We stopped in on a Monday night after finding this place on yelp and reading the reviews. The common review is the price compared to the amount of ice cream you get or don't get, which we found to be true. Overall, the ice cream was good but nothing that blew our socks off. Also, the kid behind the counter just looked like he hated his job. read more

See all

Gave this place 3 stars because the ice cream is good portions are below average and big upcharge for toppings we ordered 3 large cups one with sprinkles only one with hot fudge and dry walnuts and whipped cream and another with one topping it came out to 37.00 a bit pricey ... don't think we will be returning read more

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the winter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by. read more

My friends and I came in after a hot sunny afternoon on the lake. The aura was very much like a small town's favorite ice cream shop, and we quickly learned why. Despite the large size of my group, we were met with warmth and kindness by those at the counter. I ordered the cookies & cream ice cream in a kiddie cup. While some places make their cookies & cream ice cream too sweet and vulnerable to a quick melt, this one was balanced and well refrigerated enough to enjoy to the fullest. I enjoyed every little bite, as did my friends, and we imagine others who visit will experience the same! read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Cookies & Cream Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

Service is excellent, ice cream is delicious, especially the lavender, and very friendly environment.

My oh my what a find! Incredible ice cream, freshly made, local ingredients. Passionate service. Incredible. read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Apricot cream, ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

Expensive, insanely delicious, long line, worth it. The pistachio was the best I've had. Cute area for little ones to draw on easels. A little jungle gym and some outdoor tables for sitting. read more

See all

We stopped here for some much-needed treats after getting positively soaked to the bone at the outdoor concert in Bethel. Our daughter was a real trooper through it all so we wanted to do something special for her. We know about Sticky Fingers because they're the only local [to us] proprietor selling Jane's ice cream, which we all love, and which was a favorite of one of our late mom's. We like that they're open about using Jane's since it's such a high quality product and they don't pretend like it's their own ice cream. The shop is a tight squeeze and be forewarned that while service may be slow, it is extremely friendly, so you won't mind the wait and it will likely strike up a pleasant conversation with your fellow patrons. The vibe in here is chill and homey and we appreciated the welcoming ambience. There's a big patio outside to sit down and enjoy your ice creams. We were all happy with our flavors. One of us got peanut butter fudge and salty caramel pretzel. Both were excellent. The other got Almond Joy and cherry chocolate, and while we appreciated the inverse of the latter (chocolate ice cream with cherries instead of the typical other way around), the coconut on the Almond Joy was incredible...so rich! Our kiddo was equally happy with her killer chocolate. Overall, we had a really nice time here and were happy to support such a do-good/feel-good establishment. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in the area. read more

Such a cute little ice cream shop! Stopped in here after grabbing dinner across the street and absolutely loved it. Sticky Fingers offers some unique flavors like Lavender (so good!), Banana Cookie (delicious), and Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso (need to try this next time). They also have a spacious outdoor seating area, which is perfect for the summer. Friendly staff, too! read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Banana cookie ice cream - kid size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

Delicious ice creams and fantastic service make Sticky Fingers a treasure in this little neighborhood.

Visiting Sticky Fingers D is the highlight of our visit, when we come to see our Mommy. As an ice cream fan I try different local ones in every country I happen to be. This one is my go-to place. Owner is wonderful, but also other staff members. read more

Friendly staff Delicious ice cream Great selection of homemade ice cream Parking lot read more

Fun place across from the lake. My husband enjoyed his standard chocolate chip mint. I tried the apricot orange blossom with the homemade French hot fudge sauce. So good! The flavors were rich and the fudge sauce was like fancy chocolate. While I ordered a medium they kindly put it in a large bowl so it wasn't a mess to eat. The owner was great! Friendly even on a busy day'. Big area in the back to eat and relax with friends and a play area for the kids read more

The ice cream is delicious. You can tell it is made with much love. Can't wait to try the soup during the winter!! Thank you!!

Great food no matter what season. James is amazing to deal with. I love visiting the shop either to have the wonderful ice cream or the delicious soup and rolls in the colder months. read more

Delicious ice cream, great toppings (really appreciated that you could get walnuts and pecans as toppings), and there was a pullup bar in the awesome (and very family friendly) outdoor space! read more

Best ice cream flavor selection ever! Very scenic location. Friendly owner. I'll be returning. read more

Incredible ice cream, lovely owners and fun music in the summers! Highly recommend! read more

Incredible ice cream! The dulce de leche, killer chocolate and salty pretzel are all excellent choices. Definitely get a waffle cone, too! For those not a fan of ice cream, they also have pops, coffee (including cappuccinos etc.) and specialty bottled soft drinks. read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

The dulce de leche ice cream was so good we had to get two! My family also enjoyed the killer chocolate and pistachio flavors. The service was even sweeter! Thank you kindly for the warm and welcoming hospitality, the big smiles and care to meet our needs certainly did not go unappreciated. We will be back for the apricot orange blossom, lavender, and coconut almond joy flavors! And I was also very happy to see vegan flavors that change daily ! read more

The ice creams are amazing. The staff is very friendly. I haven't had any of their homemade soups but my son and daughter-in-law rave about them. read more

I scream for Sticky Fingers! A real gem! Unique, addictive and incredibly memorable flavors! Owner is a fine gent with a wonderful personality who embodies everything that an Ice Cream shopreneur should be! Sweet. Delightful and Genuine. Highly recommended can't wait to return! read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Delicious Chocolate Madness with 'Signature Blue' Sprinkles yum - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

From the space to the food, to the owner, this place is just delectable! The ice creams are delicious! Taste just like how an old fashion ice cream should taste with a modern twist on flavors. There is a great outdoor space for seating and even toys available for little ones to play with. James, the owner, is delightful and genuinely cares about his customers and takes pride in his food. We can't wait to come back to try the soup and stew when it's cooler! read more

Great ice cream and great service from the very kind owner. Have not tried the non-ice cream items, but I need to.

