They have a great selection of food, the bathrooms and tables are clean, and the staff are very friendly! Took a while for our food to come out though, considering it was only my family of 4, and 2 other small families there, but the food was worth the wait! The salad i got (i believe it was called the antipasto salad) was delicious, and tasted very fresh! read more

The food was only okay after they got the order right. Unfortunately it was served without an apology for me having to come back to fix my take out order and was questioned like I was trying to rob them. Avoid the cheese steak with the slimy bun. ​ read more

Big hits were the taco salad and (biggest hit!) the Toledo's Alfredo! Fast, efficient service by courteous servers. read more

See all

First time eating at the new location. I love that it's larger but the decor and atmosphere is dull. The food-was delicious! I got the small lunch lasagna and it's far from small. My husband and brother each got what was to be a small pizzas they were more like a medium and they loved them. My cousins got cheesesteaks that were to be small they were not small but delicious. Portion size is great, price was great, food was great and so was the server. 5 stars Ambiance-2 stars read more

Their Food and Prices are excellent. The angel hair pasta with clam sauce was large enough for two meals. The bread was excellent! I am not from the area, but have a friend at the nursing home up the road. I stopped at Toledo's both times on my way back from my visits. read more

Toledo's Pizza - Angel Hair Pasta with Red Clam Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

Not much of an atmosphere here but the food and service were both 100% fine. I got the small lasagna lunch special; my partner got the small stromboli lunch special. Both were quite large and both tasted good. Without hesitation, I would eat here again. read more

so what can I say, this is a small shop in the cut, that has been here for years. The food is on point, and the staff was super friendly. If you are in the area I would definitely recommend there pizza it was next level read more

Overall all the Delivery we've ordered from Toledos over this year has been excellent. You gotta try their subs, pastas, pizzas, cheeseburgers, fries, onion rings, it goes on and on. They're all great read more

See all

Finally a place where the yelp rating is correct. The pizza here is good. I was slightly worried since there were zero pictures of pizza on the yelp account, but I figured people devoured their slice and forgot to take pics lol Crust, sauce, amount of cheese - they do a good job. Oh, also get an order of their French fries. Crispy succulent babies. Check out Toledo's! I haven't tried Frank's yet, but it's on the list. Toledo's has some good pizza. Northern Jersey approved ;) read more

See all

The food is always great portion size is always large. The new location is much bigger than the old location. The service here is always friendly. read more

We strayed from our normal pizza place and tried Toledo's based on all the positive reviews. The pizza was decent; however, I cannot say this is the best - or even one of the top five pizza places in Waynesboro. One the night we ordered from Toledo's we ordered two large cheese pizzas. The gal on the phone was nice and said our order would be ready in 20 minutes. When we showed up the pizzas were ready and hot with a total price of around $23. The pizza tasted decent but we personally felt improvements could be made. The sauce was fairly generic. It lacked depth and flavor compared to other places in town. Additionally, the pizza could have used some more cheese as well as another minute or two in the oven. The crust was a bit underdone and still doughy for our taste. I plan to try Toledo's again for a sub or other item but when it comes to pizza there are better options in Waynesboro. read more

We instantly adopted this place as our 'uh-oh, we didn't plan dinner, what should we do?' go-to. Great pizza, decent subs, giant calzones, amazing chicken parm, friendly staff, QUIET restaurant (why do others have to play their music so loud?) and there's almost always an open table. They have fancier, more formal meals and specials, and maybe someday I should try one. Walk in, seat yourself. Service can be a little slow and relaxed, this is not a fast food place or pizza chain. They do deliver. Pizza reheats well the next day, the fantastic fries do not. read more

The new location is fabulous. The food continues to be great. And they now deliver to the Penn National community. So many tables at this location, they can finally accommodate large parties with tables in the center, and for the more intimate setting they have booths along the windows. It's been packed every-time I've gone by recently. Stop in and give them a try. read more

Food was absolutely horrible. Smelled like gasoline service was horrendous. The servers were talking bad about my children and me so loud that I could hear them from a mile away horrible place to eat read more

Food was absolutely horrendous. The service was horrible. The girls were talking bad about me the entire time and laughing at me overall not a very great place would not recommend to eat honestly, just save your money at that point. read more

Pizza is very consistant. Dough has been treated properly. Chicken sandwich is excellent, big as can be. I drive past two pizza joints to get there. read more

Top notch, great pasta. Pizza was also good. Definitely try a chicken salad! Very friendly staff and very clean. I highly recommend!

Great food at good prices!! Large menu! Enjoyed Greek salad, pizza, fries, cheesesteak sub, Italian sub. Great takeout. read more

The food is seriously good. My family hasn't had anything bad, yet. Veggie stromboli=yum. Steak and cheese stromboli=nom. Spaghetti=totes delish. Alfredo with chicken and broccoli=so so good. Their bread is made in house and is so freaking good. Clean restaurant. Plenty of seating. Good parking. Service was great. Kyle was very attentive and got us anything we needed. Watch the step going into the women's bathroom. Wash your hands before flushing the toilet because flushing turns the faucet water really hot. I can't comment on their pizza because I feel that would be a betrayal to Frank's. I will definitely eat here again, but I won't eat their pizza. I've heard it's good, though. read more

See all

Wife and I were wandering home and needs pizza. Pretty good pizza at a reasonable price. Onion rings were great! Garlic powder was missing, needs to be added. read more

Maybe next time, Ordered cheese sticks and a large pizza. Cheese sticks took forever to come out, pizza came out soggy. When asked what was wrong we informed staff the pizza was soggy like wet cardboard (probably under cooked and rushed due to late cheese sticks). The manager was in the back washing dishes so a waitress had to take the job to try and tell us we would have to pay full price. Full disclosure, my wife and I each ate one slice and my 2 boys ate a slice each as well( they will eat anything like little animals after a hunger strike). My wife and I both had a look of disgust after finishing our slice. I thought hey maybe it was just this one slice but no it was the whole pizza. The slices were so soggy one could not hold it in their hand without it falling to pieces. The true feeling of anger comes from the manager who at first told me I was paying full price and by manager telling me, I mean waitress because the manager didn't come forward. I paid for my cheese sticks and drinks but not the pizza. Hopefully my next encounter will be better but for now I plan on steering clear. read more

This review is based the kitchen, not on the food. Sign on the door asked for patience when we walked in the door. Little did I know it would take over and hour and half to get a medium pizza. Customers who were seated after us received food before us. Granted they were busy, it should not take that long. I believe our pizza went out the door with another customer. We did not even get refills on our drinks and was offered a minor discount for the inconvenience. Just be ready to wait. read more

Sometimes it is amazing. Every time I order a pizza we'll done with extra cheese it is never well done. It's so disappointing to order a pizza wait 45 min then have it show up looking like crap. It is very hit or miss. read more

I definitely recommend Toledo's Pizza, though they are more than just pizza. If I'm not ordering an extra cheese, I'm always getting their grilled chicken salad, which is amazing. We go back and forth between delivery and pick up, as we don't live to far from them. They are always so kind and on time. All together, great food and wonderful people! read more

Good Food....but owner is a joke. Will try to charge for every little thing. You pay .25 cents for one napkin on delivery order. If you want to get a order and the pizza price comes with two toppings, if you want to take off one topping and sub a different one. You have to pay for a extra topping.You can take off a topping you are paying for that is fine and not give you anything for that. Cool if it is in his pocket nothing for customer service. Same with the sub sandwiches. Notice when delivery comes never a copy of the bill. I would ask for my bill and check it to see if extra charges. I have ordered from here for the last few years. After today I WILL NEVER GIVE THIS BUSINESS MY BUSINESS AGAIN. There goes about 100 dollars a month. Also if the order is wrong they will send you a new order but want the old order back. Bet he tries to sell the order. I was under the understanding once an order is out of the business hands they need to throw it away. Always worried about the pennies but dollar cent dumb. read more

