The Nautical Whimsey is located in downtown Tupelo along Main Street. This spot serves comforting…read moreItalian food with very generous portions and a decent bar selection. THE FOOD The Highlight: The Tiramisu was the star of the evening--moist, semi-sweet, and rich. A tasty end to the meal. Starters: The freshly fired Cheese Bread was another win, topped with fluffy, warm cheese. A comforting start. The Entrees: The portion sizes for the Gnocchi, Lasagna, and Fettuccine Alfredo were enormous. You get a massive amount of food for the price. * Note: The execution didn't match the size. There were issues with texture and flavor depth across the main dishes. For example, the Fettuccine Alfredo sauce was watery and bland rather than creamy and rich. SERVICE & ATMOSPHERE The dining area has a homey, casual feel. The hostess and server were patient, and the waitress immediately swapped out a glass of red wine that had oxidized, which was appreciated. PARKING Plenty of streetside parking is available. OVERALL The Nautical Whimsey provides a large amount of food for the cost. It is a solid choice if you need to feed hungry teenagers who value quantity over culinary precision, but foodies looking for high-quality Italian might want to look elsewhere.

Food: excellent food with very large portions We got the…read morefilet, lasagna, and my son got the grilled cheese Service: the service was wonderful and very prompt Ambiance: we sat outside and very much enjoyed it! They had music playing and the weather was wonderful! We will definitely be back!!

The food was spectacular. My husband is Italian, he had the Sampler plate and I had spaghetti with…read moremeatballs. Excellent.... The service was great and the plates had plenty of food. While we were there, several ppl had to get " To Go Trays". Great place!

This is a great place to eat after church on Sunday!! The service is wonderful! Everyone is so kind…read moreand helpful. They all go out of their way to help you! The food is really good, as always, hot and fresh!! The atmosphere is very nice!!

Always delicious! Service is usually great and I love the atmosphere. My favorite restaurant in…read moreTupelo, MS.

Everything was great. Although steak wasn't cooked as we asked,but didn't say anything.read more

Always a good pizza, especially for a medical plaza. It is worth trying. My son always insists we…read morego when in town from Memphis.

The pizza here was tasty and crispy, but lacked the "pizza" flavor I was craving. It was really…read moresweet, almost sugary at times. Not my style, but pretty tasty

Service food and drinks are amazing. Great place to go eat the atmosphere is always friendly and…read morewelcoming.

Ate at the bar. Good burger and great service from Abby! Probably going back tonight for wings and…read morea drat beer.

Food : as usual pizza salad etc was good! Girls at the…read moreorder counter were courteous, had some requests on kids menu that were handled flawlessly! Place is clean! We ate on patio, weather was great! Wish it wasn't so noisy out there but location is the problem! Person bringing out our food was very lethargic to say the least, brought only one meal at a time, with considerable space in between! One meal was almost complete consumed by the time the 2nd person's food was delivered and for sure by number 4! Had to ask for flatware, there were no condiments on our table. Had to get from surrounding tables. Went inside to a table to get paper towels! She never ask if we needed anything else, in fact I'm Not sure she even ask who had each dish she delivered just sat it down and walked off!

Pizza was good and, as in past visits, the service was very good for the type of restaurant and…read moremenu prices were reasonable. Staff were friendly.

Staying in a hotel because of the ice storm and was happy to see Tupelo had a restaurant that…read moreserves this type of food. This food was a delicious comfort. Very flavorful and great portion for the price. The staff were friendly and helpful and the place had a great aesthetic and atmosphere. Would love to come back and dine-in or have a beer at the bar.

I don't live in Tupelo, I'm here for emergency management. I really wanted to find a place with…read moretraditional Greek food or at least a good gyro that wasn't a chain restaurant. I think Apple Maps found this for me, and if I didn't work 90 hours a week and they didn't close at 10 I'd probably be here a lot more than I should. Food was on point. The bar was awesome. Staff is great and I'll definitely be going back before I leave, hopefully a few more times. Great music piped through the speakers too. Such a cool place.

As I walked in, I thought this could be a fun place for a group of friends to hang out and have a…read moregood time. The decor is fun and of course pays tribute to Elvis! Everyone I encountered was friendly and helpful, great customer service. I got a small sausage and mushroom thin crust to go. As I waited I took that opportunity to look around a take a few pics. They were pretty busy so my expectations were high. I don't review regular pizza places the same as a Chicago or NYC pie, that wouldn't be fair. We all know the crust makes the pizza and I didn't appreciate this crust so much. It had a strange texture and taste. I couldn't put my finger on it almost like play dough. Maybe because I got a thin crust. I would definitely revisit this place to try something else on the menu. I hope I just caught them on an off day.

Ok I have to update my last review. Came here again because it was convenient and across from our…read morehotel. I did not want a chain pizza like Pizza Hut or Domino's. I forgot we came here before and I did not like the crust. I STILL don't like the crust it's heavy, dense with no flavor!!!! Blah, the crust is not light Neapolitan style or New York style, it is just dense bread dough like. I got the hippy I think it was called which is vegetarian I want to say the toppings were fresh, but I couldn't tell. Friend got the artichoke dip appetizer. It was fine. services are fair, you order at the counter and they bring you your order but how can you be a pizza place and have horrible pizza dough? I agree with my last review, I called it "LOST" Pizza because they lost a pizza dough recipe. Next time....Pizza Hut!!! Another star for good beer selection.

I love Pyro's Pizza in Tupelo and am sad and a bit confused to hear that they will be closing their…read moredoors on June 7, 2026. I was told that this decision was made by corporate despite a considerable increase in sales since the new and current manager has taken over this location. The new staff is very friendly and the service is great. The wood-fired pizza with fresh meats and veggies is delicious. They offer a gluten-free pizza, too.

This is no Blaze pizza, where you get as many toppings as you want with no up charge. A $14 build…read moreyour own pizza ended up being $26, and big enough to feed an infant.. Overly drenched in 'finishers' and toppings were incredibly sparse. And considering that this is Tupelo, just rated lowest cost of living in America, if you're smart you'll go local and get four times the pizza for half the price. I was barely acknowledged by the staff when I walked in to pick up my room temperature pizza. I can't speak to the ambience because I grabbed it and left. In hindsight, I should've given it back.