Linda, our server, was amazing. Have to give her credit for being pleasant, prompt and friendly…read more She added to the experience. The food was also amazing. I forgot to take pictures cause I was chomping it down. Let's start off with the Apple Butter on the dinner rolls, delicious. The butter was creamy and very flavorful. The rolls were fluffy and yet still thick. Had the Grilled Ham with Mashed Potatoes and Veggie Beef Soup. The soup hit the spot to start my meal off. When that thick cut of ham was placed in front of me, my mouth was watering already. The first bite was juicy and crispy. Grilled just right. Add in a creamy with chunks mashed potatoes. And a great gravy.. I could not have been happier, I am still longing for more! The atmosphere was homestyle for sure. Cozy, felt like I was out in the country at grandmas. Will def be back when I'm in the area again.

We dined here last year (see previous review) and again when in the area the other day. The…read moremanhattan with turkey was good, with flavorful gravy. The chicken and noodles were fine, but we thought the turkey had more flavor. We've debated both times if we should get the buffet, but on neither visit did it have roast beef nor pie. Pie is the main reason for us dining here and our appetites just don't warrant more than one plate of food (especially all those heavy starches) AND pie, so it isn't worth the extra cost for us. Although again, if the buffet included pie, we'd get it. Also...we were told a 10-15 minute wait but waited more than 30. The hostess claimed they called us on the speaker but we were no more than 20 feet from the hostess stand the ENTIRE time. None of the three of us heard our name. They took my phone number when we arrived but I got no call nor text. People entered and were seated before us. So I went up and asked. She claimed to have called us and rolled her eyes at me.

Great experience! Need a place for dinner for 75 hungry campers! This is the place. Everything…read morewas delicious from the homemade bread to the pies and OH that strawberry dessert! Great hosts, friendly servers, relaxing atmosphere, and great food! Highly recommend no matter your group size.

Dining at Yoder's Homestyle Cooking was the most amazing memorable experience I have ever had. The…read morefood was delicious especially the poppyseed chicken. The service was spot on and the ambiance was exactly what you expect at an Amish Home. I can't wait to visit again.

The clean, bright dining room and friendly attentive server foretold of an excellent meal to come,…read moreand so it was. We had a pair of sandwiches and salads, and all of it was terrific. Fresh ingredients, prepared and presented well. It almost felt like we were on a cooking show. When we're in the area again, we will definitely return.

I had the apples and oranges salad with grilled chicken. It was amazing. My waitress was very…read moreattentive and nice. The outdoor seating in the backyard is beautiful. My only complaint was my salad took awhile to come out. But it was worth it!

Pretty disappointed as we specifically drove this route to have breakfast here again. When we ate…read morehere 2 years ago we were delighted by the food and service. Today was pretty underwhelming. The bacon that we absolutely loved the last time was not the same - extremely dry and flavorless. The biscuit is was not biscuit-like at all, but more like a squishy and kind of soggy bread. The biggest disappointment was the $2 upcharge for us splitting a plate. Not many places do this anymore, but the Village Inn does. And if you're going to charge extra, at least split it for the customer (as many places do without even asking!) instead of just throwing an extra plate under the main dish. Everything else was fine. Our server was nice enough but not very personable. Just kinda meh about our entire visit this time.

Wonderful place to eat!! The food was great, came out hot! The atmosphere is a quaint little…read moredinner. The staff were friendly and efficient. Would definitely recommend!

This restaurant has changed its name (same owner) and transitioned to a fine-dining restaurant with…read morea prix fixe monthly rotating menu and a small traditional menu. The food was excellent. We had the March tastings menu and were blown away by the food. Service was excellent as well. A little pricey for some, but it was worth the money.

Not many options for Sunday brunch/lunch in Elkhart county so we decided to try here. Cute place…read moreand super nice staff. That is where the positives stop. They had a special for "Irish coffee" being St Patty's Day. Sure why not one of my favorites! I get a regular mug of coffee with Bailey's. For the record Irish coffee is brown sugar, Irish whiskey (preferably Tullamore D.E.W.) and whipped cream. Typically in a footed glass mug. I should have known better I was in Middlebury, IN. We inquired about an appetizer having garlic and onion. We were asked it if was preference or dietary? Does it really matter? But it is dietary for one of our party. After being told it had both we made other choices to split. Well the pretzel bites came with this HEAVY garlic cheese stuff that was the consistency of mashed potatoes. We also ordered poutine (another of our favorites) what came out was curly fries! (yes curly fries) with breaded cheese nuggets (yes breaded) with some brown thin gravy! Our main meal; one wedge salad (that was cut into quarters) with steak. Beautifully cooked beef medallions with zero flavor or seasoning. Nothing, not even S&P. The guest with the garlic/onion dietary request, asked what cheese comes on the nachos. She was told shredded and it's melted. So when her nachos came out it had mashed potato garlic cheese! She asked to have them remade. Which the server kindly did, her reorder came with a little melted cheese (you know when it's over heated and not cheese anymore) with sour cream squirted lines. I had the veggie burger which was actually good! The green goddess dressing is super tasty. Overall the place was nice and clean with super cute wallpaper in the bathroom. The prices with very reasonable. Would I go back, probably not. I wish them all the luck, might not be for us but I am sure they have fans.

