I just had the most incredible experience with Your Pie Pizza. But before I get to that, I want to tell you about the first time I had their pizza. I was starving after a long day at work and was searching for a place that offered a personal sized pizza. I glanced at their reviews and menu- sold. I ordered the hot honey pizza and chocolate chip cookies. Delivery was quick and the food was delicious. Not a "I was starving and anything would have been good" kind of delicious- but insanely good. Fresh ingredients, perfect topping ratio, and cooked perfectly. The cookies were the icing on the cake. I was so impressed I called to tell the manager how amazing everything was. We ended up having a 10 minute conversation that left me feeling like a valued customer. I've ordered many times since then, including today. When I pulled up DoorDash and tried placing my usual order, it said they were closed. I called to double check and learned that their head cook had no showed to work. The 80 year old gentleman who owns Your Pie Pizza drove in from Shallot to get everything up and running. However, DoorDash had been disabled for the day- which meant no delivery. Instead of turning me away, he insisted I give him my order so he could deliver it himself. He reminded me so much of my grandfather. I knew declining his offer would have insulted his kindness. He was the sweetest man ever. We had a great conversation about customer service and commitment. And of course, he refused to let me pay. This will forever be one of my favorite places to eat. Thank you Maynard! I can't wait to check out your new restaurant, Sweet & Salty Grille. Wishing you nothing but the best! read more

Really enjoyed our early meal. Zias and great white pizza w caprese. Yum. A lot of food so we are raking it home. Service is excellent and he really cares about food. And he is nice. Go! read more

We were craving pizza and it was amazing! Wifey needed vegan options and they had them as well. We had our grandkids with us and they atr the whole pie! (Kid size of course). The gelato was awesome as well. Will definitely come back. read more

I was staying at a hotel in Wilmington with no vehicle so I decided to order from this pizza place that had good reviews. I ordered the pizza and a small salad and when the person delivered it, I realized the salad was not delivered. The delivery girl apologized and said "they said that this was all that I was supposed to take." OK, so that's fine. I'll contact DoorDash but then when I open the pizza I noticed it's not really what I ordered. I completely thought it was for a different person. It had bacon all over it, and I did not order anything with bacon, nor do I eat bacon. So I called the restaurant and I said I just wanted to verify that I didn't make a mistake in ordering this, and asked if this pizza automatically came with bacon on it? (Maybe I didn't catch that or misread it.) The person that answered the phone was so nice and apologetic however, the manager that was SCREAMING in the background was so angry, would not let me get a word in edgewise. He just kept screaming, "She'll have to call DoorDash! We haven't even gotten paid for this order!" I kept trying to talk through the young man that had answered the phone to say "I'm not asking for anything. I'm just trying to find out if this pizza automatically came with bacon and it wasn't listed that way on the app. May I speak??" then the manager started screaming, "I'll redo it for her, but she has to come get it!" I kept trying to tell the young man on the phone, "I don't have a vehicle. I cannot come get another one. I'm just trying to get my question answered, but he will not stop screaming in the background at me." The young man finally admitted yes it was their fault. They made it wrong. They shouldn't have put bacon on it and no, it does not normally come with bacon. He continued to start screaming again. "We haven't even gotten paid for this!" I finally had to hang up. I had already contacted DoorDash about the salad and so then I had to make another claim on the pizza because I can't eat that pizza not with the bacon on it. And it was crumbled up so I couldn't pick it off either. I did not want to run the risk of accidentally consuming the bacon. I tried getting the refund from DoorDash and they offered me less than what the order had cost. I had to reach out to help further and speak with someone and I explained to them to what happened and they gave me my money back finally. But the issue here is with that angry manager at this restaurant. Mistakes happen, I understand that, but I was just simply trying to ask a question. I wasn't placing any blame. I wanted to find out if I was the one that made the mistake. I'm not sure if he was the manager or the owner, but I will tell you it was on June 24 between 4 and 5pm. Horrible customer service. Do not recommend. read more

