The Amish Farmhouse Tour Company in Lititz referred this place to us. The donuts are amazing. My favorite was their Apple Raisin Critter. Their popular item is called long shots which was very good. Inside looks and smells like a bakery. read more

Achenbach's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

This bakery was referred to us by The Amish Farmhouse Tour Company in Lititz Lancaster. Wow what authentic donuts and their star item is called 'long shots' was very good. But our star item was their Apple Raisin critter. The inside ambiance was you donut shop look, feel and smell. read more

See all

3 long John's, yummy Cinnamon buns and while we did not try other items the crowd all had positive things to say. Opens early.

The chocolate eclair is absolutely amazing! I stop every time I'm in town to get mine. The service is friendly and it's an old school bakery. read more

They have a variety of baked goods. I wanted a "whoopie pie", got traditional chocolate vanilla cream and a peanut butter cookie and cream. I took a picture of the powder cream doughnut i also purchased.. Delicious! read more

Achenbach's Pastry - This is their powder custard fill. It is fresh and delicious.. IService was great. Friendly and helpful. - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

Most delicious cookies and pastries plus excellent informative staff. The "Home of the Long John." Don't miss the Moravian Buns, Fastnachts, and molasses cookies. Staff could not be more friendly and helpful. read more

Maybe I came at a wrong time? It was an hour or so before closing. A custard filled donut and a chocolate cupcake, I felt - were a tad stale. The the custard was oozy plentiful, the donut's interior was kinda crusty and the chocolate cake portion of my cupcake, was crumbly and not very chocolatey. read more

Had to stop in for some fresh Long John's before I left Lancaster. It's a local favorite and highly recommended. They have a huge selection of pastries. Just wish they had gluten free options. read more

See all

Best long johns in Lancaster and most likely the world :) check out their weekly donut flavors for some great selections. read more

Achenbach's Pastry - Cream filled long John with Peanut butter icing - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

See all

Achenbach's is a Lancaster County staple! And open during COVID (with modified hours). Cakes, muffins, pastries...there's something for everyone. Long john's - so simple, yet so good. The caramel brownies were dangerously addictive. read more

Achenbach's Pastry - Chocolate & PB - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

See all

Update: We had the best experience getting out son's first birthday cake here. Everyone was blown away by how incredible it was. They also know my son by name and always give him a donut hole when stop in. We love this place so much! read more

Achenbach's Pastry - a cake with a teddy bear on it - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

Yes please! This is a wonderful little Dutch bakery along the side of the road. If you aren't paying attention, you will drive right but it....and then you will be sad. We got a dozen donuts here yesterday day and it was hard given that their pies looked amazing! I might have to come back for dessert. The long Johns are nice and simple unlike other bakeries. They aren't this gargantuan cream filled mess...they are a manageable size. I would say my favorite out of everything was the biscotti! Firm but not tooth breaking, and not overly sweet! read more

If in the New Holland, PA area, you must stop at Achenbachs! They specialize in the long john, but I've yet to have a pastry is didn't enjoy. Three helpful hints: First, get there earlier in the morning. If you don't, they tend to run out of a lot of items due to their popularity. Second, it gets busy and parking is very limited. You may have to park alongside the road and walk. Finally, be patient. The inside is not large and you may need to wait in line to get in during the busiest of times. Understand, though, that places that busy equates to quality and customer satisfaction! They're great! read more

See all

Their donuts are crazy good!!! Especially the long Johns with Vanilla icing is the best. Everything that they make is so yummy! read more

We've been getting long johns from Achenbachs since I was a kid. I introduced my boyfriend to their donuts, and he's a huge fan. I decided to get a long john cake for him for his birthday. I had never ordered a long john cake, so I didn't know what to expect. All I told them was to make it fishing themed, and they exceeded my expectations! It was very well decorated, delicious, and very reasonably priced. read more