Small town Americana at its best! Fantastic patty melt. Attentive waitress. Fun to be at a truly…read morelocal place.

Wonderful small town bar. The breakfast sandwich is absolutely amazing!…read more Bikers friendly.

This place is amazing! it feels like I'm right at home. the servers are so friendly, the food is…read moreamazing, the building is beautiful and the peanut butter is awesome! every server left me with a smile. I couldn't stop eating the food, and now I feel very full, but it was so worth it. thank you all!

This was the best dinner I have ever had. The peanut butter and jelly they served was to die for…read more the chicken and steak were so good, and the mashed potatoes were nothing short of perfection. I recommend to anyone that wants to have a cozy dinner that is perfect. The service was the best service I ever had considering, extremely friendly and kind.

Our family of four had an Indiana-Ohio road trip and I really wanted to stop by an Amish community…read morefor some homey lunch. We arrived on a Tuesday at 12:30 pm and there was a 15-minute wait to be seated. After we were seated, we were served with fresh bread, Amish peanut butter, and apple butter. It was very much appreciated because breakfast was several hours ago and we were starving. We proceeded to order and share the fried chicken dinner with fries and the smoked ham platter with mashed potatoes, gravy, and bread. The fried chicken was a bit small, however everything else was plentiful. We were stuffed but we had a room for dessert. We shared the old-fashioned sugar cream pie with vanilla ice cream. It was a glorious way to wrap up the meal! Since we were concluding a road trip, I did not want to have to cook after arriving home. We ordered homestyle meatloaf with potato salad and country roast beef with sweet potato casserole for take-out. The waitstaff planned very accordingly and had the kitchen prepare it so that the take-out will be ready once our meal concluded. Everything held up well on our three hour drive. My one complaint is that the meatloaf was a tad dry and did not come with sauce like a classic one normally does. When you are in an Amish community, it is almost wrong to not pick up baked goods. We also stopped by the bakery and bought peanut butter, sweetheart jam, Dutch apple pie, and banana cream pie. Whole pies are approximately $16.99 each. They were delicious!

I love pie. This place is pie heaven. The only downside is that the pie is put on the buffet by the…read moreslice, and it's hard not to eat the entire slice because it is so good, which means you get full before you can try all of the pies. There's salad, bread, soup, entrees and sides too - all cooked Amish style. I loved the beef noodles, meatloaf, and broccoli salad. I sampled some other dishes, but had to save room for pie. There were some really delicious puddings too - blueberry with fresh blueberries in it and a warm bread pudding. Delicious! Service was quick and friendly and I think it's a good value for $22. It's best to arrive early and plan for a long walk afterwards (to work off the pie).

Small town Indiana cafe with wholesome Amish meals and pies and good service. Old fashioned charm.read more

We have eaten at Tiffany's many times, and I've ordered the grilled chicken sandwich before and…read morealways enjoyed it. The restaurant was extremely busy tonight--even on a Tuesday, every table seemed to be full--so they are obviously doing a lot right. Unfortunately, this visit was disappointing. I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich, which has always come with sides in the past, but this time no sides were brought out. When our waitress came by, I asked about them, but they were never delivered. The grilled chicken itself tasted good, but the sandwich was very dry because it came without lettuce or mayonnaise. By the time we realized the requested items weren't coming, we were well into the meal. I know restaurants can get overwhelmed when they are this busy, and we've had good experiences here before, so I hope this was just an off night. I would definitely come back, but tonight's meal and service weren't up to what we normally expect from Tiffany's.

Always fresh off the press, hot and delicious…read more Price is right, Ultimately beats the competitor across the street by a long shot. The family is regular, and the food is always fresh, with the fastest service. We love it here. If the competition across the street could compare in service, we might consider it.. but after 10 years of eating here, we just won't take the chance.

Holy shit order the Philly cheese sandwich!!! it taste just like it doesn't Philly except the…read morecolors different. Also the mozzarella sticks!