Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Wagner Shell Food Mart

    5.0 (1 review)

    Wagner Shell Food Mart Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Wagner Shell Food Mart

    Recommended Reviews - Wagner Shell Food Mart

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Bhirdo's by the Bay - A summertime view.

    Bhirdo's by the Bay

    4.6(5 reviews)
    43.3 mi

    For some reason or another - be it the exterior, the name, the selection of goods from cold beer to…read morefrozen pizza, the movie rentals, or the hours - usually open when other things are not -- Bhirdo's gas station has a very special place in my heart for 20+ years now. Here's to you, Bhirdo -- hopefully you stay by the Bay for many more years.

    This Shell convenience store/station sits right on a prime scenic lot on Highway 42 overlooking the…read morebay.  I couldn't believe that they had the same $3.899/gal price for regular 87 octane that matched the cheapest price anywhere in Door County at this time.  I've seen Shell prices at a lot of places over the years in both the US and overseas, and they're ALWAYS one of the highest priced brands, ha.  I had to fill up here just for grins, even though I really didn't need to.  It was an old style pump too, with no card reader, no digital screens, and I was flabbergasted and paralyzed for a moment!  I thought, well, I guess have to go in and give them my credit card for a prepayment.   But nope, Andrea the clerk inside, just says fill it up and come back and tell me how much it was.  Ha, a total old school honor system here, and a nostalgic trip to the past.  I'll go with 4 stars.  Now if they had an attendant come out and check my oil dipstick and clean the windshield and pump the gas, I'd go with 5 stars 4sure! ps - Inside the building, they have a standard, small convenience store with pre-packaged goods, i.e., no hot food.

    Photos
    Bhirdo's by the Bay - A homey gas station on a prime bayside Highway 42 lot.

    A homey gas station on a prime bayside Highway 42 lot.

    Bhirdo's by the Bay - $3.899/gal for regular, and matching the cheapest price anywhere in Door County, circa July 2022.  Unheard of for a Shell, ha!

    $3.899/gal for regular, and matching the cheapest price anywhere in Door County, circa July 2022. Unheard of for a Shell, ha!

    Bhirdo's by the Bay - Standard convenience shop inside.

    See all

    Standard convenience shop inside.

    Charlie’s County Market - Produce

    Charlie’s County Market

    2.3(6 reviews)
    35.9 mi

    prices way too high, deli chicken sits in warmer way too long white meat dries out, workers are…read morenice lol, workers are joke , workers in kitchen and cake area think they run store , no reason 3 stores prices are so far off charts, like a can of soup is double in price here compared to other stores lol, why, first they blame diesel prices then they blame distuburtor , but other stores dt have that problem ,

    I have called in to purchase a gift card for my daughter as I live in Appleton and she lives in…read moreShawano. A woman named Debbie answered the phone very rude, by the way. I asked for the manager to purchase this gift card and a manager named Jordan got on the phone, immediately very curt and unfriendly. she said we do not do this gift cards over the phone and I have just done this over the holidays. I asked for her manager over her ame and told her i would call back tomorrow. I find it difficult to believe this grocery store would not want to accept $100 for gift card. Maybe I am wrong... more to come another side note, Unfortunately this is not the first negative interaction I have had with Debbie. We were there a few months ago visiting family and bought two cartons of diet sun drop and we were checked out and about to pay and this Debbie stopped and grabbed the carton of sun drop out of our cart and instructed the young lady to remove it from our bill. she said there was a limit and we were not allowed two cartons. at the time I thought that was quite rude but ok,

    Photos
    Charlie’s County Market - Lunch meat and smokehouse

    Lunch meat and smokehouse

    Charlie’s County Market - Store front

    Store front

    Charlie’s County Market - Store front

    See all

    Store front

    Wagner Shell Food Mart - beer_and_wine - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...