The food here is great! We eat here pretty regularly. I would highly recommend the seafood ravioli. (:

Went here for dinner last night with some of my friends. The food was very good, and very large portions. The price was perfect for the food we got. I got the supreme Stromboli.... It was huge! Wasn't too crazy about the crust, it was kind of dry...but the rest of it was very very good. The french fries are amazing. The rest of my party got pizza and pasta and they all loved it. I'm extremely excited that something this nice has finally come to Waynesboro. The atmosphere is casual and very relaxing. It appeared to be clean and the servers were extremely friendly. I will definitely be going back. Great job Toledo's! read more

Toledo's Pizza - He loves it! - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

New to the area, and stopped in to order wings and breaded mushrooms. The wings are a good size snd very meaty. The mild sauce was very flavorful. The mushrooms were ok, I've had better. The service was good. I would go back but will try their pizza next time. read more

I love, love, love their food!!!! I've had both their pasta dished, their pizza, and their subs and all are delicious! The pasta is very much authentic Italian, I love their Seafood Alfredo and White Clam Sauce!!! LOTS of seafood and clams!! I always get the white pizza, their garlic sauce is to die for and just the right amount of ricotta on the pizza to make it perfect. Their homemade bread is out of this world, which makes their subs incredible...lots of fresh ingredients and they deliver!!!! It's hard to find many places that have great food and come to your doorstep in Waynesboro! The restaurant is very clean and very nicely decorated. Will continue to frequent often!!! read more

Ordered delivery. Received fast and piping hot. Got the fettuccine seafood Alfredo containing huge shrimp, sea scallops, and baby clams. Portion was huge and some of the best sauce I've ever had. Came with garden salad and loaf of homemade bread. Also ordered fettuccine with white clam sauce. White wine type of sauce that tasted very fresh. read more

Toledo's Pizza - Fettucini alfredo with shrimp, scallops, and clams. Huge portion and delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

Went in for a late lunch service was great we ordered eggplant parmesan  and small stramboli portions are gigantic  and Yummy read more

Toledo's Pizza - Eggplant parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

Food is delicious but the girl on the phone is stupid. We got delivered too several times in the past but this time it's .3 miles outside really so I guess your business is doing well and didn't need my two big boy subs two dozen mild wings a large ff and breaded mushrooms. So girl on the phone I'm sure your owner is proud of you and we will take our business elsewhere. Ps around a 10 dollar tip every time read more

Every time I get takeout its wrong. There's always something missing or incorrect. The food is okay but the service is absolutely terrible and the wait is too long for the quality of the items you get. read more

I just called to place a delivery order when they have delivered to our house several times before. Now we are out of their delivery area. They would not change their mind after I said you have delivered to us several times before. I will not use them again. read more

I have ordered to-go and delivery multiple times and have never been disappointed. Food is fresh, delicious, and delivered in a timely manner. Better than most restaurants in town. read more

Great calzones. The "Stacy's salad" is amazing, especially with grilled chicken. Way better than other pizza shops in the area.

It took 55 minutes to get my order. It was Monday night. They said 15 minutes to pick up. They have good food, it just takes forever.

Great place to eat! The Alfredo is amazing, great workers and really nice waitresses. I tipped a waitress named Maggie very sweet girl! Keep up the good work read more

Looking for a new pizza place, we tried Toledo's tonight. Excellent pizza! Crust has a good balance of soft and crunchy and good quantity of toppings. Slice folded well to eat without snapping or flopping. The white pizza had a great garlic flavor and the ricotta made for a differently nice texture. read more

The pizza is the best in Waynesboro! This is the only place my family will order from anymore. And everyone is so friendly!