We were at Libby McNeill's for dinner and a table across the way was having a small cake. First we heard a guy talking about where he got it. It looked delicious. So 8 AM on Saturday we're there picking up goodies for home. There were a lot of cakes already made. I went for a variety of 6 cupcakes. I'm saving a granola bar. I got a most unusual blue cake ball. I enjoyed a blueberry muffin this morning. There was nothing small about the muffin and cupcakes. Delicious as well. I didn't even realize they're located just a block from my favorite Mojo's Cajun cafe. read more

We love this place! Cupcakes, cannolis, candy, you name it. Everything we've tried has been great. They have an awesome sitting area and appreciate that they're open later than most bakeries. Just ordered an apple pie for my husband's birthday too! read more

2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery & Bakeshop - So many cupcake options - Cupcakes Near Me - Marshfield, Wisconsin

See all

Great bakery. Super duper nice people. I absolutely love the ambiance. Will be back

The cupcakes are AMAZING!!! They're beautiful and delicious!!! The frosting is so wonderful and not so cloyingly sweet that they overpower the cake!!!! read more

These cupcakes were tremendous! I would highly recommend this Bakeshop, from the variety (including gluten free) to the willingness to accommodate taste, this place is a gem. read more

I've tried this place 3 times. It's disappointing every single time. This time I got the pecan cinnamon roll. It was so dry. (Like 3 days old dry?) not stored properly dry?) It's more like a cinnamon flavored cake. Also wondering why it weighs a ton and a half. All the butter and still dry? read more

I have come here a few times and each time it has been a treat ;) I never noticed the little coffee lounge which was very delightful. Came here with my wife, her parents, sister and her 3 nieces, were met with very friendly service and was willing to answer any questions. Prices are very modest as well. We got the chocolate toffee, awesome. strawberry cheesecake, amazing. And the buccaneer ball was heavy but still very very good. Will come back again! read more

we just had the best cheesecake I've ever eaten! My husband wanted it for his Birthday yesterday.We happened to be in Marshfield and will make road trip just for this bakery.Today was pie day but next time! I Wish Phillips had this bakery! Thank you so much! read more

I recently took a trip to 2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery and Bake Shop, this was quite the trip for me considering I live 15 hours away. Overall, the experience was splendid. The atmosphere was lovely. The cupcakes get a 4 star because of a 8.4 rating on the density scale. I ordered a cake for the journey back home and zoo wee mama, boy was it scrumdittallyicious. In my book the frosting earns a 96/100 because of the smooth yet creamy consistency. I plan on returning with my fry in the summer time. Thank you for the wonderful experience. read more

2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery & Bakeshop - loved the cake! - Cupcakes Near Me - Marshfield, Wisconsin

Just when I think the cupcake fad has run its course, I come across another cupcake shop that counters that belief. 2 1/2 Cups is a cute store on the main street. It's bright, airy, and has summer/beach theme. As I walked in, there were a couple of things I noticed almost right away: it's a place made for sitting down and lingering over a sweet treat and they have more than just cupcakes. The second is probably the thing that might make this a longer-term venture than a cupcake only shop. The cupcakes themselves are standard, but the frosting is not overly sweet and doesn't overpower the cake itself. I don't know if that was particular to the flavor I tried: the sweet/salty with a pretzel for decoration on top, or if it's true to all kinds. The pretzel, though, was the only salty part. It made for a nice balance against the frosting. The cake is otherwise standard, tending toward "meh", but not unpalatable. It balances the frosting nicely. On the other hand, the raspberry cream cheese muffin was a great alternative, and I almost preferred it to the cupcake. There are different cupcake flavors every day and some of them sound good. It's nice to have a place like this available as a change from the typical coffee shop or cafe. For anyone wanting something different to take to the office, this works. I'm pretty sure you'd be a hit at work if this were a regular choice. It was quiet on the two mornings I came in, so timing must be important to getting the best selection. read more

See all

This place is darling and take pride in their establishment and care for their customers! They went above and beyond to help me out to make my sisters birthday so special! Thank you ladies! read more

See all

The gluten free cupcakes are awesome! I can see spending $2.95 for one But a bit pricey for regular cupcakes read more

2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery & Bakeshop - Fudge Sunday gluten free - Cupcakes Near Me - Marshfield, Wisconsin

See all

Amazing service and staff. Our cake exceeded my every expectation. Beautiful workmanship with the buttercream and fondant colors and decor. Complete work of art! The cake itself was tasty and super moist. read more

2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery & Bakeshop - Blown away by their work!! Took our concept and made it into everything and more. Not to mention it was supremely moist and delicious!! - Cupcakes Near Me - Marshfield, Wisconsin

See all

Oh these vanilla cupcakes were amazingly delicious fresh. I surprised my husband with 12 he loved them ate 2 right away! They were on time delivering these and called ahead to make sure we're home very professional. I can't wait to order chocolate next time! I highly recommend trying them. read more

I walked in and two guests weren't wearing masks. They both then walked into the kitchen (without masks), an employee walked of the kitchen (without a mask), but then put one on when she saw me. It's incredibly disappointing to see local businesses not taking the pandemic seriously, especially when it is peaking and straining our local healthcare system. It is very unlikely that I will be back. read more

The inside of the shop is adorable. I could not decide what to order, so i got a cupcake and some seasoned pretzels for my hubby. I dont even really like pretzels but these were so good! i munched on them while i was waiting for hubby. The cupcake is also delicious! The girl behind the counter was great. read more

I only wish I could give them zero stars. Overpriced and unprofessional. The cake I got was moldy. Wouldn't recommend anyone eating their food. read more

Absolute must stop for us on our way back to our parents place. The muffins are unbeatable, huge and delicious. Haven't found something we've disliked yet! read more

This was a great discovery in Marshfield! A colorful, fun bakery with cupcakes, cinnamon rolls, cookies, cake pops, mousse, cheesecake, and a nice selection of keurig coffee. My husband got a slice of turtle cheesecake and was slightly disappointed in it. It cost about $3.50. The cupcakes and cinnamon roll were amazing! Large in size and very flavorful. We tried the chocolate Bavarian and Mississippi mud. The cupcakes were $2.95 a piece, but if you bought six or more they went down to $2.50 a piece. read more

2 1/2 Cups Cupcakery & Bakeshop - Chocolate Bavarian Cupcake. - Cupcakes Near Me - Marshfield, Wisconsin