This may be my favorite pizza place in southern NH for simple delicious thin crust pizza. Sauce is zesty, cheese in a perfect amount and a nice tooth to the crust. They do slices too and for 2-2.50$ really hit the spot when you want something fast and don't want to spend much cash. read more

If you are in downtown Keene, dont miss Amici s. This is real pizza pie. Not too cheesy and a nice thin crust if you ask for it. We also appreciate all that these owners do to show their for the community. Very generous people. read more

The customer service is trash. Food is correct, sometimes & the way they handle incorrect orders is rude and, frankly, appalling. Been a customer for 10+ years. Has only gone downhill under new ownership. Today was the last straw, will not be returning. read more

Hand's down my favorite place in town for subs or pizza.(Their appetizers are great too). Usually I have them deliver and have never had a problem with my food or the driver being late. read more

In short, this is the best pizza in the area, hands down, no competition but I won't go here anymore. I can't count how many times I have gone in Amicci's during my short lunch break for two slices of cheese and a Coke only to be told; "We don't have any cheese right now, we need 15 minutes". Why, during the lunch hour, do you not have slices of cheese ready, habitually? That last time I went in, I asked for two slice of cheese. When they handed me the box I opened it to put some crushed red pepper on it and the slices were half the size of what they normally are with these two huge cheese bubbles on them. It looked like they over cut all these other slices and left this one slice that they cut into two to stretch it. I said to the person at the register, "Look at these slices you gave me, they are puny." The whole place just started at me, no apology, no "I'm sorry sir, let me take care of that for you". Forget it I said, give me another slice please. "Sorry sir, we're all out of cheese, we'll need 15 minutes" That was it, good pizza or not, I'll find some place else to get my pie. I don't get long for lunch and I always end up leaving mad. read more

The pizza here is really good. Friendly staff. Wish the bathroom was a bit bigger, hard to change a baby in there. PAC man is available.

I moved from Keene to Boston three years ago and I'm still talking about Amicis pizza. All time favorite.

Worst pizza ever! I had frozen pizza that was better. The Greek salad I had was buried in canned black olives and bland domestic feta cheese although the iceberg lettuce was fresh. Do not recommend. read more

Everyone has their own preferences for Pizza, so it's impossible that the whole world would agree, but this is what you get: Thin, totally authentic fresh thin crust, just the right amount of [not-too-sweet-but-flavorful] sauce, and the perfect ratio of toppings. Not greasy at all. My one tip (but I do this anywhere) is to order your pie well-done for a slightly crispier crust and a little more brown on the cheese. Damn, I want some pizza now... read more

As a new Yorker I have high expectations for pizza.. This pizza is exceptional! People in this area are clueless when it comes to pizza, however Amicci's gets it right! read more

Although I was really looking forward to this based upon the excellent Yelp reviews I had read, I was NOT impressed. Poor seating. Poor service. Pizza was nothing special...bland really. Not recommended. read more

After spending four college years in New York City, I have longed for a slice of pizza that can even come close. As a first pass, I ordered two plain slices from Amicci's, and I must say that it was a nostalgic moment for me. The sauce is relatively mild but offers a fair share of flavor. The dough is thin, not too heavy, and a happy medium between doughy and crispy. There was just a tad more (and I mean a tad) cheese than I am accustomed to for a thin crust pizza mainly due to the fact that I fold my pizza. While this style of pizza is not for everyone, it is strikingly close to the NYC style pizza that I know and love. read more

Amicci's is the pizza my husband and I compare all other pizza to! He's military so we live out of state, but whenever we are back in the area we have to stop in and grab an Amicci's pizza. Great price, fresh ingredients, and the staff is super friendly. Conveniently located in downtown Keene so just a short walk from all your favorite spots! read more

Amicci's is one of my favorite pizza places. Their pizza is delicious -- thin crust, not overly greasy, & the perfect ratio of sauce & cheese. You can order by the slice or pie, & you also have the option of eating the pizza there or taking it to go. They also serve pasta, salads, & subs; although being that I've only had their pizza, I can't speak to the quality of their non-pizza menu items. read more

This is an excellent place to get a pizza from. NY thin crust, great value for what you get. Owner is friendly and staff is attentive. Lots of toppings, but too finely diced for me. Crust is soft and not crunchy. Try them out you won't be disappointed. read more

My favorite pizza place. Delicious huge slices that aren't overly greasy and somehow they have perfected the art of thin crust pizza that is still doughy and never burnt on the bottom or too crispy. Their subs and other meals are really good too. And they always have cream soda which is my favorite. It's very small so don't depend on eating there I usually just grab a bench outside on main street. Also there's one or two video games there that kids have a blast on while waiting. read more

In a town where there is a lack of good New York style pizza, this is really the place to go

Great place if you're looking for good quality, inexpensive pizza. Great place if you're ordering for a large group. They use quality dough for the pizza and their pita bread is amazing (worth the extra $1 or so to add it to your salad). Chicken fingers are also a good choice. read more

I'm sure people will disagree - but the pizza we got wasn't great (and I'm a big fan of NY style pizza). It was just very bland. The wings were not good. Super breaded and greasy - felt like an equal ratio of breading/meat, which is just not a great chicken wing. But then again, wings aren't their speciality. Will maybe give their pizza another try, because of the rave reviews..but I would not order the wings from this place again! Friendly service and great staff though. read more

