Dave Racer showed up very shortly after my phone call with Erica. He is very personable,…read morerespectful, and thorough. He addressed my roof problem quickly and efficiently.

UPDATE: Feb 21, 2026 STILL NO ROOF * MORE DAMAGES …read more.. BEWARE SWFL and FL: #DoNotHire #RomanRoofingInc claims to be the best in the industry?? HELP TO EXPOSE A CORRUPT ROOFER IN A INDUSTRY WHERE NO ONE SPEAKS UP AND BAD CONTRACTORS ARE PROTECTED!! - Hired Nov 2024 - Tear off shingles/deck Jan 2025 - installed new decking 15/32" not 5/8" per FBC and contract - Failed Dry-in Feb 2025 - Installed 2 more layers of underlayment (3 total) w thousands of nails + partial metal roof. Screwed up the custom roof, took it off, reinstalled halfass. - Failed 2 Finals Apr /May 2025 - Failed for numerous reasons but also for going above and beyond the scope of their license. They are roofers not a GC or engineer. - there was alot of truss work done that went above and beyond the scope of their license. No GC or engineer was involved. - Collier required them to hire an engineer for all truss work. - Filed Collier County & DBPR Complaints, Insurance Claim due to excessive delays, dmgs, lack of response from ANYONE - owner Norman Dopfer failed to respond to emails and calls since Jan 2025 - underlayment 3x, new metal roof 2x, leaked every time - used subpar materials IE: cheap roofing nails on DTW underlayment which req 11g 1.5" and min 1" non-corrosive discs or reg nails - rusting on drip edge - 3 crew teams did inferior work all failed inspections - they failed to provide W9 records during the investigation for the crews working here. - the crew lead Esteban and Tony Supv were never here onsite - Mike Hetherington the Ops Mgr was a piece of work who was never onsite except once for a forced meeting due to failed inspection. - Mike Hetherington sent me a threatening email that he was not going to fix the leaking roof, and the half ass workmanship. If I did not allow him to continue the work as is, he was going to bring legal action against me. (That is the last thing you do is threaten me) - they made a few halfhazard attempts to make patches to fix some of the many issues but they failed to address the bigger issue. The wrong plywood was installed. - In Aug I was given Norman Dopfers tel # to contact by the County Investigator. Both the state and county had a very difficult time reaching him also. - Once I made contact we tried to work together but it became obvious that Norman did not want to follow the County requirements of hiring an engineer. He was trying to do the repairs how he wanted to ignore all of the truss damages they caused, cover up and move on. - He hired a GC Chris Heyer in Aug/Sept 2025 who agreed an engineer was not required - yet the damages are extensive as you can see in the pictures. In addition the 15/32" (12mm) plywood they installed was no longer 12mm, maybe 6-8 mm due to multiple layers torn off with the underlayment. See pictures. It still did not meet the 5/8" FBC requirements and what I paid for. There are thousands of holes, its split in many places, water, and not mold dmgd. - the 3 layers of underlayment and the metal roof came off in Aug 2025 - tearing off the sealed top layer of 15/32". They put another layer of underlayment halfass down, failed to fix the main issue again, it still leaks, never replaced decking to 5/8", dmgd at least 25+ trusses in process of fixing the 1/4"+ spacing btwn the boards instead of just tearing off the entire roof and replacing w 5/8" they used 15/32"! - Norman had a friend who owed him a favor per his text Michael Sheeley AIA write him a letter stating he came to my home, and inspected my roof on Oct 13, 2025. That false statement was signed by Michael Sheeley and submitted as fact to Collier County. It was a lie. Michael Sheeley was never to my home to inspect. I filed a complaint w the DBPR and the BOAID. - I in turn hired my own expert engineer to inspect my roof. He did a thorough job and completed a recommendation report based on his findings. The entire decking needed to be brought up to FBC code. There are extensive top truss damages caused by Roman Roofing that need to be repaired before moving forward. - When Norman rcvd the report instead of fixing the issues. He hired his Atty to contact me. - the roof mfg will no longer honor the lifetime warranty on the new metal roof laying on ground since Aug 2025 due to being strapped and exposed to elements, it should have been dry and pulled indoors. - I have dmg to gutters, soffits, facia, stucco, drywall (crews fell in 8x), fiberglass pool (Failed to tarp debris fell in), 4x storage units, 1 yr of delays costing my rebuild ++ - My house as it stands today is gutted, cannot do my rebuild due to no roof from Jan 2025 with now $100K+ damages to fix from Roman Roofing crews! - REFUSING TO FIX ALL DMGS

Kayla was very helpful in a referral for a gutter company as they only did gutters with a roof job…read moreat this location. Thanks Kayla. D.W.

Looking for only budgetary information and so it's difficult to get most roofing companies to…read morerespond. Shawn went well beyond and made sure I had my proposal in a timely manor.

Good communication. Decent/competitive pricing (I cannot say, "inexpensive", since everyone is high…read morelately). However, was willing to work with me to give me a decent price, all-in-one, to do the roof, plywood, soffit & facia so I knew what my total cost would be, rather than a cheaper price and getting hit with $xxx extra for plywood, $xxx extra for soffit/facia, etc. Time frame was relatively quick as well. Despite being out of Marco Island, the quote was actually the 2nd lowest (the first being a company that wouldn't include the "extras"). Theoretically, Mighty Fine Roofing is the lowest, but I cannot really compare exactly. The highest quote was about 75% more. Rusty was a pleasure to work with.

I gotta give this company a 5 star rating. I hired them for work on my roof and they did a…read morefantastic job. Their price is very fair and beat the other bids I had. Their son, Joseph, was the only company that inspected the attic to see if everything was in good repair. I strongly recommend to give this company a chance to work with you.

JGF is honest, reliable, easy to communicate with, and prices are reasonable. John replaced our…read moreroof, soffit, rain gutters, repaired garage ceiling and painted house. He and his team leave worksite clean and are trustworthy. We were so happy with his work in 2023, we have hired him to build an attached lanai this year. No need to shop around, JGF is the best we have found. Thank you for your honest, quality service.

I needed a new roof after Hurricane Ian. John actually answered his phone when most weren't! He…read moregave me a timely quote which was reasonable compared to others. He did the work when he said he would. He also answered my questions as they came up. I happened to be home when the final inspection was done. The city inspector said some of the materials were higher quality than normal!

This review is long overdue. Their customer service was horrible. After hurricane damage, we were…read morecautious and agreed on a set price in the contract--but the final bill was a few hundred dollars more. When we questioned it, the associate said, "It's Friday, I don't have time for this." Completely unprofessional and dismissive. Their mistake, yet we were treated like an inconvenience. Never again.

Nastar Roofing was contracted to replace the flat roof on our condo building. The project was…read moredelayed three separate times without any explanation. Their crew left debris and exposed areas of the roof during rain events, causing interior water damage to multiple units. Despite repeated attempts to address these issues, management failed to provide resolution or even return calls in a timely manner. Based on our experience, I cannot recommend Nastar Roofing to any property manager or HOA looking for professional, reliable service.

I had a roof leak where my screen room met the house. I recieved 4 estimates and 3 of them did not…read moreaddress the leak. They suggested flashing ideas that would require lots of shingle "shuffeling". Keith from Evans was the only one who suggested actually fixing the leak. At one third the prices I have received from the others. Without destroying my roof in the process. Great job. Leak fixed!

The price and job was excellent. Luis did amazing work and according my expectations.read more