This place is a hidden gem! So cool! We got there and was quickly seated inside. Kind of bummed we didn't get to sit outside in the porch area but it was nice to get seated quickly on a Saturday night. We all enjoyed our delicious meals but if you're in a hurry, this isn't the place for you! It definitely took a while but was worth the wait. I got the pork chop and my wife got the steak sandwich. They were all pretty good and we will definitely be back! read more

See all

I had the apples and oranges salad with grilled chicken. It was amazing. My waitress was very attentive and nice. The outdoor seating in the backyard is beautiful. My only complaint was my salad took awhile to come out. But it was worth it! read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Apples and Oranges salad with chicken. - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

First time going to the restaurant and it will not be our last. The service was outstanding and the food was just fabulous. read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Smoked duck - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

Tara took good care of me on my lunch break. Service was fast and friendly. Not too hungry so I ordered soup of the day and some grilled bread for dipping. Pleasant dining room which I chose over patio which would be good in summer but too cold for my liking in March! Chicken taco soup was very good. Definitely return some day! read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Dining room - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

The gem that West on Warren is could be in any classy area in America: Chicago Orange County, Boston, Austin, Phoenix, Seattle, etc. Wonderful experience. Relaxing, welcoming, and the food is delicious. Every small town should have a place like this for some people to elevate themselves. It's different. Special. read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Different. Special - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

Got in just before the grill closed. I had the duck wife had tacos. Food was spicyer than wife normally eats but so well prepared she ate it. My potatoes were very very garlicky Local band was playing 69's 70's rock. They sounded nice and were a fun addition I would come again. Was here for rv repair. It is walkable if you are hungry from coachman and even from hotel if you are very hungry. Be careful walking back to hotel after dark no sidewalk read more

Hidden Gem in Middlebury - An Unforgettable Dining Experience at West on Warren I've eaten at my fair share of steakhouses -- we were originally aiming for a LongHorn or Texas Roadhouse, but stumbled across this little place near our hotel in Middlebury. From the outside, West on Warren doesn't scream "fine dining" -- it looks like a small, unassuming spot tucked away on a quiet street. In fact, I almost drove past it. But then we followed the sign that said "Enter in the back," and suddenly we were in this charming space with a cozy vibe. After a long day in non-air-conditioned offices, we were just hoping for something decent indoors. What we got was one of the best meals I've had -- anywhere. Let's talk about the food. I was initially bummed they didn't have a filet on the menu... but I got over that fast. The chefs here are magicians -- not in the frilly, overdone, "California experimental" way -- but in a way that blends flavors so thoughtfully it feels like each dish has a personality of its own. The bruschetta? Not just a bunch of chopped toppings flung on bread. It was sweetened with just the right vinaigrette, topped with shaved mozzarella, and had this elegant complexity that made you pause mid-bite. Then came the ribs -- beautifully tender with a sauce that wasn't overly sweet or smoky, just right. Even the coleslaw had a little kick to it -- warm, zesty, and nothing like the bland picnic slaw you're used to. The potatoes? Deep fried with a seasoned crust that had us scraping the plate. And then -- oh yes -- the brown sugar cheesecake. It had a cookie crust and a velvety texture that made me wonder out loud if the chef might be single. I'm only half joking -- I would have proposed on the spot. Sadly, she's taken. But I'll just put it out there: if she ever wants to move to Naples, Florida, we'd welcome her with open arms and open mouths. Naples is gorgeous -- the palm trees, the beaches -- and it desperately needs this level of culinary brilliance. Please. Move south. In all seriousness, this place is a Michelin-level gem hiding in a small town. The portions are thoughtful, not overwhelming. The prices? Totally reasonable for the quality. And the flavors? Out of this world. Whether you're treating your significant other, impressing guests, or just want to spoil yourself, this is the spot. I'd give it six stars if I could. read more

Ugh where do I start everything was amazing, it was such a cozy spot to dine in at. It was my first time and not my last. I wish I had pics of our entrees but we did not spare one minute lol. Cocktails were super! Service was great! Outstanding first experience! read more

See all

Surprising, delightful dinner with delicious food and a small town vibe. Blackened fish tacos were out of this world, with green beans and parmesan on the side. The fish had a little kick, was nicely seasoned and well-balanced with the lime and mango salsa. The beans were so fresh. Who knew a simple side of beans could be so delicious? Dessert was a tiny pumpkin stuffed with a thick filling. I wasn't a huge fan of the dessert, as the filling was too thick for my taste. However, the presentation was charming. I read some reviews saying service was slow. We experienced excellent service from the minute we walked in the door. Tyler was especially pleasant, and gave wonderful recommendations. The pace was perfect and added to an enjoyable evening. I plan to make a trip back from Chicago with this restaurant on my list. I'd like to try the duck or prime rib. read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Pumpkin with cream cheese filling - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

