Visiting The Stashe in Fayetteville While visiting the ring shop in Fayetteville, we stopped by The Stashe next door. We were in West Virginia with family and our dog, and were happy to see they offer a pup cup for dogs. I went with the Blue Panda after some deliberation, but also sampled the Dark Chocolate Raspberry--both were excellent. Portions are generous for the price, and even though my cup looked small, it was still a great bang for the buck. Here's what we had: * Pistachio (cone) * Blue Panda (cup) * Cappuccino Crunch (cup) * Pup Cup (for our dog) Every flavor was delicious, and we'd definitely come back when visiting Fayetteville and the surrounding West Virginia area. read more

The Stache - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Tasty ice cream in Fayetteville! This shop shares a space/doubles as a restaurant ("The Take Out"). Parking is a little tight since it's downtown but we made it out okay. There's a little bit of outdoor seating and a few tables inside but it's mostly to-go. They serve Hershey's brand ice cream and have a large selection, including sugar free and dairy free options! The space is very cute and has lots of fun stickers/posters/decor. Service was fast and friendly! I wasn't wowed by the flavor selection -- it didn't super suit my preferences -- but we did come at the end of the day at the end of the week, so I certainly could've had better luck at a different time. We all wound up with Moose Tracks (vanilla base, fudge ribbon, peanut butter cups) and it was enjoyable, like all Moose Tracks! We were happy and it was a nice way to round out our time in WV. If you're looking for a treat, this is a good option! read more

The Stache - Single scoop of Moose Tracks that I took back to the hotel! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Lovely little spot on a super hot day! Lines are long but go pretty quickly. We enjoyed cherry and strawberry ice cream with LOTs of cold water and fizzy drinks. Customer service is quick, to the point and ensures everything is done right the first time around! read more

Waffle cones and a decent ice cream selection. Cute place to sit on the deck and enjoy some yummy ice cream after hiking or for a dessert after dinner ! read more

It has changed a lot through the years. I remember when it was in a different location. It had lots of 80s memorabilia. I loved their shakes. They are now under new ownership and in a different location. It is a little further down. If memory serves me correctly, it is actually the old women's services building. They serve food now. They no longer sell shakes. That was a downer. They told me the food is really good, but we had already eaten at Pies and Pints. We got three regular cups of ice cream. It came to a little shy of $18. The ice cream was good and there were flavors I'd never heard of before. read more

The Stache - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Great ice cream shoppe with a variety of flavors. Photograph coming soon. With in walking distance of the Fayetteville Court House. read more

Standard ice cream offerings - nothing special. Scoops are SMALL, and I had a giant hair in my ice cream from the scooper. They happily exchanged it, but definitely over priced for what you get. read more

The food was very tasty and it had a a lot of flavor, and the service was very nice and friendly, and the ambiance was like a a dive bar and a log cabin. read more

See all

Had the dark chocolate raspberry on waffle cone. A bit on the sweeter side for my taste but good ice cream and good location. Refreshing after long hike. read more

My kids were set on milkshakes after a day of hiking, no milkshakes, but they did have a sorbet freeze type of drink, which was quite refreshing! Cute ice cream shop, but especially wanted to comment that my son dropped his and it went everywhere, the girl working the counter was incredibly patient, got us some towels to clean up with and then remade it for him. Her kindness was greatly appreciated!! read more

Great selection of ice cream flavors! Reasonable prices. They also have outdoor seating. read more

The Stache - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Yum yum yum! We got 7 different kinds of ice cream and could have done more. Try the cookie ice cream sandwich with cookies from a local bakery. Truly a gem. The staff was very kind. Highly recommended! read more

We came twice for dessert after dinner when we were visiting in town. They sell Hershey's ice cream--about 10 flavors or so. We really liked the praline pecan. The strawberry cheesecake wasn't very good. They have shakes, but I wasn't a big fan. They just pour milk in with the ice cream. Their sauces are just bottles of Hershey's chocolate, caramel, and strawberry sauce. The thing I liked the most was a sundae with praline pecan ice cream, caramel sauce, and pralines. The service wasn't great either. She seemed mad that we were there and not very friendly. Overall, if you want ice cream in Fayetteville, this is your place. Nothing fancy, but it gets the job done. read more

The Stache - Praline pecan ice cream, caramel sauce, and pralines sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

A cute little ice cream shop in town. They have great unique flavors of ice cream, as well as your favorite classics. I ordered a scoop of white chocolate cherry in a dish and really enjoyed it. They give you a good amount of ice cream for the single scoop size, enough to fulfill your sweet tooth but not completely stuff you. I love the theme of the shop and the atmosphere is very welcoming to everyone. Right now they only have takeout, but you can easily order your ice cream from the safety behind the door. Perfectly located near other shops and New River Gorge. read more

