Bravo, tonite show was incredibly funny and amazing as always. When you are in the area, you MUST go to Yellowstone Playhouse . If you are not in the area, what's your problem, come to Island Park Id and watch an incredibly fun show! I drive from California for this place! I'm going next week too!!! The food is so good, get the prime rib! The owner runs the show, is in the show, and is one of the funniest performers you can see..... 5+ stars read more

See all

The food was amazing. I was surprised that they could feed so many people so quickly *and* have it taste absolutely excellent. They have a remarkable system for getting a huge number of people fed efficiently in a short time. If you are looking for high-end sophisticated theater-- you are in the wrong place. If you want a good laugh (with some jabs at local culture) and good improv and singing talent you'll enjoy your evening. The building is very nice as are the facilities and the way the seating is arranged. Much more comfortable and new than some local/tourist-oriented theaters I've been to. Good family fun. read more

See all

Amazing gigantic tasty prime rib with rolls, corn, beans, salad! My prime rib was the largest prime rib I've ever had on my plate in my life and super tasty!! The show was hilarious and so much fun. The songs and singers were excellent, heartfelt and melodious harmonies. Loved the tribute to the military, veterans, and active duty! The finale celebrating the 250th Anniversary of Freedom was a wonderful ending. Kudos to the staff, chefs and the entire ensemble. Thank you for making our last night of our Yellowstone vacation so memorable. A toast to you for many more years of success at the Yellowstone Playhouse. read more

We saw zoomanji here and none of us really liked it. It honestly wasn't a good story and not funny at all. The mc was funny and that was the best part of the show, a little stand up. My husband and I actually disliked it and wished it would end so we could leave. and my kids (7, 10, 13) who are easily entertained didn't really enjoy it either. I will say that the food was pretty good and more than plenty of it. We got the prime rib. Which was good for prime rib. Problem is we don't really like prime rib. The sides were really good. And we ordered a chocolate moose and it was amazing. Our kids got Mac and it was good, although they would prefer Kraft (ha). The staff was also really great. Very friendly and helpful. We had heard that this place was really entertaining so we were disappointed. We are possibly willing to try it again with a different show since we visit our cabin every year. If we do, I will update. read more

First off, food was absolutely delicious! The prime rib dinner portion was huge and we had to take some home. It was amazing! The cast and crew were very easy to work with before the show started and the show was so funny we were laughing the entire time! Definitely recommend for families, kids, or even adults to come and enjoy Yellowstone Playhouse. read more

Good times, delicious food, great family fun. We have made it a tradition to come here the last 3 years. We love Island Park, West Yellowstone, and the Madison River. Now adding the Yellowstone Playhouse to the tradition. Great fun memories and we can't wait for next season. Thank you for the amazing prime rib portions! Don't change a thing. read more

See all

If you're going to be in or near Island Park, this is a MUST!! Y'all...my husband and I booked tickets last minute after a colleague told us we had to...and YES!! He wasn't wrong! It was a great way to end a long day at Yellowstone. First, let's talk about the dinner...hubby and I got the prime rib and it was delish!! Also on that plate was a baked potato, beans, corn, roll, and salad. Everything was good (and I'm a super picky eater). Definitely isn't run of the mill buffet food and is deserving of praise all its own. The whole dinner was worth writing home about - next time I'm going for the homemade Mac and cheese! Plenty of food!! Well worth the money! The show was delightfully funny and very family friendly (no vulgarity, cussing, or anything sexual whatsoever) How refreshing! We had the opportunity to sit next to a family with some younger ones and they enjoyed the show a lot. So much laughter from those two. But for me, the best, was the whole family vibe. The cast and crew - fantastic job! Not just acting but the service (yes, they serve dinner and bring out concessions during intermissions). Everyone was so nice from entrance to exit. And that verse of Happy Trails will leave even the grumpiest of humans smiling from ear to ear. Beautiful family, awesome operation! The only thing I didn't love...they need Venmo or something so patrons have options for tipping staff/actors. Until then, make sure you have cash because they deserve it. read more

Had a great time, so much fun. Great food and great people. The play was amazing, had us laughing the whole time.

Food was excellent and the variety show was a blast! Drew and his troupe are superb. We have been to Island Park 3 times and Hurricane,UT twice. Such fun clean entertainment. read more

Low expectations going in having attended similar places. The show we saw was Butter Knives out and had the prime rib dinner. Dinner was great! Huge slices of prime rib, good sides. Not a huge fan of plays or musicals so to say these guys entertained and impressed is a big understatement. I loved the MC wasn't PC!!! I loved the way he conducted, we all laughed so I think everyone did too. They are actually prepared for noisy kids and active in keeping your experience the best it can be. Their cry room is actually sound proofed with huge windows. Lots of cool references that kept everyone laughing, sit coms, movies, LDS. Very family friendly. Happy to support such professional actors. Also if you read this far FJB! Think these guys and all America feel this too. read more

Yellowstone Playhouse - Inside, very nice dining hall. - Dinner Theater Near Me - Island Park, Idaho

This show was great, we saw Butter Knives Out. It was kitchey and funny. The choreography and singing far exceeded my expectations. There were plenty of jokes built in. Some were Mormon jokes, I even got few as a non Mormon. I'm a very liberal person and felt very welcomed. Moving on to the food - it was better than expected as well. The prime rib serving was easily double the average serving size and super tender. The desert was a quaint surprise. Overall, it was super fun. The only thing to at was missing was a hint of fermentation in my lemonade. read more

We had a terrific time! The dull package with prime rib dinner is a winner! We loved the show. Staff was excellent.