I heard that Hawaiian pizza was better with BBQ sauce instead of marinara, and thanks to Your Pie's many options, I was able to try it. Though I did not become a pineapple pizza convert, I'll gladly return to try something more in line with my usual tastes. Recommended! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Ham and pineapple pizza on whole wheat crust - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Me and my best friend went because it was the only place open on Christmas eve, but wow!!! I love the decorations and the whole mood of the place, employees were so nice! We got a pepperoni pizza and I was amazed at how good it was! Only bad thing was how thin and crunchy the crust was, other than that everything was perfect! I seriously recommend this place! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Elf on the shelf! - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

It's laughable how slow this place is. Still waiting for 2 pizza and 10wings and it's been over 20minutes. I think everyone working here is high On something cause they kept asking what we ordered and it's super strange. They made the wrong size pizzas haha idk what is happening here. read more

Horrible manager!!! Pizza was undercooked and soggy. Hardly any cheese on the cheese bread-no taste at all. Owner refused to give a refund-insisted on remaking it. Out $30 for nothing. Would never go back to this location. Manager seemed like a con. He gave another lady the same story about not being able to give a refund. So much for customer satisfaction! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Undercooked - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

I have not been here in many years and from my memories it was delicious.i dont know if they were having a bad day or what. But it was awful. The breadsticks with cheese had no flavor and they were hard. Thrown away. The pizza was a crisp that it was a cracker. It was so average. . read more

See all

not safe for gluten free people any more!! absolutely horrible and unsafe. They grabbed a GF pizza crust with dirty gloves and put it on the counter with all the gluten ingredients. Things went downhill from there. read more

Your Pie Pizza - They tried to make my gluten allergy pizza here. - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Only one person working during dinner time. He is extremely slow and stops to help online orders ahead of customers standing in line.

So I actually love eating from this place but today I don't think I will ever eat there so the man came he was little order that he messed up he put his hands on his nose put the pizza in the oven then did another customer pizza without any gloves just digging his hands in all the cheese and all the ingredients That's disgusted and your nails was dirty and then the other young man had gloves on so I don't think I can never eat from there again at least not from him because that don't make no sense read more

Not sure what was going on tonight. Employees were friendly, but didn't seem to retain information given to them. The website says they close at 10pm, the door says 9pm but they turned the open sign off at 8pm and when a woman walked in they said they were closed. Wings didn't seem cooked all the way, and the ranch was just weird...didn't even taste like ranch. Odd experience all around. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. Me and my family came in trying to order pizza and the guy up front kept ignoring us, he didn't know the answer to what was in ANY of the ingredients, my mom has a dairy allergy and he couldn't tell us if the pizza had cheese in it, finally he decided it didn't and my mom googled it and it in-fact had cheese, dairy and eggs. So we tried to order for 15 mins and he is standing there laughing and giggling and wasn't coherent with the words we were saying. We asked him if he was laughing at us and he said he was " Having a good time" And we all could guess what that means . We look over to our right and we notice the other guy working has his hands in the ingredients without gloves ! And we watched him make an entire pizza without using gloves the whole time . I was trying to be optimistic and wondered if it was his . Afterwards , I saw him bring the pizza to two elderly women sitting outside . I knew morally this was very wrong . So, I confronted him about it in which he responded VERY rudely and tried to tell me he "doesn't have to" .So, I notified the women ourside eating the pizza and they were also very uncomfortable with the fact he didn't use gloves and kept thanking me for telling them. So don't eat here unless you're ok with getting an unsanitary gross pizza. DON'T come here ! read more

I really do love this place. This is one of two places in town where you can get a real keto crust pizza NOT made with rice flour. My type 1 diabetes wife can eat their keto crust pizza all day and not spike. I think the regular crust is great, too. The people working here are super nice, just really helpful and professional. It's a cool space with gelato! Go check it out. We will definitely be back. It's family friendly, nice patio, great people. read more