Great ice cream I've never tasted such great flavors. Loved the lavender and all flavors.

One of Bethels hidden treasures- if you haven't had their soups yet I highly recommend you pickup a quart or two for supper!

I am in my late 40's and have eaten a lot of ice cream in my life. This ice cream shop was a unique experience. The closest thing to it is Prince Edward Island's local COWS ice cream- it was the best I had enjoyed in my life up to this point- but Sticky Fingers has achieved something truly special with all of their flavors and textures. The opposite of commercial ice cream. Tasting the Orangeblossom Apricot or the Pistacio or the Coconut Almond Joy and homemade hot fudge were all multi-faceted tasting experiences. The owners are culinary artists. PS- the outdoor seating area is very kid friendly. Enjoy!!! read more

We had the loveliest visit with the man wielding the ice cream scoop, and he did NOT steer us wrong! The Apricot & Orange Blossom ice cream paired with Lavender was excellent ~ both intriguing, and the Lavender managed to hit the perfect note of floral-enough without tasting like soap, which is no easy feat. And the coffee-based one that I had (can't remember the name of it) paired with Dulce de Leche was inspired as well. All of the flavors were balanced and not overly sweet, including the Dulce de Leche, which is so often over-the-top sweet. SO good! (We were actually in the market for lunch, were stymied by several restaurants that we thought were going to be open and then weren't ... and were perfectly happy to have this divine ice cream in place of a "real" meal.) Would 100% recommend this gem of a place. read more

Come for the ice cream, come back for the soups, stay for James. A trip to the Sullivan Catskills is not complete without a stop at Sticky Fingers. Their ice cream is the best around - creative flavors, each the best in their category, at a beautiful water-side setting. Their soups are phenomenal - hearty and full of flavor. Don't miss the garlic butter and bread on the side - you'll be raving about it all week and craving it for even longer. James, the proprietor, is the best of humanity - warm, generous, an effervescent spirit, welcoming, gregarious... oh, I can go on. If you're lucky James will be there during your visit - be sure to introduce yourself and enjoy the opportunity to share space with such a poetic soul. read more

Great ice cream and also soups! Nice place for the kids to play outside. Interesting flavors.

some of the best ice cream I have ever had and Ive had a-lot , the coffee, strawberry and orange apricot wowwowwow

I followed the yelp reviews and got the dulce de leche which was good... BUT I absolutely should have ordered the Lavender instead Ohhh man was is absolutely yummy. My partner ordered it and I was so jealous that I didn't. Lol read more

Very kind owner, with a wonderful selection of flavors. Nice outdoor area to relax, and toys and a jungle gym for kids

Great customer service. Friendly and helpful personnel. Most of all the best ice cream I've ever had. Creamy, so flavorful, delish.

Cute little ice cream spot in Kauneonga Lake. It's seasonal so it's only open Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day or so. They aren't elaborate or over the top, but the selection is decent and it isn't too pricy either. I recommend grabbing a bite at one of the restaurants there, then stopping in for a sweet treat to nosh on while enjoying the lake scenery. read more

Sticky Fingers Delectables - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Kauneonga Lake, New York

Yummy ! They even have breakfast ! Great place for the kids to enjoy ice cream .. Mango sorbet is amazing and so is the cookies and cream ..this city girl approves!! read more

Just take my money!! We stopped in here by accident, we were trying to find parking for another restaurant. I saw the sign and made a mental note for after dinner. Well bust my buttons, this place is ice cream heaven. So many unique and delicious flavors, homemade cookies and pastries and great customer service. This is a place I will travel out of the way for. It caters to families which I love!! They have outdoor seating spread out all over. They have a jungle gym, an outdoor high seat, little tables and chairs and other little toys. We load up the tiny humans with sugar and then let them burn it off. The owner is a super chill Austrailian. He has a contagious smile and a very relaxed demeanor. The like was out the door and he killed it with service, fast and efficient. This place is one of the many reasons I love Sullivan County in the summer. I hope they're here to stay during the warm months. read more

See all

A real treat for white lake and very tasty homemade hard ice cream . Right in the middle of town and perfect dessert after a local meal

Beat ice cream in the county, beat host, and loveliest place to sit and eat it. No trip to the area is complete without at least one trip here. And in the world yet check out the soups and amazing garlic butter with buns. read more

One of the best I have had honestly, it's the perfect blend of creaminess without excessive sugar. Pistachio was my favorite. Great spot looking forward to next time I have my sweet cravings. read more