This place is disgusting and cheap, basically like going to a Chinese restaurant. Food is frozen and unfresh. If you see the cooks outside you'll understand what I'm saying. Lol read more

Seriously the best. Has been my favorite pizza place forever. Whenever I move away, I can wait to come back for a visit so I can have some pizza. Highly recommended for anyone passing through Keene. They have more than just pizza. They have subs, appetizers, and salads. I love this place. read more

Amicci's pizza is delicious. I ordered a sausage and ricotta pizza, and it was amazing. The dough was perfectly cooked, there were just the right amount of toppings, and the ingredients were super fresh. I'll definitely return. As an added bonus, our pizza chef (James) was both friendly and cute. :-) read more

Pizza was soggy, I could tell the peppers and onions were frozen. The wings were so fatty that we couldn't even eat them, the worst I've ever had!!! Granted it was 10 minutes before closing, but still. read more

We were staying in Keene and had tried a few other places but they have the pizza I grew up on. We got great jalapeño poppers and chicken fingers! Got to introduce my husband to Chicken Finger pizza finally! I love that I could order on their web site! Fast delivery and pretty tasty food! read more

i can not believe how bad it was .. got jalapeño popper with a side of blue cheese looks like they used it as a foot ball before delivering it . Subs were cold and gross . 50 bucks just to make something else at home . read more

Decent New Haven/New York type pizza, which for Keene is saying a lot. People here seem to think Greek style pizza is the genuine article, which must explain the otherwise mystifying popularity of places like Athens. Meatball sub was just okay. A good place to grab a quick slice of pizza. read more

Great tasting pizza. True to NYC style,flavor and taste. The price was right too. I thought the staff was courteous and quick. It was a busy night but it didn't seem to matter to the staff. Bravo. If want good NYC pizza, eat here. Going to try the White Prosciutto next time I'm in town. read more

Amicci's has it all. They have the big flat slices of pizza with tons of toppings to all kinds of subs you could want, hot or cold. It really depends on the pizza you are into this is ny style with a unique sauce. They have specialty white pizza with proscuitto and feta that cannot be rivaled. For subs you must get the steak tip. Mad juicy marinated tips in a fat bulky roll. If you are not totally thrilled with what you get the first time you order switch it up and get something else because they make really good everything you just have to try it out. read more

Best pizza in Keene hands down! Fresh, hand tossed dough and the pizza isn't greasy. The crust is so chewy I love it. Give this place a shot. You'll love it. read more

I ordered a sub here and it was the worst sub I've ever eaten. It was supposed to be a toasted veggie, and it just had pieces of uncooked vegetables and a tiny amount of cheese. Bread was warm, not toasted. The staff was very unenthusiastic and clearly didn't care about the food they were making. read more

Best pizza on the planet. We live about 25 minutes from Keene and every time we go to eat in Keene we have to go to Amicci's. It does not matter what kind of food we want we just abort and get pizza. It is a thinner crust and it is crispy. It is really good when you take it home but there is nothing better than when the pizza is right out of the oven. read more

We ordered the Caprese white pizza. The dough was great but the pizza itself was relatively flavorless. Occasionally some garlic would make its way into a bite and that helped. There was obviously cheese, tomatoes, and olive oil, as well as dried basil or oregano. A better quality olive oil would make a ton of difference, and perhaps using fresh herbs. I wouldn't order this again, but I'll give them another chance. read more

Me and my girlfriend are obsessed with this pizza place. They have huge pizzas and load up on the toppings. I also really like the crust which is extremely chewy. There is going to be dripping grease! In my opinion it adds to the character of being traditional New York pizza. Their prices are very reasonable for the value you receive. Also they have other foods such as subs, salads, pasta etc. Me and my girlfriend think this is the best pizza in town. Many others will disagree but we love this place. read more

Amicci's is, by far, the best pizza I have ever had in my life. Ramuntos has made a decent pizza as of late that I enjoy, but it still doesn't top Amicci's. Whenever I order from them for large groups of people, everyone always asks the same question, "Where is this pizza from?" Everyone knows its amazing when they eat it. It's truly hard to mess up a pizza, but Amicci's takes a great thing and makes it the best it can be. read more

Just had a very rude experience with the help. We've been loyal customers for years. Tried their on-line order system and had a problem when the pizza was delivered. When we called (understandably upset), the help was rude, aprupt, and hung up before eve attempting to reach a solution. Hope to have this resolved soon, but not getting my hopes up. I would advise against using the on-line option. And beware if you have to call with a problem. read more

I'd vote for best pizza in town! And BIG slices are a bargin. Nice folks, too.

One of the only pizza places I'll done at. Good crust. Good sauce to cheese ratio. :)

LOVE! The pizza is my favorite. I used to travel out of town to get Papa Ginos...but no more.

Worst pizza I've ever had. Based on the reviews I thought it would be good. The pizza was so soggy that I could have used a third hand to hold one piece. The box was soaking wet and the pizza tasted exactly like the box from sitting in whatever liquid it was sitting in. Every piece of topping fell off of every piece I tried to pick up. Eventually I just gave up and threw it out. Pretty nasty. read more

Our familys favorite delivery pizza and great subs too!! Family owned is a bonus!!