Since this is a franchise, so owner operated not a company chain, I want to give Your Pie in Wilmington props for being my go to delivery treat! Either the kids pasta or pizza meal delivers tastiness at such a reasonable cost every time. At $8.74 each, both the pasta and pizza are made with quality ingredients in a good sized portion. I customized each to contain broccoli and plant based sausage this week. The Alfredo sauce on the perfectly cooked lemme pasta is just the right level of creamy-ness. The perfectly baked pizza is thin crust style and can be customized to have only vegan cheese on it. Each meal comes with a generous scoop of either vanilla Tahiti or Chocolate gelato too and a small drink. Both gelato options are great. For rainy day deliveries, I don't think you can go wrong with this choice. read more

See all

We are here for vacation and placed our order online. We picked our order and got back to our place and it was so undercooked. We tried to heat it up and eat it but it didn't have any flavor whatsoever and the dough was still very undercooked. We both ate only one piece and decided it was not edible so we called the restaurant. The first person we spoke to was nice and was apologetic for our experience but I guess she was unable to make any decisions as to how this would be handled and gave the phone to the 'manager'. When he got on the phone he was very passive aggressive and said the we checked the order when we picked it up and said it was fine , "what changed between then and now'". Yes, we did look at the pizza to make sure they were the correct as to what we ordered, but we didn't taste it or pick it up to make sure it was done all the way. We tired to explain that checking the order and tasting the food is not the same thing. He stated that he would make us a new pizza but the problem with that was we were about 20-25 min away and it was already 8:30pm. We really didn't want to drive an hour for a pizza we really didn't want anymore. We said we would bring him the pizza tomorrow so we could just get a refund but he stated we had to get the refund on the same day as the purchase. Then he said he would refund us but he would have to give us money out of his own pocket tomorrow and he would do whatever it took to make it right. Then he said we need to take multiple pictures of the pizza we didn't eat to prove to him we didn't eat it. We expressed our confusion to the whole situation and how it was being handled. He ultimately stuck to this resolution and we didn't get a refund. We plan on contacting corporate to inform them of our very negative experience. We will never visit here again. read more

Your Pie Pizza - CHEESE STICKS - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

The food and drinks are good. Atmosphere is par for the course for a pizza joint which suits clients just fine. Two employees are very nice, and one is extremely rude which ruined my last experience there. I won't be patronizing them again. read more

TOTAL: $26.82 - 10" Pepperoni Pizza - 10" BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (lasted me two meals) ‍SERVICE: Very kind and friendly folks! I placed my order online and when I came in to pick up, they had the pizzas in a warmer to make sure they were fresh! FOOD: Both pizzas were good! The ranch that came with the BBQ chicken pizza was really nice! Not the best pizza I've ever had, but a solid option and all the customization you could want, especially if you want just an individual portion rather than a big pizza. TRAVEL: ~16 mins. Pizza was still nice and hot when I made it home! No big grease spots seeping through the box either. Your Pie would make a great lunch option! Get (more than) a slice! read more

Your Pie Pizza - BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

Got four pizzas to try. All delivery thanks to this coronavirus crap. The Ischia - Margarita The Nat - basil, feta, chicken, spinach, etc The Lineage - Supreme Build my own - meat I'm not sure what is up with the names but I do appreciate the variety of pizzas and the fact you can pick your own toppings. The pizzas are only 10 inches. Now 10 inches may be a respectable size for other things, but it is small for a pizza. Basically individual serving size. Taste was good. It's a decent pizza. They have other items on the menu as well. read more

See all

This has become a favorite for my boyfriend and me. We love the wings, pizza, and cheesy bread. You really can't go wrong with anything. The service is always friendly and they go above and beyond. I cannot say enough good things about this place. 10/10 should try it. read more

Bomb pizza. Got our order wrong when we did delivery. Were bummed to recieve one of our pizzas as a plain cheese pizza instead of a pizza with sausage and peppers and pepperoni. Everything else was amazing. The one with cheese was really gross so we didn't end up eating it and in total spent almost the same amount we did on the pizzas on delivery fees and tip, so this was really annoying but everyone makes mistakes. Other pizzas were bombbbbbbb!!!! read more