Absolutely love this place! The show is always off the hook! The food and service is always amazing! A must see when you're in Island Park! These hard-working folks are such a blessing to all of us! Thank you all so much!!! read more

Yellowstone Playhouse - Dinner Theater Near Me - Island Park, Idaho

A fun, quirky, and charming production company with a complementary prime rib dinner. Family owned! Please come support the arts in Yellowstone! read more

This was a last minute fantastic decision to go to the playhouse while on vacation! We had an amazing time, laughed until I almost cried and had a wonderful meal! 10/10 excellent choice! The play, Idaho Jones II and the Johnny Sacks Secret was perfection! HIGHLY recommended!! Thanks, Donna read more

Yellowstone Playhouse - Dinner Theater Near Me - Island Park, Idaho

See all

This place is amazing! We have been back time and time again! The shows are funny! Drew does an amazing job!! If you ever question if it is worth the price... THE ANSWER IS YES!!! We keep coming back!! We already have tickets to our next show!! read more

I can't say enough great things about the playhouse! The food was excellent, our grandkids loved the Mac and cheese (there was enough for us to sample). The steaks were excellent as well as the sides. High point was the entertainment though! We saw the variety show and there were so many hilarious skits plus some great singing. Highly recommend making this a part of any trip to the Yellowstone area! read more

Great show! I haven't laughed that hard in a long time. Family friendly, the staff makes you feel like your watching you favorite crazy uncle doing a bit in your living room. Definitely a must see if you're in the area. read more

Short version: Highly recommended for a fun night out. The show: I love small community theatre & have acted & been involved in much of it, so I'm prejudiced towards it. Still, in all honesty, the acting, direction & production value were outstanding. The MC, who also acted & directed, was hilarious, blending local & national events effortlessly & humorously into the show & his stand up ad lib. If you've never been, you'll be pleasantly surprised at the high caliber entertainment up on the little stage. The food: We did the theatre only & skipped the meal so I'll leave that to someone who indulged. From the looks of it (school cafeteria style seating & tables, styrofoam vs. plates, pitchers of something to drink), we may have made the right call. Think "Sunday afternoon social" at a small, rural church. Because we didn't eat, we were seated right up front but extreme stage right, pretty much the front corner. Luckily, one of the very funny actors was seated there for much of the show so it was actually a perk for us. I'm sure it would have been a serious bummer if he or we had been seated stage left. read more

Yellowstone Playhouse - Hilarious! - Dinner Theater Near Me - Island Park, Idaho

Had a wonderful time. Food alone was worth admission. Everything was professionally done and the show was wholesome and thoroughly entertaining. Everyone there puts in an incredible amount of work and it is evident from the first minute you walk in. It is definitely worth a trip. You will have a great time. read more

I literally just drank so much lemonade. Food was really good. There's this guy with a sweet mustache. He was my favorite. read more

If your in Island Park this is a must see. People come from all over several times a year to see the different plays. The dinner theater has choice of chicken or prime rib. You would not really expect much from the food for a dinner theater. I was blown away by the Prime Rib. It was the best I have ever eaten. 6 others in our party said the same thing. They have a special rub they use and inject it into the meat as well. This makes the inside of the Prime Rib as good as the flavors in the outside. They use high quality meat and make it add tender as you will ever taste. The beans, corn bashed potato and rolls are the perfect side dish. They also serve a salad and cute little dessert. I watched a guy buy 8 cinnamon rolls, then come back to buy 4 more. They are amazing. As for as the food is the entertainment is even better. I was surprised to see the guy that served the Prime Rib be the star of the show. I am not sure I have ever laughed as hard as I did during the show. I have been to comedy clubs and comedians in many ships and this was funnier than any of them. The staff understands that your their guest and they are very accommodating and friendly. They go above and beyond any normal service for sure. You can just buy the show to enjoy on its own. I highly suggest doing the dinner theater for just a little more. Your not gonna get prime Rib if that quality and flavor anywhere for about 15 bucks more. I had read positive reviews but was blown away by the quality of the food and entertainment. If you have not been there you are truly missing out. Awesome experience in a beautiful setting. read more

Yellowstone Playhouse - Dinner Theater Near Me - Island Park, Idaho

See all

We opted for the prime rib dinner and a show and we were not disappointed!! Our original reservation was cancelled due to unavoidable events, they gave us many options including a refund or seeing a different show. Since we are in the area all summer we opted for another show, however, they put us on a waiting list should an opening come up. They fit us in to the show we originally booked and we couldn't have been happier. The food was delicious, they were extremely well organized and the play was hilarious!! We are just sad we only got to see one show! read more

