We absolutely love this place and the one they have in the Heights as well. We're never…read moredisappointed, food is made fresh every day and the owners and staff are amazing.

Amira and Tom are the owners of this wine bar! Hey did amazing job creating different wines. The…read morerosé table wine is amazing and perfect for a warm summer day. The have created such a warm and welcoming environment for some family fun. The backyard is filled with space to sit and play some yard games. This is a must do if you are heading to shelter island.

Bought 15 skip laurels here. 12 out of the 15 are completely dead less than a year later. Terrible…read morequality plants. They were planted in large holes with loose, rich soil at the bottom, adequately watered and got partial sun (they are supposed to do well in full shade or full sun). Didn't matter. 90% of them are completely dead now. That's nearly $2,000 in dead plants.

I used Bay Gardens to completely overhaul my yard which had been over grown with weeds and bushes…read more It wasn't a cheap job but it was done quickly and, most important, correctly. I could say more but I think the before and after pictures speak for themselves. The first picture was right before the came, the second was right after the put down the grass seed and the last picture is a few weeks later.

This is a family business and I've been assisted by three different family members as well as…read moreNoreen. All were very helpful. They have a great selection overall and I like that they offer larger sizes on some of the trees and shrubs. Everything I've bought there is doing great and I won't hesitate to drive the 45 minutes it takes me to get there next time I need something.

This nursery and garden center in Aquebogue has a selection of plants, shrubs and trees like I…read morenever seen before anywhere else. It's gigantic! I kind of felt overwhelmed with how much and just how huge this place really is. I passed by it hundreds of times on my way out to the North Fork but since I need to redo my yard, I figured I'd stop in. I was seriously impressed by the selection. Prices even for the more mature trees and plants are rather reasonable as well. They do offer delivery but that's going to hit you hardest in the wallet. The staff is hit or miss, you'll either get someone who is friendly and helpful or a complete snob. This is a great place to come for plants since they seriously have nearly everything and recommended. I just wish they were closer to where I live.

Beautiful flowers that are well priced. The people who work there are very helpful. Stacey and…read moreWilliam do wonderful things for your lawn party flower arrangements. They are both true artists.

Friendly staff, central location and a great new selection of native plants--lots of choices now!…read moreIt used to be hard to find native plants for sale on the East End (plants like the ones you see happily growing in nature preserves or along hiking trails in the woods). You'd have to order online or search every display table at our local retail outlets, and then check to be sure those are really Long Island locals, attractive to birds, nourishing for pollinators and hardy enough to grow in our mostly sandy or loamy soil. Native plants don't need fertilizers or even much water after they've settled into the right place, so you're not wasting money or resources. Wittendales has clearly labelled "LI Local" pots with blue and yellow stickers (think Swedish flag colors), along with posters, signs, and a binder with plant care tips. If you need help coordinating plants that play well together , I'm told their displays of color coordinated "companion plantings " will change as the growing season progresses. Also, they have reasonable prices!

We come here every year with my daughter in her annual hunt for specific species of flowers. She…read morelikes them because of the quality and reasonable prices, but most of all for the natural vibe. It doesn't feel like shopping, but more exploring. There's something quite special here. We pick up our lunches on the way over and find a spot to sit overlooking the expansive farm and its accompanying river. Once we're done eating, we explore the different areas of plants and the quaint general store. Staff is on hand to answer any questions and assist as need be. It's a beautiful day out enjoying a unique hidden gem on Long Island. I'd never know it was even there had it not been for my daughter bringing me.

I want to preface this by saying that I absolutely love shopping locally, and this spot is very…read morebeautiful! The workers are very nice and all plants are lush and full, at reasonable prices. This being said, as I was entering one of their store sheds, I noticed a painting that is blatantly racist and disgusting. There's honestly no explaining this, as it is just displayed for everyone to see. I'm very disappointed to see this type of racism still so brazenly in 2026. Probably won't be coming back any time soon.

Ryan was so helpful! The owner was busy but took time to connect! Loved it! They truly were so…read morenice. I highly recommend them fast service. They really handled my order carefully and I would definitely use them again.

Amazingly helpful and friendly! I love this place. Highly recommend to everyone. Well priced and…read morebeautiful flowers.

Boutique store - more than bed linens. Unique home accessories, gorgeous pillows, glasses, trays -…read moregood spot for host gifts. The owner and staff aren't pushy, engaging if you do want help.

We discovered FP when we were on the hunt for some beautiful items for our new home. This store not…read moreonly had a beautiful selection but the service was spectacular with Sarah the owner and her staff being so knowledgeable on all the products and ranges in store. With so many great international brands to choose from we found so much more then anticipated and have become regular customers.

What a wonderland this is! How "Echo" could leave such a negative rating is beyond me and clearly…read moreexhibits ignorance- or at worse jealousy! This antiques store is a throwback to a time prior to EBay- when antique shops were a treasury of discovery... and shop-owners were knowledgeable , fair and extremely patient- ( especially with my husband's silly questions and ruminations). Dworkin and Daughter is a reason to come to Shelter Island!!

I had a wonderful experience at Dworkin & Daughter this morning! The owner was nothing but polite…read moreand friendly! She and I had a wonderful conversation about her shop, her items, and the sentimental value she has for them. She told me about her travels and past as well. She sold me one of her very loved pieces from her own collection so I can gift it to my mother. She was so lovely and so excited it was going to a home where it would be appreciated. This is easily the best antique shop I have had the pleasure to visit so far. I have the outmost respect for the owner and her business and anyone is lucky to get to know her!