I am not sure what happened to the people with these bad reviews. But, I am sure families occasionally have bad experiences at any school. Anyway, I asked around the Island like this poster had recommended, and I heard nothing but good things about Whidbey's Waldorf school. So, we went to visit and took a tour, sat in on classes, interacted with many students, teachers and administrators: verdict, a bunch of the kindest, most well-adjusted folks I've met , and they have to work long hours in a school all day, every day. I work with public school kids in after school programs, and they can't wait to get out of school. When I ask them "what did you do at school today" or "how was school today"...they always respond "I don't know, nothing" or just shrug. When I asked the Waldorf kids: each kid began excitedly spouting off what they made or learned about that day or were going to do the next day! I would have loved to attend a school like this! I read some of Steiner's philosophies, and through years of study, in brief, he believes that the child brain is not fully prepared to process reading and arithmetic until around 3rd or 4th grade. By forcing reading and complex math before this, is strictly memorization. Some kids will be good at it earlier, but for the majority, children's minds will not comprehend reading and arithmetic until 3rd or 4th grade, when most kids potential for absorb this material in a permanent and meaningful manner with somewhat level out. Remember always having to review a ton of math and English when you returned to elementary school in the fall each year? Well, anyway, I am not surprised many of these bad reviews on different sites are about how their 7, 8, and 9 years olds couldn't read or do math as well as kids in other schools, because it's not part of the Waldorf early education curriculum. AS for the sprituality, behind closed doors stuff.....Well, I can't honestly speak for that, but I do hope I can get my kids in to Whidbey Island Waldorf School for next year! It's seems like such a nurturing place. read more