Taking a fall getaway and was looking for dinner in the Middlebury IN area and was so glad to have found West on Warren. The meal was so delicious for my wife and I. My wife thoroughly enjoyed fish tacos with fries. I was so happy with a hot popper grilled chicken sandwich. It was on a delicious brioche bun. I enjoyed a house salad with wonderful balsamic dressing. We shared some great fries that were even better with an orange dipping sauce. My meal was not skimpy. I walked out full and happy. Street parking. A excellent location tucked back a block from the main drag. Ate on the patio that had sliding garage type doors that let in the clean fall air. Patio over looks a rock garden enclosed by a dark brown fence. What an excellent staff. Very friendly and they know the menu well. Our wait person Mary M. was superior. They greeted us cheerfully. This restaurant definitely has chefs in the kitchen. This made for a really memorable dining experience. Saw several items I would like to try. read more

See all

My first time at West on Warren, our group was really impressed with such a nice menu with so many interesting options. The ambiance is very pleasant and the decor is so cute and very Instagram worthy! Very cheerfully decorated. My Asian salad was very nice. I'm vegetarian and therefore have many salads when I go out to eat. I was really impressed how crisp and fresh my salad was, the dressing was delicious and not too thick or salty like so many salad dressings are sometimes. Our group also loved their dishes, the poke bowl beef dishes were very good, especially the carrot and potatoes that came with their meat dusted. Their menu changes and there are so many nice and interesting options. If you haven't been to this really cute restaurant in Middlebury do go, you won't be disappointed!! read more

See all

Lovely little restaurant bar with really good food! I had the steak with truffle fries, minus the Alfredo sauce, and it was delicious! I sat out on the glass enclosed porch and watched the beautiful waterfall fountain, and it felt very peaceful. It happened to be the town's Fall Festival, and was a gorgeous day to walk around afterward. The service was friendly and great, the food was awesome, and the atmosphere comfortable. It was worth the drive up from Syracuse to check it out on a friend's recommendation. read more

Wow...excellent establishment with good tasting food! Our server was very now attended and had great recommendations. Brussels sprouts were cooked perfectly! Baby red potatoes had great taste! Rum punch has a Caribbean flavor and oh so yummy! Oh yeah read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Chicken club - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

The house turned art gallery and restaurant with full bar is wonderful experience. We sat in the bar that has only a few tables because they said they were booked. It was still very nice and we got to chat about the town and the business with the bartender. Food was FANTASTIC. as good or better than any restaurant we have eaten at in Indy. read more

Been here several times and have always enjoyed it. Unfortunately this time wasn't up to par with our past visits. The young man at the host stand was not friendly. He sat us inside, where it was freezing cold. Our server tried to help with the temp, as all guests were cold, but it was pretty still uncomfortable. They were apparently very understaffed... service was terribly SLOW. Food and drinks were decent. Kind of a disappointing experience overall. read more

See all

Great service, nice choice of entrees. They have outdoor searing with with windowed garage doors for plenty of sunshine and no cool, fall breeze. I had a steak swarma special, delicious! My hubs had the jalapeno burger- but not a lot of kick. The soup special ham, potatoe was very good. I would definitely recommend this place! read more

Creative and tasty menu that changes throughout the seasons. Also do some live music and trivia nights.

Overall an enjoyable evening. Weather was beautiful and we sat on the patio. It was trivia night which was a little annoying but not terrible. Food was very good and our waitress great. The only downside is the speed of service which was very slow. We placed our appetizer and entree orders at the same time. It probably took 30 minutes to get appetizers. Our entrees came out fairly soon after that but I suspect only because closing time was approaching and kitchen staff wanted to get out of there. read more

The last time we were here it was only so-so, especially the service. But Friday night we arrived before any huge rush. Service was much better and so was the food. Hubby had a poke bowl with salmon. He said it was great and flavorful. My burger was good, and most of it was cooked to what I ordered. Fries were good despite the light batter. We won't let as much time pass before returning. read more

See all

Food was very good. Fried dill pickles are a longtime favorite. Had the fish tacos. Would definitely order again. And the fries were nearly perfect. Service was marginal at best, although it seemed to be our particular server. We were seated for over 20 minutes before she acknowledged us, and then it was only after we asked where our server was. She breezed by us, told us we she would be with us in a minute. Ten minutes later, she still hadn't appeared. When she finally came back, we ordered drinks (two Arnold Palmers, a soda and a water with lemon). We also ordered an appetizer. We were half way through our appetizer before our drinks arrived. She never acknowledged the wait, much less apologized. She was not the only server, in fact she was one of three, plus a bus boy and the hostess who was filling water glasses, so lack of help on the floor could not be an adequate excuse. Our food took awhile, but it was a busy night. I can easily deal with a backed up kitchen, if, in fact that is what was going on, but it didn't seem to be the case. After our food arrived, not once did she stop by our table to check on us, offer a refill on drinks or ask if there was anything else. Our busboy got us extra ice. We are all very good tippers. Tonight, not so much. I left an 18% tip. The night before, I left the server a well-deserved 30% tip. One thing we hadn't expected was live music. Although it was nice, it made it very difficult to talk, especially since the patio is loud, even without music. One of our party was in from Denver, another, although a local, had never been to W on W. We were very excited to bring our out-of-town guests to dinner here because it is usually such a great experience. They were good sports, and everyone was very happy with their meals, but it was a little disappointing, mainly because of the poor service. read more