If you miss this Playhouse you have truly missed something special at Yellowstone! This was a highlight of our trip and something the whole family enjoyed. The food was good, especially loved the rolls. The show was Mel Brooks level funny, while always family friendly. I was especially impressed with the quality of the singing. The owner's improvisational skills made sure there was never a dull moment. If I had one negative thing to say about the Playhouse I must have forgotten it while laughing. read more

If you're in town for Yellowstone, this is a must see, especially with kids. Ok so the food isn't great but it is good enough and you are subsidizing the awesome show put on by the actors. We saw the third run of the Princeless Bride, and it was hilarious. Probably even better if you are Mormon or from Utah or Idaho, as there are lots of BYU and LDS jokes in the show. But that's a small part, and the show kept the adults and the 5 year olds laughing throughout. read more

We went to this Dinner show on their opening weekend. Of course they was called Mack's Inn playhouse for years. This is just a new location and waaaay bigger & better. It's great for families or groups. I just went with my wife this trip and it was fun. The cast is seasoned and did a great job we went to see Pirates of the Caribbean and it was a great time. We wished we had brought more of our family but maybe next time we will we love supporting the arts & enjoy this kind of venue. The food is served buffet style and we had the Prime Rib is was excellent, I recommend that one with a lil horseradish it's awesome. When you first get there your salad is already on the table and their homemade ranch dressing is delicious! Then you also get a roll, Corn, baked beans & a baked potato, really a fine meal. The service is also excellent with the actors serving the food & drinks. They also had water or lemonade to drink. So YeH we will definitely be back again!! read more

See all

Good food + good humor = great night. We saw the variety show. It was funny with some great voices. Go for the food. Go for the entertainment. Go to support local arts. Just go! read more

THIS PLAYHOUSE is in ISLAND PARK and OH MY GOSH!!! This place is hilarious and the FOOD is delicious! We have lived in Idaho for 3 years and have seen 5 shows already! We typically camp nearby and go to a show one of the nights. Anyways, Prime Rib is the way to go, but the chicken looks good too. Intermission snacks are yummy - don't forget the cinnamon rolls. We buy them and eat them for breakfast the next day. These SPOOF shows are amazing - so funny with current references. During the Three Amigos at Del Taco Ranch, the lead was trying to get the other actors to break character by bringing in new jokes throughout the night. "My daughter Chalupa, she is so ugly" (how ugly is she?) Then he'd have a surprise punch line. It was hilarious! WE LOVE this place and hope they'll be around forever and ever! Go for your birthday or anniversary! You wont be disappointed! :D read more

What an incredible evening. The food and service was top notch. The show was entertaining. Wiuld recommend that anyone that visits the area make it a point to reserve a night at the playhouse. read more

the food was mediocre at best. we were packed into our seats like sardines and had to turn our chairs around to watch the show. the "show" was horribly written, unfunny, offensive, and just plain bad. it was racist, dragphobic, and transphobic and packed full of Mormon inside jokes and conservative viewpoints. do not go here if you like good food, good theater, or good people because you will find none of those things. read more

Enjoyed dinner and the show. This is a great way to support local families and the arts.

Absolutely the best! WhT a great group of performers! Meal was good chicken and prime rib. Lemonade was the best! One of the best evenings out in Island Park. We most certainly will return! read more

We have seen two shows so far this summer. Fabulous and fun! As Promised Great food and Big laughs. We have been seated in a place where I can sit my oxygen and walker. The people we meet are nice. The show we saw tonight was fun and thoughtful. 8.21.19. Another fab show tonight. Great food. We have had the prime rib the Mac and cheese and tonight the chicken. What did they do to that chicken!?!? Delicious!!!!! All. The shows this summer have been so fun!!!! read more

Yes. Just yes. If you haven't got to experience this... Go. Spend the money and go! Wonderful experience thanks to the serving staff also being the same people to put on the show. Food was phenomenal and the people were so kind! I'm not saying anymore because it's not mine to spoil! read more

Seriously the best part of summer in Island Park! Talent is amazing hospitality is 2nd to none!!! You will not be disappointed! Laugh til it hurts and then laugh when you get home talking about the shows. read more

This place rules for a super funny and entertaining night with all sort of fun current pop culture references thrown into the shows, as well as humor mocking the regional culture, all in good taste! I've been to Andrew Durant's shows for 7 or 8 years and all of them have been totally on point. Love the succulent prime rib dinner too! read more

Came on a girls trip with my mom and aunts. Enjoyed the dinner/comedy show. The food was good with large portions. The comedy show was funny and interactive. I will totally come back again. Good job!! read more

We were invited to the Yellowstone Playhouse for a work party and we had such a great time. The food was good and the entertainment was great. Looking forward to the next time we get to go. read more

We came for the show only. We got a slapstick comedy play AND a stand-up comedian all in one. Super fun night, highly recommend it!

Inconceivable how great our night was seeing The Princeles Bride! Clever writing, phenomenal acting, and tasty prime rib. We were visiting from Florida and thought this could be a tourist trap. This was not the case at all. So many locals. A great find. Belly laughs galore! read more