The Stache - a bench in front of a store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

See all

BEST ICE CREAM EVER! After a long hike, and serious I mean loooong, we stopped by this local ice cream parlor and it was our salvation. I ordered the Magical Unicorn and boy was it magical. It had this sweet cream flavor with some fun little surprises sprinkled in. Owners were very nice and helpful, plus even gave us a few plants from their store. If it weren't for our strenuous hike schedule, would definitely stop by again to buy a pint...or two! Hands down would recommend stopping by here if you're in town or just finished a 6 mile hike. tl;dr - do yourself a favor and treat that sweet tooth. 10/10 read more

The Stache - a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

I'm allergic to milk, and your sorbet made it possible for me to enjoy "ice cream" with my family. Libby was really great and made my visit a pleasure. read more

TLDR: The food is Hershey's ice cream and toppings. The service is unappreciative. I would go back again if I was in the area and wanted ice cream but only because there's nothing else available. read more

The Stache - Pralines and cream ice cream, caramel, and pralines sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Love this place! Good place to hang out at and People there are very nice. A lot of flavors to choose from, and they are all great. I picked White House Cherry and strawberry cheese cake, I enjoyed every bite of it read more

The Stache - White House Cherry and strawberry cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

A good ice cream shop in Fayetteville. The place is small and they have limited flavors, but the portions were very good and the price was very reasonable. The service and atmosphere left a little to be desired. read more

Great ice cream place near where my friend & I were camping this summer! Lots of flavor options

Lots of ice cream options with many sizes. I got a kids size and even that was enough for me. Make sure you look at the ceiling art work.

Great ice cream. Customer service was fantastic and very friendly. Can't go wrong by stopping there.

Cute little creamestry shop in Fayetteville, WV. Really sweet girl at the counter. Fun flavors and lots of fun combos! Definitely a must stop on a hot WV day! read more

See all

Enjoyed I loved the decor and atmosphere. Brooke provided excellent customer service. The ice cream was delicious at a good value. I had gift certificate for $10 (no expiration). We had at least 3 scoops for $12.I enjoyed a strawberry and strawberry cheesecake split scoop with the Shirely Temple from SouthSide Junction making a delicious DIY float. I had kids scoop of magical unicorn. I loved the uniqueness. read more

Cute town , cute shop . Several ways to have a cold treat . Scoops in all types of cones and cups , milkshakes , and sundaes . Prices are average . The shop has tons of candy and novelty items for the offering as well . Limited indoor seating , some outdoor seating . Street parking . Very friendly staff , delicious icecream. Very nice location , near a few really great places to eat , would be very easy to have a nice meal and walk right to the Stache for dessert. Would return if in area again . read more

The Stache - Entrance - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, West Virginia

See all

Such a cool little ice cream/candy shop! Great customer service!

This is a OK place to grab Hershey's ice cream walking around the cool town of Fayetteville while supporting your local economy. Nothing too special as far as service, we generally stop here every evening after bridge day. This time I couldn't handle the 10 min wait for one customer at the bar so we left without any ice cream and had dessert down the street. read more

I really enjoy this little place. Very cool atmosphere and wonderful service. The smoothies are terrific and no added sugar!

Owner was having a bad day and told people she did not have to serve them. Very rude to customers She does not fill the cones. It is a waste of your money. Additionally the codes were stale. The owner had to wash everything and mad everyone wait. read more

Yummy ice cream in a cute little place right downtown. The owner is super friendly. I had cappuccino crunch and it was coffee ice cream with chocolate swirls and a toffee crunch. read more

Good ice cream. Cute outside seating. And my dog loved his vanilla ice cream cone. Would come again

Disappointed they didn't have cap crunch (they were sold out). But they were super friendly, the place is neat & clean! Must try it!!!!

Always happy to get the Stache when we come to Fayetteville. A cute small business, the owner is always nice, and the ice cream is always good! I recommend the Strawberry Milkshake! read more

What a wonderful, tasteful, cozy feel to this fabulous ice cream shop . Delicious ice cream coupled with warm and friendly service . Despite the fact that we walked in 10 minutes to closing, we were greeted with warmth and positive energy. Local artist products brings the community connection as well as fun ice cream Stache pictures decorating the walls . So glad we decided to stop in ! read more

Hands down one of the cutest little places I have ever been in!!! Such a family friendly attitude and atmosphere. There are plenty of flavors of hard dip ice cream to choose from as well. There are milkshakes and floats too. Overall very happy we stopped in read more

Best little Ice cream shoppe!! So cute inside carrying the "The Stache" theme throughout! Owner super friendly and welcoming! We stopped by twice, it was SO good! read more