I have been going to Mario's for many years. I love NY style pizza and this place rarely misses the mark! The old spot they had may have satisfied their needs to provide good food but atmosphere was missing. Their new place on Glenburnie (next to Speedway) is SO MUCH BETTER! Over the last couple of weeks, I have gone there for lunch about 7 times. Their staff has improved as well!! They make you feel welcome now as in the past, the cashier(s) acted as if they'd rather get in a car accident! The staff now? Wow!! Always helpful and greet you like you are the most important customer they have! I love what they've done improving the layout and the lighting. The area for ordering is more open and inviting. Refills? No problem and you don't get that "look" of being bothered! Now the food. For me, best pizza in New Bern! I know there's other spots and while they may be good, they make you feel rushed at times. Not Mario's! Very pleasant and ALWAYS smiling making you feel welcome. They now have new toppings that no other place offers, that I've seen. I had their buffalo chicken this week and it was REALLY good! They also had slices with CLAMS! A LOT OF CLAMS! They do not skimp on toppings! Their Sicilian? Amazing and offer that in slices but not as often as I'd like. When I asked about it when not available, the owner offered to make one on the spot! Really? Seems like this guy (wish I knew his name) gets it!! Not sure why there are others that have such a low opinion. Probably because they were trying to get free food! This is not "fine dining" and in my opinion, they get it right. If not the first time (no one always gets it right the first time), they will make it right! I will definitely be going back more often than in the past! Mainly due to location and staff! Food has always been really good to me! Cheers to the owner for making the improvements, which was not inexpensive! read more

Great pizza! We got take out, but I would love to eat in because the ambiance is so lovely. We will be back for sure!

We shared a small antipasti salad, a slice of Sicilian pizza, carbonara pasta (which came with 2 garlic knots and a side salad) and tiramisu. Plenty of food plus 2 beers were about $45 before tipping. The salad and pasta were really good. Didn't love the pizza; it was so barely sauced it was a bit dry. We made the mistake of dining in. I didn't mind the causal decor but the pizza was served on a paper plate and the utensils were plastic. No idea why Yelp thinks I'm complimenting the ambience. I'm not, lol, but I can't deselect it. This a good takeaway option, fairly priced with friendly service. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch. We ordered a small pie and a beverage. We pay and card machine asks if we want to leave a gratuity. Why? We do all the work? We pick up the order at the counter. We have to get our own condiments. Speaking of condiments. When we brought our pizza to the table to eat, my wife asked me to get the jar of garlic powder. When I went to their condiment station, the row labeled garlic had. I jar there. I asked behind the counter, where is the garlic. The counter person replied that they don't know. I then asked, well can I get some please? He said he is new and will have to check with the kitchen staff. He came back with a plastic container and said there would be a charge. Why? Are you kidding me Mario's? No a pleasant experience. read more

Mario's Pizza - Meatball Parm Sub - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

The New Mario's is serving up some yummy dishes. I had the chicken parm with angel hair, and my Husband had the chicken piccata with angel hair. We split a rice-ball as an appetizer. Food was delicious. However the ladies behind the counter were Lovely, especially my girl Tiffany! Shout out to Lady! You rock! Prices are average, so that's a plus. I highly recommend tipping the ladies in cash, not card. From my experience the serves don't see most of it, and they work hard for it! Definitely will be returning! read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken Parm with angel Hair. - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

Recently they relocated into a new building, what a fantastic upgrade. Food is awesome as usual. Be patient because the recent move has increased business and they are adjusting. Love the changes to the menu and overall restaurant experience. read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Great food good service reasonably priced definitely recommend if you need to bring home a great meal for the family this is what I suggest.

Watch out the moved locations but they haven't lost a touch on the way! great Pizza and great wings. The staff could use some work on smiling more (elderly women) but that's not to be said of them all. My experience was great and so was the food definitely an option to rely on. read more

+ the food was tasty. great ambience. great service as well. i ordered a couple of slices & a large pie to take. enjoyed them both.

Made this Italian jersey girl very happy, real pizza and real cheesecake! Very friendly and good service.

Mario's has just relocated to a new location across the street from the old one. They did a wonderful job on the building. Their food has always been good and there are many additions to the menu. Best pizza in New Bern and we're from NJ where they know how to make it. The ambience is the best of their relocation. The only negative thing about Mario's is you have to order up front as there is no table ordering. They do now deliver the food to you as opposed the getting it yourself. Unfortunately the food doesn't get to your table all at once, so you don't eat together in many instances. read more

Pizza was just ok. $15 calamari appetizer was a small, greasy mess. Stand in line, order at the counter and carry your drinks to your table. Paper plates. Large pizza, 2 drinks...$53. Overpriced for quality of food and self service dining. On a positive note, the new location looks nice inside and out. read more

I saw a post on Instagram advertising their chicken piccata, so we drove right over on Friday and gave it a try. Wow! It was delicious! I highly recommend. My wife had a calzone and she was very satisfied with the flavor, crust, etc. Mario's is moving to a bigger location and we can't wait to try it. read more

I've ate here multiple times and it's been nothing but absolute perfection. But what drove me to write this review is because today I got to try an Italian pastry made by a pastry chef from Sicily. It's very delicious and looks absolutely stunning. I hope y'all can continue to have homemade desserts. The customer service has also been amazing. it's a wonderful family environment. Thank you guys for the amazing food. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

Great pizza and Italian dishes. Good prices and fast service. Only downside is they are across the bridge so it's order and head over immediately. read more

Fried ravioli here is absolutely amazing, pizza is really good. There are a few tables for dine in, but probably best for small groups. Service is great! Would definitely go back!! read more

Ordered a pizza for pickup and paid in the app. Waited in line for 20 minutes to pickup a pizza that was sitting getting cold while the front counter ladies fumbled to find everyone's orders and tell everyone how their boss steals all of their credit card tips. Pizza is generally good but they need some management on busy nights. I won't be going back. read more

excellent costumer service great taste fair price but they do not offer chives sadly. not a deal breaker just disappointing

chef was horrible. scolded at me for requesting a refund after waiting 55 minutes for a single pizza that came out undercooked and horrible. used to love Mario's. probably won't go back after that. Sad read more

Great pizza and wings especially coming from a New Yorker. The ability to order online was seamless

amazing food, in my opinion this is the best pizza in new bern. calzones are also very good. real authentic italian food which is rare around here read more

To the pizzas calzones and Stromboli's it's all good. My family and I have tried it it's all good But chicken Caesar salad is the best but only made by AJ .. The employees are friendly and very helpful. read more

The best around!! I don't like spaghetti usually but love theirs!! The staff is always friendly! We drive from Kinston to eat here!

My wife and I went to Mario's this past Monday evening. We ordered 2 slices of pizza with extra cheese and an eggplant parmesan dinner. 1)The pizza was not hot and had not enough sauce and extra cheese. The pizza tasted terrible and the crust tasted like cardboard with a shipping label glued on it..!!! 2)The eggplant dinner was also terrible and inedible!! The cheese on top was burnt which made it tasteless and charred; the eggplant was under cooked and too tough to eat; dinner lacked enough sauce to at least make the eggplant at least a little palatable.. The spaghetti was overcooked and stale; it was not served hot except for the hot spicy sauce which we did not order. Our experience at Mario's convinced us that; "a napoli sanno come fare e servire pizza e cene italiane!" read more

Great NY pizza. Great staff. Everyone has been super friendly and pizza is always a winner.

Love this place from the millions of choices of huge NY style pizza slices, the multiple gelato flavors and chocolate canolas. All for the win. Ubee never disappoints read more

I was at a car dealership when I was offered a piece of pizza from this establishment. Man it was perfect!! I had to buy some of my own. The customer service was good and they listened to my order request and the price was pretty good. read more

We recently had Mario's Pizza do home delivery. Both times the food was excellent especially the lemon cake. The cheese steak was outstanding and the pizza is always great. It was delivered hot and well packaged. We will be back! Thank you! read more

I've had pizza from all over the world. The best I've had was in the Mediterranean, and this place had surpassed expectations. My husband and I got three slices total. I went with the mushrooms because I'm a mush fanatic. I couldn't put it down. The crust was crisp and cheese perfect temperature. I've lived in New Bern for four years and never tried because of the poor reviews. My husband kept raving about how Amazing it was so finally decided to come. By far the best pizza place in town. I suggest eating in house to get best experience the flavors and crispness. Otherwise you're risking the integrity of the pies! Do it!! read more

Mario's Pizza - Fungi - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

I order at least once a week and It never fails, I always get Great tasting food & $ervce

I am okay with their pizza .. I have had true NYC pizza and yeah .. there is a big difference.. sorry.

First time trying this place as my usual spot is closed on Sundays. We ordered the fresh basil, romano, tomato pizza and 10 hot wings with ranch. So, the pizza isn't what we expected (mostly a lot of sauce, basil, and grated dry romano (not melted) but it was really great. Crust was a bit dry. Will try their cheese pizza for a better understanding. The wings were nice and very spicy. Issue was they put the ranch dressing underneath the wings so it's covered in sauce and looks gross. With delivery it was $30, plus I tipped. Kinda pricey for a pizza and 10 wings. Sad the pizza was cold though, maybe an issue with the sauce being exposed without melted cheese? Will try again, pick up and get their cheese for a better experience. So far it's one of the better pies. read more

Awesome pizza! People working there are awesome as well! Crust was perfect. Slices served nice and hot. Highly recommend.

I eat at Mario's every week! Their pizza is always great and the people that work there are always very friendly. This is the closest to NY pizza that you can get without traveling to Brooklyn! read more

Best pizza in New Bern NC. Best crust, and toppings. I gotta eat it at least once a month minimum. Calzones are huge. It's the best. Italian subs..the best. read more

I placed an order on my way home from work when I noticed the $4.99 calzone and Stromboli special posted on your Facebook page. I ordered 2 calzones and 1 Stromboli and also confirmed the $4.99 special with the woman on the phone. My wife picked up our order and was charged extra for chicken in the calzone as well as 75 cents each for cups of sauce. How can you serve a calzone or Stromboli and not include sauce? I would of appreciated a heads up when ordering that sauce and certain toppings are extra. I'm not one to argue over a few dollars, but charging customers extra for different toppings and cups of sauce is a little ridiculous. What was supposed to be a "Thursday Night Special", turned in to a regular priced order from Mario's. My calzone looked good but was filled with fake grilled chicken that you get pre-cooked in a bag. And my wife and I both agreed that the calzones were wet and dripped grease when biting into them. Just not a very good experience this evening... read more

Mario's Pizza - Calzones looked great but filled with grease and no flavor - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

I am a New Yorker and this pizza is the best in NC.Nice place and Jay was a great hostess.

Always good, always fresh. Any time I'm in New Bern the pizza comes from Mario's. Thanks guys!

If you are from anywhere north of NC save your money. Soggy pizza, sub that came in a frikkin styrofoam box? Helllloooo! Sub was more than sub standard- didn't have some of the ingredients stated on website and the bread was like a Wonderbread bun. Yuck. Even my dog turned up her nose. Well, not really but I have to say- this place came recommended by a neighbor whom I will never take recommendations from again. read more

Had the wings ... the meat looked n tasted old ... there was A Huge Feather attached to the fried wing... Ranch dressing is runny ... n quite flavorless... read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken wing with feathers fried - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina