This shop is everything you're hoping it to be and more…read more Need some funky pens? Tiny tea cups? Funny socks? Jewelry? Vintage clothes? Books? They've got it all. It's certainly a smaller shop but it is jampacked with magical things. My boyfriend and I probably spent at least half an hour in here just wandering around. We both ended up buying some things to take back home. It was just definitely a fun little spot to explore while in Shepherdstown. I hope this place stays around for a very long time because I'd love to visit again someday.

Wonderful experience!!! Highly recommend Kind employees,…read moregreat pricing on everything from clothing to china cups.

A very nice second hand treasures shop. Nicely organized and displayed. Almost doesn't feel like a…read moresecondhand store! Staff is very friendly and hello you find things if you are looking for something in particular.

O'Hurley's General Store is fun, the very definition of eclectic :-). Every little thing I ever…read morewanted, and many more that I want now that i've seen them. It's full of curated artsy and rustic decor and household goods, jams, teas, clothing, and a very imaginative selection of toys and trinkets. The store is bigger than you think, with at least three rooms behind the welcoming front room. There's parking right out front, and they were open on Memorial Day (2025).

We have spent many hours here both shopping and listening to the Thursday evening music! what a…read moreremembrance as we have since moved south but have returned a couple times to sit again for several hours listening to musicians from all walks of life, ability and personality share themselves as we dream they did in times past. No performance at the Music Hall or Kennedy Center every exceeded theirs here. We pray they never stop.

I had a little different experience than most reviews. I think it is a great place to shop. I…read moredidn't not find being on the seller end a very good experience. They must have been burnt so many times that they have every safe guard set to protect themselves. The young lady working the day I went to pick up my items was very to the point. I didn't sell any of my items in 3 months which was fine (18 out of 20 items were clothing items new with tags). I was in there for about an hour an a half looking for my unsold items after the consignment period ended. I found 19 out of 20. I gave up on the last item. I was still planning to try to sell another group/type of items. However, after going to retrieve my unsold items, and feeling unvalued as a consignee, I have decided not to sell there again.

Sheila was great to deal with. She gave me a lot of guidance and was very fair on the items we…read morehave on consignment. The store itself is very organized, clean and very well arranged. The items in the store are very good quality. Furniture, home accessories, clothing, jewelry etc.

This store is enormous and very organized. All of the items are in nice condition. I saw some…read moreclose out bulk items that were great.

What a great place to find some awesome stuff! This store is packed with great deals. I shop here…read morea couple times a month because they are always getting more donations and new stuff. They have so much clothing and household goods and the prices are great! I often stop in to say hi to Amber and her staff and check out what's new. The staff are always super friendly and eager to help. I found a great coffee table, clothes, some artwork and even stuff for my dog. Would definitely recommend checking it out!

There are some great dealers here. The place is looking…read morebetter than ever. Good decor. Would love some more furniture and garden. I try to go every 2 weeks.

I've been going to this HUGE antique shop for seven years. I always find something, usually too…read moremany things! Standard set-up of individual dealers' booths. Just about anything you could imagine buying, someone has it here. Antique china, kitschy items, collectibles, tools, books, linens, etc. There's even an antique doctor's buggy outside for sale. Every time I take out of town visitors here, they end up shipping boxes of things back home. Friendly staff, free coffee, and restrooms.

Always clean and organized, clothing is fairly priced and I don't ever really see anything…read moreoverpriced or poor condition.

We stopped by to make a donation of some household items. The donation center is at the side/back…read moreof the store. After we had finished making the donation, we went inside the store just to check it out and was surprised to see it was very well stocked and full of people trying to look at clothing and household item deals. There are many new stores in that strip-mall that we need to check out also.

Too many 'extremes'! Big difference in prices, (ex: men's shirts - one - $2.50, another was…read more12.50), linen section was very messed up, had to untangle sheets before you could see price, size, etc. Also, too many things should have been in trash instead of thrift store!!

This place is much cooler than you'd expect. You can find an old sturdy dresser in their shop and…read moreask for it to be painted bright turquoise or fuchsia. We also found cute necklaces and antique books for gifts. It's fun to explore the shop and get decorating ideas from the awesome and interesting Miss Bailey. Other points: The selection changes each time we visit. It's outside of Martinsburg with no parking or other issues. Non-pushy, but helpful staff. More of an artsy warehouse feel than a grandma's attic feel of some thrift shops. Very decent prices as of now (before it's discovered by tourists). Relaxed feel. Good layout (not overstuffed).

My mom and I live in Middletown and we went there wondering about dropping off clothes. The…read moregentleman there told us the information about what clothes they take and how they commission the donor of the items. However, when he was talking about the clothes they take which is "high end" items; he glanced myself and my mom up down while talking. Now let me say we weren't all dressed up that day as we were going to local nurseries to look at plants as well; but that is still highly offensive.

I've been wanting to check out this consignment shop for awhile now and finally decided to stop in…read moreover the past weekend. First, I absolutely love the name. I love play on words like that. The gentleman working inside was very welcoming and social. The whole star was 50% off that day, which my addicted to shopping mind said "SCORE!" All the items in the shop were in good shape and I saw many that still had tags. Prices matched what I would expect for consignment. But, unfortunately, nothing peaked my interest. I felt that all the styles were too old or too young for me. I kept an eye out for any high fashion labels but they evaded me. I'd shuffle through again, though!

Fantastic selection of great stuff and along with great prices, make this a MUST stop if you are…read morenear!!

Great store with a lot of selection and great customer service . Got a steal of a deal on a Atari…read moreJaguar and a long box resident Evil . No to mention the staff is great . I even had the pleasure of meeting The owner Rene from storage wars. Cool people and great store !!