I moved to New Bern from New Jersey four years ago, and I'm so grateful to have found this little…read morepiece of home away from home. The pizza is exceptionally good, the garlic knots are delicious, and the mozzarella sticks are honestly some of the best fried cheese I've ever had. Don't sleep on their subs or salads either! I've had the Italian sub and the steak and cheese salad with oil and vinegar as the dressing--both are absolutely spot-on every time. There are a few tables available for dine-in, and if you live in River Bend (the neighborhood it's located in), they offer delivery right to your door. Ordering for pickup is also super easy and convenient.

On the road again & kept hearing about these homemade Mozzarella Cheese Stix from this local…read morepizzeria...so I had to try it out! Yes, if you are in The New Bern area and have a craving for Pizza - This is the SPOT! 1st they told me it would be about 40 min & they showed up w/in 25-30min!!! The Mozz Stix are amazing (see pics). You can order a 3 or 6 piece & comes w/ pizza sauce for dipping. Also ordered a slice of cheese just to check out their sauce & style - great thin crust w/ flavorful sauce & extremely large slices for $2.95. Finally had to check out the Stromboli. Ordered the Steak & Cheese and it did not disappoint. Overall this spot is a local hidden gem w/ homemade flavorful items at a great price range. Definitely worth a try if you are in the area!

Absolutely love when we come into town, we have dinner at Abruzzo's Pizza! This time we ordered…read morePepperoni, black olives and 1/2 mushroom. Excellent Pizza!!! Wonderful team in getting the orders filled and served piping hot! Yummy! We are leaving with a half of pizza for a late night snack!!

I was told this was the best pizza in Jacksonville, but I have to disagree. It was mediocre at…read morebest. There was nothing really special about the pizza. I took it to go, so I didn't eat in the restaurant. I cannot comment on service or ambience.

Thank you to Sugar Hill Pizzeria for hooking us up with a free pizza after a long night working a…read moregas leak outside the pizzeria. The guys from Wright Traffic of NC appreciate you greatly. The pizza is great and the staff are friendly.

Really tasty food! Quick service and friendly staff too! Will definitely be back if I come to this…read morearea again!

Highly recommend! We are in town from the DC area and were super impressed with the freshness and…read moreflavor of the pizza. Also love the fact that they have vegan cheese for our vegan daughter. Ordering online could not have been easier and we all appreciated the infinite customizable options. We are a picky bunch and they got everything perfect and delivered so quickly. This place is a win!

I am beyond angry. We came here straight from the beach because a local gluten free group would not…read morestop raving about this place. As the mother of a gluten free toddler, and gluten free myself, I trusted that recommendation completely. I will never make that mistake again. Walking in, the place was flat out disgusting. A trash can shoved directly under the soda machine, jammed against a booth, flies swarming around it like nobody had cleaned in days. FLIES. Next to the soda machine. The only open table and booths were dirty. Like, more than crumbs. We should have walked straight back out the door but we didn't, because we were exhausted and had a 3 hour drive home, and we thought, "How bad could it be?" Incredibly bad, it turns out. The "gluten free" crust was thin, flimsy, and burnt around the edges. And the aftermath has been brutal. My toddler and I have both been glutened so badly we are sick, in pain, and completely wiped out the day after what was supposed to be a fun family trip. Instead of beach memories, I'm nursing my kid through cramps and misery because this place could not be bothered to handle allergen prep or basic cleanliness properly. If you have celiac disease or a real gluten allergy, stay far away from this place. Whatever cross contamination is happening in that kitchen is dangerous, not just inconvenient. I don't care how many people recommend it, the risk is not worth it. We will never go back, and I will be telling everyone I know to avoid it too.

Seriously best pizza around and they have a GF! Wish GF was…read morea large but we make it work. Finally becoming "regulars", always place an order and then we just get there in time to just sit and eat and enjoy! They only have beers for the alcohol menu. Bring quarters for the kiddos!

The food and service is fantastic!! They are fast in completing our orders, and it's our go to for…read morea pizza night. We love Fat Daddy's!

37th Street Pizzeria is a fantastic restaurant in the New Bern area. The prices are very…read morereasonable. The food is delicious. The staff is always so friendly and courteous. You sit down at a table and the staff and the atmosphere makes you feel like you are sitting down at your Italian grandma's kitchen on Sundays. It's a very easy restaurant to make it to. They're located right on Neuse boulevard, past the traffic light on Simmons. Overall this place is great and convenient. I would definitely recommend keeping 37th Street in your queue for a future visit. You will have a happy full tummy afterwards.

I have been going to 37th Street Pizza since I was a kid and my parents took me. It was just past…read morethe railroad tracks on Neuse Boulevard (43 going out of town towards Vanceboro) on the right. When they moved to the location they are now, we continued to go because we loved the pizza and other things they offer (plus we lived in the neighborhood right behind it) we would have gone to eat there no matter where they were. Have I ever had a not so great experience there, yes. I called, spoke with manager on duty, and as much as we come there, she knew who my husband was (we eat mostly take out at home now). The staff is great, the food is great and I love the inside of the restaurant, especially the booths! I will not write someone off for one bad experience just because of one, which was taken care of promptly! So, my opinion is, go there, find what looks good to you on the menu and try it. I do not think you will be disappointed. I give 37th Street a A+ and will continue to unless something horrible happens.

A "new to us" place and we were not disappointed! 3 pizzas ready for pickup in 20 min , service was…read morefast and reliable. Pizzas were delicious! I think we've tried every other pizza place on EI and Kostas has been the best so far. They have a wide selection of food, drinks in the fridges in the shop and tables outside to eat there. Highly recommend!

Pizza and wings were fine. Good service and quick. It made our dinner on our first day here…read moreenjoyable if not especially memorable.

never mind. this place has reearned there reputation and will not shut down the food is much better…read moreand has cleaner kitchen.

Very good NY style pizza! The slices are huge and thin type…read morecrust. It gets you filled fast. The sauce and the dough are on the sweeter side with a good amount of cheese and toppings. Friendly workers and neat Jesus doll on the wall.

On my second visit to Mi Amor's, I brought along my sister and we tried a large supreme pizza. As…read moreexpected after my first visit, the pizza was delicious. My sister and I agreed it was definitely the best pizza in the Chocowinity/Washington area and well above average for eastern North Carolina. Once again, the staff was outstanding and we chatted with one of the owners while our pizza was prepared. They had added a pool table since my first visit and will be adding a game room. She told me about a cinnamon flavor they have for their wings that is on my list of things to try. I also want to try their subs. So far, Mi Amor's has been a great find!

We had a night in New Bern, NC and looked for a place to eat after we ended up in downtown after…read moreshopping around. We tried their chicken Caesar salad, wings and a half pizza - buffalo and a margherita. They were delicious! The pizza was absolutely delicious and reminiscent of New York style pizza. Service was amazing and friendly. The restaurant is bigger than you would think from outside. There is limited parking in their small lot.

We stopped by on a Thursday evening. We asked to sit outside. Angel was our waitress. Angel was…read moreable to answer all of our questions. The pizza came out very quickly. I recommend the Savage noble. I would definitely return. Also note they offer pick-up as well.