Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    You Had Me At Pizza

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed • 4:00 pm - 10:00 PM

    Order You Had Me At Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    You Had Me At Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - You Had Me At Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Amy N.
    192
    98
    370

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jonny L.
    429
    17
    3

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,942 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Flames On The Lake - Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice

    Flames On The Lake

    3.7(3 reviews)
    3.4 km

    This restaurant focuses on chicken dishes. They offer verious chicken flavours (like Peri Peri,…read moreButter, Lemon & Thyme) with sides, on a pizza, as a burger, etc. Of course, wings are sold also. The restaurant is located in the new Grimsby On The Lake neighbourhood, and they opened early Oct 2022. It is relatively small but does have indoor seating for about 20 people. The interior is minimalist and clean, with two large-screen TVs. The main colours were black and red in the seating area. I ordered the (A8) Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice. You could also choose naan instead of rice. The order was large. You get about twice as much food as you would in Toronto for that price point! The chicken is marinated for a whole day with their own recipe of herbs and spices. The taste was delicious, including the chicken meat inside. I highly recommend it. The half chicken and rice came on separate rectangular dishes. Both dishes were beautiful red, white, brown, and yellow colours! Unfortunately, the chicken was mostly covered, only exposing about 20% of the large half chicken. Perhaps more of the beautiful chicken could be exposed. I was allowed to photograph a half Peri Peri Chicken on its own. I was there on a Tue 8pm to 10pm. There was only one staff member, so he had to handle orders and cooking. It was manageable since there were (unfortunately) not too many customers at that time of weekday night. He was very passionate about the food served there. There are specials. I spotted an oddity among the specials: Fish & Chips ($14.99); it seems a little out of place! The restaurant is wheelchair accessible. There is one gender-neutral washroom, and it is also wheelchair accessible. There is free street parking. Review 2023-101

    Food was mediocre at best - reheated, microwaved and deep fried…read more no wonder why they look to be permanently closed.

    Photos
    Flames On The Lake - Seating are

    Seating are

    Flames On The Lake - Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice

    Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice

    Flames On The Lake - Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice

    See all

    Peri Peri Chicken (half) ($14.99) with rice

    Oggi Bistro - Rack of lamb 8 oz lobster tail

    Oggi Bistro

    2.7(10 reviews)
    0.9 km

    The food did not have a lot of flavor and we were really looking forward to rich Italian flavor. We…read morewere prepared for a leisurely dining experience based on other reviews but it took an hour to get our food. Our total dining experience was 1:45. Our waitress was awkward and seemed frazzled. Not sure if she was new or overloaded or perhaps both. We probably wouldn't go back. I gave a two rating based on the cool ambiance and my husband's opinion. The patio with a live musician was cute and enjoyable.

    Went for a birthday dinner, and the food itself was perfectly fine, but the service experience was…read moreso slow. To be fair, we did have a new server who was still in training, but the bigger slow down seemed to be coming from the kitchen and not from her. Though we did order an appetizer which came within about 25 minutes of us ordering it, the main course didn't come out for nearly 45 minutes after that. The pizza we got is an appetizer was delicious and we both really enjoyed having a little bit of that to eat before the main courses came out. This was a Groupon deal that came with a three course option so we got to choose from a limited selection of the menu, but it was a good value purchase for sure. I'd try them again and see if we just caught the kitchen on an off night as there were lots of other yummy sounding things on the menu. Also, the outdoor seating area had a very nice ambience to it, and the weather was perfect for dining outside.

    Photos
    Oggi Bistro
    Oggi Bistro - Tomahawk veal chop parmigiana with gnocchi

    Tomahawk veal chop parmigiana with gnocchi

    Oggi Bistro - Osso bucco/risotto

    See all

    Osso bucco/risotto

    You Had Me At Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...