We attended a work dinner at West on Warren, which was my first time there- so I can't comment on a regular sit down experience. We were located in their indoor/outdoor area, it had good ambiance and a decent amount of space for our group. If the ceiling heater was on, you were very warm & if it was off, you were very cold. No happy medium. The food was served buffet style and everything we tried was good! I really enjoyed the stuffed mushrooms and carrots, especially. We appreciated that the staff members were friendly and really attentive, our glasses were always full, which is always a plus! read more

Love their wild rice and mushroom soup! Service was excellent. The restaurant was clean, quiet, and comfortable.

The food was delicious! Everything was so fresh! I had the apple pecan salad and a cup of vegetable beef soup. Fortunately, I had room for dessert, which was a carrot cake drizzled with maple syrup. Yum! The staff was so friendly, accommodating, and patient as we requested another table over the one they had reserved for us. The only slight negative I would give is that it was a bit too noisy for our aging ears. read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Vegetable beef soup - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

See all

The atmosphere was pleasant and the food was pretty good, but our waitress had a bad attitude. My wife had planned on having fish tacos, which they were out of. She explained to the waitress that she can't digest anything dairy (butter, milk, cheese) which was met with annoyance (like I've never heard anything so ridiculous in my life). She asked that her vegetables be cooked without butter, which they were, but they were also covered in Parmesan cheese. WTF? You'd think in this day and age when so many people have allergies that servers would be more understanding and trained better. read more

Met an old high school friend here for lunch. The food was pretty good, and our waiter and the staff were friendly. read more

The food was stellar, service was excellent. The restaurant has a cute modern feel and was great for a date night with friends. Best classy joint with great food in the area (most restaurants in this area serve comfort foods). I had a steak. I thought about that steak for a week afterwards. That's a good sign. read more

Don't ask me how we stumbled upon this gem but we did! We stayed in Shipshewana for a Dustin Lynch concert at the Blue Gate this weekend and we were having a hard time finding a place for dinner. We walked in at about 5pm with about a reservation and got sat immediately at the bar (my favorite place to sit anyways). We saw the had bruschetta of the day. Olives, tomatoes and garlic oil. Freakin SO good! Everything on the cocktail menu looked fabulous so I asked the bartenders recommended. She suggested an old fashion so my husband and I went for it! Didn't dazzle me but didn't disappoint either. For our main entree I got a glazed pork chop over rice and beans with spicy bbq carrots! My husband got some kind of fish sandwich. -side not, I don't eat seafood so all I can say was his looked good but I can't speak on how it tastes. But MINE WAS SUPERB! I was also creepin on the lady next to me who got the Chorizo stuffed chicken.... Holy Crap. I almost had my order switched. Are you starting to understand that there is no bad food here? Lol Besides the fantastic food, I just want to point out the bartender (I wish I got her name) was a rockstar! She ran the bar and took orders effortlessly no matter how busy they were. If you're ever in the area, please stop in! read more

See all

Our lunch was full of flavor, the service was friendly and helpful. We sat on the back patio, fully enclosed and warm on a very cold day. Highly recommend this spot! read more

We decided to try this restaurant since we're staying in Ligonier and shopping in Shipshewana. Pretty good restaurant for a small town although there are lots of tourists in this area to support it also. We sat in the small bar (2 two top tables, bar seats for 6) for drinks and dinner. It is Friday in the summer and folks have reserved the outside tables until quite a bit later. Our waitress did a great job, very attentive. We ordered drinks, good classic martini, decent gin and tonic. The bar selection is not huge, just fyi. We ordered some bruschetta to go with our drinks and ate a few of them but it was too sweet for us. The bread wasn't toasty enough and was soaked with the balsamic. I wouldn't get this again. Braised pork tacos for RRR, mushroom butternut squash risotto for me. His tacos, two of then, were very good, lovely pork with a nice mango pico de gallo topping. All the other reviewers are right, the risotto is amazing. Very creamy and rich with plenty of nice mushrooms and bites of butternut squash. The downside for me, it is too rich and the serving too large. I would suggest splitting and having a salad with it. Or take it home. The chef could go lighter on the cheese, which is in the dish as well as topped with goat cheese. Risotto should be creamy on its own and not need the addition of cheese. All in all, a nice place for dinner in a small town. read more

A friend and I were going to attend a concert in Shipshewana and wanted to get a nice dinner beforehand. I had been to a nice place about a month ago but it wasn't open on Tuesdays. I had heard good things about West on Warren and we weren't disappointed. I had a ribeye which was cooked to order. The service was attentive. We ate on the lower level patio which was very nice. I will be going back at my next opportunity. read more

Unbelievably atrocious service/ stunningly bad. We had a medical emergency and their response was awful.

