Sometimes on a road trip you just gotta stop for ice cream! ...so we found this jem on Yelp…read more The girl that helped us quickly said the best thing they have is their famous warm apple dumpling pie served with cinnamon soft serve ice cream...and she was right! So good and glad we stopped by!

Delightful spot! We asked the super sweet waitress what to order and without missing a beat she…read moresaid the apple pie dumplings and boy was she right. This dessert was just what we needed to get some glucose and finish our road trip. The dumplings are warm, gooey, creamy with ice cream of your choice. Voila!

Homemade ice cream that was delicious...what else do you really need? My almost 5 year old ordered…read morethe cookie monster ice cream and they even added candy cookie monster eyes to it! The service was fine ... the girls working the counter were all friendly. The ambiance is your typical ice cream shop. If you're in the area and looking for ice cream, look no further!

What a terrific homemade ice cream shop! On a cold day of the Charles Dickens weekend in downtown…read moreWellsboro, my sister and I ate ice cream. Sister Goldilocks ate a single dip of banana chip ice cream in a bowl. Being an overachiever, I pigged out on a dip of banana chip and a dip of coconut chip in a waffle cone. We enjoyed the homey decor of this establishment and friendly employees. There is an ice cream flavor for anyone who enjoys the fresh frozen treat!

Okay, so it's a long story on how I found myself seeking out Pecora's Creamery, which is a tiny…read morestore at the end of Pecora Road across from the old dairy. Inside is clean and quaint, with tasty breads, meats and cheeses from local farms. And while those are darn good- let's talk about the ice cream. This is the creamiest, most flavorful ice cream I have ever had in my life. No like seriously. This ice cream is small batch and it's AMAZING. I had the chocolate peanut butter egg (their Easter flavor), my husband had coffee, and my son had chocolate. Each was phenomenal in its own way. I don't know when I will be back in this area of Pennsylvania but if I'm anywhere remotely near, I will drive out of my way to have some more. Seriously folks, this ice cream is special.

The smoothest ice cream in a bucolic setting. The staff is friendly and the refrigerator cases are…read morefilled with a variety of products

Large verity of ice cream flavors the ambiance is family friendly with a touch of tropical flavors.read more

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the…read morewinter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by.

We stopped in on a Monday night after finding this place on yelp and reading the reviews. The…read morecommon review is the price compared to the amount of ice cream you get or don't get, which we found to be true. Overall, the ice cream was good but nothing that blew our socks off. Also, the kid behind the counter just looked like he hated his job.

This little ice cream shack is the best around! The ice cream is so fresh and flavorful, toppings…read moreare plenty, cones are crunchy and there is so many options to choose from. Ice cream in a cone, in a cup, dipped in many different choices, sundaes offered in smores, peanut butter, etc, they even offer a treat for your dog! Staff is sweet! They pay attention to detail so your ice cream is always perfect! If you are nearby stop by for a delicious treat, maybe take one to go too!

Had the chocolate soft serve with chocolate sprinkles and GF had the vanilla with chocolate…read morecrunchies. Yummmmmm

Tutrone's Ice Cream is a great place for your sweet tooth! Their homemade ice creams were smooth…read moreand creamy with a variety of unique flavors like Almond Joy and Boneyard Gravy (vanilla ice cream with fudge/peanut butter swirls with chocolate covered pretzels)! They are very generous with their scoops so that was a great surprise! Service was great and the place had a lot of seatings surrounding it. There's even a family friendly area where they had two life sized Connect 4 games for kids to play with. The area was kept clean and the vibe is very family friendly. Would definitely return here the next time we're in the Poconos!

Really good customer service by a group of young individuals working fairly hard to the many people…read morethat fled to the Poconos in the summer. They did have one or two sugar-free ice cream options. Many flavors of Italian ice. They do the hard chocolate exterior dipped cones. Two options for soft ice cream. You can get a sundae with a wide variety of toppings. I lost count after 25lol. Me and my family come to this place at least once or twice a summer and we are never disappointed. I do believe they are open seasonally. Outdoor fire pits for you to sit at while you eat your ice cream, so, even if it's a little cold or feeling like fall weather, you could be warm and eat cold ice cream at the same time and be completely happy. Highly recommend you stop here on your way home or on your way in!

Love this ice cream shop! The employees are friendly teenagers who eagerly explain the various…read morechoices. I had a dip of butter pecan and a dip of coconut ice cream in a chocolate and nut dipped cone. Mom enjoyed a dip of strawberry cheesecake ice cream and a dip of butter pecan in a waffle bowl. Delicious treats! Good portions for the cost. Great cinematic decor. Fun, eclectic collections were displayed throughout. You can eat at the counter like we did, or sit in the open dining area. Parking and access are ideal. Close proximity to Ollie's, Key Foods, and other stores in that plaza.

They serve Liebys ice cream and they leave it in the freezer too long. I don't like ice cream with…read moreice crystals all over it

7/19/2026. Sometimes my friends like my area here because it never seems to change. Well my father…read moretold me that Heislers had been sold. It was a tough thing to accept because this area is rooted in tradition and nostalgia. I just was thinking "this must be the end". I wanted to visit Heislers because I found out they had beautiful sunflowers. I was so eager to see the fields of flowers! Heislers has 6 beautiful acres!!! For this reason guests may take 3 complimentary blooms. When I asked the attendant there he said we could take as much as we want. All complimentary but if you wish to have a Heislers vase that will cost you 14$. I'm absolutely thrilled with the new changes so far! I sure hope they will stay open much longer than Labor Day too. We shall see. Heislers has put a cute soft pretzel building in, in place of the ancient pizza place that used to have some weird assorted junk for sale in the past. I heard the new owners had soft pretzel business experience. I did not try them but I will. I would love to see a sesame seed option, please. I got strawberry cheesecake ice cream and my husband chose salted caramel which he reported was delicious! I didn't order any hot food nor did I look at the hot food menu- but I will in the future. Also- I was thrilled to see sought after merchandise in the small room that houses the ice-cream freezer. I am very happy to say I finally got my shirt!! Thank you for not making it white!! I can never keep a white shirt white!! I look forward to making memories here at this traditional business which the new owners are elevating and adding beauty and elegance! The sunflower sitting areas, the merchandise, mini golf, pretzels, live entertainment, beautiful lights, and lovely shelters are really bringing this business into 2026!

What a disappointment! I did not expect to pay $38.00 for the same order I paid $20.00 for last…read moresummer, 2 burgers 2 shakes and an order of fries. Outrageous price for mediocre food. The "smash" burger was overdone- the fries, cold and flavorless. The milkshake still tastes the same but appears to be smaller and is topped with whipped cream, was not given a choice on that addition. It's still a beautiful setting and they have made a successful effort to refresh the property. Sadly, I am afraid the high prices will discourage most people, I can't imagine what the bill would be if you brought the whole family! I would suggest going back to the simpler menu (and crinkle cut fries) that kept Heisler's so successful in the past. This used to be a regular summer stop for us, unfortunately it won't be at these prices.