So I wandered into this place after a Google search for somewhere to buy seafood other than my…read morelocal grocery store. I didn't know exactly what I wanted, was just thinking something fresh as I was preparing a seafood alfredo so almost anything would have worked. I walked in and the gentleman behind the counter asked what he could get for me, and I replied that I didn't really know (as I was planning on asking him for recommendations) He looked at me and said "then what the hell are you doing here?" (with kind of a grin on his face). I'm not saying that comment would have been accepted by everybody however my interpretation was that he read me pretty well and he was correct in the fact that I thought it was funny. But anyway, I told him what I was thinking about doing and he recommended some bay scallops and shrimp... I got home and made my alfredo sauce, some pasta, added the seafood and oh my gosh. The quality of this seafood was off the chart. I thought I was doing pretty well with for example the shrimp I was purchasing at my usual supermarket however after tasting this, I will be a regular customer. The place is rather small, and they don't have an excessive amount of anything as far as I could tell, however they have a little bit of everything. I'm quite sure they have more in the back at least what little space there is in the back, and I did read reviews in other places (or maybe even on here I can't remember) that apparently you can get on their email list and therefore you will know when the truck comes in if you really want fresh seafood. So anyway, definitely a place I would recommend to anybody that's in the Elmira New York area. You will not be disappointed.

Just theBESt Get the cocktail sauce…read more To go with shrimp Buy extra m Believe it The boys are whats up!

I met a friend here today and shared a few great brews and two delicious cheese and smoked fish…read moreplates. don't know anywhere in town where the appetizers are so thought out and interesting! I also asked for advice on their fresh salmon to take home for dinner. August was extremely helpful and explained the differences between the three fresh salmon choices. I choose the Scottish salmon and oh boy! it did not disappoint! Salmon was super fresh tasting, August put it on ice for the ride home! Simply seasoned with salt, pepper and paprika with a few lemon slices. Absolutely delicious. Thank you August for your expertise and kind service!

Went to Captain Cook's for the first time I'm from Long Island and was really missing seafood the…read moreseafood I got at the stores blah I got four dozen clams from him as I was baking and making linguine and white clam sauce with some friends they were a fantastic fresh sweet and now that I know I can call ahead of time and even order specialty products like super soccer on calamari with a lot of legs fresh I was very very happy what a nice gentleman also received us and while you wait you can have a nice bloody Mary really nice place to go really enjoyed the experience

Outstanding quality fish and some seafood. Service is friendly and knowledgeable. Very fresh!read more

I depend on Anthony to bring the freshest seafood into Sullivan County, which was a seafood desert…read morebefore he came to town. Whether it's whole fish, filets, steaks, shellfish, scallops or his flavorful Salmon and Fishcakes (my "go to" lunch choice btw), it's ALWAYS fresh, delicious, and he's always good natured and helpful ... Can't recommend Anthony and his place highly enough.... SUPPORT THIS LOCAL RESOURCE!

Hi my Name is Nichole Yesterday was my first time ever At Archar Seafood and i had a wonderful…read moreexperience with The owner Micheal he made me feel welcomed and loved he's hilarious by the way lol but overall the seafood is fresh beyond fresh again i went yesterday and i went today thank you You have a forever customer

Great product and service always. I have been coming here for years. The staff is always friendly…read moreand prices are reasonable.

Came here as my friend wanted to make fish for one of our dinners. Overall, we were happy with our…read morepurchase. BOFM upon entry has two nicely spread out ice troughs full of fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, and more. We were told that the owner makes regular trips to New York to obtain the seafood and that all are not farm raised but wild. I cannot guarantee that, though. The place smelled like it should and not of old product or unclean. Our staffer made nice conversation with us and was nice that he had some common things with my friend that they could discuss. The prices were on par with what I could possibly get in Philadelphia at the Reading Terminal Market but may be considered high here in the Poconos. We got some trout and bluefish. They prepped the fish how we wanted it. My friend also picked up some Branzino for the ride back home. Our dinner was excellent!

Quirky personality but product always hits the mark. I have…read moreclam bakes and order 200, 300, 500 clams at a time. He always has them and they are always wonderful. Fish looks beautiful. I always say I'm going to try it and then never make it back.

Has amazing Haddock and Macaroni and cheese. They are fast and friendly always. All of their…read moreseafood is fresh and it's made fast and to your liking. Love this place been going here since childhood!

I just love this place. Very friendly reasonable prices and great food... I go whenever I am in…read moreCortland

Call in service for fast service .cooking done in store great pricing for great food . Parking lot…read morecan be a challenge . Owner is a seasoned fish vendor and quick to answer most questions.

Pete never fails, another successful seafood boil with the freshest seafood we bought from Pete's…read morefish market. Only place to buy seafood, they will never let you down.