Achenbach's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

I've never been to the shop so my review is just for the treats. I came to the area from Philly for my cousin's wedding. The wedding cake was made out of long johns. I've never had one before but I will definitely be sure to get one when I'm in the area again! They were so good. I had a chocolate one and my fiance had a vanilla one. Both were equally as good. We also took home some whoopie pies (red velvet and chocolate). I had my red velvet whoopie pie after breakfast and it was delicious. I was only planning on eating half because they are big and full of cream, but the cream wasn't overly sweet for my taste so I finished the whole thing. I'm kind of sad because I don't have anymore but I hope to be back in the area soon to visit family so I hope I can stop in and try some more treats! read more

See all

Very good donuts "long John's" at an awesome price. Their options lack a refined look you might expect from a 21st century bakery, but the flavors are wonderful and will remind you of "grandmas baking". If you want a tasty pie, a box of donuts, or a loaf of bread... give Achenbach's a try! read more

RUDE, RUDE, RUDE!!!! The baked goods aren't nearly good enough to compensate for the attitude we just encountered. We asked for a simple row of their long john donuts and the response we got was just uncalled for. We are from out of town and come here each time we travel to PA but this will be the last time. read more

I get it they've been around for a long time and one of the generational businesses - but honestly their donuts taste like they are made and frozen and taken out thawed and frosted... cannot for the life of me see the appeal... read more

One of my family's favorite bakeries for 3 generations. However, I have to take a star off for an emerging trend of inconsistency. Over the past 9 months or so we've all noticed that the quality, flavor, size, etc of their pastries has started to vary a lot. One day everything will be fine. The next week a certain doughnut will taste like only half the flavoring was added. 2 weeks later that doughnut tastes great again, but another one is half the size it's always been. Following week all is back to normal, but the chocolate long John frosting tastes weak and slightly like peanut butter. Then, magically everything is perfect and the same as 20 years ago. Nothing earth shattering, but a little disappointing from a bakery we've been loyal to for as long as we can remember. read more

Best long johns and Moravian buns in town. We live in Lititz and drive out this way just for their pastries. They're always so kind and have a lot of patience with my 5 year old who has a hard time deciding which donut he wants. I recommend them to all our friends/family who visit Lancaster. read more

While I only had a chance to buy and taster their donuts everything else looked good. I was very happy with the donuts that did buy. Also the people working there were friendly. Next visit to the area and I will try more of their baked goods. read more

we absolutely love all of Achenbach's delicious bakery items. so glad we live close. the iced raisin vanilla ring and long johns are the best around. we highly recommend their products and excellent service. Robin and Steve Enedy Millersville, PA read more

Excellent, inviting, inclusive, and charming service, who show not only great love for the food they make but for the community they're in. Long johns are delicious, especially the peanut butter ones, though I suggest trying them all! read more

If you know, you know!!! The Long John's are out of this world!!! Peanut butter is my fave and never a disappointment!! Great customer service with delicious baked goods.... Always a staple when I'm in town. read more

Mediocre at best. Giant has better donuts and pastries. I don't see what is so good about this place imo

I've been coming here for long John's since I was a little kid. Now I live over an hour away, but still make the drive from time to time. Despite other reviews, I appreciate that they have their beliefs front and center in their store: It lets me and others know that I am safe there. read more

Achenbach's Pastry has been around since '54 and offers baked goods made from scratch. They have their famous Long Johns, breads, pies, and cakes. The hubs and I stopped by while in the area and picked up some of their famous Long Johns. Three flavors were available: vanilla, chocolate, and peanut butter - we got one of each! The vanilla one was the best, as the doughnut itself was fluffy and fresh, and the vanilla frosting was nice and creamy and not too overwhelming. The chocolate one had a nice cocoa powder taste to it, but the bread itself was stale. The peanut butter one was the least favorite out of the three, as the bread was also stale and the frosting didn't really taste strongly of peanut butter. I highly recommend in stopping by early in the morning to get their fresh batch, as that makes all the difference. Supposedly they run out closer to the 1PM mark. They also have cute little stuffed 'Long Johns' to purchase as a souvenir. Limited parking in their private lot. +vanilla Long John +visit earlier in the morning +bakery tour available +stuffed Long Johns sold for souvenirs +limited spots in free lot read more

See all

I haven't been to their store, but I picked up some of their baked goods during a recent stop at Javateas in Ephrata. We had a chocolate cake slice with icing, and a sandwich cookie. The cake slice was good, but the cookie was great! The cookies had pieces of peanut in them and the middle was peanut butter frosting/icing. Very good and I would absolutely get it again! read more

A classic bakery in Lancaster County, really nice selection, known for their Long Johns

My best friend took me here, to share a piece of her childhood with me. I live by the ocean in NJ. I bought a few things per her recommendation: long Johns, strawberry lemon danishes, and chocolate cream filled donuts! The danishes were absolutely delicious, the long Johns were so huge and definitely a share item. So yummy! The cream is sugary but delicioussss! read more

See all

Three Words: Peanut Butter Longjohns! This place is amazing! And well worth a drive from ANYWHERE! I got a baker's dozen of their fresh doughnuts, including both the chocolate and peanut butter longjohns. Both were amazing, but the peanut butter longjohns are to die for! Their homemade custard is fluffy and light, which makes for an incredible mouthfeel. Finally, the Pecan Sticky Buns are AMAZING! My mother, who spent a fair amount of time in the area as a child, was ecstatic! She said they were exactly like the ones she used to have as a kid! The prices are reasonable and the baked goods sublime! What more can you ask for?! read more

Achenbach's Pastry - These donuts were incredible. Three words to live by: Peanut Butter Longjohn! Just sayin'.... - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

Beautiful and delicious cake for my dad's birthday. So moist and affordable. My whole family loved it. read more

Achenbach's Pastry - Amazing - Bakeries Near Me - Leola, Pennsylvania

I'm not sure what happened but their quality went south. I ordered a long John birthday cake and was expecting quality decorations and delicious fresh baked long johns just like I got here many times in the past. Instead I got a cake with very poor quality decorations and very dry day-old donuts. Of course not discounted for the very poor quality. So very disappointed and quite frankly embarrassed to serve it for his party. Please don't let this place go downhill. This was always a no-brainer for good quality baked goods. I'd definitely be wary of ordering something special again from here. read more

I tried the chocolate long john today and was not disappointed. If I was closer, I would visit them every week. Love this place!

I'm giving this review/rating based mostly off the few items I have tried. Once I have tried more, I may update my review. The longjohns are what keep me coming back! They are so good, that I find myself leaving the house 5 mins early for work just so I can stop and get one - or two. The frosting isn't sickening sweet, it's creamy and perfect. The donut itself is airy and not dense, which means it's a winner in my book. They offer a great deal where if you buy a dozen, they throw in one donut of your choosing for free. This is great incentive for me to bring in donuts for my coworkers as well. Here is where I knock off a star. I have tried a couple of their other pastries as well, and haven't been as nearly impressed as I am with their longjohns. Their cannoli was rather disappointing. I may be more unforgiving since I'm Italian and have had my fair share of amazing cannolis, but the one I tried here was just not right. Also, the pie I tried was rather bland in flavor and nothing to write home about. I will be back to try more of the variety of pastries that you have to offer. I would like to try some of the cakes soon, so hopefully I can update my review. read more

We love Achenbach's. Their long johns are the best. Always get a Long John cake for our son's birthday.

The place has product to die for! However, don't eat in the restaurant, or you'll find a place to Die in. The place is seriously, and I mean seriously unable to keep good management (in the restaurant, I'm talking about). The pastry is probably the best in the area! I can'tSay anything better about the pastry, but I probably could about the restaurant. Good luck, and God be with you. read more

Very disappointing experience. Ordered our wedding cake here and it was totally a disappointment... it was so dry our guests were throwing it away and neither were our instructions for the layers followed. I'm a professional baker so I know what quality is. I called expecting an apology and compensation because that's how I would respond but instead they accused us of lying and offered to send us 25 dollars which I found very insulting. They've lost our business, not from product quality because things happen sometimes, but because of their attitude and customer service. I won't be recommending them to anyone. read more

Always a great spot for fresh treats! My son is a huge fan of the gingerbread cookies during Christmas, and we love picking up garlic bread for a great dinner addition. The vanilla crumb or maple long johns are the best! read more