Amazing! Try the gelato too! Great food, friendly service and convenient location. We love eating here! read more

This is my first time to this outlet, parking at this strip mall was easy, loads of spots to choose from. Upon entering the restaurant, there was no line and I wish Pete it by the staff behind the counter. on this day, there was a one topping special for $4. But I decided to go with a drink and a salad for a total of $13. Your pie is a personal Pizza joint where you pay 1 price and you get to pick any number of toppings on your little personal Pizza. I selected maybe about 7 toppings, I expected my crust to be soggy when it came to my surprise my crust was crispy and my pizza was very well done. As I was stuffing my face with a pizza, I saw a another table enjoying that pizza which was a smaller size than mine. I asked a staff and was told that it was a kids size pizza. Adults are welcome to order the kids pizza. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Surprisingly crispy crust despite the many toppings - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

your pie pizza is probably the best make your own pizza spot in Wilmington, North Carolina I ordered a barbecue chicken, bacon ranch, and it was amazing super crispy super flavorful. I mentioned to the cook it was better than blaze pizza by a huge margin and the customer service was absolutely amazing he gave me a free sample of the ice cream to try out and the place even has Uno for you to play at the tables i would say its amazing spot for a family night out or a cool date night.. read more

A fried recommended this place as I am from out of town. He said it was the best pizza ever. I am a pizza snob having had real NY pizza and been to Italy. I was looking for Keto pizza. The staff was soooo nice and fun! Really cares about my experience as a newbie. You can pick your topping which I loved. The keto crust was not bad. I love pizza so real crust is a tough replacement but it was good. I loved the toppings. Overall amazing! I will go back read more

For dinner one night I was craving pizza. I had seen a special happening at Your Pie for a truffle pizza with roasted red peppers and mushrooms that I just had to try. I called in my order so I could quickly go grab it. When I arrived at Your Pie, I gave them a call, and they promptly brought it out to my car. I ordered the deeeeelicious truffle pizza and one of my go-tos- the meatball pasta that has a ton of cheese in it. My orders were both hot and ready to go so by the time I got home, they were the perfect temperature to eat. Highly recommend Your Pie for tasty treats! read more

The best pizza we've had since moving to Wilmington. The crust was nice a crispy with a touch of chew. Had the hot honey pizza and the flavor was fantastic! Warning as with any jalapeño temperature varies and this one was hot AF but delicious. Definitely going back. If we get two in a row like this changing the review to 5 stars read more

Average at best, nothing special.That is a scoop, wow! This is the worlds smallest s pop of ice cream ever. But whatever! read more

Your Pie Pizza - That's a scoop? - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Hands down the worst first experiences at a restaurant in the Wilmington area. The restaurant was almost empty but still waited several minutes for someone to show up at the register to pick up a carry out order. Someone who saw me walk in, who turned out to be the manager, finally got up from their chair in the corner to finish packing our order. We ordered a supreme with extra mushrooms and onions and a great white with chicken, mushrooms and jalapeños. When we got home our pizza was already cold and neither pie was made as we requested. No additional toppings were added to the great white nor were extras added to the supreme. We were told by the manager that the ticket that printed in the kitchen had no edits or extras however the emailed receipt we received had all the extras that we requested. After calling the manager on duty to provide feedback on our experience he got loud and extremely rude, said that the website is not operated by the company and that it contains wrong information but that they are not responsible for any errors caused by the website, he said that there wasn't anything they could do, so I'm stuck with food I did not order and out more than $50. The website also charges an automatic tip, which the person I spoke to does not deserve. If we could give them a 0 we would. Please save your time and money and go somewhere else. read more

See all

First time I came here it was amazing. 2nd time I came here not so much. We came it at 7:45 and they told us they were closing in 15 minutes and we wouldn't be able to eat inside. Even though they advertise everywhere that they are open until 9pm. Had to ask them to speak up so many time because they talked so quietly. One of the girls didn't know how to make a sandwich that was on the menu me how do you work here and not get trained on how to make what you are serving. I loved this place a week ago but now that I've had this kinda experience I just don't think I'll be coming back. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Says they are open until 9 but they arnt I guess - American Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

This place is horrible. The customer service was worst than the case of diarrhea and bubble guts that both my boyfriend and I received literally while eating this disgusting overpriced and small portioned meal options. I completed a survey and shared the same story I'm sharing now that the food tasted good, like it tasted ok but it gave us the sh$$'s. That's a fact. I was contacted and it was pretended that I would get my full refund in the efforts of making the exchange fair. The lady and owner Jada O'Malley continues to lie about an $40.29 refund. On the follow up for my refund the first time she claimed that she thought the issue was handle... yeah it was be you were the one handling it and didn't. instead you lied! Now I have email proof and will share it to show how much of a liar you are! read more

Now! I absolutely love this locations crustless pizza options and the new Hot Honey (when they remember to put it on, BC they charge you for it) but today I was sad because over the weekend I received a flyer for a new product and come in today not too hungry but wanted to try it! Standing in line I asked for the kicken pepperoni sticks and was told they do t make them here, I was disappointed. So I ordered the regular breadsticks instead. Hopefully! Today was really busy! So I think I'll stick to my earlier lunch time when it's not so insane and staff isn't so rushed and kinder! But I hope you get all the items you send your mail out flyers for! read more

See all

I went here last night with my girlfriend for doordash around 15 minutes before closing and the two people who were working were Paul and Charles, they were both SUPER friendly and amazing people and they made me feel super welcome and honestly they made for such an amazing environment and atmosphere and vibe, sense it was close to closing they even gave me a free small pizza because why not and sense I was doordashing it was a very nice snack to have for the road, I recommend this place very much and thanks again Paul and Charles for making this place a great and fun restaurant to dine-in :) read more

Update your hours and stick to them! We called ahead to double check when you close before coming and we're told that you closed @8:30. Arrive @7:58 and we are told you close in two minutes, but offered to put pizzas in boxes to go.... Okay, fine. 30 seconds later as we are deciding what to order... Sorry guys we can't do that we are closing. WTH! This not the first time either. read more

Drive out of your way to get a personalized pizza like none other in Wilmington! Great service, outstanding selection and always fresh ingredients! Our family loves Your Pie!! read more

Our pizza was cold by the time it got to us and ome is undercooked while the other is burnt on the crusts. There was 1 pepperoni on each slice of pizza . WAY overpriced for the small pizza we received especially since it wasn't good and we couldn't even eat it. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY. read more

If you ever want really good pizza quick, stop by Your Pie. They are brand new to the Wilmington area. The restaurant is really nice and clean. They have lots of pizza toppings to choose from or you can just order a signature pie. The pizzas are cooked in a gas pizza oven and they come out with perfectly cooked crust. You can also have whole wheat crust if you like. Seems to be a great place to bring kids too. read more

See all

Great atmosphere, great food! I have always found staff and owners to be accommodating-always trying to give a great experience. Very clean restaurant. I love the pizza-but recently started enjoying their salads. It's a must! read more

Wow! Your pie is so so so delicious! The fact they serve whole wheat crust is the only reason I tried this place and I will never get pizza anywhere else ever again! This pizza is out of this world! Chose your crust, base and cheese And toppings! The fact they have gelato and wine DEFINITELY IS A PLUS! Oh and good beer!! Very healthy eat! I come here before oR after the gym and always wish I could have like 5 more pizzas! But the main reason I'm writing this review is because their customer service! They are always the sweetest nicest staff! Extremely polite and attentive Coming by to check on the food offering to take trash and get refills!! Way to go guys! Very clean atmosphere also! Like white glove clean! read more