I've only been in town for a few days, but I think there are strong odds this may be the best restaurant in Monterosso. Here's why:
Food - I had the eggplant parmigiana and my partner had the shrimp sautéed in brandy. We both really enjoyed our dishes. The eggplant was smothered in delicious mozzarella, and the sauce and eggplant tasted great.
Service - Our server was friendly and attentive. We were greeted warmly and seated quickly on a busy night. This isn't a huge place, so I'd recommend starting the dinner search here and then considering a backup if the wait is too long for you.
Ambience - What a beautiful restaurant! Everyone wants to dine al fresco in Italy, and I understand why, but the inside of this place is very charming. The art on the walls is very nice and the plates were sort of Kintsugi style as it looked as though my plate and my partner's plate were each broken in half, then a half from each plate was repaired using the half from the other plate (and the entire plate was glazed, so the porous joinery was sealed and hygienic).
Menu - Many restaurants in the area have very similar menus (which make sense in such a small place), but Tosca endeavored to have four daily specials and a menu that included a few dishes not as frequently seen in town.
Tosca is a likable place with very good food. It's a newer spot too, and they're clearly keeping it clean and beautiful. Highly recommended. read more