We went here for dinner on a Friday night. The place is super nice. Outdoor seating was ample and there is a deck above. We got to hear some local singer who was pretty good. Had a bit of sticker shock at the entree prices. The menus on yelp don't appear to be current ones. I had catfish dinner which included asparagus and polenta. It was $30. The fish was OK. Lots of tempura type breading and only I filet. Would have preferred two filets for the price. Burgers were around $18. The service was good we didn't have to wait long. read more

Low key casual with outstanding food. Great walleye! Great fried green beans! The burgers are great too. Tip - watch out you could pass it easily it blends in to the neighborhood houses. Also, like many places they close early. read more

Attended a wedding reception and enjoyed it. The staff was very attentive and quick with drinks. Great margarita here. Tried their espresso martini and was not impressed but other than that a great experience! read more

The cat fish tacos and apple walnut salad were wonderful!! We will be back!! Best restaurant in Middlebury!

Had the chicken gyro and it was awesome! First time eating here and it go back anyway. Service was great, food was great

Holy crap this place was awesome!!! https://m.facebook.com/westonwarrengrill/ We came here because the chef's mother lives on our farm and we like to support local, (really local, you know), and we knew that Chef Zach had moved from the well known Fiddlers Hearth to a new place because he was having issues with the chef at Fiddlers Hearth and wanted to do his own thing. So glad he did because not only is the location really cool, deep in Amish country where you can see horse and buggy activity, but the actual restaurant has modern character mixed with "old farm town" charm. There were several areas for seating options, including an outdoor "roof top style patio, two garden rooms, a nook and a bright and comfortable dining room. ...AND Chef Zach's food was simply AMAZING! I will definitely be back here. My folks ordered and split an Achiote chicken wrap with beer battered fries. The order was so big that it really looked like two separate dishes, but they got on just fine with one to split. They went on and on about how good it was.... it looked good with guacamole and corn succotash I ordered a basic burger and added swiss cheese and of the 4 side options, fried, chips, soup, or salad, I, too, ordered the beer battered fries. Wow! First thing... I ordered my burger medium rare and it came exactly that. It was well seasoned, came with the accoutrements, and had a nice brioche bun. The fries were plentiful and fried to perfection, light and crispy. The secret sauce that comes with the fries is a SHOW STOPPER! AMAZEBALLS!! I could drink that stuff, spicy, tangy, but of garlic and other flavors. I will go back just for the sauce We all split a piece of rhubarb cheesecake and not a crumb was left. It was thick and creamy, house made cheesecake with tangy local rhubarb compote on top to balance and add zest. What an awesome lunch!! Thanks Dad! read more

See all

Great atmosphere. Terrific new menu. Always great service. Everything from some great drink items, really well done appetizers, and new entrée options for both lunch and dinner. Good going guys you never disappoint. read more

Layout is totally inefficient for indoor seating, I almost wore 4 drinks by colliding with a waitress through a narrow alley to go to the restroom. Food was overpriced and overcooked. I ordered the fish tacos..yuk..it was battered, with heavy greasey taste, that kept dripping, peeled tasted worse. The side of asparagus was hard. Over grilled to a crunchy stage, I felt like a donkey chewing the parts that should have been discarded, and the tips were supposed to be tender, but they were not. All of it was hard and unchewable ! It's not worth $17 !! Should have been $6.00 The Polenta was too sticky, served with the same kind of overcooked aspurgus. Adding shaved Parmigiano doesn't make it gourmet !! Why serve Polenta with nann !!! Another $24 down the drain. Pairing of foods is a must know how Green salad was ok because the chef didn't cook it !! They need a well trained chef to charge those kind of prices. Waitresses should know the food served!! Not I don't know ..that is not acceptable!! The place was too hot and in need of better ventilation. No wonder why so many burgers were delivered to tables !! No fancy cooking is needed there. It was the cheapest $15 ! Never going back !! And don't waste your money here, but go to the best honky tonk restaurant next door !! Finally Middleberry customers need more respect, ppl aren't not stupid, they travel and know good food and aren't afraid to pay for it !! read more

Phenomenal food! Wonderful atmosphere, great service! First time here and highly recommend. read more

West on Warren Gallery + Grill - Chicken gyro - American Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana