnyard burger which is ridiculous. Fully loaded. She can't eat half, good I'll eat it later! But she loved it. Sons had chicken quesadillas. Everything was excellent. Full of flavor. Fountain sodas. Sweet tea. Outdoor seating in the shade. read more

Stopped on our way to the OBX, and needed a quick bite to eat and bathroom break. What a small town gem! Ordered a beef cheesesteak hoagie, all the way (Mayo, ketchup, mustard, pickles, fried onions, sweet peppers & hot peppers)... it was OUTSTANDING! Originating from the Philly area, some of those things on a cheesesteak would be considered blasphemy, but it was DELICIOUS! 10 out of 10! Also had a side of onion rings which I would pass on next time and just order a 2nd cheesesteak! Staff is super friendly and sweet! Bathroom could be a little cleaner. Great little patio area with tables/umbrellas & gazebo fire pit area. Must visit when traveling to the OBX! read more

See all

Me and my family went here a few times and we absolutely love it. We live 20min away from here. I highly recommend that if you are near the area you should totally try it. The food is fantastic and the people working are very kind. read more

I will admit, I am a bit of a steak and cheese snob... but Barnyard Betsy's did not disappoint!!! No skimpiness on meat, cheese and toppings. Sandwich's are full of flavor. The service was wonderful, the entire staff were very polite and friendly. The owner herself was cooking, taking orders and was the first person to speak when we walked in the door. The inside doesn't have much seating, a row of stools and high top table, but there are tables and seating outside. Definitely recommend this as a stop on the way to or from the Outer Banks. read more

We limped in on Easter Sunday. Weary from the road and half-past starvation. Huge portions and small town Southern hospitality were our salvation. It was a welcome respite on Main Street. Watching the locals and smelling lunch cookin' A nice patio and room to stretch our feet. I posted that burger on Gram and got lotsa people lookin. The loo was fresh and clean, the kitchen even moreso... The enormous Barnyard Burger filled up my entire torso. read more

Barnyard Betsy's - Barnyard Burger upside down - Sandwiches Near Me - Creswell, North Carolina

See all

Really hit the spot. Ordered ahead on the road home from the beach through the website and was good to go on arrival.

Found this little gem heading back from the Outer Banks. I got a simple ham and cheese sandwich but it was delicious and my husband got the Philly Cheesesteak. He said it rivaled the best he ever had. I tried a bite and had to agree. The flavor was on point! Definitely recommend stopping into this small town and trying this place out read more

The best cheesesteak sandwich was full of flavor! Wow! Family owned and operated- excellent service! Clean, quaint, and welcoming. Highly recommend read more

So great. The whole staff was awesome and the food was amazing. Would definitely go back again.

Huge awesome sandwiches. We definitely could have shared one. Fresh ingredients and the owners were super friendly. Just a short hop off 64 on way to OBX and worth the stop! read more

We stopped here last year on our way home from the beach. It was the best steak and cheese I've ever had on my life. I'm writing this review so late because I had to look it up so we could stop on our way to and from the beach this year! Staff was also super friendly and fun. read more

Hidden little gem off 64 on the way to and from the OBX! The sandwiches are absolutely delicious and everyone is friendly . read more

Great food and great service Love the restaurant such a great place to eat at. Recommend read more

10 stars. 4/4 diners loved it. So good I'm writing this in the car right after we left. All this was good obv: *Italian hoagie (huge) *Adult Quesadilla ("tons of chicken") *"barnyard burger" had burger patty AND chicken and cheese and a fried egg *Turkey sub Downtown Creswell is tiny but looks like it's on the come up Also the staff was really nice Also the bathroom was super clean read more

Excellent cheesesteaks! My husband literally jumped up to compliment the cook after his first bite. It's a cute little spot close to the state park. The workers were friendly and helpful. read more

SOOOOO YUM!!! Get the chicken quesadilla. It will change your life. We were driving through from Florida to the outer banks and decided to randomly stop here for lunch. Best decision ever!!! I will go out of my way to find this gem again!! read more

See all

Better get there before noon. Food is great. We ordered the cheesesteak hoagies and had to mix the tea, since one was so sweet I think you make get instant diabetes if you don't mix. Regardless great place. read more

Barnyard Betsy's - Better get there before 1130am. Man this place is packed and the food is great ! - Sandwiches Near Me - Creswell, North Carolina

Tasted good, clean. Definitely don't recommend the cheesesteak if you're going to eat and drive. It tasted good but requires a fork and knife. read more

An interesting place with great food. A wonderful spot found by accident. Well worth a stop

Definitely make a detour for this delicious food! Fresh ingredients, quick service and fantastic food. Everyone left happy and satisfied. The corn fritters were sweet, the fried okra on point. The kids loved the burgers and I had fried fish. Generous portions and reasonable prices. We sat at the outdoor dining area and we had ample shade on a hot summer day. read more

The food is amazing for a good price. The customer service is excellent as well. 10/10 Highly recommend!

Family owned place with great food and customer service! Chicken quesadilla and fries tasted excellent and were reasonably priced. Next time I will try a cheesesteak since I found out they moved from Philly. read more

Lovely place! The food was delicious, the staff is very friendly, clean restroom, and the prices are reasonable for the amount of food you're getting. Highly recommend for those coming come from OBX! read more

This woman that owns this place is a saint and so polite and accommodating. The food was delicious. Vegan and vegetarian options. Great outdoor place to sit and a little bar if you wanted to sit inside . Sorry no pictures, we just dug in! She even came up with something creative for one of our dining party members. If you are around this way, go get some food here for sure! read more

We all got the cheesesteaks. Had too many pickled peppers for some, but I loved mine. The tasty meat was seasoned and chopped up fine. Friendly and helpful staff. They have tables with umbrellas outside, so we could have our dog with us. We enjoyed our stop traveling back from the Outer Banks and would go again when in the area. read more

Left outer banks to head home without eating breakfast. We were starving and looked for a place to grab a quick bite. Saw this place on yelp and decided to try it. Only half mile off exit but VERY WORTH IT!! Had two breakfast sandwiches with sausage, egg and cheese. They were huge, fresh made and delicious! So worth the wait! read more

Great food and even better people!! I highly recommend this quaint little eatery. My husband and I happened upon this place on our way to Kill Devil Hills. read more

Great food! Small place... But is worth the short detour! Yum! Delicious cheese steak sandwich with all the fixins'! The locals love and regularly sell out the daily specials! read more

We stopped by this place on a whim coming back from OBX and we are so happy we did. This restaurant is a little hole-in-the-wall in such a charming little town. The staff was so very pleasant and kind that it made the experience 10x better. The employees constantly had a smile on their face and made sure everything met expectations. The food was fantastic and such large portions for a small price. I can't express how happy we are that we stopped here. read more

See all

Got the cheesesteak sandwich for lunch. Large portion. I got it with sweet peppers which seem like they are pickled (vinegar taste?). I was OK with that but my husband would try the other peppers next time. read more

The Grilled Chicken sandwich with all the fixings ' was hot, fresh and tasty! The chicken cheesesteak was equally delicious. No photos because we ate it way too fast . read more

The beef cheesesteak might be the best I've ever had!!! Very nice atmosphere. Convenient off the hwy and service was prompt. I don't live in the area, but I will stop in every time I'm driving through. read more

Had a delicious quick lunch on the way back home from OBX. Such friendly staff (the owner/hostess gave me the warmest greeting) that had my order ready within minutes. The burger, Italian hoagie and onion rings were great plus the fresh cut chips were a delightful surprise. I'm so glad we stopped here and plan to return the next time we're in the area. read more

This cute place is a less than 2 min drive off of 64 in Crestwell and the food is fantastic. With friendly service, great cheesesteak and food at a good value, this should be a regular stop for anyone traveling between the OBX and the Raleigh Durham area. Hoagies are loaded with meat and super tasty too. And you will need an extra napkin, which is a plus! read more